Have been going to Mario's for over 40 years. It's a typical pizza joint, with wonderful food, and good service. Great place to go when you're in the mood for homemade Italian food! read more

The pile of bicycles that are always in front are a turnoff. The place is noisy because of the teenagers and the message to me is they don't want older customers. read more

So I use to go here as a kid and it seems like nothings really changed since the last 10 years! It's a pretty small place, the decor is not that appealing, just very dull looking. I ordered the chicken parm with pasta. I really wanted spaghetti but the guy said it would take too long and gave me penne pasta instead. I was kinda bummed about that. I got it to go and they packed it in 2 separate containers, which made it annoying to eat it separate like that. The pasta tasted microwaved/reheated. But the chicken parm was actually really good! The guy at the register was really nice aswell. Service was quick probably because they weren't that busy, but beware, this is the goto spot for the high schoolers during the afternoon and after school hours so it can get pretty packed. But in the summer it's not that bad of a crowd. I'll probably eat here once in awhile but it didn't blow me away. read more

See all

the staff so so friendly and welcoming to everyone they make sure to explain everything and try to help as much as possible read more

Mario's Pizza - bakery - Pizza Near Me - Oceanside, New York

I come here so much with my friends and the workers are so nice and friendly and the food is great they are very good and talented workers the food comes out quick and fresh and it's great read more

Mario's is a great pizzeria. The workers are nice and the food is tasty. There is a wide variety of food and when compared to other local pizzerias, Mario's is one of the least expensive. There is adequate seating and it is overall a nice dining experience. I would highly recommend. read more

Great food, we love their pizza. Workers are courteous and professional. Quiet ambience, unless you visit during school hours ( high school is near by) read more

Delivered pizza burnt, tiramisu was freezer burnt. Frozen solid. Spoke with the manager who was unapologetic. Said that's how tiramisu comes. They have no where to put it so they stick it in the freezer? I asked what about my burnt food. He said listen, I don't know what happened, I'll give you a break next time.... I won't be returning thanks. read more

Mario's Pizza - Burnt, unacceptable - Pizza Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Just ordered dinner from this place and was sadly disappointed with the lack of understanding by the chef to what was on the order ticket. Ordered 2 chicken souvlaki platters with grilled chicken. Asked that there be no dressing on the food, but rather on the side, for dietary reasons. Asked for tzatziki sauce on the side, as well. The last order was for a chicken and pasta dish. That was the only thing that was correct. When we opened the dishes the chicken souvalaki platters had oil and vinegar all over it. They only sent one tzatziki sauce instead of one for each platter. Spending almost 50.00 in today's climate is not the problem. I The problem is, that for your money you should get what you asked for. I called and was given double talk by the person who answered, saying the chef must have made a mistake. I was told they could send another sauce and a replacement but then the owner got on the phone defending the order was correct....nothing was offered. Being unable to eat this drenched salad, and could only salvage the chicken from each. It is unfortunate that this business is so unwilling to see an error and try to correct it. The location was only one owner for more than 35 years but now this new ownership is just not doing right by the customers. Sadly, we will not return nor will many others. Thanks read more

Great food and service highly recommended eat here or takeout often dinners are always good and lg portions

Best Pizza in Oceanside. When you order a large pie you get a large pie. Other places give you a pie with tiny slices. Only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is cause they close kinda early for a pizza parlor in my opinion. read more

Hi. I usually don't come on here to complain but I have to say this. Mario's pizzeria near the high school, on brower. I went there when I was in school and always would grab a bite before class. But I don't know if they are under new management or something but I think I should have went somewhere else. I got a chicken parmesan wrap, my friend got a eggplant parmagianni hero, and my sister got spaghetti with butter. When we got this it was just grease, oil, and I'm sorry but just disgusting. My sister's pasta it was spaghetti, and it was like floating in a sea of butter and oil. My friend's eggplant wasn't even cooked correctly and it was leaking grease. And my wrap was cold and the chicken wasn't all the way cooked and I know I don't know what's going on behind the scenes. But the food wasn't even cooked correct and it didn't even taste good. We only took two bites and after only a few hours, we are all sick. From sweating foreheads to throwing up to very dizzy headaches. I thought I was the only one but I read more comments and people have the same thing to say. I called and told them about my experience and how the food was greasy but they just hung up on me. I just wanted to put awareness to this for awareness to other food goers. I'm sorry to say but I don't think I'll ever go back. read more

