Another closed place and a late review--better late than never, right? Enzo's Pizzeria was such an interesting experience, to say the least. It was hands down the weirdest thing I've ever encountered in Ithaca. I decided to try their Chicken Gyro Entree, and it was an eye-watering $28 (what!). As a native New Yorker, I was desperately missing the halal food carts that I used to have access to in the city. Now, in Ithaca, I was craving that familiar taste of home, so I figured--why not give their gyro a try? I looked past the steep price point in hopes of finding something that reminded me of those beloved street carts. Unfortunately, it did the exact opposite. The gyro didn't taste anything like the authentic New York City street food. It was like a knockoff version where nothing tasted quite right. It was so off yet it looked similar, I couldn't believe it. Seriously, if you're ever in Ithaca and get a hankering for a gyro that reminds you of the Big Apple, steer clear of Enzo's. This experience was just plain weirddddddddddd. So, lesson learned: sometimes, it's better to stick with what you know and love from home! read more

I ordered a build your own pizza with pepperoni and sausage through Ithaca to Go. Great Pizza! thin crust! perfect! and fast delivery! this goes on my favorite! read more

Excellent food with excellent service. Their Buffalo and barbecue chicken pizzas are excellent. I'd also highly recommend their chicken shawarma with extra chicken. read more

Horrible. Extremely overcooked fries. Almost thought they were sweet potato fries but no, just regular, extremely overcooked fries. Also the owner is racist and made really uncomfortable comments. read more

Enzo’s Pizzeria - overcooked French Fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Ithaca, New York

No sauces with cold mozzarella sticks. Pizza was warm not hot and barely cooked. 2 pizzas 7 mozzarella for 75 dollars. It's really underwhelming. It got here and was similar to gas station pizza. I would never order again under any circumstances read more

Enzo’s Pizzeria - Chicken Wings Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

Amazing food, great company, fantastic place to be. I really enjoyed the pepperoni and cheese pizza. I love speaking with Enzo after a long night to share with him my experiences. One of my favorite places to be after hours read more

Such a great establishment!!! Great customer service and it is always dependable. Great quality and service!

When I ordered the Walker Special, I thought I was getting chicken breast with broccoli rabe. What I got was ziti, a little sauce, a lot of mozzarella, and little broccoli crowns. The owner refused to refund my order. read more

The owner is a creep. I have been to this pizza shop a few times, and each time the owner behind the counter has been really creepy with his questions. To be honest the pizza is not even that great, the only thing that's nice about Enzos is the fact that it is open until 2 AM. Not going back. read more

I used to love this place. Had great pizza and the best falafel in town. Then it got new owners and everything went to hell! The pizza is over seasoned with the wrong herbs, poorly cooked. The "buffalo wings" are breaded in Italian flavored bread crumbs... gross. And worst of all the falafel is garbage. They overcharge for a very poor product. Do yourself a favor and skip this place. read more

Excellent service! Enzo always goes above and beyond for his customers. Highly recommend the shawarma and gyros !!

This was the worst place that we had lunch at during our vacation. We went there because they were halal but we would have been better off going to the Starbucks down the street. The rice was stale, the falafel wasn't cooked properly and the owner himself was creepy AF. read more

My partner and I ordered food from here tonight and we paid $24 for an 18 inch pizza and received a 14 inch pizza, we even took the tape measure out and double checked our receipt because we were so confused. We also got mozzarella sticks and it's almost $2 per stick for an order which with everything going on with COVID I understand that places may have jacked up prices but this is just ridiculous, and the marinara that came with it was ice cold. Although the preparation and delivery was very fast the food is beyond disappointing. Better to eat some cold pizza rolls out of your freezer instead of ordering from here read more

I only go for the felafel pita so maybe I shouldn't give this place 5 stars but felafel pita is quite good if a bit more expensive than the felafel carts I used to enjoy when I lived in NYC. It is a lot better than felafel I got once at the collegetown pizza place a block or two away on Dryden. read more

Eww, is this a joke? I wouldn't open a "pizza" place if I had no clue how to make pizza...First, there's 5 gazillion items on the menu which is never a good sign. I'm surprised they don't also offer wedding cakes for Christ's sake. Here's an idea, offer less and make those items really well instead of offering loads of crap...the pizza was some kind of dense disgusting dry crust with barely any sauce on it, did I say DRY??? I may as well go have eaten the box it came in. The "salad" was the cheapest saddest iceberg lettuce with "mozzarella" slices that tasted like tofu and a side of "balsamic vinaigrette" that was literally all balsamic vinegar, no oil. The best thing I ordered was a can of Coke, thanks...actually, everywhere I've eaten in Ithaca thus far has been extremely sub-par. Apparently these "businesses" are used to pedaling trash to drunk blacked-out students who don't know any better...must be how they all stay in business. F*^@ing GROSS. read more

Ordered Buffalo Chicken pizza at 5:55pm with expected delivery 6:35. When pizza had not arrived by 6:45pm, checked with Slice rep who contacted shop and was told pizza on way. Got call from driver at 7:05 that he was two minutes away. Pizza arrived at 7:25 - cold and no discernible buffalo flavor. No apology or explanation from driver. read more

They have good shawarma and lamb over rice. Those are things I have tried here. Its a halal shop. So the chicken quality and taste is good. read more

Enzo’s Pizzeria - Chicken Wings Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Enzos is the best. My favorite food in college town. The food is it the best. No other falafel I'd rather eat .

amazing pizza! the best! I love the chicken bacon ranch slice. the garlic knots are also very good!

