Best service possible sitting at the rail. Chelsea taught me all about pull tabs. She provided great recommendations and made me feel at home at this place. People go to restaurants for the experience not the food. She was the best. read more

Great place, food and Staff. Dusty was our server and was nice and helpful. Food was great, love the meat eaters calzone. Meatballs are super good as well. Will return again! Other staff I have great things to say about are Will, Devon and Chelsey. read more

We went there for lunch and believe it or not there werent alot of people their and the service was great and the food is amazing like always . We order the fire sticks and the creamy tomato soup! Yummy it was a great lunch read more

Excellent pizza, some of the best around. They now serve breakfast which is also amazing. Great staff and a good place to catch a game or just chill at the bar. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

Great pizza? Not really - but it's good..... They have something for everyone - great selection of toppings, very flexible for customizing you own pizza. Other dishes available of course. Nice servers. Would I go back? Yes, if I'm in Sumner - but I would not make it a destination. read more

I had "The Elliot" pizza, which Farrelli's touts as a recipe for diabetics. It was excellent and our server Aaron took excellent care of us. read more

See all

Firstly, the pizza here is pretty good. I like wood-fired pizzas (have a ceramic wood oven myself) and I find the pizza at Farrelli's very tasty. Haven't tried much else other than a salad a time or two, which have been fine. However, the service in the dining area is S...L...O...W Doesn't matter time of day, how busy or not they appear, it is a very long wait from being seated, to drink orders, to getting the bill. Mind you, I've never found the service to be unfriendly, but it is noticeable just how languid the pacing of a meal here tends to be. Also, the dining area is a bit of a mish mash, a more coherent look and feel would go a long ways towards a nicer atmosphere. Bathroom (men's room anyway) is tired and dirty, always a turnoff. So, the food is good to very good, so hopefully the in-house issues can get resolved, I'm willing to try a few more times for certain. read more

Ordered the artichoke dip appetizer, the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and the apple crumble. Customer service was great and the food came out quickly. We just moved to Bonney Lake and are happy to have found a good pizza place close to home. We will definitely be going back! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Apple crumble a la mode - so good! - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

The pizza is always good with delicious crust. The service wasn't very good for only a few people being in the bar during lunch. The waiter and bartender were too busy talking selfies instead of waiting on customers. read more

Good west coast based pizza and very kid friendly. We like to come at least once a month. It's the least stressful dining experience we have with our 3 little kids and the food is goo too! read more

Stopped in this past Sunday late afternoon. We sat in the bar. Clean , welcoming atmosphere. Right away as we were walking in our server Shannon kindly greeted us. Food and drinks were great. Staff overall were great. Will be back. read more

Everything at/from Farrelli's is top notch awesome...staff, decor, environment, and of course the food. Never disappointed when I go there. Thanks for always providing the best of everything. read more

I'm a huge fan of wood-fired oven pizza. The slightly charred crust, the smoky flavor mingling with the cheese and meat, adding a nice, acidic tang to the sauce. Delicious. This pizza had tangy sauce. Otherwise, it had nothing else a wood-fired oven offers. I even asked for crispy crust, which didn't really happen. Really, it's on par with Round Table. Fresher-tasting, but this is not what most people look for in wood-fired oven pizza. Just OK. read more

Extravagant food and service! Service was quick, nice and fast. Our server Rochelle was terrific! So kind and sweet! Very friendly! Great happy hour prices!!! Will return! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

Good food, calzone was a bit small for 15 dollars. Food took quite awhile to come out

Not the best experience. Dined on a sunny Sunday afternoon. Our server was friendly and accommodating. Overall we came away underwhelmed. Our pizzas were adequate but lacked in the flavor/seasoning department. The seating layout is oddly shaped, but not a negative. The rest if the staff seemed distracted. Again not a big deal, just an observation. I ordered a mojito -- it was foul. Thick and way too sweet. Hopefully it was the execution and not the recipe. I asked for a beer instead and out server was happy to oblige. Not bad. Not good either. Room for improvement. read more

