Pizza that's been sitting around for several hours shouldn't be served - especially @ $5 / slice !

Fantastic food, service and ambience. One of the best pizzas on the island. Service was outstanding. We were in a large group, the food kept on rolling and the servers were attentive read more

The food is excellent and huge portions Wait staff are great. New owners are very friendly and accommodating Highly recommend this place read more

My wife and I have tried Angelas several times. The food is always spot on. I've had chicken cutlet Parmesan here. My wife had shrimp with mushrooms. It was excellent. Also the pizzas I had the vodka pie excellent consistent read more

The buffalo pie is amazing, ambiance, and service are exceptional. 10 out of 10 will go again.

This is the fourth time that items paid for were missing from the order. Very poor system of checking orders being picked up. read more

My family just had a Christmas party at Angelina's and it was fantastic! From start to finish Enrique was absolutely amazing. He helped us plan the party and was extremely professional yet friendly and helpful! He was there to ensure we were happy throughout the entire day! The food is so delicious!! Every dish fresh, hot and tasted amazing. Whether you're going there for takeout, or lunch with a friend, dinner with family or a party in the back room, you won't be disappointed! Angelina's is perfect for all occasions. read more

this restaurant was such an amazing experience. Me and my friends went and it was just so beautiful and cozy and a really nice place. It was so clean and beautiful. workers are so nice. read more

Very homey Italian food. Nothing experimental, nothing bad. I enjoyed it. Staff was great, food came out in 15 minutes, and the portion was great. The spaghetti and meatballs was more than enough for two. And also you get free hot bread when you sit down. I highly reccomend. I request they add Angel hair pasta, and also do more online advertising. read more

Angelina's - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Owner is the nicest guy ever. Super friendly, and even gave us food for free as long as it didn't go to waste when they were closing. Food and service is great! read more

The entrees and the pizza here are both phenomenal. Everything here is consistently fantastic. The owner, Vinnie, is a gentleman and the staff is great. This is my families go to place for Italian. My family has been in Lynbrook since 1908....I've live here in and off my whole life and have tried every place in the area....Angelinas stands out, to me, as the best. My favorite pie is the Grilled chicken with diced tomatoes and fresh garlic...Mozzarella with no sauce. It is AMAZING! read more

Angelina's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

The food is always excellent here and you will never be disappointed. Make sure you come hungry. I can recommend the escarole and beans side order and the grilled chicken toscana. Always great read more

I understand there's a new owner. I must say the service was exceptional, my dinner was one of the best clams and linguine I've had in a long time! My husband had a chick parm which was great! We will definitely be going soon read more

Went to Angelina's Pizza Restaurant for a birthday party at their party room, Hospitality amazing, great food and nice and clean ambiance. Will come back ! Good place to have a corporate meeting and enjoy some good food ! read more

I've been going to Angelina's for a very long time and has been a local staple. I have always been happy with the food. Unfortunately they changed ownership recently and while the food is still good it's not great and the service is very slow. Meatballs and spaghetti is still very good and the pizza is good but seems like a slow turnover and sits out for a while. read more

Just stopped in for a slice of pizza late night. Staff were warm and friendly. Everyone in the front were wearing masks. May slice of cheese was nice and thin and tasty !! We sat in the back patio which was a nice open space with picnic tables and umbrellas. read more

Best pizzeria in New York by FAR! I always get the best service and everyone is kind and the food is amazing. Extremely cheap as well! 20/10 would recommend read more

Very disappointed The restaurant is very beautifully decorated for the holidays. They seem to have a decent selection of pizza. I opted for a plain cheese slice. It was nothing to write home about. I found it very bland and mushy, it reminded me of cafeteria pizza from school. It tasted like a low quality cheese and had very little sauce. The sauce from what i could taste was very sweet. Overall not for me. They were friendly. read more

