Sorry, this is not my cup of tzatziki. A lot of my family likes this place and, sure, there's not a lot of Greek in the area to compete. My thoughts: + Good bang for your buck. Solid on ingredients and meats. + Very nice service. They gave us a free dessert with our order. - Not a lot of flavor. Even the regular gyro, which smells wonderful, doesn't taste out of the ordinary. Avgolemono soup did not really have lemon. On the plus side, the lemon potatoes were a hit all around. + The spanakopita was crunchy crust with soft interior. ---------- The rice pudding, in my mind, had no flavor and was overstuffed with gigantic overcooked rice. The worst I've ever had. Yet the rest of my family seemed to like it?! So I just can't even. I'm not eating here again but I won't fault others who do. It's a choice, you like what you like, and again, the service was very friendly to us. But I will keep going the extra miles to Thavma in Livingston for my high quality taste. read more

Not sure what happened but ordered the following for pick up and was disappointed. Everything looked great... until we started to eat. Falafel platter with soup, fries and came with a pita. (2/5) Pita was SO HARD and stale like when you microwave a piece of bread too long. Falafel was ok but borderline frozen vibes. The fries were also soggy so maybe not the best for takeout. Soup was piping hot and tasted ok but thicker than I expected and the orzo and chicken were overcooked. So sad. Lamb-beef gyro pita (2/5) Meat was overcooked and again the pita was hard as a rock.... Sadly for the price just not worth it. We have other options in Fairfield and beyond for more quality. read more

Gyro World - Falafel platter - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

The food was delicious and the service was very good. The seating and tables were clean and the decor was brilliant! My friend and I met the owner who was very hospitable and thank us both for our support. A must visit for a great dining experience! read more

See all

Huge portions great prices, beautiful ambiance. Has a little store for some Greek items. read more

Gyro World - Taco gyro special $9 with fries. - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

I had high hopes for this restaurant. I was excited to try the gyro. Upon entering restaurant the decor is very modern and staff is welcoming. They have Greek grocery items near front entrance. There are tables and chairs for dining in. Parking is limited as there is street parking and in the back parking lot which is small. The kitchen is open and you are able to view staff preparing food. I watched as my gyro was being prepared and meat is not cut fresh from the spic the worker took the previously cut meat from a warmer. The meat is dry and lacks flavor. The portion is generous. The pita was dry as well and hard on the edges. Taziki sauce was OK . This was my first time trying this restaurant and I won't be returning. read more

Four and a half stars for Greek takeout. Clean, bright space with a Mediterranean vibe. Plenty of tables are available. You order at the counter and they bring the food to your table of choice. I had the pork souvlaki sandwich. It was better than average for sure. The meat was tender and flavorful. Could have used a bit more tzatziki and tomatoes. But it was fine. My wife ordered the beef and lamb gyro platter which includes a generous portion of meat. A small Greek salad. Fries and a pita. It was very good. My only small knock is they don't offer any all lamb items. But that's OK. I will definitely dine at Gyro World again. read more

Gyro World - Beef And Lamb Platter - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Service was excellent and ambiance is casual. Great place for lunch. Really like the food especially the gyro, lemon potatoes, and lemon potatoes. read more

Gyro World - Lunch Box - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Food is horrible. I ordered twice and I'm not gonna order again chicken super dry no taste. read more

Gyro World - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Wow! Just wow! I stopped into Gyro World tonight for their soft opening. I was greeted by so many wonderful employees. I was offered a sample of spinach or cheese pie. The spinach pie was delicious. It was hot and full of flavor. I ordered my food to go and it was exactly as I ordered. My family and I thoroughly enjoyed our Beef and Lamb Gyro sandwiches. The meat was incredibly soft and tender. There was the perfect amount of tzatziki in the sandwiches too. Now that our gyros have been consumed, it's time to tackle dessert. Thanks to the crew at Gyro World!! The restaurant has a great vibe to it. We definitely plan to be back really soon. read more

See all

Everything from the food to service to ambience was amazing! The restaurant was extremely clean which in my opinion elevated the experience, could immediately taste how fresh the food was. The tzatziki is arguably one of the best I've ever had. Came here for a quick 45 minute lunch date and did not disappoint! The cake was a little too sweet for me but very fresh. Overall 9.5/10 read more