Very good. Pizza was very good, service was very good,cocktail was also very good..overall good experience ...we will go again...we had the Hawaiian pizza, the only thing that would have made it better would be more red sauce...we liked the dressing on the chop chop salad a lot. This is a nice little neighborhood bar and pizza place in Sumner near the Fred Meyers. ..not sure if they have any more locations. .. Google Farrelly ' s read more

Staff was friendly and nice and food was delicious. Drinks were good too my only complaint was appetizers took forever but that was fine with me we weren't in a hurry. read more

Our server Tayler was excellent but we're all still missing the Picacho bytesA great place to watch sports with all the TVs and a nice fireplace read more

Cool concept but nothing special. Great bar and atmosphere but the pizza was really greasy. Pasta was greasy as well and actually made me pretty nautious to be honest. We were pretty bummed this place wasn't as good as expected... read more

Prices are ridiculous. Service is so slow even though they were almost emply. Would hate to see how long it would take if they actually had several customers. Went for lunch, and it took an hour and fifteen minutes to get two slices of pizza and a full size lunch salad. Will not be returning. read more

We really liked this place. Don't know why it has 3.5 stars. Great pizza and service. Manager was very attentive. Overall great experience. Give it a shot. read more

This is my husband and my date spot either after church or when we crave the spaghetti and meatballs. We drive from the Kent East hill all the way to Sumner for this place. We had one bad experience and the Manager Autumn invited us back. I didn't want to go back but my husband did so we went back and never ever had a bad experience since then. The people who work there are amazing! And the food .. Perfect. This past Sunday we finished church and waited outside 45 mins for this place to open and once again service was excellent , Jesse was our server and the food was delicious. I had the spaghetti and NY husband had the meat calzone. We both agreed that the cook on that day cooked the best food. Thanks for being there for our special date nights Farellis! We love being a part of your family read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

This pizza is well below average! We had a relatively large group for a work function and thought this would be quick and appealing for all. The ingredient quality and portion of toppings was poor considering the price. Our co-worker recommended, but believed the place has gone downhill since her last visit. The pizza was flavorless beyond being just plain salty! Plenty of other options around here to choose on our next visit. read more

Come here often, pretty good pizza and like the dads cheddar bacon salad!! Good service to always sit in the bar great drinks awesome bartender! read more

Finally went back again and they redeemed themself. Very happy too because this place has great food!

Had Joe as my server today. He did a phenomenal job. Great attitude, really attentive and overall excellent service.

Needs some improvements on drinks, i ordered "raspberry lemon drop" was VERY SWEET, i let it go first time. So my next drink i ordered a "lemon drop" Way to sweet end up taking it back.., coming from bartending industry those drinks were not even near what it's called lemon drop or raspberry drop! Other than that go from place to hang out read more

Your website has errors. I can't even order one day in advance, it freezes after the order, no payment option, no confirmation. Are you in business to sell pizzas and make money? Are you unaware of your website inefficiency? Try placing an order at 11:30pm a day before, choose a time for curbside pickup, then watch as nothing happens after that. Click on everything possible and frustrate yourself. Thanks a lot. read more

Although the pizza is ok, as a guy from Nyc who never paid $31.00 for a pizza, I will never buy another pizza from them. You not even close to authentic to Nyc or Chicago. Sorry read more

I waited 30 mins for a table for 4. 2 kids under age of 10, were cranky and hungry. 2 parties of 5 were seated before us. The hostess thought we had more in our party when we were sitting right in front. Pizza and cheese sticks were good though. Being "busy" because they can't hear how many in a customers party is not a worthy excuse. If you listened, you'd seat the customers correctly in a quick wait time.... read more

My terrible experience at Farrelli's compelled me to open a Yelp account. No food. No respect. No way. We waited 45-60 and did not receive our very simple order. During that time we received no indication that there would be a delay and were only checked on once in that time. When asked about the progress of our meal the waitstaff accused us of lying about our wait time and would check the time stamp on our receipt. It was clear that they forgot our order. Having waited nearly an hour the waitstaff then informed us that our pizzas would be fired soon. There was no apology for their error or long wait. We asked to pay for the 1 drink and small side salad we received and informed the staff we wanted to leave. They offered for us to speak a manager but one never met with us. Apologies were given to other tables for the wait but not ours. After the fact they blamed a party for the long wait time. We order 1 small pizza, a personal size pizza, and a small side salad. All we wanted was a quick and simple lunch with my mother on a Saturday. We ended up going to a nearby local restaurant and were served a delicious meal in 10 minutes. read more