If you are gluten-free, don't walk but run to Angelina's! Their gluten free pizza and pastas are the best I've had!!! I missed eating Italian food because of my gut issues but Angelina's provides high quality and delicious alternatives. To all my gf people out there, it can be hard to find a solid gf option that can compare in taste to the original but Angelina's definitely delivers. On top of all this, their customer service is amazing, everyone at the restaurant is friendly and warm. Great food, and people! 10/10 experience!! read more

Stopped here after a long time! Not what it used to be! The pizza was just eh! Nothing to write home about! The staff is just plain nasty which makes me not ever want to come back! Rude, no thank you, no nothing! When asked for a receipt, it was just thrown at me! No thanks for coming in or have a good day! Don't waste your time here read more

This is a great establishment love the food the atmosphere and employees really recommend

great atmosphere!! very pretty inside! food is great. they have a bar && more intimate dining options.

It's one of my family's favorite places to eat Italian food! My favorite thing to eat there is spaghetti And meatballs.

Best local pizza with amazing staff and environment. Highly recommend for takeout or dining in.

WOW!!!! Great food, great service, nice staff, clean, and good prices. Make if a point to go to Angelinas for lunch or dinner.

First time here. Food was amazing. Friendly staff. Great ambiance. Highly recommend Angelina's. Will return to try other dishes. read more

Angelina's - Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Platter comes with salad or pasta - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

Food was mediocre, but service and private room was excellent. The restaurant was just renovated and we we're the first to use the private room in the back of the restaurant. At least 40 guests were in the room. Nice big space for the kids to run around and not be in anybody's way. Service was excellent but there was a long wait for main courses. Maybe that was planned by the couple setting up the event. The first dish served was sliced mozzarella and tomatoes. The tomatoes we're bland. Next we had stuffed mushrooms with a generous amount of red sauce. I think they used the sauce to cover up the dry overcooked mushrooms, not good. The next dish was the calamari, that was the best thing we ate. Very tender just out of the fryer. Salad was bland wilted yellow iceberg lettuce. Main meal was ok but both chicken dish and veal tasted exactly the same. Sauce was bland. They were very busy on a Saturday night, maybe the pizza is better than the other meals. read more

Angelina's - Veal marsala - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

Our large group of fifteen were finally apprised of the 'Undisclosed Location'...Angelina's. Checked Yelp and found several mixed reviews. I'm not a huge fan of southern Italian cuisine, I know I'm weird. I do admit that I have had a few wow moments dining at a restaurant here and there, but haven't found anything to conform me. Even dined at the once infamous Felidia's back in the day and even her kitchen, God bless them, couldn't fully convince me. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing, I don't know..anyway. Angelina's - quantity over quality. Lucky for me. Should I say lucky? Yes, luck is the best word to use. So, lucky for me I wasn't feeling that well and had no appetite. At first, I only had hot beverages to soothe the soul as large portioned apps of fried calamari and mozzarella sticks were passed around...umm no thank you, I'll stick to my tea. Once the mains were served, I finally succumbed to a small taste of the ginormous eggplant ricotta pizza pie, as I do favor eggplant a bit. My first fork full was an instant recognition of bland, no distinguishing herbs stood out nor was there any depth of flavor in the sauce or the ricotta. Other mains were strewn about the table but I had no desire to indulge further. It could've been due to a lack of appetite, but I asked around and the consensus hovered around the same. If it weren't for the pleasant staff and the company of these wonderful group of gals my rating would be bordering more on the side of zero. So, I'll simply end by saying been there, done that, won't be back. read more

See all

Great cooking. Always goes beyond just red sauce. Always something not quirky perfect though, like stale bread

Upon waiting for our movie to start I decided to take my son out for pizza here. The cashier, older gentlemen definitely needs a course in Customer Service. Needless to say, I did not feel welcomed and strongly felt that being an African American women had everything to do with the way I was treated. The ordeal took place as I was paying or else I would have never given my $$ to this establishment. read more

Came here with my husband on a Saturday night without a reservation but were able to get a table right away. We were starving and definitely over ordered. I had the chicken with cheese and broccoli and my husband had the sausage and chicken with peppers. We also ordered the monachina. Everything was delicious. The portions were pretty big, we had to take our food home! Upon entering I felt a little uneasy because the tables were pretty close together and those people were not wearing masks but we felt fine after eating there. read more

