People, if you're looking for a reasonable place to throw a family birthday party, this joint is worth a mention. Three words: 29 inch pizza!! HUJJJJJAASSSS! More like a XL pizza on heavy doses of enhancing tomato steroids. If Arnold Schwarzenegger married the Little Caesars "pizza pizza" guy, Fat Cat's party size pizzas would be their offspring. I was fixated on the mushroom/sausage half of the XL. Sausage had great taste, and I love shrooms. The toppings are nicely distributed throughout, too. Booow chicky wow wooooow. The sauce is lite, not heavy; middle of the road: not too tart or sweet. The crust was wonderful! I took from the middle of the giant pie, and- prepared for a doughy, uncooked crust - I was so very wrong. My guess? They cook the crust somewhat before putting the toppings on, and cooking it the rest of the way. Give it a go, if you're in Lancaster and feeling like some pizza! read more

See all

Showed up early for pickup to have a fresh pizza to take home and spend a little money in their bar as well. They handed me a luke warm pizza 7 minutes early. I did not notice till I was in the car headed home when my Wife pointed out the pizza is not even warm!!! Took it home had to re-heat the oven and cook it at home....Pushed our expected time an additional hour. Disappointed to say the least! I will go else where in the future. Lesson learned!!! read more

Slow. Slow is the best description of Fat Cats. When I say slow, I mean painfully slow. I hate doing this because their pizza is so good!! I have never been able to pick up a carry-out order faster than 1 hour, even though I'm told 45 minutes. Delivery is almost always 1.5-3 hours... I will say that even though delivery times are absurdly long, the pizza arrives fresh and hot. Ordering from here definitely takes careful planning on your part. read more

Management was disrespectful. They should never argue or get snoody with a customer. Maybe she was just having a bad day but that wasn't my fault. My issue started at the drive thru which was a cluster of a mess. Maybe some signs with arrows or paint on the ground directing people where to go? So I walk inside to get my food. The person at the register didn't want to get my food but did it anyway and then the manager came over and wasn't happy and saying that this won't happen again and I'd be the reason this place got shut down for not following the rules. I came here almost every weekend for about 7 years....and the manager was correct in saying that this won't happen again. I will not be back. read more

The past two time I have went to fat cats I have had horrible service. The first time our waitress never checked up on us, another waitress had to get us refills and our check. The second time we went we got stuck with the same waitress and she did the exact same thing she did last time. Also our pizza wasn't completely cooked and me and my boyfriend both had upset stomachs that night. read more

The last few times I've ordered pizza at Fat Cats they have skimped on the toppings, the cheese, and the pizza sauce. Tip, I think you should probably ask ask for extra pizza sauce. The pizzas have been coming out as thin as paper. read more

Fat Cat Pizza - Take n bake, take it home and bake it pizza. 1/2 pepperoni, xtra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

There was barely any people in the restaurant but still took 45 minutes for them to even put the pizza in the oven. They weren't slammed at all it was just the chefs being lazy and working slowly because of the small amount of people. When we finally got the pizza it was slightly raw and it took another 20 minutes after we finished to get the bill. My drink was running low the whole time and they never refilled it once. They definitely need to work on their service. This was just embarrassing. read more

Fat Cat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

We were just in your store next to Walmart in Lancaster we were placing an order to see if we wanted you guys to host our rehearsal dinner where we planned to spend a few hundred dollars we got bacon on our fries after specifically asking for no meat and they put up a HUGE fuss about a replacement then we finally got one after waiting 20 minutes we get home and our pizza had pepperoni on it read more

Great pizza, good selection of drinks, and reasonably priced! The only negative was the wait times. We did have to wait extended amounts of time for our food and for drink refills. Beyond that it's a really cool place with live music! It has a laid back/casual atmosphere and is a nice place if you're just looking to relax with some music! read more

My boyfriend spent 1879 on a pizza you ordered a large with bacon mushroom and extra sauce and it was the driest pizza I've ever had from Fatcats.When called to complain they only want to get my boyfriend a five dollar credit or come back immediately to get the pizza they kind of sucks when you get all the way home after you get off working all day so I wouldn't recommend going there. Christie's if you ever have a problem replace your pizza at any time read more

I recently (2-2-14) did the All-the-Way. Loved it!!!!! Highly recommended if you like a sweet sauce. read more

Pizza was yummy!! We had The Works and Hawaiian personal size pizza with side salads. Clean and friendly staff. read more

