Wow. Old school, fantastic NY style pizza in Valley Stream. Happened on this little hidden gem by having it recomended by a silly AI program and so far, it's 1 for 1. Don't ask for salad pizza or some other fufu weird concoction made by someone who doesn't know anything. Go in for a guy who's been spinning pizza for over 4 decades, will greet you with a friendly smile and serve some of the best old school NY pizza I've had in many years. Every time I'm in the area I'm stopping back. Outstanding. read more

Back again as I was back in the area. Eddie is truly an awesome guy - super kind to everyone who walks into his shop. It is cash only so keep that in mind! He clearly cares about the food he serves - the ambiance is so old school and nostalgic with those benches and red tables. I'll come back every single time I come back to visit my home town. read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

See all

I don't like pizza, but I like Eddie's pizza! Pizza is not the same as I remember from the 70's, except here. So, on the rare occasion I want pizza, I'll be at this place. More of a take out vibe, and always friendly service from Eddie. P.S. I saw someone thought these reviews weren't real, but since I already ate two slices, the only proof is a picture of my plate with nothing left but pizza marks. read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Empty pizza plate, regular slices were so good! - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

Eddie is such a lovely man. The pizza is fresh delicious and definitely old school, which is the best!!!

Basic Long Island pizza - nothing special at all I think they're paying the reviews people or it's all family - at least 5 pizza places in area better read more

Wow! One of the best slices I've ever had in NYC! I was blown away! I unfortunately didn't get to take a picture of the pies but at least I got a pic of two slices! It was so good that I even ate my 3rd slice cold! I never eat pizza cold so that's how you know it was good lol I would def like to come back here if I'm ever in North Valley Stream! read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Pepperoni & regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

From the moment I walked in, I knew it was going to be a great experience. This place is exactly what you want when you go for a ny slice! Crispy, flavorful, and fresh! Eddie is a wonderful person and excellent cook! You can taste the pride he puts in making the best quality food! Near the back, there is plenty of seating if you decide to eat in! 10/10, highly recommend! read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - A taste of the Cheese Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

See all

Great pizza great guy chicken prom is also good cash only no credit cards meat ball hero good

Honestly this is the best pizza on Long Island by far amazing not only is Eddie wonderful and nice and a pleasure to talk to he makes the best pies and he cares about his customers and you can tell highly recommend going there and saying hi to him because it's totally worth it read more

See all

Classic old style NYC pizza, what's not to love? 2 gold medal slices and a can of soda for $6.50, plus Eddie threw me a free shirt. Love this guy. Love this place. Great energy and ambiance. I'll be back for certain. read more

See all

Great Pizza!! Reminds me of the pizza I grew up with in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. Perfect Cheese to Sauce to Crust ratio and the same every time. Plus, Eddie is the nicest guy in the world. If you want the best pizza on Long Island, look no further. read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

This is an old school Cash only Pizzeria. The man working there said he's been there over 40 years and he made one hell of pizza. Very delicious very tangy.. Very reasonably priced. The place was very 60s. Just a great old school, Pizzeria. read more

Great pizza and great value! Eddie is super nice and very personable. Got 4 pies for a school event and the kids loved their slices! Thank you, I will be back. read more

I used to go here MANY years ago and honestly didn't know they were still around! Still the best regular pie around! Old school pizzeria and the place hasn't been updated but the pizza still amazing! read more

Great neighborhood pizza shop! Food is good, service stellar! Been going there for large pie for over 20 years.

Good little old fashioned small family business. The pizza is good. I believe the gentleman making and serving the pizza is the owner. I did a double take when advised a whole pie was $18, but alas, it was a medium pie. Give the guy cash, it's a small joint. read more

Friendly service, good prices and great pizza. Everything made fresh, you walk in and by the old school pizzeria vibe you know the pizza is going to be good! read more

Great pizza. Only top shelf ingredients here. You won't be disappointed. Eddie great guy too. Been there 40 years.

Walking into Eddie's, it's like walking into an 80's time capsule. Great ny style pizza amongst other things, nice & crispy and very tasty. Looking forward to returning and trying different things on the menu. Everything on the menu is reasonably priced and Eddie is such a friendly welcoming guy. read more

See all

Food & service were very good , real personal individual looking forward to going there again

Best Pizza in the world. The sizes are better. The shirts add charm to the store and Eddie is very nice!!

The pizza you grew up eating. Eddie is as classic as his pizza. Had it for the first time last night and he stayed open an extra 15 minutes just to make sure my pizza was done to his liking. When I told him it was my first time he made me a slice while I waited. Old school stuff, the kind of stuff that's missing these days. Thin crust, no flop, nice crunch, plenty of cheese and delicious 'just sweet enough' sauce. When I'm back home (retired to FL), I'll never spend a dollar in another pizza parlor. read more

Amazing old school pizza. Eddie is a true pizza artisan. You don't find pizza like it anymore! read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

Eddie D's Pizzeria is hands down the best pizza on Long Island--no contest. The crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is always fresh and melted to perfection. Whether you're grabbing a classic slice or one of their specialty pies, every bite is a home run. One thing to keep in mind--be ready to wait. They don't have pizzas just sitting around; everything is made to order, which is part of what makes it so fresh and delicious. My kids absolutely love this place--they can't get enough of it, and honestly, I can't blame them. If you haven't tried Eddie D's yet, you're seriously missing out. Just go--you won't regret it! read more

Amazing service EDDIE is just an overall great person with a big heart. And the pizza has such a nostalgic taste #Amazingpizza

10/10 i love eddie hes kind and understanding. Place is amazing, cant go wrong with a business thats been around for 40 years and only focuses on the pizza! read more

Best pizza in town. Hands down. To add, Eddie is so kind and hospitable. Highly recommend.

