We recently moved to the area and have been looking for a good pizza place. This is the place!! The restaurant is small and cozy and intimate. The lighting is perfect. Every time we have came here the staff is really friendly and the service is quick. We usually order the Wicked's No Equal. It has pepperoni, sausage, garlic, ricotta and oregano with a red sauce and the garlic bread sticks. We've also tried the cheesy bread and both are delicious. The pizza is so good! The right level of crisp and it always comes out hot and fresh. The toppings they use are high quality and have so much flavor. We love this place so much! If you join their rewards it's linked through the Toast app. It's very easy to use and your points stack up fast giving you $5 off pretty quickly and then $10 off for your birthday. Best pizza in town, we are obsessed. read more

See all

Another place unfortunately I did not take pics. Here for the first time because I was craving pizza and was going to a concert afterwards. Waitstaff was extremely nice and accommodating. But for $30 to build my own small pizza with sausage, mushroom, onion and roasted peppers, there wasn't a whole heck of a on it. Pizza was good I will say that, but I think they could have been a little more generous with what they put on. Caesar salad was good but I think they should have called it a crouton Caesar salad. Way too many croutons and the salad was pretty much doused in dressing. read more

We went off and each got a large pizza and shared. We really enjoyed their pizzas! The environment is a mix of bar and restaurant. But it wasn't too loud when we went. Service was a little delayed and took a while for our food to come out. But nothing of major concern. Our waitress was very attentive and helpful! read more

See all

Wicked Pie Pizza is one of a kind. Loved their "Say It Ain't So" Pizza and their meatballs appetizer. The Pizza crust was light and airy, crisp and perfectly done. Their takeout service was prompt. I am definitely going to dine-in the next time and try their meat pizzas. Tip: Free bubbly Dec 31st with a large pizza purchase!!! read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza I have tried in the area. The inside is very creative from the chandeliers to the bar. It's fun. This is wood fired pizza with a perfect crust! We tried the cheese sticks which are really good and then the pizza was just AMAZING! I don't think you can go wrong with any of them! Try it you WILL NOT REGRET it!b read more

For a $30 pizza, this was honestly below subpar. We ended up throwing away over half of it. The crust was so hard it felt like we were eating chips, and the pizza was extremely greasy--so much so that we had to dab it with paper towels as soon as we picked up a slice. We also waited over 20 minutes for pickup. The employee kept forgetting my name and asked me four separate times; each time she got distracted and never checked on our order. We ordered cheese bread and chicken wings, which were both fine. However, we paid extra for ranch and did not receive the ranch we paid for. This is the second disappointing experience we've had here in the past few months. After being loyal customers for several years, we likely won't be returning. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Large Wicked's No Equal - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

My mom and I were in Puyallup for the Sew Expo and having a craving for some pizza, so we headed to their cute little downtown area for some Wicked Pie. Lucky for us, we happened to be there while they were celebrating their 8th anniversary, so they had a sweet offer going on: complimentary champagne and cheesy bread! We enjoyed our bubbly, and the delish bread, while we perused the pizza menu. While several combos were tempting, we were feeling adventurous and ordered "The Chosen One," which is their semi-secret pie which has no ingredients listed and just the promise that we would love it. And yes, we did! The Chosen One is a fairly simple pizza but wow, was it good. I won't share the toppings because, hey, the mystery was part of the fun. But let's just say, it was quite yummy. We ordered a small and it was more than enough for the two of us to share. I also ordered a cold pint of Manny's because, hey, when in Rome! I appreciated that this was a 21+ pizza joint, and I loved the "haunted house" vibe. The service was also super fast, and super friendly. I will definitely make a point of returning here next time I'm in town for the Sew Expo! read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

My husband and I frequent this establishment, especially on Sundays because they have an awesome happy hour. That is until today when we got our bill! we each had two happy hour well drinks I had a well margarita and he had a well screwdriver. There was a $2 up charge per drink. When I asked the waitress why there was an extra eight dollars on our bill. She looked at it for a long time before she started trying to explain the fact that they are specialty cocktails because there's mix in them. It was utterly ridiculous. I know what a well drink is and a margarita with cheap tequila and a screwdriver are definitely well drinks. they really need to advertise what they consider a well drink. And they should educate their staff on this. Because Brooke our waitress had no idea what she was talking about!! WE WILL NOT BE RETURNING read more

