Angelina's is one of my family's FAVORITE places to eat. Staff is ALWAYS nice and accommodating! I asked for a dish that is no longer listed on the menu (linguine puttanesca MY FAVORITE) and they didn't hesitate to make it for me anyway. Our waitress, Kelly, just like the rest of the staff, was so nice and helpful that our whole experience, as always, was great. FOOD IS ALWAYS AMAZING! read more

A pizzeria/Italian restaurant that is consistently good. I love their pesto and the Caesar salad. The decor is very traditional with a checkered tablecloth motif. Recently I placed an order for pick up. When I got it home one of the items was missing. I called and arranged for it to be delivered. That process was pleasant and professional. When the order arrived there was an extra slice added with a handwritten note saying " sorry , enjoy one on us". Now that is customer service, folks ! Highly recommend! read more

Angelina's - Note after a mistake was made on our order - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

The old school decor reminds you that there are still places where tradition matters. Dining here takes you back to a time when neighborhood restaurants were part of the fabric of an organic community. Not the curated, manufactured so-called "communities" designed by real estate developers. Angelina's is a place you can go for delicious, quality food, and where the staff treat you like extended family. Some restaurants are hit and miss. Angelina's is a hit every time. When I'm back in the neighborhood this is my go-to. read more

I've been here twice so far and looking forward to coming back since it's a quick drive from Queens. Both times I've dined here we got the calamari. It's honestly the best I've had recently. We generally order 2 kinds (one drenched in marinara and one with sauce on the side : (either spicy marinara or a vodka sauce). I think the perfect lunch here is a big plate of calamari and their Caesar salad. Their dressing is house made and it's perfection. They also have a full menu with pasta (great options) and plenty of pizza options. My husband tried a grandma slice and he definitely liked it. I ended up getting a linguini entree the first time I dined here and it was quite delicious. Service was fine, it's definitely a very busy spot to eat during the weekend. As for the seating, they have plenty of room for large groups, those looking to have a drink at the bar, or someone coming in to grab a slice. Definitely a place with lots of options. It's definitely a spot I look forward coming back to. read more

See all

I went to dinner with friends this evening to Angelina's and everything was fabulous! From the salad ( try the goat cheese salad),soup, and entrees ( I skipped dessert) everything was seasoned to perfection. The sole Francese was excellent as was the chicken Sorrentino,all made possible because of our fabulous server Enrique. He was polite,courteous and incredibly efficient at his job especially when it came to navigating the menu according to our likes and dislikes. Run to this restaurant for a great meal and spectacular service! read more

I took my 89 year old mom who is semi disabled and uses a walker and my sister to treat them to pizza because that's what my mom wanted and the front tables were full, only the tables with high chairs were available, when we asked if we could sit where the dinner tables were at because there was only one couple in the whole area and so many empty tables, they said we couldn't sit there. My mom can't sit in high chairs. They watched us walk out and had no compassion, courtesy or empathy to see us seniors with a mother who needs a walker to make an exception for her. I will never go back there again. Terrible!!! I felt so bad, awful to go to a restaurant and be treated with such discourtesy and lack of compassion for older people. read more

Went here for a slice with my girlfriend and her sister and mom , who is older and uses a walker. As we entered we noticed most of the tables in front were already filled with students from the local school, so we ask the guy behind the counter if we could sit at the tables in the back since there were many empty tables. He said "No you can't eat slices at the table" what? Really? Isn't this a pizza place? Not like there was a line waiting for the tables- there was no one. Good business practice. Not! So we left and went across the street to Vincent's pizza.I know there aren't the same owners, but with how hard it is to run a business, I would think you would find a place for your customers- what are you there for in the first place? They didn't even seem to care we left- the guy was loud and obnoxious read more

I was in the mood for some good ol Italian food so I couldn't wait to try this restaurant. When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked in and was greeted. I sat at the bar and Christine served me and was nice. I ordered: - red wine - Shrimp portobello - Rigatoni Bolognese - Baked cheese ravioli - Chocolate Mousse The food was really good. I really enjoyed the Rigatoni Bolognese the most followed by the dessert. Everything was flavorful and good. All in all I had a good experience. read more

