When you're on the go delivering packages this is prime location to come to and grab a quick bite to eat. The service is quick unless it's a school day and it's during a rush. The location has seating but it's limited and very small so no large groups. They have an complete Italian menu I am going to try something else one day when I'm not in a hurry read more

We are visiting from Hawaii and tonight we didn't want to go out for dinner so luckily Joe's Pizzeria is just up the block. We ordered a cheese pizza, wow that was good. I'm glad we had a chance to have this pizza. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

Great value pizza was great frozen dishes to go were very convenient. I would recommend eating here and take out .

I recently ordered a white pizza with mushrooms to go. The pizza was very good. Made fast & good quality ingredients. The ricotta and mozzarella were both fresh tasting. read more

We've been routinely using Joe's pizza since COVID started, and we've been really pleased with our new choice of pizzeria. In the past I had visited Joe's once or twice for a slice and some zeppoles and given them a 3-star review, but I'm updating to 4 because of our experience over the last few months. While the pickup time can sometimes be a bit later than estimated (we call ahead), the quality is worth it. Joe's cheese slice is absolutely classic, exactly what you think of when you imagine a NY slice of pizza, with just the right amount of cheese, a sweet tomato sauce, and the perfect crust consistency. We have also ordered a chicken parmigiana slice (a house specialty) and it's my new favorite pizza. The chicken always comes out delicious. We also tend to get zeppoles with our meal and find it to be a great after-pizza snack. Bonus points that it's attached to one of our favorite Italian restaurants, Ruffino, so whether we're looking for a slice of pizza, delicious seafood or some fresh pasta, we're covered. Thanks to the Joe's staff for continuing to fuel our weekly pizza night! read more

Joe's Pizzeria - Chicken parmigiana pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

I love their food and I always order from them, but the owner is very very very nasty. It's almost not worth it to order from them. He's a nasty nasty man. The food is amazing but he is so mean. read more

I went there Thursday night around 8 pm I ordered a lasagna it came I went home to eat it as I opened it up I sean it had peas in it I explained to the owner that I have a allergy to peas he told me he couldn't do anything for me I called him up the same night and he told me he was there until 1030 pm I give him a zero review I will never go back there as long as I live and my family and friends are not going there either read more

There's nothing like real New York Pizza at it's finest! Love this place! The food is fresh to order and SUPERB! I had met Joe the owner (& cook), he's an incredible man!The way that he runs his business is "golden" five stars! While waiting on our order, Joe had served us some fresh garlic knots, and Zeppoles. Bon Appetit! I never ate a Zeppole before, I thought they were doughnuts at first until Joe explained the Italian difference! Business was busy and I didn't mind the wait. I enjoyed talking to him. I can tell that he truly cares for his customers. Thanks Joe for an Excellent experience and learning lesson! read more

See all

Family place thx It's Liza and my two twin boys they smile when they hear me say let's go to Joes read more

6/1/15......My first time here. Ordered a meatball and extra cheese pie and a regular pie for take out. It was very good. It will not knock your socks off, but it will not disappoint. The Italian gentleman behind the counter was friendly and chatty. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - the location of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

WOW. I WILL NEVERRRRR GO BACK HERE My husband ordered a pizza tonight, its 845 on a Friday so we expected a wait. 30 minutes, not a big deal at all. We ordered 1/2 pepperoni, and a calzone My husband walked in to pick up, and there was an older man slamming things behind the counter. My husband waited, mentioned he was picking up, the man grabbed a hot pizza from on top of the oven, opened the box, noticed he forgot the pepperoni and proceeded to grab a bucket of pepperoni from a refrigerator and toss pepperoni on top of the pizza..... ‍ Now... my issue isn't that he forgot, he seemed to be alone. My issue is how it was handled. My husband will Never ever ever say anything about something so as not to make a scene. I on the other hand feel that just like everyone else, we work too hard for our money to get that kind of service. So my husband left with our dinner and didn't say a word to the man. I called once my husband got home and told me what happened. And I asked the man first, if this was maybe just how they did their pepperoni. He said "no I forgot it. Come buy a new pie if you don't like it but the pepperoni will be hot." I explained that a fresh pie shouldve been offered to my husband at the moment it was forgotten, or maybe he shouldn't have been charged for the pepperoni- something to make his mistake correct. He got nasty and said again it is fine the pizza is hot. I asked them to deliver if we ordered a new one and said he WONT do that. I wouldn't ever recommend this place based solely on their business practices and lack of ethics. read more

I have been going to this place for years and always forgave the owners poor attitude when it comes to customer service. Now he has a younger generation that is even more rude than him. Can never seem to get an order right anymore or care to. Also called me names which I would not repeat and offered to snap my neck today what a shame read more

Whenever i want a great Sicilian Pizza locally I go to Joes. Has excellent tasting sauce and doesnt skimp on the cheese. This Sicilian I ordered was in the oven just a few minutes longer than it should of been but I don't mind a bit of a crisp just as long as it not burnt. Most times it's just perfecto. Always good service and gives me free zeppole for my family to take home. read more

