Pricey spot in the hamptons but the service was great and they have a wide variety of items on the menu. Great margaritas. Go for the traditional as its the best one rather than the specialty ones as the specialty ones can be a bit overpowering on the specific flavors. Love the fresh in house chips with variety of sauces. The hottest red sauce really had some kick. But loved the verde (green). The burritio was on point. Tasty al pastor pork with great ingredients in the burrito. The tacos were also very good especially the fish taco. Mexican corn was farm fresh corn with great mexican cheese and spice. Would try again when in the area. read more

Came here for lunch and had a pleasant time. My group ordered the quesadilla, a bowl and some tacos and we split everything. The food was fresh, flavorful and well cooked. For a Saturday at lunch time, it wasn't too busy which was nice. Service was super friendly and the place is well themed and clean. Would absolutely come back. read more

Came here for lunch a few weekends ago. Was a quick in and out with friends locally - this place is good for that. I liked the aesthetic and the staff was nice. Food was OK at best. Some items were good while others weren't. Best thing we had were the burrito bowls. I believe I got carne asada and cauliflower rice with all the fix-ins. It was great. They brought out a bunch of hot sauces, which was nice. Other people got the barbacoa bowl and an assortment of tacos. The tacos weren't very good in my opinion. The fried fish one was best. Others were really lacking. Ordered guacamole and chips for the table. Guac was OK. The sauces/salsas it came with were great. Ample amount of chips, which I liked. I'd come back for lunch. I'm not too sure about dinner read more

eLTacoBar is a new MEXICAN concept by Chef Laurent Tourondel in Sag Harbor, New York. Their dishes are all handmade authentic Mexican recipes using fresh local ingredients. Also Cocktails, its menu features appetizers, salads, bowls, tacos, tortillas and MORE! I come often and have amazing dishes with my favorite Cocktail Passion en fuego! read more

Tried the cod tacos and they were SO fishy! The staff kept trying to rush us through our meal. It was a terrible dining experience. read more

I recently visited a newly renovated Mexican restaurant that showed great potential. While there were some positive aspects of my experience, there were also a few areas that fell short. Overall, I would describe it as an average dining experience that could use some fine-tuning. Let's start with the positives. The interior design of the restaurant was impressive, and the renovations had clearly breathed new life into the place. The ambiance was inviting, and the beautiful bar added a touch of elegance to the overall atmosphere. The restaurant was new and it's first weekend open so we were patient with the idea things were being worked out. They were attentive to our needs and guided us through the dining experience, making our visit more enjoyable. Now, let's talk about the food. Unfortunately, the dishes we ordered failed to leave a lasting impression. Nothing truly stood out among the tacos we tried. We sampled the chili lime shrimp, the Baja style cod, and the eggplant taco, but none of them managed to wow our taste buds. On a positive note, the guacamole chip and salsa platter was a true delight. The guacamole itself was so delicious that we couldn't resist ordering a second serving. It was undoubtedly the highlight of the meal and showcased the potential for flavorful offerings at this restaurant. Moving on to desserts, we decided to try the churro dessert. Unfortunately, our excitement quickly turned into disappointment when we tasted the dipping sauce. It was practically inedible, leaving us wishing for a better accompaniment to complement the churros. On the beverage front, the restaurant redeemed itself. They offered a selection of fresh, house-made juices that were quite good. Additionally, the cocktails were a hit, and we thoroughly enjoyed them. One thing that struck us was the striking resemblance in format to a nearby establishment, K-Pasa. The similarities were quite surprising, and it made it difficult for this restaurant to distinguish itself in a crowded culinary landscape. In conclusion, while our experience at this Mexican restaurant had its ups and downs, we believe it has potential. With improvements in the overall flavor profiles of the dishes and refining the dessert options, it could become a noteworthy dining destination. For now, it seems to excel in cocktails and its standout guacamole, making it a decent spot for drinks and snacks. If you're in the mood for a casual night out it is worth a shot, and for sure if looking for a great drink and some chips at the bar! read more

eLTacobar - Tacos - Mexican Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

There aren't many places left in Sag Harbor to grab a quick, informal dinner. We tried this place against better judgment last night. Service was excellent. Room was pretty nice, though the musical shift from AC/DC to corrida was a little jarring. Food, not so much. Shrimp taco was pretty good, cauliflower taco was bland and uninteresting, street corn was genuinely grim...I sincerely hope it wasn't frozen corn, but I'm really questioning it. It had the taste and texture of boiled, not roasted or grilled. Boiled corn covered with crema was borderline disturbing. read more