See all

Angelinas is serving up some of the best family style Italian dishes that I have had in a while. The inside is SO cute. The mural on the wall is so beautiful. I also love the table cloths. The staff was so nice. It's a really hard choice between my favorites. I was SO excited to come to try the gnocchi and it exceeded every expectation... BUT once he hit me with the francese sauce on the Verde....... It may have been game over. Food ordered: Personal margarita pizza Chicken Parmigiana Alla Vodka Chicken Verde topped with francese Gnocchi with Bolognese sauce read more

See all

I was impressed by the quality of the pizza here. The crust had a perfect texture, and the ingredients tasted fresh and well balanced. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. I'll definitely be back. read more

Angelinas's dishes are very distinctive, especially their pizzas and pasta, which are rich and flavorful. The restaurant has a quiet atmosphere, making it suitable for dining with friends or family. The service is attentive and thoughtful, making you feel welcome. I would definitely come back again. read more

I had an amazing experience here. One of the workers was incredibly kind, welcoming, and friendly from the moment I walked in. You can tell he really cares about the customers and the quality of the food. The pizza was absolutely delicious -- easily some of the best I've ever had. The crust was perfect, the ingredients tasted fresh, and every bite was incredible. Honestly, his pizza beats every single pizza I've tried in New York and even Italy. It's rare to meet someone who is both such a great person and such a talented pizza maker. If you come here, make sure you try the pizza and say hello -- you'll leave with a smile and an amazing meal. read more

Absolute Gem of a restaurant! My son wanted Italian for his birthday dinner and we decided to give Angelina's a shot- and boy are we glad we did! The restaurant is nicely decorated for the holidays- very clean and nicely kept. There's a pizzeria in the front as well as full bar. The staff is so pleasant especially our busboy Carlos- such a polite and nice guy! We also had a chance to chat with the owner she was super sweet too! Food- we started with baked clams and the crispy calamari salad- this was my favorite! For entrees we ordered penne with butter, grilled chicken and fries, chicken brushetta - came with a pasta dish- I ordered the penne with pesto, and linguini with white clam sauce. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious- the portions are plentiful - we had enough to take home. We ended our meal with a cannoli that had a candle to sing happy birthday to my son! Truly cannot say enough good things about this place- even the bread basket was delicious ! While walking out we noticed they have happy hour from 2-6 during the week- can't wait to come back!!! read more

See all

Recently ordered several half trays for a home luncheon following a funeral. The food was delivered and set up on time, and our delivery driver was very kind and efficient. The pasta with sauce, chicken parm, chicken francese, and eggplant rollatini were still warm and delicious. The Ceasar salad was fresh and crisp. Even for half trays, they were packed! There was so much food! Oh, and the garlic bread was terrific! The prices were very, very reasonable for what we received. Overall, if you have a catering need for your home, visit Angelina's. (I've promised myself a visit to eat at the restaurant which is spacious and inviting, too.) Thanks to Enrique, our delivery driver, and the whole staff. read more

Sunday evening light bite, after a movie. Just the shrimp with spinach and mushroom appetizer for me and eggplant parm for spouse. Both very good, nice bread basket and smiles, though it took a while to get the food. If it's done to order, can't expect speed. read more

Not sure how the pizza tastes, because we had the restaurant area. It is way too bright in there, and NOT a private room, as it appears on their website. It is open to the pizza section and public. The waiter wasn't friendly and he rushed us. The "runner" did everything, so he deserved the tip instead. ( but not too high because he kind of wasn't friendly) However the Salmon was great and the dishes are great proportions. read more

Happened to be in the Lynbrook area this afternoon for a movie , we wanted to grab a bite before the movie and originally planned on going to prime down the road but they were closed and I'm happy they were because I wouldn't have stumbled on this gem ! We sat in the back in a booth, super spacious and not those tight uncomfortable booths some places have. Our waitress was Ashley and she was really sweet and accommodating . We ordered : vodka slice , grandma slice, chicken parm and rigatoni Florentine. Everything was good but my absolute fave was the rigatoni Florentine and the Caesar salad . Everything was fresh , service was perfect and the prices were very reasonable . read more