Place is a hidden gem. Feels like you went in a time machine to what pizza places looked like when you were a kid. Probably because it's never been updated. Cash only. No delivery. People seem to call ahead even if they're sitting down. Eddie is the only person that makes pizza. Menu is very basic. Was shocked at how inexpensive it was. I had to make sure he got everything. Eddie and the other worker couldn't have been nicer to my kids. read more

Old school actual old school New York pizza by an older Italian gentleman. It's so hard to find that nowadays. I got the chicken pizza it was awesome. I got one slice upset I did not have more cash and I was rushing to class. Cash only, so make sure you bring cash. Owner was very nice, will definitely be back. I tried taking menu photos but the sun wasn't in my favor that day. Definitely a must try, made me happy on a stressful day read more

Eddie D's Pizzeria - Menu items - Pizza Near Me - Valley Stream, New York

See all

Old school NY pizza spot. The first time I tried to grab a slice was too late and they were closing. When I opened the door the smell knock some nostalgia gears into rotation and I was taken back to the daily after school pizza slice trip of my childhood in NYC. I had to come back and try it. When I returned I met the owner who was making the pizza and he was very welcoming and classic pizza guy. Very friendly and made me feel like a regular. Plenty of regulars arrived and they would talk like old friends. So this place is definitely a neighborhood staple. I ordered a regular slice and a pepperoni slice to get a baseline. The regular was delicious and definitely old school, great crust, no flop, and the cheese was not too oily. The pepperoni slice had a bit of flop but was delicious. The slices were a bit smaller than I expected but the price was fair. I paid $8.00 for a regular slice, pepperoni slice, and a can of Pepsi. Cash only spot! I was satisfied enough to ask for a third slice, this time opting for a mushroom slice and it was also wonderful. This place is a classic pizza spot, no new specialty style slices. So no grandma or Buffalo chicken. Which is fine because enough places already do that. The decor is dated to the 80's or even earlier. Which is also fine because this is not a date spot, it is a classic pizza spot, grab a slice and go or sit down for a few minutes and recharge. Come here if you want to walk into the past and taste old school NY pizza with a nice sauce and real cheese. Definitely visiting Eddie again and going to start ordering pies from there. read more

Pizza Place like it was 40 years ago. Unpretentious-classic-slice and soda - forget the over rated maxi-fashion slice when you come to Eddie D's. Music cranks like the 1980's too. Last but not least - owner pleasant too. read more

Eddie D's is amazing, affordable pizza. The great service and kindness from the owner really shines through. My husband and I really love Eddie D's. The wait time for a pie is long, but it's all worth it. read more

I found this pizza shop in Yelp and the reviews were good enough to entice me to give it a shot. Upon entry I was greeted. It was lunch time on weekday, but I was the only customer. The owner was very friendly and told me he had old fashioned pizza. I ordered a plain pizza and pepperoni slice and a Coke. The pizza was good, however it wasn't memorable or flavorful in a way to make me go out of my return. There's a lot of good pizza in the area to settle. The pizza tasted good, but it just didn't have a wow factor. I also wished it was oven hot! The lunch special is a good value, two slices and a fountain drink for $5.50. Inside also didn't feel very clean. My tables looked like it needed to be wiped down. It wasn't atrociously dirty, it just don't looked like it was recently wiped for cleanliness. read more

See all

The pizza was delicious and garlic knots were amazing! I usually go once a week! Service is fast

First timer. Just happened to be driving by and decided to try this spot out. Eddie did not disappoint. His pizza is simply delicious. I love how flavorful the slices were and the crust had a perfect crisp and crunch. Just what I needed. After eating 2 slices, I decided to order a few to go. I can definitely see why he's been in business for 38 years! I highly recommend and will definitely be back. read more

first timer. Eddie was very welcoming. Pizza is delicious Cash only but definitely worth it!

Have ordered here a few times and it's one of our favorite pizza places. Owner is super friendly and seems to really put his all in his pizza. Will certainly be back soon. read more

A great local spot for pizza. The owner, Eddie, seems to really care about what he does and is very kind. The pizza is very reasonably priced and tasty. A classic spot in my opinion. read more

Just met Eddie the owner. What a great guy! amazing Pizza. He has been been here 40 years this is a must try.

A friend of ours recommended this spot for a traditional NY slice since I'm from California. It definitely lived up to there hype. Eddie was really nice and outgoing. We told him he had good recommendations and it was our first time there and he gave us two slices and garlic knots for free on top of our order. Pizza was immaculate. Light, thin, no flop, not too greasy, great taste, great undercarriage, good crunch. Overall 9.5/10 on the slices. read more