Please read entire review. We ordered the Alfredo tortellini with grilled chicken. The chicken was dry and they weren't able to make a smaller portion during dinner time. I ordered the rigatoni montanara. Again, the grilled chicken was dry. To my taste, the pasta was over done ( I like al dente pasta). My father had the special which was artichokes, fusilli, and shrimp, olives, and tomatoes. He said it was good and the shrimp was cooked perfectly. I haven't tried their pizza in years. If I go back I will update my review. The service was good. When they got the order for my salad wrong, they quickly fixed it and brought out the correct salad. NOTE: I am not saying Angelina's is bad. This is just my personal opinion and preference. read more

See all

The food is consistently good and they do great take out of dine in - I think it's the best Italian place in the area.

The service I gotten from the short Latino man was very prejudice I ask for a trey for my food and he made a smart remark towards me but when the older European man asked for a trey he gave it to him with smiles smh read more

My first tome out in 15 months since covid hit we Stopped in on a whim w a friend. The food was aaamazing. The waiter was excellent. The menu was awesome Thank you read more

Located right in the heart of Lynbrook on a street surrounded by stores to suit your every need (stationary, ice cream parlor, movie theatre...) Angelina's is the type of restaurant that once you have eaten there, you are sure to be a returning customer. I can definitely vouch for that because I used to frequent Angelina's often when I lived in the area. Prices are extremely reasonable for the amount and quality of food they serve you. Excellent homemade soups - I ordered the Pasta e Fagioli and it was loaded with beans and pasta in a perfect tomato broth. The serving of Lasagna was enormous - I ordered the special ($11.95) and it also came with a side of 3 meatballs. The menu is extensive including an abundance of specialty pies. Delicious desserts as well. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Nice bar area and tables as you enter the restaurant so even if there is a wait when you get there, after a couple of drinks it really doesn't matter anyway, it's worth the wait!!. Weekends are always extremely busy and unfortunately, they do not take reservations. There is on the street parking and ample parking in the back. A nice big private party room is also available for that special occasion. Angelina's is just a great restaurant to go to for a great Italian meal. You will never be disappointed, and I promise, you will be returning!! read more

See all

Love it here!! Been coming here for the Sicilian pizza since a baby boy. It's definitely a staple in lynbrook for sure!! Please treat yourself if you're ever in the area. read more

This review is long overdue. Angelina's is a solid 3-Star Italian restaurant in Lynbrook. Especially with so many Italian venues to choose from across Long Island (in just about every time), competition is fierce. Angelina's can best be wrapped up in 3 words: reliable, efficient, and value. Over the years, I've both dined in and ordered to go at Angelina's. The menu is fairly standard and familiar for anyone who knows Long Island Italian cuisine. In addition to a full-service Pizzeria (separated from the main dining room), Angelina's serves pastas and other meat/chicken/veal/fish entrees (think your standard chicken parmigiana, penne alla vodka, meatball hero, etc). If you're dining in, they also provide fresh bread and olive oil and butter at the table, and most entrees come with a house or Caesar salad. Sound familiar? Again, it's the standard at most Italian restaurants around these parts. Also standard here is the service and quality. As I mentioned earlier, this place is reliable. Every time I come here, the food is always the same (very good quality) and the service is friendly and efficient. The place is also kept clean and the prices are fair for this kind of cuisine. I don't have any gripes about this place. It's solid. Bottom line? If you're in the Lynbrook area and craving Italian food, Angelina's might just be the place to go. read more

See all

Clean and bright but food is below average. The restaurant looks really nice and they were busy on Monday Night. The soups were good, we ordered three different soups and we enjoyed them all but the dinner every one was disappointed and left 75% . Dinner for three is around $190 including tips. It is bit expensive too. May be their pizza is good and we will try next time read more

Angelina's - Dining - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Pound for pound best restaurant in the area . Large portions of great food and always good service