Better than expected - we ordered a slice of plain cheese pizza, 2 salads and 2 fountain drinks. The lady at the counter was super sweet and helpful and brought the meal to our table. No issues. Decent quality pizza and classic Italian-American faves. read more

Came in for lunch. Ordered the snack pack medium pizza wings and a quart of pop. $35 Food was served quickly. Pizza was decent. Wings were great. Just enough crisp with extra sauce. Very casual inside and clean. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

See all

Wow!! Literally the WORST pizza i have ever tried in all of my life!! I am sorry. The young people that work there are absolutely lovely, but that pizza is DREADFUL!! The dough is puffy, the sauce is sugary, and it's just not IN ANY WAY a tasty pizza at all. Anyone that thinks this is whatvpizza should taste like is sadly, sadly mistaken read more

Love Pudgie's in Watkins Glen! These guys are Rockin it today during the Grand Prix. The pizza is great and the staff is even better.

Great pizza great vibe easy to swoop in and pickup. Not fancy pizza be delicious. Definitely get extra garlic butter on the side!

Good pizza, good service, plenty of dining space and parking. Place was clean and food arrived quickly. read more

Disgusting pizza & wings ! Delivery took 1 1/2 hr , so not worth the wait . Food went in the garbage

Real disappointment overall. Pizza slices not hot, they totally forgot the salad. They made zero effort to clean tables. Counter service was inept. Didn't seem to have any management. Wouldn't even give a thought to returning. read more

Courteous friendly service. Absolutely answers any questions, and reasonable pricing.

ordered online because we had coupons and it was a long work day. ordered a party pack. Half sheet pepperoni and the other half pepperoni, sausage, and ham. with hot wings and honey bbq wings asked for it to be ready at 430. arrived around 420 understanding I was early and ok to wait a few minutes. at 438-still not terrible - was told wings were taking bit because they were trying to get them extra crispy which is what we requested. after having waited this long I grabbed the pizza and wings when handed over the counter and headed home. got home opened the box and we had a full sheet pizza of chicken wing. Not. What. We. Ordered. lesson learned. don't trust the management to double check your pizza for you. check it before you leave. funny thing is the people just in front of us who did carry out sure were surprised when they got home and had pepperoni and meats instead of chicken wing once again Pudgies did not disappoint with their medicoore service and poor management. your best bet would be to go to Walmart buy some frozen dough or a shelf stable packet, shred some cheese and choose your toppings. At least you would know what pizza you're pulling out of the oven !! read more

If you need a quick bite in the Watkins Glen area, this is a great spot to check out. Note: this is an order at the counter, and they will bring it out to your table. We were in the mood for appetizers and ordered chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks. The sauces were alright, my favorite out of the two we got was the garlic. I'd come back again! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks - Chicken Wings Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

A familiar name in the pizza business, my husband and I decided to stop in and grab dinner on a recent Monday night. We lost power at the AirBnB that we were staying in and had to get in the car and head into town to stay warm until power was restored. Being a Monday night in winter, not much was really open, so we opted to go to Pudgies. Being from Rochester, we know the name and used to enjoy Pudgies regularly when they had a location on Titus avenue. We just grabbed a couple of slices that were already cooked. I got a slice of cheese and a buffalo chicken. The buffalo chicken was actually really good, and I was happy with my choice. Again, it was great that they are open later on a Monday night because we would have been out of luck for making dinner at our place. read more

waited 25 minutes for one cold sub and no one was inside the place. would not recommend.

I've eaten here twice in two different locations and the food just sucks. Pizza is horrible and I got a sub the other day, chicken Parm, and all it was was two chicken fingers fried with sauce and cheese. Just horrible, and the employees are grumpy as well. read more

Tourists roaming around for food after Seneca Falls and we were so lucky to find Pudgie's. Food was quick, yummy and great portions for our group of 6. Nick was patient and even chatted about the location and franchise. We truly enjoyed our post hike lunch! read more

Best pizza in town. Great atmosphere. Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. Definitely recommend their dessert selection and pizza. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

See all

Their giant sheet pizza is amazing. It's doughy, thick crust, slightly sweet sauce, perfect amount of cheese. I am salivating just thinking about it. Wings are solid. Mozzarella sticks and chicken tenders are standard. They have a fried dough with powdered sugar appetizer that makes you feel like you're at a carnival. Debate no longer - just go get Pudgie's! read more