Fat Cat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

See all

Couldn't wait to get a pizza again from here , and opened it in had hair in it ! And then had to wait for another one to be made , and the missed it all up with wrong toppings ! And waited over a week to hear back from some one after l kept calling ! And got hung up on by ( Angie) when some one finally returned a call ! NEVER AGAIN ! WORST RUDEST SERVICE & PRODUCT ! Thanks For the hairy Pizza FAT CATS ! read more

Would give 0/5 stars if I could! The sad thing is they do have really good pizza, but I have NEVER experienced such horrible customer service in my life. I called and ordered a large pizza and cheese sticks for delivery (I live less than 5 minutes away from the shop) and they said 1hr - 1hr and 15 minutes. I thought okay they're probably busy. After 1hr and 50 minutes I was getting irritated and decided to call to see how much longer it would take. I waited on hold for 7 minutes just to be hung up on, and when I called back the OWNER was rude as hell to me. More than 2 hours later I finally decided to cancel this order and got domino's instead, who delivered in less than an hour thank god for domino's and fuck fat cats pizzeria. read more

This place is awesome all the way! Meatball subs with a sweet italian sauce and the homemade meatballs that melt in your mouth as the cheese strings behind. The pizza is so very good; the crust is just the right thinness so that you can enjoy the fresh toppings and no need to ask for extra cheese, that is always taken care of the first time! The employees are very professional, nice and willing to assist you. I have never had a problem at this establishment and will continue to reorder. The people who are whinning with one stars, aren't legitimate with their rating as they sound more like individuals who like the usual processed food you get elsewhere that all tastes the same as they use the same chemicals to keep the food fresh. Good job Fat Cat Pizza Ety Road, Lancaster! Keep up the good work and great customer service! read more

Not a place to go if you're in a hurry for a pizza. They are very slow. People are friendly and the pizza is usually really good. Every time we visits they seem to be under staffed. read more

Tried the trusty and true Fat Cat Pizza buffet. They redeemed themself and became an above average pizza joint. I just wish they ran coupons! read more

Place has really went down hill! Looked like pizza toppings were just thrown on. All on one side not spread out. Service was slow. No hot water in restroom, let alone being clean. Staff eating behind the bar. read more

Awesome entertainment, great pizza options. Fun and resonable prices. @leightennison

I was looking forward to an evening of fun and food with friends when I was told they couldn't handle a party of 12. We went on a night that did have parties in both party rooms. However, the main dining room was fairly empty. A very young teen assumed I was with a party when I came in. He spoke rudely to me and I told him I wasn't there for a party, I was having dinner with friends. I told him there were 12 of us. He told me they didn't have room and couldn't handle a party of 12. There were many open tables in the dining room and I asked if we could just push them together. He said no. He then asked another server if they could seat a party of 12. She looked at me, laughed rudely and said we can't serve 12 people. The young man said, "guess you'll have to go somewhere else". I worked in restaurants through high school and college. I loved large parties because the tips were great. We weren't asking for any special treatment or attention. Just a group of middle aged ladies wanting to have dinner together. I counted 5 servers on the floor and saw several people in the kitchen so I knew they weren't short staffed. Even if they truly couldn't have accommodated us, they could've simply apologized and explained why, not said go somewhere else. Rude attitudes cost them quite a bit of business for the future. read more

The food was pretty good. But I can only give two stars because of the slowness and dirty tables. Not busy either. We had to choose one of a couple tables as all the others were dirty. We waited at least 5 min before anyone even came to give menus. Then after ordering we waited about 30 min for our pizza. Then another long time to get check. Food good just won't come back when I'm in a rush. read more

Went to fat cats on a Sunday evening wih my wife and mother. I split a BBQ chicken pizza with my mom and my wife had the Stromboli. The pizza was pretty good. The sauce was sweet and the chicken was cooked well. I had jalapeños on half and it was good n spicy! My wife's Stromboli however was just okay as it was filled with mostly peppers a little pepperoni and cheese. From the outside it looked like a pizza with toppings in the middle and wasn't very tasty. The service was not bad as they came to the table enough but the food took a little longer than usual but we didn't mind. read more

We must have caught them during a pepperoni shortage. They were hidden under the cheese and very scarce. In general, the sauce is very sweet and reminded me of what you might find at a kids birthday party. The restaurant was clean and wait staff was pleasant. We will not go back but it wasn't a horrible experience, just not our taste. read more

