Eek. Wanted to like this classic place, but the pizza was pretty horrendous. The sausage was not fresh and had an odd texture.

Very nice service and friendaly, super tasty pizza margherita and chicken . I will go again and try more....

Worst pizza place EVER! First I call into make an order and he tells me I got the wrong Ginos. I tell him the address cleared that up Walk in .., yells at me "cash only" I say "I know" Picking up. I ordered 2 salads 4 slices and a chicken roll- $60 They used spring mix for a Caesar salad. He was right I should've called Gino's in Long Beach read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Ordered a large pie, half-plain/half-pepperoni and sausage, last night. Order was ready within 20 minutes. I came in and was immediately greeted and recognized. I even got some free garlic knots. The pie was freshly made and absolutely delicious. Great crust, it was fluffy and crispy. The pie was devoured immediately. Ordering a fresh pie is definitely the way to go. Definitely recommend. read more

Gino's is an outstanding pizza restaurant that has been a Lynbrook favorite for 50 years! Perfect thin crust NY style pizza. Delicious! Never misses! Mario has been running Gino's for decades and he always aims to please. Highly recommended! read more

Absolutely horrible experience. Right out of the get go the one who answers the phone gives so much attitude. I tried to push past it and ignore it thinking it was just me but he continued to pushy and rude and outright disrespectful. Kept asking for my address even though I am ordering pickup I have no need to be telling u where tf I live. I don't know how that affects anything to me ordering but kept pushing to see where I live and after I called him out for being rude completely lashed out and acted like a child. Please head my warning never order from these pieces of shits their food is probably ass anyway they probably spit in your food too absolutely horrible people read more

Poor service attitude Pizza is terrible Poor hygiene omg i never go to the store terrible like that Never come back again read more

Comfortable local pizza shop. Guys at the front are quick and courteous. Pizza was fresh, lots of options. I had the buffalo and plain slice. read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Inside of pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Ordered a chicken parm hero - what a mistake and waste of money. When you pick it up, you never know what you will get - will it be good or bad? IT WAS THE WORST - dry overcooked no sauce, no cheese. It was so disgusting that after a few bites, it went in the garbage. There is no quality or consistency. Its also the same with their pizza. Sometime its perfect but other time its either under cooked or burnt. Sorry but I won't be back. With the prices today, you've lost my business! Good luck, you need it! read more

This is the last of the old-time neighborhood pizza places, where getting a slice and chatting up conversations about New York sports teams was commonplace. Happily, Mario and his staff has ensured Lynbrook residents and neighbors that this piece of nostalgia is around to stay! It has stayed true to its simple recipe of delicious fare and friendly service. Salute! read more

The best pizza in the world ! The people are very nice. The prices are reasonable. The parking in Baldwin Gino's is very convenient.

I normally order through Uber. This restaurant follows instructions well and always reads the notes for special instructions. The food is always good and the portions are often enough for two meals. read more

Excellent pizza, great staff, old fashioned pizzeria feel inside. This place is 100% worth the visit, great guys!

I've been going here since I'm a child.Literally since I'm 6. The BEST old school pizza around. I've moved 90 minutes away and still make the drive back. Good luck trying to find pizza like this anywhere on The Island. Still owned by the same family. Just a few steps from the Lynbrook train station. read more

My favorite slice in Lynbrook- and that's saying a lot considering how many pizza spots there are in this town! Very old school vibe, but sometimes that's how you know you're getting the best slice am I right? read more

This is my go to pizza place in the neighborhood. Born and raised in Queens and particular about my NY style pizza, this place does it for me. Kind staff, very friendly and accommodating read more

The best Chicken roll in NY . I been in many places around Nothing like Gino's rolls and I'm not even mentioning Chicken Parma

You can't go to long Beach and not stop by at Gino's and have a wonderful pizza . The pizza are delicious and the garlic bread. It's a very busy place but worth the wait read more

How do I describe ginos? Hmmm I know! 1: outstanding pizza! 2: service is amazing. I'm even friends with the workers there 3: the seating is great Also it's right near where I go to school so I can go there for lunch if I wanted to durning the school day! Ginos of lynbrook is totally recommended Go try it out you wont be sorry you tried it! read more

I've lived in a bunch of different states and I travel to countless cities and towns and states all across the US... and I've had pizza everywhere along the way. This past Tuesday, in a hurry to get to the airport... my wife and I stopped at Gino's thinking we'd catch a quick couple of slices then sprint to JFK to fly home. These guys are every decent guy you hoped to find behind the counter... salt of the earth... the genuine article. The pizza? We had Sicilian and regular. I'll cut to the chase; they've got the absolute best NY pizza you'll ever find anywhere, EVER. The very, very best there is. Pizza the way it was always meant to be! Don't miss Gino's Pizza!!! Five stars!!! read more

Very good pizza. we're surrounded by pizza places here, but this one is old school. Reminds me of my child hood spot.