Be warned: Do not enter. My friends and I came up here to go hiking in Watkins Glen State Park over Labor Day weekend. Many restaurants were closed, so we didn't have much of an option as we doubtfully came in here for a quick lunch. It was not quick. We ordered and waited at least 20 minutes because they had forgotten our orders. When the food did come, they missed my friend's pizza slice and when she went to the counter to get it, the person at the cash register handed it to her WITHOUT GLOVES. No one was feeling the food... until my friend started feeling nauseous a few hours later and threw up. We thought that was the end of it, until a couple of days after the trip, she got food poisoning and went to the hospital. That said, I was the most skeptical of this place but probably had the least worse lunch: eggplant parm with ziti. It was edible, and I did not get sick. read more

Saturday night, staying at the Inn at Glenora, 10 min. north of Watkins Glen, and after having pretty fancy meals at the Inn on Thursday and Friday nights, we wanted PIZZA...delivered! First place we call says two hours to deliver. (Things are busy because the Xmas wine trail has lots of people in town.) Pudgies says 1 hour, so we go for it. At 55 minutes, the ladies go up to the entrance. They return about 5 minutes later with our food. I was stunned, I tell you! I expected the whole thing to go south. Not only did they deliver exactly on time, but we got 4 excellent personal pizzas. Thick, light doughy crust, excellent cheese and toppings. We'll be back next year! read more

Absolutely awful! The service was painfully slow. I paid cash and she just kept the change, no receipt either. The pepperoni slice had one piece of pepperoni and the calzone was by far the most terrible thing I've ever tried. No fillings, tough dough and they slathered the top with margarine?!! We ordered two calzones and they only brought out one. I asked her oaf she was bringing the other one and she said "I don't think so, but I'll check" and just never came back. We couldn't prove we'd ordered two because we never got our receipt so after waiting around for her to return and realizing she didn't plan to, we left. read more

Not bad for chain pizza shop. Wings were bigger than usual. Place was clean and staff were spot on

Ordered delivery pizza and wings per the suggestion of the bartender at the Glen Motor Inn when we found out that the restaurant at the Inn was closed for the night. The bartender said that they deliver all the time since it's right down the street (8 minutes away) and they even had menus at the front desk that he could grab for us. There were so many seemingly good pizza options and I was dying to get a taste of the local pizza. We ordered the "National Award Winner" chicken wing pizza and a large order of garlic parmesan/hot wings. The total for the two items with delivery and tip was close to $40 but honestly you couldn't pay me to want to go through the ordering process again much less eat this stuff. When we called to place our order, the boy on the phone insisted that I give him the address and phone number of the Inn, which the bartender was more than happy to give to me to provide. He was shocked because he said that Watkins Glen is pretty small and that Pudgie's should have known where it was. The estimated wait time was 30-45 minutes, so after 50 minutes, I called to check. The same boy said that the driver was on the way and that he should "literally be there any minute." I didn't want to keep the driver waiting or our group hungry, so I hurried upstairs to retrieve our order. Well....there was no driver for another 35 minutes, but I sat in the lobby waiting anyway just in case that "any moment" was the next minute. The chicken wing pizza is a disturbingly strong buffalo sauce that will burn your throat and nose to smell. Quite possibly the greasiest pizza I have ever seen and a doughy crust that isn't worth eating except that it helps to temper the buffalo sauce if you alternate bites of pizza and crust. The boyfriend was hangry and pissed that they counted a shriveled wing tip as a wing. Seriously for $40 and over 2 hour wait, I am shocked that this is the sh*t quality we received and that this place is even still in business. read more

We ordered pizza here one night. Got 2 pizzas , breadsticks and a salad. Wow the pizza was really good. Rarely that I travel and the pizza is that good. They require masks. In addition they had beer and I was able to get a six pack for our house. read more

I'm continually disappointed with the Stromboli. I loved them in Ithaca. I think the first time in Watkins was good, but then I got a doughy one. I thought it might have been a fluke so I ordered again and still doughy. I didn't order for awhile and then thought maybe a medium won't be doughy. I was wrong. I'm very disappointed. I LOVED Stromboli's from Pudgie's and now I'm not sure I'll ever get a good one in Watkins again. Please prove me wrong! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Doughy Stromboli - Chicken Wings Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

First stop for a quick lunch on the way to our VRBO. Love pizza, and Pudgies did not disappoint. Party of 4 and we all got the 2 slices and a drink. Standard cheese for me. Red sauce is a little sweet and nice for something a little different. Others got the chicken ranch and buffalo chicken - everyone was happy. read more

So we were in for the weekend visiting and figured we'd grab a quick pizza for lunch to take back. We ordered a sheet pizza with pepperoni and received a large. The girl with the poorly dyed platinum blonde hair was INCREDIBLY rude denied that we ordered it even though there were four of us confirming it. She had a very poor attitude and quite frankly was very strange while she kept scratching her arms and her cheeks on her face which had marks on it which, working in the ER I've only seen with meth withdrawal which now makes me even more uncomfortable to consume the wrong pizza. read more