See all

I've been coming here for many years. The food is really good, the restaurant is large and a lil old school with the red checkered table cloths. The waitresses/waiters are very nice, no attitudes. The items in the pictures below are very good. I really like the bruschetta pizza read more

See all

We had our family Christmas party at Angelina's for the 3 rd year in a row. The staff is always so helpful , the food was delicious and it was decorated so beautifully for the holidays. read more

Their take-out portions have been reduced to a kid's meal. When I called and spoke with Enrique, he could not care less.

i was looking forward to trying their food but when i placed my order on doordash they called me and told me i didn't spend enough & cancelled my order..i spent a total of $18 with tip.... why are you on doordash if you're not going to deliver! mind you i was just 5 minutes down the road! do better read more

everything is delicious!! it alll went wellll!! the people here are so welcoming and i love them all! read more

Angelina's - Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Me and my friend throughly enjoyed our experience at Angelina's. Bets pizza in all of lynbrook by far

I was with a big group of my friends and we walked in and said the truth which was our parents made reservations and they said they would not accommodate us in the back and told us to sit in the front and buy their pizza. We then said okay and tried to sit in the front and basically they didn't have enough room and told us to deal with it. We then went to the pizzeria across the street and we reccomend. The workers were rude and disrespectful at Angelina's. read more

Very nice food lthe place great food and great s service I ordered pizza and penne la vodka and salmon delicious

Great pizza and environment! Can't recommend enough. Love this place! Had our engagement party here and everyone had a great time! A Lynbrook institution read more

We keep going back to Angelina's because the food is excellent, the staff is efficient , helpful and friendly The owners are generous and also very friendly. The dining area is ample and a cozy mix of booths and tables and the bar service is excellent. Give Angelina's a try, youwon't be disappointed. read more

I have developed a gluten issue in the past year and last night we stopped by Angelina's. The gluten free personal pizza was excellent. I added mushrooms which enhanced the flavor. Our server who was a young lady was great. She was friendly and attentive. The place was packed and she was busy but she stopped by often to make sure we were taken care of. We have been here a few times but this time left a great impression. The place was clean and the service excellent. Stop by it has a great menu and good variety of wine. read more

We had an amazing meal and amazing service! Highly recommend! My daughter is obsessed with their pizza and my other daughter their penne a la vodka! read more

The service here was great. got our pizza out incredibly fast and the owner was really nice

the service was friendly and the vodka pepperoni slice was buttaa. I also enjoyed the atmosphere

Authentic Italian pizza that's reasonably priced. Staff are friendly and made sure that we were well served. Definitely a place to stop by for a quick slice or with friends. read more

The chicken vodka bomb is too die for here. 10/10 ! I'm a normal customer definitely recommend

The pasta and entrees were cooked properly and quite good. The service is efficient and timely. Generally, a very positive informal dining experience. Ambiance is children friendly. read more

Great food. Baked clams were delicious. We all enjoyed our food and had plenty to take home. Angelina's has great food and I love that it's consistent. read more

An update since my last review. Angelinas has now been in the hands of the new owners for almost two years and every change has been positive.Food items are the same yet the place is cleaner and run better than it was. When they took this over they knew they had a good thing going and when you have a good thing going you leave it alone and they have done that.Sadly some original regulars have not returned and that is their loss. I am now going on a being a Saturday night regular for 17 years. read more

The food is always delicious! Today we stopped in for a quick slice and thoroughly enjoyed it. The food, atmosphere, and staff are all wonderful! A definite must try! read more

It's lunch time and staff seemed too busy to accommodate things like a booth in the back where the air conditioning is nice instead of at the front even though there were only a few customers. Not making a whole fresh salad pizza because they don't sell well. It feels like they need front of house professional development. Too hot to enjoy. read more

Absolutely love this place! Food is amazing, portions generous, and prices reasonable for what you're getting. The staff are extremely friendly and always add an extra something to the meal. Love coming here!! read more

Pretty good overall. The atmosphere was pretty nice and liked the choice of music and Italian theme. Pizza was delicious. It took a little long but the guy was pretty nice. read more