This place is the Best Mexican Food in the Hamptons, Flavorful, Fresh, the quantity is exceptional for the price it's Gold. From the Burritos, quesadillas, the bowls. Excellent, Excellent. The service there is extra friendly and order comes out Hot and perfect. Could not recommend more. My kids love it so much as well. We grab it for the office or to go to the Beach! read more

So disappointed with Sabrosa. I ordered a Burrito Bowl with "Lime"White Rice, Pinto Beans and Carnitas. Flavorless. I tried to add more hot sauce to it to give it some flavor. Unfortunately, that didn't help. I also ordered chips and some pico de gallo. Again, flavorless. I will say the portion size was good but I gave 3/4 of it away because it just wasn't tasty. I wanted more salt, more Mexican flavors, and I wanted it to at least taste as good as Chitpotle. Sadly, I did not have a great meal here. It was very clean, the staff was friendly but I would not return or recommend. Sadly I was still hungry after lunch. read more

Ordered 2 chicken burritos with avocado, total $36.50 + $2 tip. Gave them the benefit of the doubt that the food would be tasty and worth the price. Not the case, beans are bland, rice is plain, sauces are extra. There was no flavor. Also everything was measure with a scoop smaller than an ice cream scooper. So burritos are tiny compared to others. I will personally stick with Chipotle. This place is overrated imo. Staff was nice, place was clean. read more

me and my buddies all came here and all of our stomachs hurt. costumer service was lame

Very nice place, clean place and the staff is amazing. The food is delicious.I I highly recommended

Although the restaurant is clean and the workers are very nice, the food I got tonight was pretty awful . The rice was hard and unflavorful . The cheese look like it came out of a grocery store generic shredded cheese bag. It was very skinny and tiny not like a nice quality shredded cheese . The chicken was terrible . Most of the time the food is decent but tonight really turned me off... not sure if I'll go back read more

Dear sabrosa, what happened? You used to be my go to for a good reasonably priced meal. Now the price is still good but what happened you quality control? I cake in on an evening to get a burrito bowl. As always ordering and getting out the door was a cinch! But, when I got home, opened up the container and took a bite out of the food- it was terrible! The rice was hard and not al dente hard, hard as in left out all day hard. The beans and meat had zero flavor. I found myself adding a ton of salt and hot sauce to give it a bit of umpf! Needless to say it was pointless. One of the worst meals I've had here. Such a pity read more

This is our first visit here. I have to say I was pleasantly surprised. The food was reasonably priced and a good portion. My wife and I split the Ultimate fajitas. It was very good. The steak was seasoned perfectly, however, just a little tough. Although, to be fair, it is hard to find a tender steak for fajitas after they have cooled for a bit. Made happy plates. Very happy. read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Ultimate fajita. Made it disappear. - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

Used to be so much better! The quality of the food has gone down Hill. Chicken is chewy. Cheese is imitation cheese. Everything was always delicious and fresh. What happened? Haven't returned in months because of this. read more

regular here but today was not it. Prices definitely gone up a ton in recent years and I received halo a portion! read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Burrito Bowl - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

Its my favorite place to get lunch on my break. The staff is always friendly. Food is always hot and fresh. I would recommend stopping in for a quick burrito. read more

My brother and I came across this place while driving to Montauk for a film shoot. The two stars were for the service received, which was nice. The food, is probably the most tasteless food I've eaten since I ate a meal in Applebee's in 2014. I had the fish tacos which were the special of the day. read more

Was there for a quick dinner and was disappointed with the limited taco ingredient choices. The food was sugary sweet which I don't want in my meal. Not close to authentic Mexican and won't go back. read more

Love everything about this place, except for my experience last night. The girl who served me and rang me up felt the need to nickle n dime me while making a burrito bowl that cost $17. When I asked why she said "oh you got quinoa, onions / peppers and guac" and just turns around to help the next customer. My bowl was technically half quinoa half brown rice and for a few onions n peppers. Mental not made, next time she does that she can keep the bowl and eat it herself. You can say as I ask for the items that they cost extra. I understand it's a business and you can't just give things away for free but comon let's not be ridiculous...now ask the owner if it was worth it to not get a 5 star review ???? read more

A great Mexican spot similar to chipotle off of Montauk Highway...convenient, clean and great service. Loved my burrito bowl and chips/guacamole! read more

I have been here several times, so my review isn't based on one visit. Food: 4/5 stars. It's yours substitute chipotle because there isn't one for many miles. You can see they're trained to not put much into the food based on how they very gingerly scoop the rice and even the sour cream. It's descent and properly priced for the region. Service: each time I have gone here, I was never greeted when I first walked in, and I typically had to wait about five minutes before someone took my order. Mind you, I am the only one in line and just standing there waiting. I am also standing very close to the ordering area, not standing far back as if I was still pondering what I was going to order. Even when someone comes to take my order they just get right into it without even a greeting. On one occasion I ordered a burrito, and the employee had torn part of the shell, but just try to cover it up and still served it to me. In my experience at other similar locations and restaurants, The employee usually replaces the shell itself, which makes sense because how am I supposed to eat a burrito that's falling apart? It doesn't feel like anyone there is actually interested or happy to work there. Parking: easy to find location, with ample parking. read more

