This is mostly a catering shop but they do offer a menu for dine-in or carryout. They have a daily special. As far as food goes, its fantastic.The recipes are unique and I've never had anything that isn't blow your mind good. That said, this is a unique little spot in a strip mall; its not much of a "destination" so don't go looking for ambiance. The employees are so friendly, I'm always offered a free little taste of something, and the food keeps me coming back for more. And more. And more. read more

Great sandwiches and soups. Ruben and chicken tortilla soup is what I had on my last visit and they were so delicious. Top it all off with a brownie and my lunch was complete. This place is always busy for lunch but well worth the wait. read more

Had a Reuben and a cup of vegetarian chili. Both were yummy. Always a good meal here. Never disappointed. My friend had a reuben too with a tomato basil bisque soup. Tasted it and it was very good. Had a sample of dessert and raspberry mousse was spectacular. Can't wait for my next visit read more

Love this place! Come here at least once a week for lunch, Which is about 80% of my lunches eaten out. If I'm feeling like eating healthier I get the chicken appleberry salad. Otherwise I get the Cajun chicken club with spinach artichoke pasta. I haven't had a bad thing on the menu! I try to get there early because they get PACKED at lunch, which is just a sign of how tasty the food is! read more

Good sandwiches, avoid the soup. Sandwiches are tasty, like the pasta side dishes they have. However, I've ordered three different soups and they've all been very disappointing - most water, and always very thin. I expect a thicker, heartier soup. read more

Fancy Pantry makes good sandwiches, salads, and soups, but it's always a little hectic during lunch time. The Portobello loaf is good, but rich. They shout out every order from the counter, so you may want to sit outside. read more

By far the best catering I have ever had. I order lunch for my office every month, and all the food brought from Fancy Pantry was amazing. Not only was all the food great, but Fiona was exceptional as well. She started helping us with other items at our party as well, and was so helpful throughout the entire night. I don't know what we would have done without her! Our office is still talking about the food a week later! read more

Such a delicious place to eat! I came here with coworkers to have lunch today and at first I was going to have a solo lunch but I decided to just have my lunch with people instead and boy was I glad! This place is like a version of Panera Bread only it's your mom and pop's kind of place! The place is very spacious and their menu has a very vast array of selections to choose from including your wraps, salads, and sandwiches. Each day they make their daily specials so I had their Tilapia Taco and it was SO DELISH! I couldn't believe how fresh the ingredients were and how just all the flavor profiles went well together! The tilapia taco came in a wrap along with mango salsa, which I loved and you get to choose your side-I had the red potato salad and it was very good. I devoured my lunch in 15 minutes! I couldn't believe how fast I had finished my lunch! Towards the end, I found out that they served strawberry lemonade so I asked the runner/bus boy if they had that to serve as part of their fountain drinks. She was super polite and nice and told me that specialty drinks are separate from fountain drinks. Five minutes later, she came back with a complimentary sample drink to taste! It was REALLY good, guys! I was very shocked and impressed with their service and just down-right sincerity of being genuine that I fell in love with the place! I wish they served those tilapia tacos everyday, but now I'm kinda curious to see what they offer every day in their daily specials! Definitely coming back whenever I have time and taking the bestie with me too! Thanks Mr. and Ms. Kennedy for providing me with a fantastic lunch! read more

Delicious Apple salad, though a little overpriced once you add chicken. No vibe, vanilla atmosphere. Hits the spot for a quick weekday lunch. read more

Fancy Pantry was contracted with to provide a brunch, with the original count of 30, at a backyard wedding approximately 3.5 months ahead of the event. The menu was finalized and all was well. Two months prior to the event, as the COVID pandemic continued, Fancy Pantry was notified that 8 people would not be in attendance and the count was changing from 30 to 22. The response from Sadie (the owner) was "Sounds good". "This Covid world is a mess." So it was a surprise when, two weeks later and with a final count of 21-22 Sadie sent a note: "I am not sure how to proceed....such a tiny event". I did not want Sadie to lose money so I responded "Charge whatever is fair....do not want you to lose money". All was well (at least for me). Another week goes by and another note from Sadie: "Typically we do not go out on an event for less than $1,000.00 worth of food. We made an exception since your group was a little smaller due to Covid. But now I am not sure what to do, because I want to be fair to your group also." All I could think was, she knew the size of the group and had responded "Sounds good" but all of a sudden it is a problem so I inquired as to her intent. The response (17 days before the event!) was surprising: "If you have another option, I would love for you to take that. How about the afternoon caterer? Is he able to do the brunch, by chance?" This was followed by a phone call from Sadie to me berating my wedding planner who she had NEVER met and extolling her own business...shameful! In retrospect, Sadie did us a favor as this story has a happy Cinderella ending. The evening (reception) caterer (Chef Cary's Cuisine) delivered the "glass slipper", providing a wonderful selection of delectable, palate pleasing delights for the brunch and evening meals. read more

