We tried this place for the first time, We got the menu in the mail and noticed the prices were not too bad and free delivery which was refreshing. We ordered the linguine and meatballs with tomato sauce, Tortellini alla vodka, garlic bread and cheese and the 6 zeppoli. Delivery did take a awhile but I realize Saturday night is a busy night so It wasn't the worst thing. When we did get the food, we noticed the plates were filled with adequate product but then I saw their was 2 small meatballs with a large plate of linguini . The pasta looked very old and the sauce had no flavor and appeared old. No presentation, no greens on top to color the dish. Everything was bland. I make better meatballs. The same goes with our other pasta dish. The garlic bread was not crunchy and had to pull it apart like licorice. There was displaced and minimal cheese on the bread. Nothing was freshly made. The zeppoli was old, pully and you could break your tooth on the ends, The food was not made with love. Just a typical fast food joint that does not take pride in what they do. read more

Just had a great delivery from this place. Pizza was hot and bottom still crispy when it arrived. Chicken roll was excellent as well. Will definitely order again! read more

This is one the best pizza places in Long Island. service is 10/10 and I will definitely buy from here again. the penne alla vodka is my favorite. Also Jose Quinteros was a very friendly delivery driver. I love him so much. raise his pay. read more

Never tried this place but thought I would give it a go because on seamless seemed that reviews were okay. Should have cross referenced on Yelp. Ordered our meal and it was due for delivery in 35-45 minutes. 1.5 hours after placing our order, the food finally arrived (we are a 6 min drive from restaurant) cold and mediocre at best. Writing a review to let fellow Yelpers know of the experience but really to help me remember to never order from here again. read more

Take out Date: December 13, 2014 So my family had a holiday party on the 13th. They ordered pizza from here and from Gino's. I managed to snag a Sicilian slice from this place in the chaos that ensued once the pizza arrived and my food loving family gathered in the kitchen and dining room to grab pizza. I'm the polite one so I had to snag my slice and be as nice as possible. The slice was good I wouldn't go crazy over it but I definitely wouldn't hate it either. My verdict is this is a decent pizza joint to go to! read more

The pasta dishes are delicious and plentiful! We had the broccoli rabe pasta with shrimp and the linguini carbonara with grilled chicken and it was SOO TASTY! We ordered garlic bread with mozzarella and my family ate it so fast I only got one piece. We ordered the food for delivery on UberEats and it arrived hot and fresh! Today we ordered a pepperoni pizza and a sausage and mushroom pizza with two orders of sautéed broccoli rabe and 6 garlic knots. The pizzas were DELICIOUS! The pizza crust was thin and crispy! Just the way we like them! The broccoli rabe was so garlicky and delicious! The food arrived quickly and was still warm! We LOVE DON GIOVANNI'S and will definitely order from them again! read more

We place our order at 11:25 and it arrived at 12:55. I spoke to the restaurant twice asking when it was going to come. The first time they stated it would be there in 10 minutes. 20 minutes later I called again. The food lacked flavor. We order shrimp parm and the shrimp was dry. The stuffed shells looked like a mess, it appeared that they overcooked it. We try to support local businesses during tough times but this restaurant has to do a much better job. They lost a potential loyal customer. read more

The food is great and is worth the try. My go to spot for pizza while at work. The people are such nice, humble, hard workers that make you feel like family. The pizza is thin and crunchy and satisfies all the right spots read more

Solid, consistent Italian, with great wings! Many times you get the frozen breaded wings, not here! Perfect!

