Love it here!! Been coming here for the Sicilian pizza since a baby boy. It's definitely a staple in lynbrook for sure!! Please treat yourself if you're ever in the area. read more

This review is long overdue. Angelina's is a solid 3-Star Italian restaurant in Lynbrook. Especially with so many Italian venues to choose from across Long Island (in just about every time), competition is fierce. Angelina's can best be wrapped up in 3 words: reliable, efficient, and value. Over the years, I've both dined in and ordered to go at Angelina's. The menu is fairly standard and familiar for anyone who knows Long Island Italian cuisine. In addition to a full-service Pizzeria (separated from the main dining room), Angelina's serves pastas and other meat/chicken/veal/fish entrees (think your standard chicken parmigiana, penne alla vodka, meatball hero, etc). If you're dining in, they also provide fresh bread and olive oil and butter at the table, and most entrees come with a house or Caesar salad. Sound familiar? Again, it's the standard at most Italian restaurants around these parts. Also standard here is the service and quality. As I mentioned earlier, this place is reliable. Every time I come here, the food is always the same (very good quality) and the service is friendly and efficient. The place is also kept clean and the prices are fair for this kind of cuisine. I don't have any gripes about this place. It's solid. Bottom line? If you're in the Lynbrook area and craving Italian food, Angelina's might just be the place to go. read more

See all

Stopped by Angelina's tonight on a whim. I must say I was surprised at how friendly and hospitable the staff was. The place was very clean. We ordered a pepperoni pie which was made fresh to order and it was delicious. We even were able to try some freshly made cookies. My family and I will definitely be returning. read more

I was here for my sister's birthday yesterday and I was actually expecting it to be bad. I was happily disappointed in my expectations this turned out to be a pretty good place. I was actually here for two previous occasions but I didn't want to judge from those prior experiences since I wasn't reviewing back then. My family is huge so we ended up taking up a few tables and some space in here, our waitress was pretty accommodating to all of our needs. I indulged in the garlic bread from the bread basket and it was well worth it. I ordered an appetizer of tomato, mozzarella cheese and roasted red pepper (at this time I can't recall the correct name for it). I split it with my brother and his friend who was with us for the afternoon birthday party. For a meal I got a salad with mesculins, goat cheese, dried cranberries and walnuts. The salad was also very good all the veggies served to us in our salads (my main meal and my family's pre-meal included salads) were very fresh. My family also seemed to enjoy their meals too. As far as I know no one had anything bad to say after we left here. Another great Italian spot in Lynbrook (this town seems to know how to do Italian well) I'd come back again! read more

See all

Clean and bright but food is below average. The restaurant looks really nice and they were busy on Monday Night. The soups were good, we ordered three different soups and we enjoyed them all but the dinner every one was disappointed and left 75% . Dinner for three is around $190 including tips. It is bit expensive too. May be their pizza is good and we will try next time read more

Angelina's - Dining - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

great atmosphere!! very pretty inside! food is great. they have a bar && more intimate dining options.

The service I gotten from the short Latino man was very prejudice I ask for a trey for my food and he made a smart remark towards me but when the older European man asked for a trey he gave it to him with smiles smh read more

My first tome out in 15 months since covid hit we Stopped in on a whim w a friend. The food was aaamazing. The waiter was excellent. The menu was awesome Thank you read more

Pound for pound best restaurant in the area . Large portions of great food and always good service

I like to have lunch out but I can't have a regular food so I decided to bring my own food from home and have it together with my friend so my friend ordered from this place including her drink and I brought my own drink from home too but The manager told us that I cannot bring my own drink if they sell here, I feel disappointed because they didn't Even asked me the reason why I bringing my own food, I been here few times and I never had this situation very uncomfortable. So they lost at least 2 customers for that reason. read more

