Ordered delivery and I regret every bit of it. The food arrived in a sad, sad state. Ordered Penne Ala Vodka with shrimp, New England Clam chowder, grandma slice and Italian Cheesecake. Well let's start with the slice, hands down the worst slice I've had in New York and that's saying a lot. It's really hard to find a bad slice in NY but this place has got your back if you want one. Bland, cold and not cooked well. The Pasta, all of Italy is in mourning after this dish. The pasta was extremely undercooked, I love al dente but this wasn't even in the realm, the sauce was watery and barely even coating the pasta, the shrimp no flavor, no sauce clearly cooked in water and just thrown on with no thoughts. The New England Clam Chowder, solid flavor profile just one huge issue. NO CLAMS!!! The Italian Cheesecake was meh, just run of the mill low star bakery quality. It may be Memorial Day weekend but this meal was all the wrong memories and a living nightmare. read more

Vincent's restaurant has the best pizza around My favorite go to is the potato egg, ham and mozzarella hero Get it- you won't be sorry! read more

(04.18.26) First timer here! It was worth it! My kiddos enjoyed every bite of their pizzas. As I turned my head over to the next table one of their dishes caught my eyes. So I had to order it. (Sorry for creeping a little ) The fried calamari with the medium spice sauce was delicioussss!!!! I definitely have to come back and get this dish again! Yummmm!!!! The ambiance felt very family owed and felt very welcomed. Thank you guys! See you guys soon! read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Pepperoni Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

I pulled up and was waiting for the bus in 100° weather so the options for a cool spot were a juice or pizza. Of course I chose pizza. At 39 I'm not ashamed to say this it's my food or choice over anything. Anyway I walk in an older gentleman who had the same idea was all smiling and we made some small talk about waiting for the bus. The guy behind the counter acted as if I was interrupting his busy day when he had zero customers to wait on which was unpleasant. And when I tasted the pizza.... It tastes the same- zero flavor, too soft and unpleasant. I don't know why as a NewYorker/ Pizza Lover certain things are just standard in my mind. Soft pizza no crunch- but why? Is it for senior citizens? Should I have asked for extra crispy? It is my fault for trying all the pizza on Long Island. Anyway they had a small parking lot, parking out front, and a front and back beverage station which gave the impression that they are very busy at times. They had a decent amount of tables and are diagonal from the movies. They had a significant amount of flavor options and I believe they serve beer. I sat inside and wasn't offered any pleasantries so I just got up and got my own napkins when I noticed that I was not going to be offered any. They had a steady stream of singles and doubles come in and leave with food to go around every ten minutes or so and two more staff member who were closer to the kitchen in the back making small talk. They were playing the Yankees games and as I sat there fake eating my pizza (bc I couldn't do it) I wondered if they flavors were catered towards aged individuals with a sensitive palate as the 3 other patrons hading out from the heat beside me were aged. Anyway it wasn't the best use of my $4.50 and in their defense I did not self season my pizza so I do not have a positive recommendation here. But I did take a lot of photos. read more

See all

Highly recommend making reservations or you will be hungry and cold by the time you get seated. There is a small vestibule to wait in near the front door with no seating and the door is constantly being open because of all the patrons coming in to check in or leaving stuffed. High energy and fast paced. A little noisy but as expected due to the lively atmosphere. Tight seating but all worth it. Great food, great service and generous portions. We go here several times a year- lunch or dinner. read more

I have been coming here for 30 years and the pizza and service have always been great. Try the meatball parm hero!

Drove here for a dinner meeting because it's open late and I really love the calm atmosphere. The waitress was very attentive and took our orders right away. I ordered a cappuccino and a minestrone soup so far ! Everything is delicious, tasty, and fresh. I would definitely come back to try more on the menu again soon. read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

See all

The food is always the best. The server makes you feel you are the only customer. The room is lit perfectly and just a great meal every time. read more