Ok, so I work out in suburbia and my office building doesn't have a restaurant/cafe so we're forced to go out at lunch if we forget to bring something from home (or we brought something three days ago and the cleaning crew rummaged through the fridge after hours and mowed through the leftovers like a pig in heat). Enter: Fancy Pantry. It's close and convenient but Jesus H. Christ! I thought the "Soup Nazi" was bad in NYC! He ain't got nuttin' on these people! There is a certain procedure that MUST be followed or you get humiliated! There are ABSOLUTELY NO SUBSTITUTIONS PERMITTED and there is a big sign alerting you to this when you arrive - right next to the "Welcome" sign which I find strangely ironic! Ironic, you know? Kinda like when J.T. ripped off Janet Jackson's leather b**b cover during the Super Bowl halftime show that year and then had the audacity to say that it "was an accident?" Honey, you were wearing some sort of shield on your bosom like you weren't expecting company at some point that night?! Puh-leeeze! The food is decent, but God help you if you'd like the Portabella Mushroom Wrap with no tomatoes! You'd think you'd just asked for the owner's first-born! Are these people so freakin' programmed that they can't just skip the light pink (no, they're not ripe hence my request to leave them off) tomatoes and just proceed to the wilted spinach? Seriously?! You GOTTA put it on there? What the heck happened to "Have It Your Way!"? Oh wait! That was Burger King back in the "old days" as my nephew refers to it! At Fancy Pantry, their motto is more like, "Have It OUR Way or Don't Get the S.O.B. At All!" Bottom line... Food: Decent if you're in a pinch and have an extra $8-10 for lunch. Customer Service: Horrible. read more

I used to really like this place but when I went in today two different people handle my sandwich with no gloves on. Gross, I won't be back! I hope he wasn't sick or cleaning toilets. That's just disgusting! read more

This is a great lunch spot. I like supporting small businesses, and this is just down the road from my office. I like their sandwiches and sides the best. I wish they would switch up their salad menu more- but that's probably just because I go there so frequently. It is quality food but a little pricey- the club sandwich and side was almost $14. I love their lemonade as well. There's is also an awkward waiting space for your order where you kind of stand on top of the tables that are dining in. Overall it's a great option to pop in and grab something different from the regular lunch spots. read more

everyone at my job loves this place. to me it is kind of ehhhhh. the wait time is a little chaotic,. the menu is a little hard to read. everyone in there is in a rush and the seating is limited. and worse than limited- its uncomfortable. hungy and not happy. and then i get my sammy. and its a little greasy. and the macaroni salad is not macaroni salad. and oh wait they called my friends number but we didnt her it. so they scream even louder and MEANER. and then she rushes up there and grabs the tray. the food is good. the atmosphere and ambiance is not. maybe it will be better when we actually use the outside seating. read more

My favorite lunch spot at the office. They have good selection of salads. I like the rub on the tilapia and the salmon has great smoked taste. They also have good daily soup selections. read more

Great lunch spot - delicious salads, soups, and sandwiches. Also have a great little kids menu with a few sandwich options.. and they brought my 4 year old a free chocolate chip cookie. Sweet little families owned place. Easy in & out. read more

I should've known better. The patio was blasting gimme-my-nickleback to the rising plastic forks of boring-ville. But, I do live a boring stones throw from the latest "hot on" locale. The menu is large and expansive, I will give props where props are due. However, my new yorker was probably worse than jasons deli. The rye was a puffy, wonder-esque attempt. And why does everyone in Atlanta try to be more NY by piling on their shi##y version of Katz's pastrami until it resembles the leaning tower? It sucks so please put less of it. A glutton for punishment, woe is me. I guess I'm still looking fir a deli as good as Capozzis south of the m-d line. But this ain't it, y'all. read more