*Pizza Review* This place has been around for awhile. Personally, I come here when I want a good Sicilian Pie or just plain regular pie in the area! You can't go wrong with the classic's at Angelina's. My taste buds are always satisfied when my family orders take out from here. The Sicilian is just the right amount of thickness, not too doughy or overwhelming, and not too thin to be considered a Sicilian pie. I ordered a couple of regular pies when I had friends coming in from out of town once. Ever since then whenever they come to visit they suggest we order from "the place we got the really amazing pizza from that time." That has to mean something!! And when I say out of town, I mean some just from the other side of Long Island and some right in West Chester, so they are no strangers to good pizza at all! Like I said, if you're looking for some delicious classic pizza, this place is your go to!! read more

Angelina's - Regular pie - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

It's a shame, we have been coming to Angelina's for as long as I could remember and after the restaurant sold, it's not the same. We use to come multiples times a month and eventually started to come less once we saw the quality change. Unfortunately after tonights takeout meal, we won't be returning. $90 worth of food barely eaten and thrown out. read more

So I went in to the restaurant itself 1 day and the food was amazing. Pizza was so good. I ordered delivery and it's like night and day. Definitely not the same quality of food and when my order was messed up and I called, they made me feel like I was crazy. I knew what I ordered and what was put in the box. And they didn't give me sauce for my garlic sticks. Not ordering from them any more. Going to Just walk in and order from here on out. read more

Puttanesca is my all time favorite pasta dishes and I've had a hard time finding any Italian restaurants who make it. That being said Angelina's makes linguine puttanesca and it is THE BEST puttanesca I've EVER had (I ate it before I had a chance photograph it, next time ;). We've NEVER had a bad dish there. We highly recommend!! read more

This review is solely based on a takeout lunch order of a couple of plain slices and 2 rolls (a chicken parm & a sausage roll). What happened to this place? A usually solid house pie slice was so bland & tasteless it might have been a frozen pizza. The dough on the rolls was so tough, I thought I'd chipped a tooth upon biting into it. The chicken parm filling was edible but also tasteless, but using pre-cut frozen sausage pieces instead of actual link sausage is a cheap way out. While we used them previously to cater numerous events, I can no longer justify spending good money for sub par food if this is what they are turning out. read more

This was my first time at Angelina's. I wanted a veggie pizza and do want to travel too far from the apartment to get one. The crust was thin and loaded with vegetables. No cheese for me and I forgot to tell them to remove the onions. Nevertheless, good stuff. Nice, friendly staff. read more

Angelina's - Vegetarian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Throwback Review Reason For The Two Stars: 1. Food I was not keen on giving Valcenia a review because the other yelpers basically said what I experienced. The food was okay. Okay, like I'm eating it because I'm paying for it okay. The quality of the food I tasted made me think that they probably have the sauce, and pasta in one freezer and mix together when a customer orders. 2. Service Honestly, my step-father and I didn't feel "welcomed" there. Empty restaurant and the waitress decides the best seat to give to us was near the kitchen, all the way in the back. I guess it was convenient for her, but it was an uncomfortable experience for me. 3. Quality Price $20.00-$30.00 for food that seemed as if someone just poured sauce and added meat on top, I could have just went to Keyfood and made my own. Would I Come Again?: No. To spend almost $70 for food and regretting it is something that scars my food digger mind. It's my opinion and always take into consideration it could of been a bad day to come in. read more

See all

Great local spot with spacious dining area and private room available. From pizza, salads, entrees, and desserts everything is delicious. Staff is friendly and kind, particularly to individuals with special needs (shout out to Vinny, Christine and Dotty). Will continue to be a regular go to spot for a late lunch after the school lunch crowd read more

Hmmm... I'm on the fence with this place. I often come here with my boyfriend and his family. They've been coming here for a good 15+ years and they love it. I personally think it's just OK. With these family owned Italian restaurants, I feel like any non-Italian that comes here gets major side eye... until of course, you show them you're a decent human being, then they soften up. The overall vibe of the place is nice. Family oriented restaurant, with a bar up front and tables & booths towards the back. Gingham patterned cloths on the tables, so don't expect upscale Italian decor. However, the food is up to par. The portions are generous and the bread is really good. I didn't like their shrimp fra diablo too much, it lacked flavor. The shrimp with penne and pesto sauce was good though. The Shrimp Angelina was good and light, nicely flavored. I've also tried their Angelina salad (greens, walnuts, cheese) which I loved. Their house salads are OK, nothing to write home about. Their balsamic dressing is VERY good. I think they put crack in it. I'll be back of course, maybe this place will grow on me. read more