See all

we have ordered takeout here a few times but today was disappointing. an order of hot wings for $14 should be better than the 6 tiny ones we received. that's $2.30 per wing. while we understand that the majority of the menu is greek but if you are going to offer wings as an option they need to meet their price point. we also ordered a gyro and a salad with bifteki which were good. based upon our experience it may be advisable to remove the hot wings from the menu. read more

Gyro World - $14 hot wings - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

First time we stopped in this weekend and this place by far is the best Greek food I had. Amazing. I was excited! The pictures featured here are lunchbox meals. The chicken is so fresh, delicious and juicy and love my lemon potatoes and salad. Oh my! The beef and lamb along with rice and salad are delicious as well. Love the ambiance and great with music playing in the restaurant. Staff is friendly and pleasant. Service was great. Yanni is very welcoming, professional and a nice owner. Definitely will be coming back and definitely recommend. read more

Gyro World - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Great prices for really good food. Service was fast and portions are generous. Really liked my Gyro and the lemon potatoes. We ordered grape leaves for the table and they were good. Not in the area too often, but would go back when I am. read more

Food was well seasoned and bountiful at a great price. Service was great and they have a small market of specialty Mediterranean items.

What a great stop on Bloomfield Avenue. The Greek chicken lemon orzo soup was excellent! Awesome chicken gyro and tasty Greek salad. Place is impeccably clean and very pleasant service. Bring your favorite bottle of wine!! read more

I loved the ambiance and the food! Service was fast and pleasant. It is self order. You can sit down or take out. I am sure they have pick up as well. The chicken skewer platter was juicy and with aroma. I will be back. read more

Just wanted to say another thank you for the rehearsal dinner Friday night! Everything was fabulous and everyone loved the food! The wedding was a very Blessed event! Thank you for helping us get it off to a great start! read more

I got combo platter chicken and beef with rice. Yummy!! The tzaziki was on the side and I added to my liking. Lots of meat, get an extra pita. read more

Gyro World - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

I am speaking as a Greek. The food at this restaurant is fresh authentic, and the taste of everything I ordered was magnificent. I had a large chuck of tiropita (cheese pie), the Gyro (pronounced "jiro" not "giro") platter, and topped it off with, of course, a piece of baklava. Top shelf stuff!! The cost of what I ordered was reasonable and well-worth the food that I ordered. The staff is personable, polite, and helpful. The atmosphere is very pleasant and allows for a good amount of folks to eat-in. The service was quick, and my to-go order was well packaged. The restaurant also offers a pretty good amount of Greek food items. Nice touch! I highly recommend Gyro World! You won't be sorry. Remember... Gyro, pronounced "Jeero" not "Guyro"! read more

Delicious food amazing service friendly clientele. Will definitely come back for dinner . read more

Gyro World - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Cute spot, modern decor and casual atmosphere. Tried a few items. Gyro trio, falafel, and a few other gyros. Gyro trio is a nice sampler to try the different meats. Chicken soup was nice and hot, texture was nice thick but not overwhelming, wished it has a bit more lemon and maybe pepper but comforting on a cold day. You can also order just the meat which is nice sometimes you're not in the mood for fillers or just going simple and light. read more

Gyro World - gyro trio - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

We just had Gyro World in Caldwell cater out party in Livingston NJ. The food was amazing! A huge hit! Chicken kebabs were generous, moist and perfectly seasoned. Came with a generous amount of seasoned rice too. Everything came fresh and hot! Food was beautifully packed too. Yanni the owner took great care helping with the order and made sure we were well taken care of. Highly recommend Them for all catering needs! Thank you Gyro World!! read more

Delicious food - recommend the souvlaki! Gyros are delicious and portions are generous. Service excellent.

Moved to the area this fall and have been waiting to try this place due to the reviews. Ordered over the phone and picked up the order. I asked if the tzatziki sauce is in the bag. I should have checked because I ordered a platter and a gyro and there was none in my order at all. I called them and I live about 2 miles up the road so they delivered it to me which was nice but also took some time as you can imagine. So unfortunately I had to eat soggy pita and lemon potatoes and had to reheat everything which made it taste 3 star at best sadly. Plus one star off for forgetting what makes the meal, quality tzatziki sauce. See picture. read more

Gyro World - Soggy food as I had to get tzatziki sauce delivered to me because they forgot it in my entire order. - Greek Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