Clearly, Sadie loves food. And her staff. And her customers. Sadie is one of the owners of Fancy Pantry Cafe, and this was such a weird and wonderful eating experience. I ate there when it wasn't open. I ordered something I didn't care for, and totally didn't understand how this place was, and in the end I could not help but love this restaurant. When I first came in, I was confused. The Yelp look up said they did breakfast, but the hours on the door said they didn't open until 10:30. The activity inside was at full speed, so I went in. I ordered a Cuban at the counter, and when it came, the flavor of the sauce translated as icky in my mouth. Sadie, alerted to my distress, leaped into action. Her prime concern was that the food wasn't sound. Apparently, it's my pallet that is faulty, but she didn't make me feel like I was wrong. She affirmed that it wasn't unsafe or spoiled, but as I didn't like it, let's try again. How about the Ruben? Okay? Moments later she sets me up with a delightful side, a pasta with Gorgonzola, her favorite, and now my favorite, too. The Ruben, classic, was marvelous. She gave me a taste of what the staff was sampling, a mini beef Wellington. It too was superb. This place was extremely busy with a dozen staff diligently tackling massive catering orders, but I could see that the ALL love what they do. They love food. They love their customers. And this high expectation set by the owners is part of the delicious flavor imbued in dishes served here. Come and see. read more

This place is amazing. The best bang for your buck in Alpharetta, nothing is overpriced. Everything I've ever ordered here is fresh and delicious. I suggest the salmon club, it's a triple decker sandwich with bacon and Avocado. Can I say it's just amazing lol. Anyways I definitely recommend this place to anyone. read more

Meh. Pricey for what you get. Plastic utensils me paper plates serving average food at a premium price. $10 Reuben with probably 5 oz of meat and a greasy non-stick sprayed loaf of store bought bread = not a winner. Publix makes a better sandwich and is nicer and faster to boot. read more

Fancy Pantry is delicious! I go at least once a week to get a salad & soup.

This is my favorite lunch place .There Cobb salad and dressing is Amazing . The salads come in medium or large your pick and everything is fresh made when you order . The service is exceptional and also quick . They do have space for you to order in and take out and also have patio seating .They have sandwiches,soups and wraps as well along with a bunch of other items . You can also place a call for pick up . They do also offer catering as well . read more

I still love it. Coming back to Alpharetta is a delectable treat for me because my beloved chicken pear walnut salad awaits me. They have a wonderful catering menu and staff, and I have experienced their catering many many times. They make lovely caprese skewers, the most amazing mini beef wellingtons, delicious buffalo chicken dip, et cetera. I had my college graduation party catered and all my friends fell in love with the food too. To this day, one friend is a proud patron of the buffalo chicken dip. Their catering staff is wonderful, as we had an entire party prepared, set up, and cleaned up by a lovely woman. This food is seriously gourmet, and once you try it, I guarantee you'll be hooked. read more

Met a friend here today for lunch, had been hearing a lot of good things about it. I had the special, tuna walnut salad sandwich with red potatoes. The sandwich was delicious, potatoes were just ok. My friend had the triple mushroom soup and half a Cuban, she enjoyed hers. It was good but to me, just a little pricey compared to most sandwich places, my special with drink was over $12.00. read more

They catered an event at my office and it was an absolute hit. I will be coming there for lunch in the future!

Great local deli-style restaurant providing great salads and sandwiches. Reasonably priced, great choices, terrific customer service and willingness to allow for any customizations desired. They have limited hours of operation, so please check out the web site before heading over, but make sure you go there on a regular basis throughout the hot summer months. Delicious!! read more

Went in here for lunch. Was a little bit crowded but not too bad.For $9 I got the Cuban and a small potato salad. It was a good sandwich but not worth the money. Maybe I am just not a sandwich guy but I left the restaurant unsatisfied. There are better places in Alpharetta (Grouchy's for example). read more

Came in for lunch, and though it took me a while to figure out what I wanted since there were too many tasty-sounding options, I settled for the Santa Fe Chicken Wrap with a side of fruit. LOVED it. The only star I would ding it for is that it was a bit pricey for the amount of food received, but they're a smart business, so totally understandable on their part. Will definitely be returning soon. read more