The food was a hour late for delivery. The food was really cold. I ordered bone in wings I received boneless. I also ordered meat lovers pizza and hardly any toppings and one topping was missing. I called the restaurant and the man who answered the phone was very rude. I will not be ordering from them again. read more

I ordered the pizza through grub-hub, the pizza never arrived and I was charged. Not a good business at all. If you fail to deliver, why am I being charged? Not happy at all. read more

It ranks as the worst pizza place in Ithaca. The wrap was crap. The calzone was all bread and the pasta was all pasta. Catch the drift. Not recommended at all. read more

0 stars. They repeatedly cancelled my order for some unknown reason. I placed it on uber eats and then it got cancelled; of course uber eat didn't care. I placed it on their website after that, but they waited 15 minutes or so... then cancelled. Honestly if there is some issue, just call the number and tell me and we are good. Now I've got two charges on my card for the next week and no pizza. Thanks guys. read more

Amazing customer service and great food. Would recommend to everyone!!!! Owner is amazing. Come here 24:7 I love the vibes

Really good. I ordered chicken shwarma with cumbers and onions, along with a side or grape leaves. Everything was fresh and delicious. read more

Enzo’s Pizzeria - Chicken shwarma with cucumbers, onions, and hummus. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Piece of cardboard pizza. Absolute worst money I have ever spent. Get anything but enzos

I have literally never had a good visit to this place. They get my order wrong every time and the people who work there always act like I'm burdening them by ordering :( The food is pretty good though. read more

worst food I ever ordered in the history of food. I wasn't expecting much. but was expecting more than SLOP. I'VE NEVER REVIEWED A RESTAURANT BEFORE. that is indicative of how bad it was. read more

Amazing food Super crispy shrimp and fries Fresh with fresh oil not old smelly oil as in many restaurants The only downside is tooo salty falafel and rice, it would be better to reduce the salt in these two items as we couldn't even eat the falafel read more

You pay $5.99 for half cooked knock off kraft mac & cheese. Gyros do not come with olives, feta or the proper breading for a gyro... noooooo... its a wheat tortilla. Horrible food, horrible staff. read more

Ordered late night delivery. Wings were dried out, smelled like stale oil. Falafel pita was soggy and pita itself was so stretchy you can use that for your home improvement insulation. Let's talk about Greek salad where you need to be Sherlock to find an olive. Feta cheese was sprinkled like Salt Bae. Salad contains just lettuce, tomato and, Feta, added dried out 1000 yr old rock chicken shawarma for $2.99 to make me feel special. If you are lucky enough you might as well find a water reservoir underneath your salad as the tomatoes gets sloppy. This wonderful negative 5 Michelin experience came out to be 50 bucks around. The delivery driver is so rude that you might need a new definition of that from Oxford. Yet tipped him. Believe in giving love. read more