I love this place hence me giving it some stars, but to have a dead fly found in the middle of eating my food was definitely gross. See the big peice of lettuce by the sauce in attached photo. read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Dead fly on top of lettuce - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

This is hands down the best Mexican Grill I have ever been to! It is so quick and easy to get food there especially if you live in the area. The employees are always on top of their game and super friendly. This place is all about nutrition and overall provides amazing service to their customers. read more

The food has a long long way to go... if you want a kick ass burrito take your money elsewhere! Customer service is also lacking. read more

Soooooo tasty! I had the tacos -- 3 on a platter, mix and match the fillings -- and my husband had the burrito salad. Oh wait, no. He had TWO burrito bowls. Everything had vibrant flavors, and looked and tasted fresh. The service was cheerful and professional. The prices are UNBELIEVABLE. By that I mean I can't believe how affordable it is. You need a place to eat out in the Hamptons, and you aren't the kind to get reservations at a place that probably wouldn't let you in anyway? Head to Sabrosa and fill up on delicious and freshly-prepared food. read more

Finally a place for good Mexican food on the east end. I passed this place every day to and from work and finally decided to give it a shot. My GF had a chicken quesadilla that was "on point" - I didn't try it, as I was consumed w consuming my massive burrito, but it surely looked delicious. We shared the corn chicken soup which hit the spot on a cold winter day. My burrito was awesome especially the smoky special sauce. I'll def be coming back here again that's for sure. The prices are very affordable and the gentleman who helped us was very kind and even gave us a free chips and salsa because it was our first time. Keep it up Sabrosa!! read more

Like Chipotle but better. Very clean, great flavors, fresh veggies and over all yumminess! I would choose this every time... read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

Who is Chipotle? This great spot on the way out East was a great find! Fresh ingredients, great selection, efficient service, a Sweetheart of a manager! Got a craving? Hit Sabrosa! read more

I work in Watermill and i probably go here 2-3x a week. Same thing as Moes/Chipotle; make it yourself burritos. Ingredients are always fresh, place is always clean and the food hits the spot read more

My wife, two kids and I went to Sambrosa earlier this week. We LOVE this place. The food is delicious, fresh, and filling but not heavy at the same time. I had the quinoa burrito bowl with their perfectly spiced chicken. Can't wait to go back and have it again The service at the counter was excellent. The owner of the restaurant and her lovely kids could not have been nicer or more welcoming. We love supporting family owned entrepreneurial businesses and this is a new favorite. Don't walk, run to Sambrosa! read more

Add another veg friendly place that won't break your bank to visit to the list! I mean, the burrito is a normal burrito, can't complain. There's not too much flavor like you would get at Cilantro's or La Fondita, but it's also much much cheaper. Burrito bowls are everything you'd get in a burrito, without the tortilla and the quesadillas are average. Pros: -Veg friendly! (They even sometimes have tofu and chili!) -Cheap (hard to come by out here) -Custom order assembly line -Organic, Grass-fed, Natural and Hormone free. -Their XX-hot sauce is actually spicy (more of a personal thing) Cons: - Not amazing, I'm sure they're still working out some kinks, but the foods not extraordinary - Menu is so limited. And the burrito bowl should be called a taco plate. - Veggie selection is also limited -Burritos are large, but everything else isn't equally portioned (even if it's more expensive). -Bland atmosphere. Clean, but bland. Overall it has potential, but it's not as fierce as a competitor as it should be. read more

Wow...I live just a few miles away but never stopped in because a friend said..."it's like Chipotle" I loathe Chipotle. As I finished up at the service station next door...I thought "what the hell." I walked in to a spotless, bright cafe with a welcome from the ordering staff. Not sure what to order...I took the mahi-mahi fish tacos along with a side of quacomole and chips. SUPERB! Can't wait to come back. This is a surprise out of nowhere. GREATfirst impression. From the welcoming staff, to the clean well cared eating area to the spotless restrooms...WELL DONE. Ill be back...soon! read more

I remember when this place opened and i hated on it - has got a very chain restaurant feeling in a pretty local place. But it has grown on me - and really the size of the burrito you get is excellent for the price. The staff is good and there's usually not a big line in there. The ingredients arent top knotch but again for how much you get its a good value. I'd say worth it 70% of the time. Don't get the extra hot sauce though. I love hot sauce and its just wayyy too much. Just go for hot. read more