Nice old school style pizzeria. Good neapolitan pizza,relatively thin crust. Order a whole pie so as to get the freshest pizza. Lost a star as they don't offer delivery, and "Mario" has an unpleasant attitude to anyone who is not 100% in line with ideas. read more

Tried and true neighborhood pizza place! I've been going to Gino's forever! This is the best place around when you're looking for a good regular slice of pizza, best regular slice in town! Which says a lot since there are quite a few pizza places around! I'm also a huge fan of the garlic knots and never leave without ordering a few! Best thing about this place is it's open a little later than the others so if you're craving pizza and think it might be too late, well you're in luck and you can head right over to Gino's! The service is also extremely welcoming and friendly, I've never had a bad experience in all the times I've been here! If you haven't tried Gino's yet then you're really missing out and I suggest you do so ASAP! read more

Haven't been here in years, but this is the pizza I grew up on and it's as good as ever! Thin, crispy crust, tangy sauce and plenty of authentic cheese. Excellent NY pizza! read more

Been coming here for years. From the crust to being able to taste the different cheeses. To top it off I called 20 mins before they closed. Not only were they polite about it but the pizza was still amazing ! Can't wait to order again read more

I LOVE the food from here! Not just the pizza is delicious but all the other food as well. Since the pandemic I stopped eating out as much. Once I returned to eating out I noticed most of my "old" favorites hired new staff members so consistency has been hard to find but not here! They are just as good, if not better than what I remember. Can't beat the quality, price, and service at Gino's !! P.S. I am a Ninja Turtle and 100% qualify as a pizza expert. read more

My good friend who is from Oceanside but now lives in Lynbrook recommended that we go to Gino's and order a plain pie to stay. He was unable to join us but his wife, my wife and myself went to Gino's around 845pm on a Friday to order what he recommended. We were given 6 complimentary knots which are basically garlic bread lumps of pizza dough. About 10 minutes later out comes a huge pizza. This pizza is old school style NY pizza, plain (just cheese), thin crust. We had the pepper flakes, oregano and garlic powder sprinklers for our slices which we folded and devoured in about 15 minutes. Both my friend and my wife had 2 slices each and I ended up eating 4. It was just great, what a treat to have a real pie as my first meal on Long Island during this trip. At the end of it all I went to pay and it was only 13 bucks. That's just crazy... We ordered a full pie so it was made fresh for us and while it sat on the table I stared at it and was sort of in wonder as the diameter of the pizza was almost the entire width of the booth table. This pie was wide and wide pies make for large slices. The food was great and I think we've created a new tradition of having to go to Gino's each visit to Lynbrook. read more

See all

Been eating at this Gino's in Lynbrook since I started on solid foods. In fact, I base all my pizza reviews on this one. Great pizza, great food in general. They use a raw sauce, thin crust, which I love; don't like a spiced up cooked sauce on my pizza. When I was a kid, I remember rolling up my crusts in a napkin and saving them in my pocket for breakfast on the way to school, and it was still good. Being Italian, if it got a little stale, I'd just dip it in my coffee. The decor could really use an updating, that is the only reason I dropped a star; and the guys working there aren't as cute as they used to be. It used to be a hot draw for the ladies, which also added to that 5th star; but overall, as far as pizza goes, when good pizza is what Italians can't do without, this place feels like home. You can't go wrong when your belly is aching for pizza to head for a Gino's sign. I've sampled every Gino's I've ever found, from Long Beach to Islip and points in between and I've never been disappointed. Most don't deliver, or offer pizza specials, so you know your patrons are die hards! So if you haven't tried them already, take my advice. They're definitely a thumbs up! I used to keep a box top in my car that listed all their locations so I would never be too far if I was craving a slice! Soooo, just sayin' give it a try, you won't regret it! read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Couldn't even wait to get the pie home. Ate two slices on the road. It smelled awesome in the car! Had to do it! - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