I tried Wicked Pie Pizza, which specializes in fired artisan pies, based on a recommendation from South Sound Magazine. They had just won an award from the niche National Magazine "Pizza Today" and to commemorate the Pizza Today honor, Wicked Pie Pizza was offering $5 off any large pie. I got a large "Say It Ain't So" Pizza and the Wicked Fired Meatballs. I must say this place delivered with some really good pizza. The crust was amazing, and the toppings were really interesting in a good way. I put in an online order, and they had my items ready at the time mentioned. Although I did not eat-in, I can say that the ambience was great, good to catch a game and some beer to go with your pizza. Service was also prompt and good. I will definitely be trying this place out more and will definitely keep them in mind any time I am craving artisan pizzas. There is only Street Parking, which definitely hampers the experience. read more

Delicious pizza. We love the crispy crust. I also love this location in old Puyallup. The service was attentive and friendly. The food was a little slow getting to us but it was worth the wait. I presume they had a staff issue last night. We'll be back. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Flying Pig Pizza (sausage, pepperoni, prosciutto) - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

My husband and I have been living in Puyallup for about 2 years and have had this place on our list for awhile. Unfortunately we were very disappointed. We went in on a Monday during happy hour and they were fairly busy. We were more than patient and while the waiter was very nice, it was unfortunate that he didn't have help. We asked for ranch 3 times during our meal and never received it. The breadsticks were good and the pizza was okay. Unfortunately my husband received his soda and there was a dead bug in the cup, while this did get replaced , it was pretty gross and I felt like it was missed due to the staff rushing. The ambiance of the restaurant was alright, it is a lot smaller on the inside, but while we were trying to watch the football channel, the tv kept glitching and was unwatchable during our long wait. We were pretty disappointed after wanting to come to this place for so long. read more

See all

Very disappointed. There mozzarella cheese was really ricotta. They denied it. Won't go back

Yum! The cheese on the breadsticks and pizza was melted to perfection, and the meatballs were a great addition to our meal. Our servers were attentive to our needs. The space inside is small and gets quite busy, so we might try takeout next time. read more

See all

I think they forgot the word "Awesome" in their name - should be Wicked Awesome Pie Pizza as that would best describe this place. In celebration of their anniversary, each guest is given a glass of champagne and each table receives their famous cheese bread for FREE (my favorite four letter F word) Their pizza is made with love. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, the crust is my favorite and the herbs in the sauce are not over powering - just the perfect blend. The ambiance is fun, vibrant and filled with laughter from happy customers. Their staff is attentive and friendly. We were lucky to have Brie helping us today. Our glasses were never empty, out table was never filled with dirty dishes (nor any other around us). It was super busy when we were there but that didn't stop Brie from smiling, making sure we were all taken care of while cleaning off tables to seat waiting customers. We never felt rushed. Highly recommend Wicked Pie Pizza! read more

See all

The best pie in South Sound. Hands down. The staff is amazing, the vibe fantastic, and the drinks well-poured.

Wicked Pie Pizza -- Puyallup's Wood-Fired Wonder If you're wandering downtown Puyallup and catch a whiff of something smoky, cheesy, and downright irresistible, follow your nose to Wicked Pie Pizza. This 21+ spot isn't just slinging pies--it's throwing a full-on flavor party with wood-fired swagger and a side of local charm. The Pizza: Artisan Meets Attitude Every pie here is hand-tossed, fire-kissed, and loaded with personality. The Flying Pig brings sweet and savory into perfect harmony with applewood bacon and pineapple, while the Twisted Hawaiian adds a spicy kick that'll make you rethink everything you thought you knew about tropical pizza. Crust? Light, airy, and crispy like it just graduated from sourdough school with honors A B. Starters That Steal the Show Don't skip the Famous Cheesy Bread--it's gooey, golden, and served with house-made marinara that tastes like Nonna's secret recipe got a smoky upgrade C. The Wicked Fired Meatballs and Pesto Flatbread are also crowd favorites, perfect for sharing (or not, we won't judge). Vibe Check: Cozy, Quirky, and Grown-Up Inside, it's part nostalgic pub, part edgy biker bar, with TVs for game night and a patio that glows under string lights. It's adults-only, so expect a chill crowd, great cocktails, and zero screaming toddlers. The Bloody Mary garnished with a pizza slice? Iconic A. Service & Scene Staff are friendly, fast, and know their menu. It can get loud and busy, especially on weekends, but the energy is part of the charm. Parking's tight, so bring your walking shoes or your luck. Final Verdict Wicked Pie Pizza is a slice of Puyallup pride--bold, flavorful, and unapologetically wicked. Whether you're a crust connoisseur, a meatball maniac, or just in it for the vibes, this place delivers. One bite and you'll be saying, "Okay, this is how pizza should taste." read more