Tonight I phoned into fat cats and was immediately placed on hold (typically not a problem) and after 8 minutes another person picked up the phone and asked me if I could hold again and I indicated that I had already been on hold for 8 minutes and now I'm being put on hold again? After 2 more minutes the "manager" came to the phone and was more rude than I could have ever imagined and when I asked to speak to her supervisor she said there was not one there and when I indicated I would be speaking with the owner her response was "go ahead, I don't care... are you going to order or. It, you are wasting my time". WOW. So I didn't place my order then. When I got home my son called in to place an order because he really wanted Fat Cat Pizza and we told them it would be for pick up so when he got there to pick up our pizza it wasn't there the delivery guy took it and they had to wait for them to make another pizza. Didn't even give them a discount. What is going on Fat Cats???? read more

It took us seven years to discover this place. A great variety of food. Love the happy hour prices on beer and appetizers. The only drawback I have is the entertainment. I feel the place is too small for this. We tend to leave before it starts because it's hard to hear yourself talk. Would recommend this place highly. They made us feel like regulars the first time we were there and that's what keeps us coming back! read more

Absolutely terrible service! 3rd and last horrible experience. The owner/manager refuses to ever speak to anyone to fix any issues! Wrong order, forgotten order, 2 hr + delivery and still not in route. Choose another pizza place! read more

If I could give a negative star I would. This place has no customer service! After multiple attempts at calling and no one answering I was finally able to order a party pizza from the Sheridan drive location at the beginning of September. They did not have the party size box so the person on the phone said they would break it down into 4 pizzas, which was fine. We asked for 2 pepperoni and 2 with pepperoni and sausage. Once they finally arrived they all were completely inedible. The crust tasted extremely old and was soaked from the grease. I attempted to call to complain and again no answer so I called the location on Ety rd. They explained that I needed to call and submit my complaint to the location I ordered from and they told me to speak with tequila. I was finally able to contact tequila and explained my complaint. I expressed that I was not interested in receiving replacements from the Sheridan drive location and she stated that she worked at the other location in the morning and would put my credit in there. I paid roughly $43 for this and when I jut went to order using the credit I was supposed to have I was told it was not in the computer. The woman I was speaking with then called tequila who stated she only offered me a credit for an extra large pizza. After stating that it was a false statement I was told that she would give me the credit for the party pizza but that after this I should get my pizza else where. Seriously?! I will no longer give any business there way nor will I affiliate myself with this establishment ever! read more

I grew up in Lancaster and Fat Cats was always the most delicious pizza. After I moved, when I would come home to visit, it was always a MUST to get Fat Cats. The pizza used to have a lot of cheese, and was filling, but the pizza now is not so great. I have tried it twice (thinking the first time was a fluke), and even ordered extra cheese, and they are very skimpy with the toppings. The crust reminds me of pizza huts, and just doesn't taste the same. It's very dissapointing, I wish they would have kept the same recipe, but they haven't. I won't be eating Fat Cats anymore, and don't recommend it. read more

My favorite pizza on the planet. The sauce is super sweet. I recommend the TNT which is 2 layers of pepperoni abd cheese.

Pizza was late an told owener would call me an that was in july an no call so i will do my buisness with christy pizza an let everyone know i was lied 2 read more

reopened last Thursday. While the new digs are nice it is the same old average pizza and average service at best.

Terrible service. After 10 minutes of no one stopping by our table to welcome us, bring us a menu or take a drink order we took this as a hint and left. There was only one persons servicing the entire floor. I could see others in the kitchen and there was a Person cleaning tables and when she finished sat at the bar. Clearly new patrons weren't important. read more

