I placed my order over the phone with a kind, well-spoken young man who was helpful and informative--off to a great start! When I arrived, I was greeted by Joey out front, whose warm, welcoming smile instantly confirmed I had chosen the right pizza place. Inside, some irresistible chocolate cake bites on the counter caught my eye--and yes, I indulged in one! Shortly after, I met the co-owner when I came to pick up my order. She was super friendly, easy to talk to, and made me feel like a truly valued customer. When I got home, my family was blown away by the pizza dough--it's pure heaven. Soft, airy, and incredibly light and fluffy. We devoured every slice and unanimously decided this is our new read more

See all

Every Tuesday a large pizza pie is $9.25 plus tax not including toppings. So today is Tuesday it's 95 degrees and humid so I am not turning on the oven so I decided to stop by. I ordered a large pie half pepperoni cooked well. The total came to $12.75. The employees are very nice it didn't take long before my pizza was ready. I am so glad I stopped by the pizza was really good, nice crust, cheese was good, nice amount of pepperoni. When you go on there Instagram page certain days of the week they have different specials. read more

See all

Listen, $11.50/$12 large cheese pie is hard to come by without it tasting like it's machine made. AP Pizza delivers both affordability and flavor. Typically, they close at 5 PM on Sundays but when we walked in, they were srill taking orders telling me that he new owners cared more about their customers than closing up shop early. The pizza dough was light and crunchy. I especially loved all the cheese they used (nonsparingly) and the sauce was just the right amount of sweet and tangy. Dining area only has 3 areas with a large leather couch by the window so patrons can sit comfortably while waiting for their food. They also offered frozen slices for just a $1 and heat and serve premade meals. I live about 30 minutes away but I'd definitely drive down to pick up a few pies. Absolutely awesome! read more

See all

We arrived on a Thursday noon. The place is very small but cozy. The couch looks cute. Kids order cheese slice and a meatball parm which was on sale. I ordered the ceasar salad. They were SO TASTY!!!!!!! Our fav was the meatball parm!!!! The kids loved it so much!!! My salad was perfect. The service was quick and friendly. El servicio y la comida fueron fenomenales. Definitivamente recomendaría este lugar. read more

See all

Wow! Wish I lived closer! Such a cute place! It's small but super cozy and makes you feel welcome, like you are going to grammas kitchen! The food is very affordable and DELICIOUS! They have frozen meals, what a great idea! Loved coming here, I can't wait to get home and devour the cheesecake! read more

See all

I'm late on my review :( but I went to AP pizza & cafe for the yelp pizza event! Upon entering everything looked very clean and well put together they even have a couch, which brings such a cool vibe into the restaurant. I got there right at opening and they were setting up for the day but I was immediately helped and greeted with a smile! I put in my order and also collected some menus to take home. And within 20 minutes, my pizza and chicken roll. We're ready to go. I was so excited to get my food. I totally forgot to check out the desserts which I've heard amazing things about and have to go back ! I have to say the pizza and the chicken roll were delicious. Even my family said we should really go back because the food was so good! If you haven't tried AP Pizza & Cafe please gooo! read more

See all

This is such a surprise. Hidden gem for sure. $10 for a large a pie in NY speaks for itself. Frozen dinners to go so I don't have to cook? SPEAK NO MORE. The crust was thin, chewy inside & crunchy on the bottom. More like a true NYC slice instead of the typical LI pizza with more dough. As for my topping, pepperoni, they are generous! I'm so used to seeing pizzerias skimping out on how much toppings they give but not here. They were definitely generous enough that I had pepperoni in every bite. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

This place is much better than Joey's Pizza, which it replaced. It's along the best pizza in Lynbrook. It also offers full dinners at a great value and frozen meals to go. Terrific service. read more

I don't know what it is about their pizza but it reminds me of Pizza how it used to taste and I mean this in a great way it's just a simple no-frills place making good solid homemade tasting food. You can get a $10 pizza on Tuesday and their prices are straight out of the 90s But the food quality does not disappoint. Definitely a place worth checking out. Interior is simple inside with several booths to sit, and service is friendly and quick. Also note they make some killer cakes for like $5 a slice! read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Plain cheese Tuesday special - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Joey's is in a section of Lynbrook with somewhat tough parking. It's facade shows it's longevity. There is an eating area that for sure needs a face-lift. Despite its age and wear, it still looks clean and sanitary. Menus are cluttered. There is a freezer with Togo foods. As I've only been once despite living in Lynbrook for almost 20 years, I've only tried the pizza. When ordering, a woman seemed to be a little short tempered as she had to break away from what seemed to be a catering order. It appeared she was wearing her pajamas. The gentleman who took my money was far more pleasant. This pie is somewhere better than domino's or dollar pizza, but below other pizzarias that would charge double. It's certainly wasn't bad, but also misses the mark for anything better than ok/fair. The sauce lacks flavor. The cheese could have been heavier. The dough was OK. It seems they use cornmeal underneath the pizza for some reason, which leaves a texture I'm personally not fond of. For $10, this isn't bad as you could feed 2 people with a pie. However, I wouldn't go out of my way for the pizza. I would return and try one of his meals which are also reasonably price. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Pizza special. Can use some more cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

The pizzas are delicious. The service for takeout is cordial. The price is excellent. It is worth a visit.