Have been hearing amazing things about Gyro World! What an amazing addition to the Caldwells. Decided to come in on a Saturday night. It wasn't too busy so we decided to eat there instead of ordering take out. We ordered a few appetizers and two platters. Our food came out quickly and we enjoyed every last bite! The halloumi appetizer was my absolute favorite... I even got my picky eater husband to enjoy it! Although part of our order came out incorrectly, the staff corrected it without any questions asked. They were attentive to our needs throughout our meal. The platters are HUGE - would definitely recommend sharing but we did not complain ... we got to try two different meats. I really enjoyed the soup that I got too .. can see myself coming up to a pick up a bowl when I'm not feeling well :) They don't serve their whole menu (we wanted an order of hot wings but they didn't have yet). Will definitely be back! :) read more

Gyro World was authentically Greek cuisine. There are very few Greek restaurants in the area. We had the Greek Salad which was amazing. the owner was delightful and staff really knew what they were doing. The atmosphere was divine with the Greek marketplace in the background. We felt like we were in a marketplace in Santorini. The pork gyro was excellent, and well as the beef and lamb gyro. The calamari was not bad either. read more

Got take out from them for the first time tonight. It was excellent! Lamb gyro sandwich was a meal in and of itself. Falafel platter was also great. To top it off, the bakala was fantastic. Everything was packaged so well. Friendly staff and convenient location in Caldwell. I am so happy that they replaced my go-to local greek place that closed read more

Dry, dry, dry. There is only one other review, matching my description. Very disappointing. Green salad with Chicken gyro. My partner's fries were very soggy. read more

From the counter help to the owner, these are lovely people! The atmosphere, the delicious authentic food, the free rice pudding they gave me, the display of Greek oils and specialties for sale, the easy parking in the back... this is a gem in our midst! Following my first visit, they catered a dinner party for 22 people that was unbelievable! They offered samples to taste, great advice and no pressure. The owner's generosity is evident every step of the way. Trust him and enjoy yourself. My guests loved it all. The grape leaves are the best I've ever had. That Tzatziki and spicy feta dip, as well as the baba ganoush were a hit. We ordered pita, spinach pie, rice with vegetables, all the meats, falafel and outrageously good lemon potatoes! Truly it was a great day. Thank you Gyro World! read more

Food is very good her. Presentation is much higher than some of the other Greek places that have popped up in the area the last 2 years. Legit meat setup as well for gyros. Eat-in and take out. read more

This quick service restaurant has outstanding food, friendly service and a charming dining space. I had the Greek salad with chicken pita wrap. The chicken was moist and the salad ingredients were incredibly fresh and tasty. There was also a nice piece of stuffed grape leaf tucked inside. My husband declared his chicken gyro the best he's had in years. My mother-in-law thoroughly enjoyed her falafel pita. They gave us small samples of very refreshing rice pudding to end our meal. This place is definitely a winner. read more

We ordered takeout and found the pricing to be on the higher side. Unfortunately, the quality and taste of the food did not meet our expectations. read more

I love it! The restaurant is super cute with a peaceful atmosphere. We ordered the falafel and the chicken gyros which were amazing. We tried the halloumi and the rice pudding which were also amazing. 10/10 recommend. read more

OTFC. Off THE FREKIN CHARTS. The vegetarian pita was AMAZING. Extremely flavorful. Just an excellent product. Had a sample of their rice pudding and it was also amazing. Great place read more

Amazing food! Delicious hand cut fries! So authentic! Owner and staff very courteous and friendly! Highly recommend!!!!

The food was fantastic! We got a large to-go order and even thought it was their opening weekend their attention to detail was impeccable. They even treated us to a couple desserts! The boxes for the platters are really nice and everything was packaged securely. Good size portions and very tasty. We will definitely go back! read more

Food is super fresh and flavorful!! Portions are huge. Hopefully we can order sometime soon

Fast, friendly service the place was very, very clean and the food was delicious. I recommended.

The first time I tried gyro world I thought the flavors of everything were awesome! I did think that the meat was a bit too salty. I ordered again today and everything was perfect! The meats were salted perfectly and it's now one of my top spots for gyros! read more

Probably the worst gyro I've ever had in my life. Because it was expensive i ate about half but could not do it and the rest is in the garbage. With a name like Gyro World, I expected it to be amazing but the exact opposite. The chicken in my gyro is shredded chicken leg which I am not a fan of. The seasoning was terrible and salty. It comes all separately, so you have to put it together and there's nothing to help you keep it together so everything keeps falling out of the pita. The pita bread tasted stale and they only put 1 piece of the corner of the tomato. what a waste of $20 read more