**FAT CAT PARTY ROOM IS A SCAM ** Our family tried too have my nieces 1st Birthday party @ Fat Cat. We ordered the "party room" and had approximately 30 to 40 people! When ordering the room, nobody told us that there were any restrictions on the party! Once we got the room set up on party day and got all of the guest there, Fat Cat's would not allow us to purchase their famous "Party Pizza"! They stated that it would be a LIABILITY! They only allowed us 1 pitcher of pop, the rest had too be purchased! Pitchers of pop were $5 each! They charged a $50 deposit, which is too come off the balance @ end of night! I inquired as too how the "party pizza" w/be a liability. I was told that they are sooo big that it would be a liability, if someone was burnt!! Didn't make sense, so I inquired further! BTW..I had just purchased a party pizza from them a month ago and they tipped it sideways too get it into my vehicle! They were not worried about the liability of my being burnt @ that time, just with the money!!! I explained that we had use of the entire party room and could potentially put the pizza's on floor, we could put 4 tables together, or put 2 tables together, all of these ideas were rejected!! I then suggested that I would but it @ another location and bring it too the party room, that too was not allowed per FAT CAT! I then suggested that we go to grocery store and purchase finger foods, that too was not allowed per FAT CAT!! I explained that I thought this was a scam because when we made reservations for the party room, @ no time were we informed that we could not buy the party pizza!! I was informed that @ no time can you purchase a party pizza @ FAT CAT and eat it there!!! Due to again the liability!!! HA ! LOL! I had expained that all of my previous suggestions would remove the liability from them and they would not hear of it ! After talking to the manager regarding this, a common employee, with a huge gap between her teeth, decided too emerge from the kitchen and " invite me too come outside"! I told her that whatever she had too say could be said in front of everyone! She explained further that we could not have party pizza and gave the LAME excuse of LIABILITY again! She also informed us that we could take our party somewhere else and she would NOT be giving the deposit back. This is all happened within an hour of being @ the party! She then invited me outside yet again! So @ this time, I informed this girl that we can go outside but w/not be doing much talking when we got there! Then she threatened cops!! WOW , after she approached me to go outside!! My sister in laws father had spoken with the manager asked her for the owners #, and don't you know they gave him the number for the same place that we were standing in! How rude was that too do to a man that was obviously your elder and showing you nothing but respect up too this point! Rather than deal with this LUDACRIS place any longer, we called DONATO"S on Fair ! They had 2 parties going on @ that time and both of there party rooms were full. After explaining our situation, they said that they could still accomodate us! The patio was ours and they also extended the back half of the inside too us also. They have NO CHARGE for the party rooms! The pitchers of pop were only $1.98 VS the five dollars that the other place charged!! We ordered 9 pizzas (large) @ Donato's and our bill was still cheaper by $50 than it was going to be @ Fat Cat for only 5 pizzas!! THANK YOU DONATO'S !! **FAT CAT YOU SUCK** You are a LOCAL business that after being in Lancaster long enough and have obviously made enough money off of your LOCAL customers that you were able too move too a brand new building! This is the Thank You that you give too your local customers, running a scam for the party room!!! I am willing too pay the $40 it cost to take them too small claims, ( on principal alone) just to get the $50 deposit back!! I told my brother and his wife that if they would walk out and move the party to the Very Accomodating Donato's, I would pay the $50 deposit for him! That was the best $50 I ever lost!!! Please People Save Your Money, Do Not Go To Fat Cat, They Are Running A Scam On The Party Room and the Party Pizza's! What kind of place can you purchase dinner there and not eat it there? What if we were a school bus load of kids we ordered party pizzas and then had too take the kids somewhere else too eat it ! Makes NO SENSE !!! Fat Cat get out of town !! read more

The best pizza in Ohio!!! I drive to Lancaster from Columbus (New Albany) just for Fat Cat Pizza. Wish they had one up here. Probably a good thing they don't......( I would gain 25 lbs. instantly). Been eating this pizza for 30 years and it's never changed. Other places r always fixing things that aren't broken. Same recipe I remember from when I was little. read more

Once Fat Cats was my favorite pizza. Then new owners took over and changed things. What a stupid move. Why change something that was so successful. I miss the original Fat Cats! read more

dont use the drive through they wont meet you in a timely manner waited 20+ minutes i honked they looked and walked away i called them from my car they said they would be right there (that was 10 minutes in i waited another 10+ no one ever came) i could have ordered a pizza from another pizza place when i pulled up and been home eating it in the time i wasted waiting on a pizza from them i called them again to let them know i was there to pick it up waited over 20 min and left and would not be returning and all they had to say was "ok we will throw it out" not even so much as a sorry or anything just like it was normal and acceptable to make customers wait forever read more

never order pizza from here have ordered pizza and everytime i have since they moved to ety road my service has been horrible i just sat at the pickup window for over 10 minutes watching people look at me then walk away previously they have forgotten to make my pizza i show up to pick it up they dont tell me they havent made it but it takes as long to get it as it was supposed to be in the first place ended up waiting twice the wait time then it was raw in like ruyn through your fingers raw wth it used to be great pizza and great service and it is still great pizza when its righ tits a shame that the horrible service negates how good their pizza is then i left and called them about and all they said was "sorry" and "ok" i hate that they were bought out and moved to a new location they have seriously gone to hell ever since read more