Whether this place is known as AP or Joey's Pizza, this place is STILL the best. This is the most AFFORDABLE Pizza around. The staff is always very friendly as well. It's a cozy little establishment with delicious food(the hot heroe subs are great too) and affordable prices. WE travel from the next town over to get it even with over a dozen Pizza Places in our own town. read more

Hole in the wall gem for NY Pizza. If you're looking for an inexpensive neighborhood NY Pizza place look no further. $12.00 for a large cheese. Say no more. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

that food was buss the people were very nice and i will be going back and the pizza was very fresh

I absolutely love this place. Thank you the food is great. I am so glade my co-workers introduced me to this fantastic establishment. I no longer have to cook every day. The portion's are just enough for the 2 of us. I get the meals without the Pasta because my Husband likes spaghetti better. Thank you for keeping the price affordable.The address is 5 Huntington Ave in Lynbrook 516-599-2929 lots of specials. Check it out. read more

Great food and prices! Specials every day. Very friendly owner and staff. Our favorites are the chicken and eggplant parm trays for $35.00, ready to pop in the oven. read more

Good local pizzeria. Enjoyed my pizza. Warm atmosphere and family surroundings. Has good prices on take home meals. Fast courteous service. read more

See all

A recommended catering place by a friend so we tried for tonight's fundraising event. We ( our church community) have used them for the first time catering our fundraising event. They did not disappoint us. They give considerable catering pricing. They just need a week or less of informing them of your preliminary order and could give changes two days prior. As per discussed with the rest of my group, we ordered few kinds but multiple orders in quantity. It will make it easier for both parties. We got 10 standard trays of the following: baked ziti, sausage and peppers, chicken parmigiana and eggplant parmigiana. I enjoyed most the egg parm, tasteful, meaty ( I mean eggplanty) and portion is served generously. I did not like much the sausage and peppers, too soupy. The packaging style is conveniently perfect for transporting, they placed the pan inside a pizza box keeping the food warm , additional star for that. You could choose delivery for a charge or pick your own. I want to come back if given a chance and try their pizza which I heard has very good steal deal. Highly Recommended for any catering service needs. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

The pizza is priced great and taste very good. I also enjoy their garlic bread. Pepperoni isn't too salty either.

Tried Joey's yesterday for the first time..very pleased how good everything was..Joey you have a new patron..my name is Mark and I'll be back...actually going to try today's specials...thanks read more

If you want the best ,affordable pizza in town, Joeys is the place to go! Besides pizza , his hero's, takeout dinners and his homemade bread are the Best! You definitely can't leave without taking a loaf for the way home , ( Maybe 2) one for the ride home! You , don't have these local pizza places like this anymore . read more

Yesterday my wife and I tried Joeys when you pull up to the establishment it's a little sketchy but it's basically like what we used to call back in the day and old school Pizza parlor very hard-working establishment a lot of to go meals frozen meals we had the pizza reminds me of old-school pizza very good awesome crust And I actually took a pie home today. We tried the frozen dinners I had the chicken cutlet Parmesan. My wife had the eggplant Parmesan and we were pleasantly surprised it was excellent both meals this of a lot of other Italian places in the area that need to close down because they're horrible but this place is pretty damn good. Keep up the great work. read more

Food is amazing, bread is handmade on premises, GREAT PRICES, such as 5 pies for $45.00, tray of eggplant, meatball or chicken cutlet parmigiana for $35.00 cold, $40.00 heated. We buy cold and heat portions in the microwave. Deliveries to 5:00 PM, service is great. Call 20 minutes before pick-up. Love Joey's food! read more

It's like inflation is being felt everywhere expert at Joey's Pizza Lynbrook. I'm always shocked how delicious their pie (and food) is for the price. read more

Very convenient, local, affordable. No public restroom. Has many pasta dishes you can buy, bring home, and microwave. Tuesday special is $6.50 pies! I got a pie for $9.50 because I added mushrooms. The sauce to cheese to crust ratio is perfect. I even love this pizza when it is reheated. Garlic knots are $2 for 6 pieces. Each box comes with 6 pieces. The garlic flavor is strong. The pizza tastes great reheated or eaten cold the next day as well. We ordered as a badminton team 2 years ago. We got 10 boxes at $5 each. Great deals from here! Their bread is also so delicous. Glad this pizzeria has been open for so many years. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

reasonable and delious, this is the place to go! you should try the frozen food, prices are right, not over priced.