Very arrogant server, I believe his name was Johan L. Not accommodated and hospitable at all! His attitude was like he was making us a favor - very bad attitude - i am developing restaurants in the city for the past 20 years and this is just not proper at all. I feel sorry for the owner which losing customers bcs of him and the GM or floor manager that doesn't know anything in the field ! Also i had to request 3 times to the little inexperience girl hostes for a table while she had no more reservations and other customers waiting and she wanted to sit us in an area which we wasn't liked at all ! Those employees need to be educated about what hospitality and customers service means !!! The food is total rip off ! $18 for 2 tiny tacos of fried cod 1 inch size each, Steak tacos ( carne asada ) $13 each with just 3 little pieces of skirt steak !! Small bowl of Guacamole and chips with 3 sauces $ 22 ! Margaritas average $21 !!! That was my first last time visited that place !!! Previous burger establishment was just amazing !!! Stay away from El Taco bar! If you want Mexican just walk 1/2 mile towards the harbor and enjoy it there !! read more

I went here with my Uncle and Aunt. They come here often, and got a waitress that they love and seemingly so does everyone there. I didn't catch her name but she is very friendly and it seems like the rest of the waiters/waitresses are too. The food is delicious and reminds me of a healthier version of chipotle because I got a bowl. The restaurant is small but uses the space well. We got churros to go which were also delicious with their Spanish-style chocolate sauce and sugary churros. read more

Food and service are just average, and for the prices we expected better. Firstly, I had asked to try the cauliflower rice as I was thinking about getting the bowl but was undecided. Instead of being accommodating, the waiter said, "I doubt we'd be able to do that." Totally get it if that's the case, but it was such a simple ask -- the restaurant should be able to do things like this if it means garnering a more loyal clientele. (In regards to the cauliflower rice, I would definitely say it's not worth getting after ordering). Second, our drinks didn't come until we were halfway done with our meal which, again, was just average. The bowl looked amazing as it came out (I got the El Pollo bowl), but tasted like nothing. We had also ordered the corn first which similarly took a lot of hot sauce/salt/pepper in order to taste fine. Again, for paying the prices they ask, you would expect better. Because of these things, I would really suggest just coming here for drinks/chips. Other than that, nothing particularly stands out. read more

eLTacobar - Chips and guac for $22, was fine (but probably best part of our meal) - Mexican Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

I've waited to eat here 3 times before reviewing. Wanted to love this new restaurant, after all, it's Mexican food - BUT - it's always off. The Cowboy salad didn't have enough chicken in it to warrant the price - disappointing. First time in my life I did not finish the chips or my quesadilla! Was happy to see they added quesadillas to the menu but something was off. My friend didn't finish his either. Also, the fun part should be the chips (which you pay for) - why so thick and hard? Thick yet they'd still break when trying to scoop the mediocre plain guacamole. Never in my life have I not finished chips! Maybe I should be thanking you. I won't be returning. Can't imagine this place last thing unless they just continue to get the new tourists that don't know any better. bring back LT Burger read more

Excellent food. The food is well prepared and has a great citrus taste to it. Immaculately clean. Attentive and helpful staff. The kind of Mexican food you could eat every day. Get the chips and guacamole. read more

It makes me sad to use Yelp as a way of pressuring places to do the right thing, but these guys are so close to being amazing... and then they enforce a strict "no substitutions" policy on literally everything, which is just ignorant and aggravating. Change the policy and I'll change this review. They get so much right otherwise. read more

Service is amazing. Food is great. I would recommend this restuarant to someone who likes mexican food. I had lunch here a couple weeks ago I got the Nacho bowl with guacamole and salsa. It was amazing! Me and my friends shared it. Then the waiter gave us a discount and I don't know why but whoever that was your the best! read more

Drinks are really good and the tacos are amazing. Fresh and flavorful. Great service and fantastic food. So glad we tried this place.