By far the WORST pizza in NY!!! Soft, doughy and blend... BULLSHIT PIZZA!!! Frozen pizza maybe better... can't believe this place calls themselves a pizzeria read more

One of the best regular slices I've ever had in my life! So good I sometimes make the hour long drive all the way from Port Jeff Station when I'm craving a good slice. read more

Not part of the other Gino's,but a true mom & pop old school Pizzeria run by Italian's that do it right!Mario and his crew make the most delicious amazing pie's! The Sicilian is my go to Pie,soooo good! I always order mine well done,they use the best and freshest ingredients and u can taste the quality! Garlic knots!pepperoni wheels and salad's w the homemade vinaigrette are also delicious!never had the pasta dishes here but i'd imagine they're fantastic,simple but comfy booth seating inside accomodates just fine,so if you're a new customer and happen to be in the area or a regular like me stop in for a nice cold fountain soda,a slice or 2 followed by an italian ice and Buon appétito! Fyi cash only and no delivery. read more

Take out date: December 13, 2014 My sister had a holiday party and we got some pies from Gino's. My family are a bunch of eaters (including myself) and I'm very polite so I managed to snag one cheese slice and one garlic knot as everyone flocked to get some pizza when it arrived. The pizza was very tasty, the crust wasn't the greatest crust I ever had but it wasn't the worst either. The sauce & cheese were just fine! The garlic knot was alright it wasn't oily enough for my taste. Overall I don't have any real complaints about their pizza and would eat it again for sure! read more

The employee at this pizzeria was so sweet. He made my day and there pizza was amazing too. Conveniently located next to Zwanger and on Sunrise Highway. CASH ONLY! However it is so worth it. I highly recommend this place due to its amazing service & amazing food! read more

I'm not exaggerating when I say that they consistently have the best pizza (that I've been to) in NY, which is a lot. Besides the taste, they someone how are consistent by not burning the crust (either bottom, or side)... it's always soft. While undergoing some dental work recently, this was even more important to me than usual. I don't know how they do it as consistently as they do. Besides the regular, you have to try the "Tomato, Basil, Garlic" pizza. And of course, the 3 guys that are there are ALWAYS courteous, friendly, and respectful. They really make you feel like family. I don't often give 5 stars. They definitely deserve it. read more

I want here today to pick up a couple of slices and use the restroom and take out even though I was wearing a mask I was refused access to the restroom. I was given a story that it's not allowed in any restaurant. Obviously that's false. I found these people particularly unfriendly as a result of there actions. The pizza looked mediocre but I couldn't tell you as I left after being denied. read more

Hands down, the best pizza on Long Island. Great soft buttery tasting dough, sauce and cheese, the perfect trifecta. If your cheese slice is good then you've got some really good pizza! read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Delicious pizza! I like A lot of red pepper on my slice, my preference. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Great, old school pizzeria that has been here, run by the same family for 50 years. Mario, Lou and Phil all make a great pie. The crust is fantastic! read more

My train was delayed in Lynbrook due to an accident, so I got off in the pouring rain looking for a spot to stay dry, grab a bite to eat, and wait for my ride. The gentlemen behind the counter were very nice, conversational and genuinely concerned about the welfare of the train passengers. I ordered a Caesar salad slice and really enjoyed it. I usually don't like pizza (I know, crazy), plus I was drenched, a little annoyed and a little hungry, but really LOVED the slice - so that's saying something. My only complaint is that it's cash only and there aren't any signs saying so; I wasn't made aware that it was a cash only spot until I finished my slice and went to pay. Luckily I had cash, but a friend of mine didn't. read more

Great pizza! Thin crust, crisp but not too crisp. High marks to the cheese and tomato/mozzarella slices. Great / friendly service as well. Will be back! read more

OPEN ON MONDAY. I tired a slice and it's one of the better pizzas I've had. The crust is crisp, sauce flavorful without being overpowering, and cheese wonderful. I told the owner Yelp incorrectly had listed him closed on Monday. He said Yelp won't correct his hours unless he pays them money. read more