I am so happy that on our final night of dining in the south end was in a high note. Devon, our server, was so attentive and made sure we were never without what we needed. He made great recommendations on the menu, and told us how he would modify it according to our dietary restrictions. It was amazing! I truly have not had better service in an incredibly long time, if ever. We had gluten free pizza with tons of veggies and mama's signature salad. If we are ever back down south we will definitely be eating here! read more

I like to think I'm a relatively reasonable person. I don't expect a whole lot and I'm pretty nice. That being said I am baffled and appalled at Farrelli's in Sumner, WA. I have had the same situation happen to me 5 time now. 5 TIMES over the last year. I call and order a Fettuccine Alfredo. Two ingredients and they're right in the name. 5 times I have gone, picked up my order and went home to open it to find NO ALFREDO SAUCE. That's right. Noodles. I paid almost $15 for a pile of noodles. I got exactly half of what I paid for. Sometimes, if I had added bacon or sausage, it tastes like maybe they tossed the pasta and meat together. It's all oily and greasy. If there is ANY alfredo sauce there is almost none. I mean the cheap $1 microwaveable Fettuccine Alfredo has more "alfredo" in it. I've tried ordering it different ways. I've tried adding extra alfredo sauce. I even ordered it once with sauce on the side. I ended up getting no sauce on the side and no alfredo on my noodles. I have never once gone up there screaming because I am not that person. I returned the dish once and then the next time I went there the person working the bar treated me like an idiot, heckling me "make sure you check it for alfredo". I can't wrap my head around it. How can the staff be that ignorant? It can't be possible. Then is it malevolence? What is happening???!!!! All I want to do is order the simplest Italian dish ever created and they can't put noodles and sauce (both of which they have) together? I go to this place all the time and get drinks and/or carry out pizza. But I hardly ever order the pasta because of this issue. I wait a bit and decide to try it again and this. I have been going there for 3 years now on a monthly basis I would say. Tonight is the final straw and I won't be going back. If their cooks can't grasp the concept of putting fettuccine and alfredo together how are they qualified to handle my food? Think about that. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Oil from my bacon and Parmesan cheese I added. No Alfredo Sauce on my Fettuccine Alfredo. - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

See all

I had a day....a crazy one. I'm pregnant and emotionally unstable. But, the bartender here, Chelsea made my day. She pulled me a good winner in pull tabs, fed me, and said how sweet I was. Food is great...service is better. This place was packed and I watched these servers scramble to get everyone's last minute happy hour orders in. Unless you work at a place with happy hour you have no idea about this struggle. It was madness and they killed it. read more

I will admit - their pizza is good, brick oven fired and tasty. I won't be back here though. The last time I went we had 6 people, we gave our name and were told there would be a 5 minute wait. After 15 minutes we asked and they said they would seat us very soon. In walks a bigger group (about 8) and they begin angling for a big table that was clearing. I could hardly believe it when they sat them there, then tried to seat us at two back to back booths....right by a large, noisy party of kids - we said no and asked why did they seat that other group when we had been there longer and they gave some bs lie about how they may have called in before they arrived and told of their big group (they don't take reservations)...it was a total lie. I will never go here again. read more

This is our favorite pizza place! Not only is the food yummy and the staff friendly, they are also clean and quick. My son can have pizza here because they carry dairy-free cheese. The Pep,pep pizza is delish. It's a great place to take your family for dinner or your friends for a night out. read more

THIS PLACE ROCKS, because it is free, because my team wins trivia every MONDAY.

If the sign on your door says you are open until 2am, stay open until 2am. Don't turn me away at 1:30 saying your kitchen is closed. If you are still serving alcohol you legally have to serve food. read more

Super friendly staff! Great happy hour menu. Personal pizzas took a little longer than expected (over 30 mins) since they weren't very busy. Pizzas were really good, chop salad was ok, items could've been cut smaller. read more