Before I get into it, the food is perfectly fine. Little has changed on that front, and portions are still massive. The taste is also perfectly fine. 100% happy there. The bulk of my rating this time has more to do with whoever took my husband's payment this evening, and it's the reason we will not be back. If you're willing to get yelled at for using an online ordering system as designed, feel free to proceed. Food's fine. This establishment lists itself on GrubHub, which I prefer, because A) I get to see the whole menu, and B) I personally don't have to call anyone and risk something getting lost in translation, as has happened with other establishments in the past. My husband is the one who pays, primarily because it's the easiest way for him to pay without having to sign up for Grubhub himself - I already had the account, so why not? Our only shared account is an AmEx, which isn't accepted everywhere, so we usually don't use it when he's picking up food for us, and because he's the one making the physical pickup and most of these places require his ID, which would need to match the name on the credit card. He also prefers cash, because we're not tacking on debt we might forget about until we've already been charged interest for it. I'm happy to keep his inbox slightly cleaner by using my own with a Grubhub account to make orders. This is the third time we've visited this shop, as we haven't made it a habit; parking in that area is a bit of pain for my husband, so we avoid it unless students are on break. When my husband came up tonight to pay for our order - placed on Grubhub - the person taking his money decided to yell at him for our decision to order through Grubhub. I was not there, but I wish to address the owner directly now: You choose to list your establishment on Grubhub. You are aware of their policies of taking a cut. You are aware that Grubhub makes the option available to pay in cash. You do not get to decide how someone does or does not use Grubhub, whether it helps them (supposedly costs less to pay with credit or to call the store directly?) or not. By taking credit cards, you *also* lose a specific cut of the money to the credit card providers or whatever service you might use to take credit; you wouldn't yell at those people, so why yell at my husband for paying cash? You are the one who also lists *two coupons* with Grubhub, knowing full well that maybe a couple of people might be paying with cash, too, especially in a college town with students that are much more prone to use technology as intended; are you going to get upset with them if they pay cash and perhaps take advantage of that free soda with $25 purchase? In short: You do not get to use that service, then get upset with someone for using that service, without running the risk of losing business because you are upset that the service *you willingly continue to use* takes a cut of the money. You are not new to Grubhub. You know how it works. You know its methods of payment that it offers. That is not our problem; that is yours. If you are no longer satisfied with Grubhub, take it up with them, or remove yourself from those listings. Just be aware that any other online ordering system is going to have those same limitations. If it hurts your bottom line, protect your business, not the thing that is supposedly hurting it, and don't yell at someone that uses it exactly as designed! None of this was new to you! I would know, because all three times, we used Grubhub, and you've continued to use it, despite people using it and probably paying cash occasionally. My husband went in there for food, not a lecture because someone was upset with the way *Grubhub* does business. My husband had enough integrity to pay even after being yelled at, because he's not a jerk. That's more than I can say about the guy doing the yelling. I had to apologize to my husband because someone was upset that we used Grubhub in a perfectly predictable fashion. My husband doesn't like Oasis as much as I did, and he only agreed to it for me tonight. Oasis, your food was good, but there are other establishments in town who will be perfectly happy to accept our money, no matter what service we do or do not use to order. Good luck with your business; with that attitude, you'll need it, especially if, as others say, you're inconsistent with your hours. Adios, Oasis, because tonight's the last time you get our money; hello, other perfectly acceptable establishments with similar food and a better parking situation. We all win, right? We won't be back. read more

I went here one late night. It looked promising with a lot of different options and middle eastern food. I ordered a falafel and it was rotten. I don't know whether it was the tomato in it or the falafel itself but it was inedible. Do not recommend. read more

The food was pretty decent. I ordered 2 slices of Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and I did not get what I initially expected. The shawarma wrap was a bit better, but still lacked complete taste. There's only one guy that was working in the back so wait time was a bit of a problem. Overall was pretty average read more

we love enzos. best pizza in ithaca hands down. so kind and the service is amazing. 10/10

The owner is inconsistent with his hours. I called him a few days ago and he said he would be open Monday regular hours. I tried calling him today and he's closed. The foods not bad, but don't bother getting attached to this place. The food is okay at the most, but the owner doesn't know how to run his business. This is place is by far the worst customer service you can possibly think of. Long story short every time I have called the owner he repeatedly told me he will be open two days from the call. I called him two days later, same story again. Either run the business, or let your customers know you will be closed for a long time. Run a business and stop lying to your customers. Oasis has been in Ithaca for almost a year now and you never know if they are open or not, it is a poorly ran business. If you are looking for good customer service, go to Istaanbul in ithaca for middle eastern food. read more

I love Oasis. I have been a few times and have enjoyed my meal. The two guys that work there are very kind and attentive. Serving portions are generous. My go to is the chicken shawarma over rice. They also make great, simple salads. Support this counter service restaurant! read more

I got the lamb gyro over rice platter. They give a lot of food, and the meat+sauces over rice made it very good. Everyone who worked there was very friendly, I would probably come again. read more

if u like to be charged $4 extra for requesting a mixed platter of lamb and chicken, if u like to receive attitude for asking for extra sauce, if u like being ripped off in quantity from time to time depending on the workers at the time, THIS place is the place for u! read more

First of all, this place is now calling itself Enzos's Pizzeria to escape their bad reputation. The owner said viciously misogynist remarks to a friend of mine after messing up her order months ago and I vowed never to order from them. That was until the aforementioned name change and they were listed as a new business on Grubhub. I got a chicken shawarma but the website only allowed one topping so I got lettuce and that was it per their own limitations on the Grubhub site. I also asked for hot and tahini sauce, which was separate from the veggie topping, and an order of fries and soda. Over an hour after confirming my order, the food arrives. I open the smallest container and the fries are overcooked and some are even burnt. I unwrap the dripping aluminum foil and find my order topped with cucumber, tomato, and onion in addition to the lettuce, chicken, and sauces. The wrapping (it was not the pita bread I requested) was burnt along the edges to the point of falling off yet the bottom was literally leaking through. After picking off the toppings I didn't want, I attempted to eat it and it fell apart in a dripping mess. I called the restaurant who had took so long dispatching the order they were now closed. Still waiting to hear back from grubhub but do not order for a place that has no respect for paying customers. read more