Rude late night close to closing obnoxiously joking with other customers who needed to use the bathroom. "One dollar" when a lady asked to use it and when she was leaving the cook haggled the poor woman continuing with the joke demanding his one dollar. Anyways my problem was that I called to place an order to pick up and go like any traditional spot. When I arrived 20 minutes after I ordered they decided to tell me that not only did they not have the three buffalo chicken rolls but that the ticket hadn't even been started. Frustrating enough the cook starts to act like he doesn't speak English although I've been talking to him since high school. I simply asked if he was alone tonight and he proceeded to talk gibberish and I said it wasn't nice to be rude to the lady. He started to get loud and brush it off i don't know. If he didn't want people to hear what was being said or what. Then when I asked for blue cheese with the rolls he said to say please, and was getting loud when I said you need to give respect to earn it. Rude, obnoxious, and terrible attitude disappointed that each time I build the courage to give them another chance they consistently let you down. Ps. Their food isn't even good. All this for some burnt rolls. read more

My favorite Italian food place. I love their staff because they're always sweet & we do go often. If you come here definitely don't miss out on their calamari !!! It's THE BEST IN THE WORLD! and OMG THE SAUCE IS TO DIE FOR but make sure you ask for it hot it's so good and I could eat buckets of it lol, their pizza is amazing especially their square margherita that I absolutely love and crave weekly read more

I came for lunch. their lunch special menu is a great value. The food is solid and definitely house made. i had the clam chowder and didn't care for it because i thought it had a very strong thyme flavor. I really don't like thyme that much. the soup would've been awesome if not for that. The waitress was super nice and gave me the salad. my entrée was this Genovese pasta with shrimp. It was delicious. read more

See all

I ordered Chicken parm with spaghetti to go. Their chicken parm was good but their spaghetti sauce tasted really bad like it's been sitting out for a while read more

Let's just start from when you call in your order. I am always put on hold for over 2 minutes. The person who answers seems to be bothered by me calling. I place the order and request it be said back to me because it's not always correct. When you arrive you stand there waiting for someone to acknowledge you. And when someone does again it feels like I'm bothering them again. For a place that has mediocre pizza and food at best they act as if they are the best. I don't usually eat their food. But I received a gift certificate and will be using it up and never return again! read more

Horrible service if you know your gonna be busy for the holidays get the extra staff this is why pp go out of buisness poor management.

Love there pizza, I drive out of my way to get either a buffalo chicken slice or chicken and broccoli slice. They always update there daily menu specials. The staff is always nice, the pizza taste really good. read more

See all

Mediocre food. I had to go home and remake the pasta. My boyfriend and I ordered penne al vodka with grilled chicken and rigatoni with meat sauce: no seasoning no taste. Not enough cheese and they gave us red sauce on the side that tasted just like ketchup. Mind you we didn't order anything that needed ketchup. I wouldn't return I had better authentic Italian food. It sucks too because the menu looks so good. Smh read more

The pizza here is the greatest! The dinners not! We ordered 2 chicken parm dinners & the chicken was tough & in pieces. The tomato sauce had too much paste in it. Hope they analyze what their kitchen is putting out! read more

Stars are only the clam chowder when we actually had a successfully delivery from here a few weeks back. It's very good! Tried ordering it for delivery Friday and they gave us chicken noodle soup instead.. Tried ordering it for delivery tonight (Sunday) and after waiting 1.5 hours and nothing arriving we called the restaurant for them to tell us they couldn't deliver bc they had no driver...why do you even advertise delivery on grub hub??! Why didn't you call to let us know? Thank you, next. read more

Casual friendly pizza joint. I go here for the delicious Grandmother pizza that Long Island is known for. Street meter parking is easy to find. Had their house Burgundy wine and it wasn't bad. Definitely try out this pizza if near Lynbrook. It's down the block from the train station. read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Burgundy house wine and Grandma's pizza slice. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

I miss Vincent's the day after I eat there. And can't wait to go back. I like the grandma pizza but prefer the Sicilian. It is award winning. you will never be disappointed. read more

We decided to try out this place in the neighborhood... we had pizza and salad with shrimp and another with steak, also we had sangria. We loved it! Prices are good service is also good. If you want also authentic Italian food, I def recommend this place. We're def come Back for lunch this time: read more