See all

Food was delicious, portion size was huge. Great service price is right . Just a real nice local pizza place/restaurant. Would definitely recommend. read more

When I'm looking for a hearty Italian meal for the right place, I think of Angelina's. What I like is that they include a house or Caesar salad with your entree; this is a nice touch, since many places will go a la carte and only provide the main course. It's a nice size salad, too, and I always look forward to it when starting my meal. My usual favorite is the Calamari Fra Diavolo, with its generous, large rings and huge amount of linguini. Lately, they've had a wonderful appetizer special that you can also get as an entree: Calamari a la Vodka -- with calamari rings soaked in vodka sauce. An absolute dream! It's usually best to get there on the earlier side, as this place fills up fast and they have a limited number of tables. It's convenient to my hometown and a usual stop when I come to visit my family. read more

good food and pizza best place to eat and get a drink and enjoy the vodka slice is delicious

If you work around this neighborhood, you know how hard it is to pick between this restaurant and Vincent's pizzeria from across the street. They both serve good pizzas and have a great selection of Italian classics. Decor seems to be designed to give a more family oriented feel- red and white checkered table cloths, booths, casual music. I ordered one of the cheapest item on the menu - vegetable grilled panini. Greasy but good. It doesn't come with any sides but the two halves sandwich hits the spot for only a lunch that was $6 without tax. read more

Angelina's - Vegetable grilled panini. Zucchini, eggplants, roasted peppers, mozz cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

the place is very clean and the pizza is delicious. i got the bbq and buffalo slice and they tasted great

I had a event here for my sisters birthday and it was nice with that being said we were gonna celebrate my nephews college graduation in june in this location but the person in charge of catering was so rude we waited for 20 mintues for him while he was on a personal phone call I honestly hope he isnt the owner because though your food is good your customer service is horrible. I guess you dont need the buisness any longer since you guys got the BSA loan from the state terrible. I HONESTLY HOPE VINNY IS NOT THE OWNER read more

What a great meal. I started with a Caesar's salad and then had the Rigatoni Bolognese. The portion size was very generous. It was really flavorful and absolutely hit the spot. The price was super reasonable. The staff is friendly and helped make it a nice evening out. The restaurant is super clean including the bathroom. I happily give Angelina's five stars. read more

So I Don't order much from here just every now and then the foods ok good but not the best that being said it is way to expensive.. I prefer Vincent's Clam Bar over any Pizzeria anyway I'd happily pay whatever it is. That's some good food and good pizza.. on top of that what I didn't like is that they offer free delivery but yet when you check your Receipt not sure many people check their receipt but there is a $2 delivery charge. This is not Domino's. Why you charging customers $2 delivery if you're offering free delivery? Then when asked if it's going to the delivery guy they say no lmao wow OK It's just $2. But still it's the principle. so they just making an extra 2 bucks off customers not cool.. I think I'll be ordering elsewhere from now on read more

Very disappointing. I ordered the penne alla vodka with chicken. It was utterly flavourless with a watery cream sauce. My wife and mother-in-law ordered personal pizzas. With one bite it was obvious that they were made from frozen crusts. In a pizzeria! All of the food had been defrosted or pre-made without a single fresh ingredient in sight. To their credit, they didn't charge us for the dishes we couldn't eat, but we won't be returning. read more

Kinda stinks. Heavy sauce and ouly soups. Skip this place. Took 45 mins to wait for puckup and the place was rather enpty.