Good food at fair prices. Nice staff. Calling it mexican is like calling "Moe's" mexican. They try hard, but it's still Chain restaurant food. Gotta get rid of the styrofoam and plastic! At least the styrofoam dishes and containers. When I'm in a hurry it's quite satisfying. Fresh salsa and chips. Good guacamole. Worth a visit. When I want really authentic mexican food I love Baby Bo's in NYC. Best Quesadila Enorme and Chipotle sauce ever made. read more

Very similar to Chipotle - a few differences though (like quinoa as an alternate to rice). A little less flavorful but pretty close. read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Sabrosa - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

This is Chipotle in the Hamptons... I'm not even sure how this is allowed. But this is Chipotle. From the menu (burrito, burrito bowl, tacos, salad) to the meat add ons (barbacoa, carnitas, chicken, steak and the associated price points), and the seating layout, hot sauce selection, and silver trays the food is served on, this is Chipotle. But since I like Chipotle, I was very happy here. They had the same choices for rice and I enjoyed the white rice with lime/cilantro; however the steak in my burrito bowl is better at Chipotle. My husband said the carnitas was better here. So, if you like Chipotle, you'll definitely be happy here! read more

Sabrosa Mexican Grill - Steak burrito bowl - Mexican Near Me - Water Mill, New York

So I can't my mind I love this place. I am a total fan Delicious although this type of meal is not my favorite. There a few places in the Hampton were the owners are working the counter providing service with a smile Brovo sorry for not being a believer at first. You guys work hard and deserve the best Worth a trip from a distance read more

See all

While going to Hampton's Bay we stopped at this Mexican restaurant. We ordered a salad bowl, which includes lettuce, tomato, black beans, brown rice, guacamole, and cheese. It was very good in taste. We also ordered Nachos with fresh tomato and onions on the side. We enjoyed it all. read more

Had take out didn't care for it, then stayed and it was much better. It is not organic. I asked and it is not organic for people who need to eat organic.The staff is very friendly, I would give them 5 stars. The meats all seem the same to me. It's clean but there is a bleach odor in the air. Acoustically loud. Take the kids and bring a sweater a bit cool inside. Other wise the food is fresh. The Hot Sauce has a real burn said the sweating man across from me. "Oh!!!" That's All She Wrote. read more

This is the closest you will find to a Chipotle in the hamptons... at least southampton, that is. Its a good mexican restaurant with decent food, but wouldn't say its anywhere as good as the king chipotle itself. I liked that they have deals on Tuesdays on tacos, but its not much of a deal if you really think about it. Their sauces are good, and that special hot sauce will absolutely burn your mouth. If your into heat, I highly recommend it. Initially it was kinda mild, but then it hits you, hard! I scarfed down my food trying to mask the heat, but it only made it worse. There is nothing impressive about the food, the rice isn't great, the chicken is alright, but can be dry later in the day. They always try to up sell you on the guac. Cant really beat the price... especially at the hamptons. read more

I'm disgusted. I go to this sabrosa with my family frequently. Most time the stuff is okay except for one, an older hispanic woman. She is short and wear glasses. If you are white, she'll give you a super small bowl or burrito with little taste to no taste. I watched her most carefully and I witness her making a giant bowl to a hispanic male costumer but prior to that, she made an awful one to me and my husband. So, If you are white don't go to her. She shouldn't get way with this. I mean does she even want to work here? How does her behavior towards whites makes any since. All paying costumers should have the same amount of food and some treat. read more

Not bad.. really, not bad. They are definitely going for the Chipotle look and feel, but this is a great alternative since Chipotle is no where in sight. Their food is definitely great for the price. But I really think it's nothing special. Maybe next time I have to try their gelato. read more

Place is impeccably clean. It's a better, locally owned, version of a moes or chipotle. Fresher food I consistently get the burrito bowls. husband gets steak I get shredded beef (I like the texture better) and they are always fresh We frequently see the guys/girls making new protein on the grills. Always spotless. I cat get over how clean the place is. Fresh guacamole I amazing They also have gelato by I haven't indulged yet Quick service too. Stop buy you won't be sorry. read more

Customer service was good as staff was friendly. The food wasn't so good. This place is a knock off of chipotle or dos toros, both of which are way better in terms of taste. Price was ok I guess. Probably wouldn't come back read more

Stumbled upon this place completely by mistake but I am so glad I did. So it's definitely like an average chipotle but healthier! And I must agree with another review posted that the portion control is just right I had the salad bowl with quinoa black beans veggies (fresh and ripe) chicken and guac. The guacamole was very fresh and had a lot of flavor. Also they had an infused water that they make, wasn't thrilled about paying 2.50 for it but it was refreshing. You could tell the food looks fresh and isn't sitting out. The place was very clean as well and spacious. I can't wait to return when I am in the area again. read more