I always used to come here after work and the atmosphere was always very warm and welcoming. Pizza was really good too. Ended up meeting the owner on accident, he was very kind. Great food for a relatively low price :) read more

if you enjoy a crisp new york style pizza, avoid this place. pizza is not good, way too thick, very greasy. i ordered half bacon ranch half buffalo pie and neither tasted like anything i've had in the past (not in a good way). lacking flavor and color, the slices seemed identical until closer inspection. regular pie is okay, still chewy, still greasy but marginally better than the specialty slices. wouldn't go back if they gave this stuff away for free. never was a reviewer kind of customer but this is the poorest example of pizza i've ever had. read more

Worst calzone, I've eaten. Was not made to order. Sicilian slice was not fresh either. Acidic tomato sauce. Reminded me of a slice i had in elementary school. What is going on there? New owners? Used to be so.much better. read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Calzone with ham - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Vincent's is our go to Friday night pizza place. They have a great pie and also excel at heros, chicken rolls and pastas. You wont be disappointed. The pic is a chicken parm hero, they don't hold back on chicken, sauce and cheese, you get your money's worth read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

It hurts to write this review because I have loved this place for years!! Love the pizza and never complained about the food, so for takeout I still recommend. But in regards to sit down and service, it's gotten too much to bear. The last five times me or someone in my family has gone there, there is always-ALWAYS-one waitress. The food comes out way too late and even getting a simple drink might run around 10 minutes. (Should someone ever wait over a half hour for soup??) And back to the one waitress part, in addition to getting things out late (which maybe the kitchen's fault too) there are always *at least* two mistakes with the order (and last visit someone that came in 10 minutes after me got their meals first for some reason?). Everyone who works there is extremely nice, no doubt about it, but it's become too frustrating of an experience to sit and eat anymore. And I waited for these mistakes to happen several times before I wrote this review. If you really want it, take out is for the best, or maybe if you spot the place completely empty you might get the attention a customer is deserved. read more

Love this place!!! Angelo makes the best pizza pies! Very friendly staff Neighborhood gem! Very clean pizzeria Dana H. read more

Terrible burnt stale pizza and terrible customer service. Will not be going back there Maybe if the customer Service was better we would try the pizza again. The guy behind the counter put his thumb on my slice of pizza while placing it in the oven ! totally unacceptable ! All the food looked old and burnt. We have been there before and the food was ok. And the customer service was better than today but I will not go back there again. read more

ordered linguine with white clam sauce & instead received chopped clams & linguine tossed in pasta water. not only was the food gross, myself & my coworker felt queasy all day after eating the same exact thing. the only good thing are the garlic knots read more

This place used to be so much better (4 to 5 stars). I loved their free birthday dinner incentive coupons that they mail to my family. The pizza is still terrific and the staff are helpful and attentive; however, the tomato sauce for the entrees varied from bland to extra extra salty during our family of 4 outings on two separate occassions. read more

Very nice restaurant to go out to dinner with family or friends. Pizza is amazing I suggest the buffalo slice. The ambiance of the pizzeria adds to the overall charm, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere. I'll definitely be returning for more of their delicious pizza and hospitality. read more

I have eaten there before and the service was very good the food was excellent never had a problem. Last week I ordered takeout and they said 45 minutes and they came on time the food was piping hot just the was i like it. I will be ordering from Vincent's from now on. I have ordered from different places and there was always a problem. read more

The service was great, the waitresses are very friendly and easy to talk to. It's a family friendly environment with lots of smiling faces. The food is affordable and delicious with great portion sizes read more

I never review but this place charged me $9 for a "pepperoni roll" - they sent me a pepperoni pinwheel which was gross. When i called, they doubled down. If you want to be ripped off, go here. read more

Vincent's Restaurant - $9 for this garbage pepperoni pinwheel. - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