See all

Joe's Pizza is a Lynbrook staple. Their pizza is authentic and delicious ! Chicken Parm is wonderful as well as the stuffed shells and manicotti. I also love their garlic knots and on the weekends you can also get some zepoles too. If you want to sit down place Ruffinos next door is also great Both great places! read more

I've been going to this place for years. Always a great pie, only caveat is that I only order a whole fresh pie each time. Like any pizzeria, the slices on the counter are only as good as the time they've been sitting there. Reheated pizza is never the same as fresh out of the oven, I don't care where you go. Joe's make a nice cheesy pie which has been consistently good for years and years. Unlike some nearby competitors nearby that have changed. Also, I recommend the sausage bagels...Nice! read more

I came around 9 for a late bite. The owner, an older man with white hair, was extremely friendly, inviting and hospitable. Best customer service I've experienced. Penne slice was good. Since it was late, he put fresh cheese on top while heating it up. Pepperoni was good too. We sat inside to eat and it was a very calm and cozy environment. Would definitely come back for more. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and penne slices. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

I'm not a fan of eggplant but the stuffed eggplant pizza is beyond great! Also ordered for delivery and it arrived faster than the ETA plus it was hot and delicious! Will continue to order from here read more

The Owner Sal makes a mean pie here!The pizza has such a great tasty combination of sauce, delicious mozzarella cheese and just the right of Italian herbs,The food you take out from the pizza place comes out of the same kitchen as his restaurant next-door, absolutely phenomenal old-school Italian made from scratch!Sal oversees everything thats cooked up,my favorites are the hero's especially the chicken parm and the veal Parm, I live in Merrick and travel all the way here just to get them, truly one of the best kept secrets in the area,the regular customers know how great and special this place really is,there is a reason he has been around for so long the food speaks for itself, give it a shot you won't be disappointed! read more

We just moved to Lynbrook from the city and already love this place. The pizza and chicken parm are phenomenal. Better than most I've had in the city. Staff is also very nice. Highly recommend read more

The pizzas they had on display didn't look appetizing. The old man who i can assume is the owner is very unprofessional. his attitude towards me was very unjust and left me to go to another place for food. Would never go back there again but I'm sure he's fine with that. go anywhere else but there. read more

TL;DR: Took an hour and twenty minutes to get a takeout pizza, order was still wrong, guy cursed like a sailor and seemed drunk. We will never go back. I ordered a pizza for my husband to pick up at 6:40. By 8:00, he still wasn't home, and we live only a few blocks away. It wasn't busy on a Monday night. The reason he was late was so unbelievable I had to write it here. My husband arrived after 20 minutes, when the pizza should have been ready. It wasn't even in the oven. The man behind the counter with an Italian accent was cursing repeatedly, and would not give a straight answer as to when the pizza would be ready. He asked at least 5 times what we had ordered. He seemed drunk, and also cursed in front of a young kid. He also at one point was overtly flirting with another female customer, then turned belligerent toward her. Then he told my husband to check her out. Eighty minutes later, he got home with the incorrect order and the slices were so uneven that some pieces were almost half the size of the pizza and other slice were very small. Needless to say, the pizza was free. Too bad it wasn't what we ordered. It was not worth the 80 minute wait. Joe's has always suffered from poor customer service, which we excused because they are close by and usually delicious. However, this experience was the single worst restaurant experience I've ever experienced or heard about. We'll be going to Regina's from now on. DO NOT GO HERE!!! read more

Sicilian pie is delicious but make sure to ask for it well done and be stern about that. Depending on who makes the pie they either listen or they don't. But if it's done right it's the best Sicilian I've had. And I'm a pizza girl :) read more

My mechanic is across the street from this place so I stopped by to grab a few slices. They had good prices so I got two cheese slices and a cappollini ball. The pizzas they had on display didn't look appetizing. It looked cold as if it had been standing out there for a whole and there wasn't much variety. He had them warmed up though and it turned out to taste pretty good but nothing too special so I couldn't complain. They don't allow us to use our phone in the store which was weird. read more

OK the first thing you notice when you walk into this place is the old slices behind the counter, so you figure maybe they don't move alot of slices? So I try a fresh pie, what a disappointment, sauce so bland it has no taste, institutional mozzarella globbed on the pie, like that's going to make it better. Joe when it comes to making pizza you're a schmo. A big time pass from here on. read more

Honestly disgusted !!!! Ordered chicken franchise over angel hair pasta, got home saw I had pasta on the side with red sauce and chicken in a separate dish . I walked back , told him the person behind the counter which happens to be the owner that a mistake was made . He told me that I must be outta my mind and I didn't say that over the phone . How dare you speak to a customer that way ... Insisted I made the mistake and was beyond rude !! I was very surprised and taken back ,... read more

Joe's Pizza has a menu sign on the door with their most popular items. It says that tax is included. The guy said that I had to pay tax if I use a credit card. He overcharged me before explaining that the menu price was old, that price on the wall was also old, and even that the price given by another employee was incorrect because "he doesn't know". read more