The conversion of LT Burger was welcomed however, the size of the portions versus the price paid was an insult to my pocketbook. We ordered Salsa & Guacamole that was prepared nicely however, the size of the portion was very small at $22.00 . The Chicken Tacos and Shrimp Tacos were a small pathetic size st $7 & $8+ that left me hungry not to mention having spent $82.00 before a $16.00 tip. One drink Guacamole & Chips 2. Tacos A Pork Belly Dinner 1 non alcoholic drink Total with tax $82.00 Tip $16.00 This adverse experience was an insult to value vs money spent. We left hungry, unimpressed and angry. read more

Food service and ambiance were awesome. Jager gave us an amazing service! The food was excellent. Love their happy hour prices.

Awesome margs and tacos! The birria tacos, fish taco and the lobster special taco were all so good! The chips and guac were great especially with the salsa. All the margs were delicious! This was my second visit and I haven't had a bad bite or sip! The space is so bright and fun. Perfect for a group, we also saw several babies there so it seems very family friendly. read more

ELTACOBAR is easily the best restaurant on Main Street in Sag Harbor. The staff is so welcoming and care about giving the customers an excellent experience. The food and drinks are delicious. I stopped in for a quick bite and ended up staying for three hours because the restaurant is so friendly and welcoming. The bartenders Nick, Jaggar, and Xavier were great and very pleasant to talk to. We also had Louis helping to serve us and he was a top tier waiter! always checking up and making sure things were going well. All in all you must try ELTACOBAR because the food is great and the staff is even better giving the consumer an excellent experience. read more

Service was great! Nick, Jagger and Xavier were amazing bartenders 10 out of 10! The next day we came back after the great experience and had Louis as a server and he was just as great! Amazing food as well as service! 10 out of 10 will definitely be coming back! read more

$22 for chips and guacamole....inaccurate pricing different on menu than on the bill and pretty awful service. Won't be back.

I visited El Taco Restaurant last evening cause all the other Restaurants in Sag where packed when I walked in door I noticed only to couples seated and and that made me wonder , after getting my food I realized why this place was so empty my food was not good at all . read more

Service and staff were lovely. The food and drinks are very basic and just so so. I was hoping something great would replace the burger place which was a much needed staple - it was great food there are no similar foods in the area. I was disappointed when this was another Mexican food place bc we already have several great ones but I would always support my neighborhood. I was disappointed as were friends and family I've brought over. Hopefully they will improve. It's not too late to bring back the burger place!! Please! read more

Ambiance was great. Server was friendly. Food was average and we left hungry $100 later. Would rather support K Pasa but my husband wanted to be adventurous and try this place out as it wasn't here last season. Won't likely return. read more

This place seemed promising, yk normal Mexican restaurant, usually places like this are pretty good. The service is horrendous, the waiter kept getting orders wrong. For a place known as a "taco bar" there are few tacos on the menu. When we asked for a small change from rice to rice they said "you'll have to order it separately". The food was decent, the steak was tender and juicy and the chips were crispy and flavorful. But the fish came out dry. Not too mention they gave everyone their food at different times! So there was no wait for food and it was fresh but the time in between the food coming out was terrible! We got one meal and the next would take 10 more minutes to come out. Really this place was terrible. "Looks can be deceiving," great example of this quote! read more

The food is great. But the manager? Nasty human who gave one of the employees a scolding in front of the customer for a small misunderstanding. Ruined the experience for us. read more

Amazing food and service!! We got the chips & guac, chicken bowl, corn, chicken tacos and churros! Absolutely delicious, can't wait to go back! read more

yummy yummy in my tummy The food is so delicious and the staff is great!! would 10% recommend.