We all know Long Island has the best pizza and our standards of Italian cuisine are higher than they might be in New York's sister states. Vincent's in Lynbrook is your typical rustic, no-nonsense, fast-talking pizzeria and restaurant. Whether you're craving a plain slice, a calzone, a chicken roll, a slice of Sicilian, garlic knots, rice balls, or even some fettuccini or meatball parmesan, Vincent's will not disappoint. The pizzeria is fairly small but somehow they always seem to have ample seating, and the full-service area actually feels like a mini Italian restaurant (not just your typical pizzeria). In many ways it feels halfway between a pizzeria and a full-service Italian restaurant, so whether you're looking to dine in or take your food to go, Vincent's will satisfy your good old-fashioned Italian-American craving. Straying from the food a bit (which again is exactly what you'd expect from a quality Long Island pizzeria), service is similarly what you'd expect. The staff behind the counter moves fast and delivers that savory pizza flavor you crave (piping hot, crispy crust, sweet sauce), while the waiters provide some extra service and attention). The restaurant is also kept clean, and you'll find a good amount of parking in the back lot (street parking can be tough). Looking for another pizza place in Lynbrook? Fugghetaboutit! read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Before you even order, the staff here is very friendly and will take care of you. The gentleman behind the counter asked me if I wanted something to drink while I waited for my take out order. No charge. I told him I didn't see garlic knots on the online menu so he gave me 6, no charge. The entire menu is delicious. Everything from the homemade soups, to the pepperoni filled knots, to their basic slices and specialty slices, all the way to their pasta dishes and specials. Want a treat? Look for their halibut special if you like fish. It is OUT OF THIS WORLD! Baked clams are always a hit in my house. Even with my picky eater. You can't lose if you come here. The majority of the bad reviews are from people who called to have their food delivered. Get off your lazy potato and take a walk or a ride and order in person. You'll have a different opinion. I promise! read more

This place is absolutely ridiculous. We placed an order through Grubhub for a neapolitan pie and noticed order was 30 minutes late so we decide to call the store and inquire about our order. We explicitly mention that it's a Grubhub order and the girl puts us on hold at first, and then comes back and tells us that it is "already out for delivery - it should arrive soon." Another 30 minutes goes by and still nothing arrives. We call back and the SAME GIRL now tells us that their "internet is down and they haven't been receiving Grubhub orders all day." What the HELL????? FIRST OF ALL, she was the same person who told us our order was out for delivery 30 minutes ago, and now she claims she never got the order at all! She literally LIED to us. This has got to be the worst customer service from a food establishment I've ever experienced in my entire life. I couldn't even believe the audacity. We were hungry and waiting for our food for almost 2 hours at that point, and this girl did not even bother to actually check if our order was actually on its way - and just straight up LIED and said it was coming. What kind of insanity is that... Now get this next: We ask them to cancel the order and refund us and they literally said they COULD NOT???? If you guys don't know how to work properly with your partnered food delivery apps then just don't even sign up with them in the first place. This is completely unacceptable. In the first place, it just doesn't make any sense that their "internet was down" because how would the app know to update the delivery times? We did notice that the order originally said it would be delivered at 5:38pm, and then the time shifted to ~6pm after a while. How did the order even get confirmed in the first place if they had no internet? This was all super fishy and I honestly have a feeling that Vincent's just hates receiving Grubhub orders and purposely did this to deter people from using food delivery apps. I spoke briefly with another gentleman on the phone who mentioned to me TWICE "next time, just order with us directly, we deliver to you." Next time?? Absolutely not. I'd rather starve than order from this place again - oh wait, I still did even though I DID order from here. read more

If I could leave a zero star review I would, I have been ordering from Vincent's for the past 2 years, but after tonight: NEVER AGAIN. This is the WORST pizza I have ever ordered. When I called to place the order I was put on hold for an outrageously long time, then the employee seemed incapable of understanding what I was trying to order, a half veggie, half plain pizza, with two rice balls. Once I walked into the shop, I wasn't even greeted with a smile or a hello. I was given the box with no opportunity to open and check the pie before I left. When I got home and opened the box, this is what I saw. The pizza is lopsided, it looks like it's missing a chunk. And the vegetables are entirely under-cooked, and greasy. The mushrooms are slimy like they've been drowned in oil. And the flavor is completely unappetizing. I am so disappointed in this pizzeria and I will never be going to back. I do not recommend this restaurant, if you can even call it a restaurant. read more

Vincent's Restaurant - Slopily thrown together half vegetable half regular pizza pie. UNACCEPTABLE! - Pizza Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Soooo don't bother ordering food from this place by the time it gets to you it could of been shipped for and made by yourself plus no untesils or napkins. How much is a plastic forks and knife horrible service read more

Great place and friendly staff. I always loved their pizza and awesome price with decent amount of food. They give you complimentary assorted bread also. However my pasta was mushy :( usually like it with a bite to it but other than that food was good. Delicious sauce ! read more

See all