My son and I stopped in for a late lunch. It was not rush hour (2:10 on a Saturday). There were 4 empty 4-top tables but they would not seat us because we were only a party of 2. He said we could sit outside but those tables and chairs were wet. I'm still in disbelief that they would rather have empty tables than seat a party of 2. I've never before given a one star review but I believe this is warranted based on this establishment's clear disregard for their customers. read more

Twisted Hawaiian and cheese bread were amazing. Service was great, they are attentive but want you in and out (which is understandable) Wine was pricey but on par with most places. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Small Twisted Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

Award-winning pizza did not disappoint. It was incredible. Service was fabulous. Interesting options were provided and I loved my choices.

Amazing food. Best pizza crust in Washington. The service was nice. We sat outside on a "parklet" which was an outside seating area with flowers. You can enjoy good food and listen to the trains pass by. read more

See all

Pizza crust is burnt every time we order from there. This used to be a great place, favorite pizza place in town but the last 4-6 months its consistently burnt crust and toppings are toasted. I tried to reach out to someone there but no response. Frankly, if I wanted to be disappointed with my food I wouldn't spend $30 a pizza on it. The salad was great though. read more

Awesome pizza, IPA and cannoli! And we are picky! Service was prompt and wonderful! We WILL be back! read more

Good service and pretty good pizza. 21 and over with about 4 beers on the menu. I had a couple glasses of the house pils and it was very nice. Inside its cool place but super loud and very long waits. We enjoyed the pepperoni, mob boss and Hawaiian. All were good. IMO, the Hawaiian didn't need bacon. The mob boss had a great balance of flavor. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Mob boss - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Love, love their pizzas! Guests must be 21 or older to go inside, so it's not really a family-friendly spot for dining in. Prices are on the higher end, but they have a happy hour all day on Sunday. Date spot for sure!!! read more

I've had WPP a few times, but always take out so I was looking forward to eating inside this time! There was a good amount of seating & I was pleased that they had a bar to sit at. We went on a Wednesday, so naturally we ordered a bottle of wine for half off! We enjoyed the cheesy bread, the caesar salad, and a large Chosen One. WOW. I was thoroughly impressed. Cheesy bread was perfect & the marinara on the side was delicious. The salad had huge slivers of parmesan that I very much appreciated. But the star of the night was the pizza. The Chosen One came with everything that is in the arugula pear salad + sausage, jalapeños & ricotta cheese. It hit every single flavor note that it needed to & I have been raving about it to everyone ever since. I can't wait to come back here!! read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - The Chosen One - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Great place for a night out on the town. We have frequented wicked pies a couple of times. 21+ restaurant with good atmosphere for a couple drinks and great conversation if you are looking for a romantic quiet atmosphere this might not be the place. More of an upbeat and easy going environment every time we visit we see someone we know, a great hometown place. Food is consistently good and we have had good and bad service depending on busyness. The beer was good but the mojito left much to be desired for. Worth a visit. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Large Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

Great service .Great Pizza .Great time. A fun place to meet up and have a truly tasty pizzza

I have never been to Wicked Pie Pizza and have been wanting to try it for sometime. I placed an online order and it said it would be ready in about 20 minutes. By the time I got there (and found someone to help me) it was ready to go. It is extremely loud in there so I was happy that I got my food to go. The reason for the 2 stars is because they forgot one of my toppings on the whole pizza, the middle of my pizza was not fully cooked, the toppings are dispersed very unevenly and their online menu versus their online ordering prices are different. The lady that helped me was super nice and appreciated the cash tip. I'm not sure I'll be back, it was an okay pizza, but kinda pricey for what it was and for the above mentioned errors. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - 1/2 and 1/2 large pizza (8 slices) missing olives and undercooked....the toppings are also dispersed very uneven. - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Going on a Sunday for their happy hour menu is a must! Really great deals and the food was delicious. The space was very welcoming and relaxing. Our waitress was on it and never left us waiting. My husband and I will definitely be back again!! read more