Your standard pizza place in Nassau county. Repeat is possible. He is kind of expensive compared to Gino's down the block which I feel is a better choice. This place serves to of people in the area where their is a lot of business where Gino's is an oasis off sunrise. read more

I used to order from here so my wife can have a gyro when the rest of the family eats pizza. She needs gluten free and even gluten free pizza's are not good for her. The Gyro was never that good as they make it very thin, almost like a cold cut. It is sort of like waiting for something good and then getting a wedgie by the entire St Louis Rams offensive line. We now order pizza from one place and get a gyro from somewhere else as the quality is just worth it that way, Pizza is alright, but not as good as Gino's or Regina's. read more

Honestly was not expecting a great meal as the delivery minimum price was low and their was only one dollar sign assigned to Don Giovanni's (I usually associate the cheap price with mediocre food) but we were pleasantly surprised! I ordered a Greek salad with chicken and the tortellini soup. The soup arrived piping hot and was extremely flavorful. The salad was what I was expecting! The chicken was fresh. My boyfriend ordered the tortellini alla vodka and he could not stop raving about it. The sauce was flavorful and the meal was perfectly portioned. They also gave him a medium sized loaf of Italian bread to go with it which is always appreciated. Only complaint is the delivery took a little longer than we had expected but it fell in the range they gave us so it was not unexpected. read more

Great pizza and excellent service. The Marinara and Grandma slices are the best slices in Lynbrook. read more

I've had food from here twice. The first time they delivered the wrong pizza and had to come back with the right one. The second time, the food made me Ill. I had chicken fingers and fries. It was way too greasy. Do not order anything other than pizza here! read more

Very simple yet very good Sicilian slice. I did not try a full pie yet but I will in the future. Small place but nice seating. This is not top of the line pizza but just as good as any other place. read more

We've been loyal customers of this pizzeria for 2-1/2 years ordering 2 pies weekly. We do not like a well done pie and always remind them when ordering. The last couple of times we received a well done pie and said nothing, this time we called to request a new one. Three people got on the phone to argue with me in raised voices to say "the pie wasn't well done, it was crispy". I told them we would not be ordering from them any longer their pies are not consistent. They told me to "have a nice life" and hung up. How disappointing. read more

Ordered baked clams and a small pie. I got the delivery an hour after I called. Pie was ok but the were a mess. The dish was upside down juice all over the place and the stuffing out of the clam. The clams stuffing was way to salty and I was not happy with my experience. read more

Don Giovanni Pizzeria - a plate of meatballs with gravy sauce and lemon wedges - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

My peeps. They are your standard local pizzeria. Friendly and the food is actually really good. Both regular and sicial

Last friday we really wanted some pasta and thought lets give this place a try... so excited to try the online ordering feature. Pretty disappointed with it though. On two of the dishes we had added in the notes to substitute for a different type of pasta. The substitution was not done and we were not informed that there was no substituting allowed. In addition we has ordered extra anchovies on the side and never received them. Overall the food was pretty tasteless: eggplant calzone, puttanesca and linguini with bolognese sauce. Oh well are search for italian delivery continues read more

I order from here once a week. Delivery is always fast and it's delicious! Prices are very affordable too! Give them a call your belly and wallet will be happy! read more

The Margarita slice was okay, but the other pizza is pretty old. They also did not offer to provide any sort of sauce with the garlic knots or their pepperoni bites (the latter definitely needed something to dip it in!). Overall, it is a okay place to stop if you need a slice or two, but as far as a go-to place, I am going to keep looking. read more

I give it one star because I can't give it a half of a star. I love subs. And as much as I hate Subway, I would eat there a thousand times before ever ordering subs from this place again. The meat was not that great and bread was old and of poor quality. I've lived in Philly and NY area my whole life and travel quite a bit in my job. These subs were the worse I've ever ate. It's the first time my wife and I threw subs in the trash before finishing them. read more

Great pizza. Always a soccer game on the tv. Top it off with reasonably priced lunch special and you have one of the best pizza places on L.I. read more

Very good pizza and other Italian specialties, with fast and friendly service. It is a small neighborhood pizzeria that definitely fills the bill, plus they deliver. read more

Well, I ordered from here twice and both time there was issues. I will say they offered to taked care of it, and I took them up omit the first time, but Not the second. The first time I agrred to a retry the final product was cold tasty but cold the second time I had issue. Is because the pie was cold. So I called and they said they will send me another. First one tookover 1.5 hours (35min was told to me on phone). Why would I wait again. The place has so much promise, just needs leadership changes read more