Fancy Pantry is a great spot for a quick delicious lunch. The soups are always great and they always have several lunch sandwich specials. I really like the potato salad and chicken salad and can always find something delicious. Great having this so close to home too. From the outside you can't really tell the great food you'll find here. read more

Favorite place for lunch! The appleberry salad is amazing!! They have the best desserts. Great selection of meats to take home and make for dinner. Love this place! read more

Great food - especially the salmon club. It's always a bit frenetic around lunch time, you don't really go for the ambiance, though - just a good lunch. The samples of the sweets are always good, but I've never had room for a whole one. read more

Excellent sandwiches and salads. Has become my clear favorite for those times when I want to splurge slightly on lunch. Sure, it's loud during the peak hours (which seem to be just about all the time), and the decor is spartan, but the food makes it all worthwhile. I especially recommend the Pantry Muffalata and Cajun Chicken Club sandwiches, and the Thai Chicken Cobb Salad. read more

Have eaten there a couple of times and both the club and the rueben were excellent. Sides are good too. Don't forget to try the desserts.

A year and a half ago I used Fancy Pantry for to cater a dinner party and was quite happy. When it was time to cater another dinner party last weekend I naturally called them again. WHAT A MISTAKE This year all I got was a run around & obfuscation. It took Sadie several days worth of emails to tell me how they were charging meals now with HER deciding what my guests would get. After I told her to forget it, she came back a few times telling me they had the best food and to reconsider. I don't care how great the food may be, when all I get is unprofessional behavior, I AM NOT INTERESTED. read more

This place is always crowded which in a business stand point is always good. The food is good however it is a bit pricey which is why I only come here maybe once a month. I have tried other items on the menu but have not been as pleased as I am with the Appleberry Salad read more

It doesn't get any better! Wonderful healthy lunch and one of the most professional catering services in all of Alpha/Roswell area. Family owned and operatrated! Owners are pros with Sadie providing the leadership on the menu creation (Graduate of the Culinary Inst of America) and John heading up the kitchen team. read more

Holy cow, I absolutely 100% LOVE LOVE LOVE this place. I've only been a patron here as of recently, but the food is wonderful!! I'm typically a to-go customer since I go on my lunch breaks, so can't say too much about its ambiance. But honestly, who cares, the food is healthy AND delicious. My two personal favorites: The Chicken Appleberry Salad and The Chicken, Pear, and Walnut salad. DEE-LISH!! They always have AWESOME specials available and their catering looks in INCREDIBLE. I haven't let myself near the desserts yet...but OH. MY. GOD. Go there. Now. read more

Fancy Pantry is really a great option for lunch. If you are in need of an appetizer for dinner that night, get the shrimp dip. They give you pita chips and the dip is GREAT!!! read more

Wish I could give this 0 stars. The experience that I had was atrocious at best. When I walked in I didn't get acknowledged or greeted while standing behind the person being checked out and there was another person standing at a free register who also did not acknowledge me. I am the only black person in the establishment at this time. After about 3 minutes the 2nd woman was done deciding if she wanted to interact with the black man and take my order. I provided my order to her, the woman barked out they don't make substitutions to their items, they only have 1 vegetarian option on their menu. Now I know for a fact they have before, I've ordered there before the EXACT SAME THING and they did it within the last month, and then it was just as bad of an experience then. I take it they don't serve many black faces in this establishment. This place is close to my job so its easy to walk across the street to get to it. For the cashier to bark out they "don't make no substitutions "shows me the level of respect and intellect I had to endure in using a double negative. So not-so-fancy pantry you do NOT have to worry about me frequenting your establishment for a sub-par veggie sandwich ever again. read more

I should have listened to Yelpers on this one. I like to support locally owned businesses so decided to give it a shot. I ordered the whole muffuletta sandwich which came with a side (I chose the spinach and artichoke pasta salad). The sandwich had one thin slice of salami, turkey, and ham inside a round hoagie roll. It couldn't have been more than one ounce of meat. Which would have been fine if I had not just paid $9.99 for the sandwich. Aside from the skimpy protein portions, there was nothing remarkable about the sandwich. Grocery store jarred olive mix, bagged bread, and sliced cheese. It was a major disappointment. read more