This is a great happy hour spot! 1 topping pizza for $10! Food: 5/5 I've only had the pizza here but it's a nice thin crust and the pepperoni sausage ricotta was definitely a favorite. Service: 5/5 Quick fast and friendly service at the table and at the bar! Ambiance: 5/5 It's a pub vibe, 21+ only, and has a dive bar feel. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Pepperoni sausage ricotta - delicious - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Arugula Pear Salad is absolutely amazing! Literally made me dine there two days in a row lol. Paired great with their St Michelle Riesling. Service was great. So friendly and attentive. I went on a Saturday evening and Sunday lunch and there were plenty of street parking and free lot parking available. Will definitely come back. Just keep in mind the place is for 21 and over only. Leave the kids with a babysitter :) read more

We usually rave about Wicked Pie but the past couple times we were not very impressed and I think tonight's to go order was probably the deal breaker for us. Before the pizza used to be the best in town and the top spot to bring guests. However in the most recent times, the pizza is very thin, you no longer can get a large with two different flavors, the overall quality has degraded. Tonight's pizza was super thin, cheese and crust was so chewy you could break a jaw. We ordered and paid for two larges and one of them was clearly smaller. Plus the chicken on the Chicken Bacon Ranch was dry. I'm usually a fan of New York thin slices but I don't even know what this pizza would qualify as. The ranch was great, as it should be because they charge for it. Now maybe the experience would be better if we ate it at the restaurant but for $65 for two pizzas, it should taste somewhat edible at the venue or in the comfort of your own home. I gave two stars (barely) because we've been in the past and it was amazing so I'm not going to forget that but yikes...the taste and quality is unfortunately derailing. What's truly wicked about this place is the fact that they're charging THOSE prices for THAT pizza. read more

See all

Most gluten free pizzas taste like an after thought, but not here! I got the cheese pizza and it was AMAZING!!! Service was great, ambiance is fun, 1000% will return. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Gluten free cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

21 and over place for pizza and drinks? Sign me up! Came in on a Thursday during lunch and was seated instantly. Staff is friendly, vibes are good. We ordered a large pizza and my husband and I both ate two slices and had a half of a pizza left over for later. The pizza had quality ingredients! We got the one with the bbq sauce, chicken, pineapple, etc. We drank the house Pilsner and it was crisp and refreshing. Overall, a nice spot to come and have good eats and yummy drinks. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Our second visit was fantastic Busy atmosphere and prompt service Very happy with the quality of the pizzas as well read more

Great pizza people! Nice work. Had a couple gals mix me a cocktail, pour a beer. Splendid

We stopped by for lunch today after checking out comicon at the fairgrounds. There was a great happy hour selection and lots of pies to choose from that sounded very enticing. We went with the Twisted Hawaiian. The pizza was phenomenal! I'm not an expert, but I would call it delicious woodfire New York style pizza. The crust and dough are fantastic and you can really taste the oregano and spices in the sauce, it really complimented the high quality toppings they're using. Not only was the pizza impressive but so was our server! I don't recall if her name was Destiny or Desiree, blame the pizza coma, but she was attentive and very friendly. Offered refills even up to the point of boxing up our pizza, which she also took care of for us. We didn't have to wait for water or refills, we were given extra napkins before even having a chance to ask, and we didn't wait forever for the check/box. About as perfect of a dining experience one could get. We look forward to visiting again when we are in the area! read more

Came into town in Dec and found this place on Yelp! Did not disappoint ..best artisan pizza! Service was fast and the wait for food wasn't long. That night we had Santa come in to say hello and that night there was live music. Wish we had this restaurant in Vancouver! read more

Pizza was fantastic and good beer selection. Sat at bar and had a great time. Would definitely go again if I was ever back in Puyallup.

Popped in because we were down south and Wicked Pie was closer than driving back towards our necka the woods. Didn't realize it was happy hour and snagged 2 pepperoni pizzas for $10 bucks each instead of $17. I added sausage to mine for 2.50. Pizza was greasy, over sauced and salty, not bad but I couldn't eat a lot of it, really liked the crispy crust though. I also got the garlic bread which I ate ALL of because it was super crispy, warm and wasn't "too" garlicky. Partner got the pear salad and that was pretty solid too, not too much bleu cheese and tons of candied nuts and cranberries which made the arugula way more tolerable. It's kinda loud inside, definitely sports bar feel. Service is friendly. read more

Wicked Pie Pizza - Happy hour pepperoni and pepperoni with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all