This pizza parlor was recommended to me, so I decided to give it a try. I'm glad I did. It tasted great. The pizza dough was thin enough, which left a lite crunch with each bite. The cheese was just the right amount. It wasn't too cheesy which can at times cause a pizza to become chewy and It wasn't too sparse which can at times leave little to be desired and in turn take away from the pizza experience as a whole. The pizza taste great when it's nice and fresh out the oven, but once it starts to cool, it no longer taste the same. They have different days during the week where they offer special deals. With the already affordable price for a pie, the deals are really a steal. With everything that's going on in the world today, saving money and eating good is a win win in my book. read more

Joey is the nicest guy you ever want to meet he has his own special sauce and the prices are fantastic

Good Pizza! Good Price! Good People! Love to give them my business. Hard working folks.

This was my first time at Joey's Pizza, but it won't be my last. The place gets busy and does quite a local business. I watched as people purchased pizzas and frozen dinners to go. But the young lady taking orders moved quickly, knew most of the customers and their orders. She was extra helpful in rec the Buffalo Chicken pizza for the group of teenagers. And she was correct because they gobbled that one up first. I purchased several different kinds of pizzas since it was for a group of students, and they were each absolutely delicious. I particularly liked the taste of the crust which I often don't eat on other pizzas. This crust was delish! My compliments to the chef. Joey's is a tiny gem hidden on a side street where all the locals go to get their pizza fix. Now I will too!! read more

Called Joey's pizzeria based on an advertisement that we received on Sunday about a five pie deal as a special for schools. Called to place an order for our team party and was told that the full page color ad we received was a mistake and they weren't the right prices. When asked if they planned to honor the price that was advertised I was told by the owner no it wasn't his fault that a mistake was made and it wasn't his problem. I would think as a business owner you would honor the advertised price to keep your customers happy and coming back....but nope not here...not his fault and not his problem. Ok well thanks and don't worry we will never do business with Joey's pizzeria again. read more

Really poor quality pizza, place is dirty and unkept. One older man I don't know if he is the owner or a worker is rude and mean. Place should not be in business. Do not waste your money. read more

I eat at Joey's once a week. I happen to love the food. The frozen dinners I've been ordering since Sandy. They are awesome for the price. Take on the 8 minutes to make I fully recommend this place. The prices are insanely cheap. And I find the food to be very good. read more

Joey seen the right concept and doing business office daily specials and office delivery and Joey always has pride and what he makes and what he does it's very important to him that that comes out like if he's going to eat it and it even comes out better than that this place is worth a try I definitely recommend it and now you can see Joey everyday live on Facebook what a great pizza store and restaurant and another thing is you will not leave hungry read more

Second time using Joey's for a large party. I ordered for 150 people. The amount of food was more than plentiful! I usually pick up because I order from this place regularly and the price was better for pick up than delivery. The staff stacked the food in my van nicely and made driving the food to the venue a breeze. The food is hearty and filling. It was also hot and the way he puts the pans in pizza boxes, keeps it hot for a good Went I'm today to order pizza with sausage, peppers and black olives. Hands down.... best pizza I ever had! read more

These guys are the best! My parents are in Baldwin and I'm in Montreal right now. They are high risk because of their age and health issues. I've been so worried about them having enough food. My mom placed and order for meals and they were delivered within 30 minutes!! I can't thank you guys enough for staying open during these tough times. When it's all over I'm going to stop in and hug all of you read more

Wish the pizza had a bit more cheese and crust would not be so soggy. Place can use a bit updating. People are very nice. read more

We regularly order our pizza from Joeys & also have used him about a dozen times for catering needs. The food is always delicious, especially the chicken parm, stuffed shells, meatballs, baked clams...heck, just about everything! The only item I am personally not a fan of is sausage & peppers. I usually order a few days ahead & the delivery is always prompt. The amt of rolls he gives is crazy! All our guests compliment on the food. A coworker used Joeys for our HS staff end of party, which needed to serve over 100 people, & it went seamlessly. read more

Ap Pizza & Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Great Food, Great Prices, off the main road but you should go there and try the food. Won't be disappointed!

If I could less than one star Joey's would get it. Growing up in Long Island, loving pizza and Italian food, I order a PIE that was horrible, and dinners so dad could have his favorites prepared in minutes to have a good dinner. Well unfortunately I would never recommended their food or their dirty store front with a crappy attitude. read more