The pizza is delicious, however the customer service is next level. Next time I'm in the area of Watkins Glenn, I'll be sure to stop by and have some of this delicious pizza! Highly recommended read more

I ordered a large Italian sub and got all the way home to find out it was made wrong. Thanks for the overpriced wrong sub for $14.25 I appreciate that. I ordered a piece of Stromboli along with it and when I opened the box before I left the store it was a small end cut with hardly any filling and all dough. I asked for a different piece and was told that was all they had left. I left that sitting on their counter untouched it was so bad. Chicken fingers... ha they were in a white paper bag leaking oil everywhere. I would ask for a container but there will be no next time. It was a $34 joke. Save your hard earned money and go someplace else there are several other pizza shows in town. read more

Pizza took an hour and a half to get to our house. It was cold and greasy. No apologies No call I want my money back read more

My family was camping out here this last weekend we stopped in for some subs to take back to camp for dinner, I had high hopes for this place it looked clean and everything plus friendly staff. One issue that killed everything was we were eating and enjoying our subs my father stopped eating with a horrid look on his face as he pulled out a 2 foot long brown hair from his mouth. We just tossed our food we were pretty disgusted. read more

Great place to order pizza. Extra courtesy received from management when we ordered and needed to cancel at the last minute...looking forward to our next order. Thanks for understanding our dilemma! read more

Pudgie's is the name that we are very familiar with in Southeast Pennsylvania. they are famous for their huge and very stuffed cheesesteaks with very fresh Italian rolls. This place is not even a distant cousin. The only thing going for it is a very clean bathroom. That's why we gave it a one star instead of no stars. We must say that the pizza looked good although we did not try it. We should've been concerned when we came at dinner time and no one was there. The steak was sparse and very dry. The roll was crispy and we think they put it in the oven after they made the sandwich.They charged $9.99 which is a disgrace. read more

We got takeout from here. They were so nice and communicative. The pizza was AMAZING! Crispy bottom, lots of sauce, and fluffy dough. Absolutely incredible would definitely recommend!! read more

Me and my family of 4 decided to order out at this pizza establishment. Completely disappointed for the cost of their pizza in comparison to the bill. Their quality is similar to Dominos Pizza with a high mark-up. Not to knock the quality, but the cost of pizza. They "stinged" on the cheese and toppings. I recommend going to Jeraldo's instead, just a block away. But their chicken wings were good. read more

Do not eat here. Staff was incredibly rude and wouldn't even let me finish my order before cutting me off. The food is very expensive and the price does not match the quality and quantity. read more

Showed up just before 10pm on a Saturday online said open til 11. We weren't allowed to sit in the dining room. A couple tables had people at them we were told they weren't sitting in the dining room anymore. There were a ton of slices left available and we were asked if we wanted them on plates or in a box but we had to take our plates out to the car to eat them. If you close at 11 it should say online your dining room closes at 10. read more

My son and I were sick of all the nasty pizza choices in our town and went to Watkins Glen for Pudgies. Pepperoni pizza was REALLY good as were the HOT chicken wings! Service was excellent and the facilities were spotless. Very nice! We will be back! read more

I had never heard of this place before but now I know it's part of a chain. Not that there's anything wrong with that but we usually like to try local stand alone establishments. Anyway we walked in and checked out the extensive menu and I ordered the two slice pepperoni pizza and drink combo. The wife ordered the breadsticks and was told they would have some freshly cooked ones in six minutes but she told them she would take the ones that were already prepared. Well guess what? The girl that took our order said she wouldn't charge us for those and she didn't! Can't beat that! The wife said they tasted just fine to her and my pizza was pretty darn good too! Friendly folks working here keep customers coming back for more! Definitely a good place to stop for a quick lunch. read more

We ordered two slices of pizza each that came with a drink. Pizza was surprisingly fresh for sitting in the hot storage tower on display. Pizza was moist and seemingly "airy". Despite the soft crust, the chicken bacon ranch had little to no flavor. I wasn't able to determine whether the sauce was Alfredo or ranch as it wasn't flavorful. Overall, food was mediocre at best despite running $20+ for a two person meal, and the staff was as unfriendly as it gets. Save your money and try another restaurant in town read more

Picked up takeout, 2 calzones to go. Would've preferred they put them in separate containers since they were to go to two separate locations, haven't had to ask before. Food is always good, counter help was a young kid, service wasn't so great. read more