Love this place for dinner. Annie & Allison were great waitresses! The dinner special is Awesome my husband & I had wine, soup & the dinner special and the bill was under $60! Wow! Annie & Allison were attentive, friendly & knew the menu very well! All the food was fresh, delicious & very filling! I was so full I couldn't eat my dessert & I love Cannolis So I took it home for later.... Check this place out for a date night or dinner with the family read more

I had a gift certificate, I hadn't been there in years !! I ordered a gramma pie ! I took it home , IT WAS THE WORST THING I EVER TASTED!!!! The garlic was raw not cooked!! The sauce was right out of the can and tasted like rust!!! I ate one slice and shit like a race horse!!!! SIMPLY DISGUSTING !!! never again!!!!! read more

The food has always been ok. New location next door. Left completely annoyed. Lots of open tables 2 people in front of us seated right away. The. Our turn. A table will be available shortly. After waiting 15 minutes a party of 6 showed up. They were seated right away. The manger. ?? What a prick. He saw we were pissed and did not acknowledge us. Never going back. Was a patron there for years even the food was average Wait till I blog this on my website of 6000 followers. Bad business read more

This restaurant has good food, tasty and well prepared. Unfortunately if you'r not a local, the wait service is abysmal. We've tried this place a few times and it is always the same good food but fair to poor service. On our last visit here, the waitress behaved like a ditz, did not bring our drink order for 10 minutes, then disappeared until tip time . Meanwhile what she was doing was greeting all of the locals, running around aimlessly and ignoring us. Disgusting! Do yourself a favor, if your not a local, order out. read more

We love to stop at the end of long day of golf and Beach. The food is always prepared to perfection and the portions are large. I ordered the chicken Verde- chicken, broccoli, Mozzarella in a lemon butter wine sauce. The chicken was tender, broccoli slightly over done but still a tiny crunch. My husband got rigatoni Vodka with Chicken. It can put piping hot and was a huge portion, he could not stop eating it. The only reason I did not give them a 5 was because of the slower service, and personality lacking bus staff. read more

We order from here every Friday and they never disappoint! Delivery is always super quick. The pizza is always outstanding and made to order. One time, the box had squished 2 of the slices and they came back with a whole brand new pie and let us keep the other one! They really go above and beyond and I am proud to support them as one of our local businesses because they give excellent service and quality food. read more

Was in recently and mask protocol was not followed. Staff members behind the counter had masks under their noses or none at all. The delivery staff was walking in and out the restaurant with out a mask. read more

One of the better Italian restaurants in the area! The staff: extremely attentive and well trained! As an experienced manager, it was definitely something I appreciated. Food: big portions, well timed, delicious and consistent! Atmosphere: cozy, open side room on weekends to accommodate the customers and bigger tables. I highly suggest eating here! I have not been disappointed yet and I've been eating here for years! read more

This was my first time going to Angelinas. I took my grandma out for lunch because she said this place just gotten re done and she wanted to try the new place ! It took us about 5 minutes to be seated which isn't bad at all especially because the place was packed ! The floors were clean, tables were clean, and most importantly the silverware was clean. I ordered a wrap and my grandma had pasta and clam sauce. We both loved our food, it was made extremely well and we really enjoyed our time there. Our server was super nice and helpful BUT she disappeared so often and we were trying to get her attention and pay for over 10 min. It was a very busy day so I do understand but she came to our table maybe twice at most. But overall we had an amazing time and I will definitely be back! read more

Got some food on Super Bowl Sunday. We ordered chicken francese and eggplant Parmigiana. TERRIBLE, TERRIBLE, TERRIBLE. Chicken was rubbery and the eggplant we could not cut, like rubber. They will never see our money again. read more

This restaurant uses a particularly pungent type of Parmesan cheese that is inedible unless you like your food to taste like vomit. And they put in almost everything! The food would be decent if not for the Parmesan, but it literally ruins almost every dish. I eat Italian food all the time, and I like mild Parmesan, so I am not afraid of this cheese. But a restaurant should be wise enough to use mild versions of cheeses if it is going to throw it into anything and everything that it serves. If Angelina's modifies its Parmesan cheese, then it would be a 3.5 star restaurant rather than a 2 star restaurant. They sprinkle it on the complimentary bread they serve. They add it to the standard side of pasta with pomedoro sauce (i.e simple tomato sauce) they serve as an accompaniment to every main dish. They add it to regular pizza. They added it to the breadcrumbs they put on top of veal and chicken dishes. read more