Take out date: March 22, 2017 My aunt and uncle came over to my mom's house for dinner so after I had gotten to my Baldwin home after my mom watched my son during the work day my mom did her thing, dialed some digits and ordered Mario's for dinner. She got me the antipasto salad and they agreed to take out the salami to make it vegetarian. I loved this Salad. They didn't bulk it up with lettuce as some places do they put a fair amount of other veggies on it and they added a good amount of cheese which is good because cheese, eggs and tofu are my to go protein choices as a vegetarian. I can't talk about the pizza as I'm rarely eating pizza anymore but as far as salads this place is great! read more

Fave place for my teen son. The decor is rundown but food is fab. We mostly order delivery. Recommend the pizza (of course), lemon chicken dinner, calzones and rolls. The giro sandwiches are good too. read more

I ordered via grubhub and was not disappointed! I ordered a regular pie and a side of fries. I made the request for buffalo sauce on the side which with other pizza places is a 50/50 request. With this order I did receive my buffalo sauce-yayy! Fried came fresh, warm and crispy which was also nice to see! Most times delivered fried come cold and soggy. For some good fresh and hot pizza delivery choose Mario's! read more

This place is really good. Sort of a hidden gem. Somehow the slces are larger than other places. Its time to moove on from Ginos people and expand your pizza horizons. read more

the food is delicious, a lot of high schoolers go there during their lunch periods but even when it's packed they're very reasonable with their time. read more

The pizza is old with little to no sauce and taste like cardboard I'd rather eat McDonald's for The rest of my life instead of this garbage read more

Mario's Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oceanside, New York

35 years ago Mario's was the place to go from OHS, and, it still is. The food is great and the staff is friendly. Pizza is just one of the foods that they have. Pastas, salads, soups, wraps, calzones... it is a full Italian restaurant. Weeknight specials eat-in are a must have. Delivery is convenient. Ther menu also offers wings which are delicious ( we like the bbq). Mario's hold both a nostalgic and a modern place in our hearts and minds. If you are looking for great Italian food, this is a fantastic choice!! read more

I ordered the Antipasto salad today for dinner. Delivery. Very good except they seem to have run out of the cold cuts! I mean it really was good but lacking. read more

First and last time ordering from this place. I ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which I've had from other pizzerias before by the slice and whole pie. I've never seen a pizza with such poor presentation and a blatant sign of apathy in preparation. It was a sloppy, dripping, soupy mess of excessive everything. The chicken was saturated and chewy, the cheese and whatever dressing or sauce they use was spilling over the crust. It literally looked like someone vomited on a pizza crust and it tasted very mediocre for the price. Not worth it. Unappetizing. Absolutely lazy, an embarrassment to Italian cuisine and NY pizza. Please do not waste your time and money, you will be disappointed. 2 Bros Pizza which sells dollar slices in the city literally has a better quality product. Ridiculous. read more

Mario's Pizza - Unacceptable, sloppy, poor quality. - Pizza Near Me - Oceanside, New York

There are a whole bunch of pizza joints in Oceanside. I grew up with Marios over the years, and I know some families who swear by it. I'm a Villa Formia boy (another Oceanside haunt), always have been, and I compare everything to their pizza. The Mario's pizza was a little too greasy for me. Maybe I caught it on a bad day, but there was just a teeeeeenie bit too much for me to really enjoy it. The chicken rolls are pretty fantastic, though I'm not a big fan of ricotta and you can definitely taste it. They're like glorified chicken parm sandwiches, just better and crustier. Worth trying out if you're passing by / in the neighborhood. No great shakes, in my opinion. read more

I've ordered from every pizza place in Oceanside. I have to say Mario's is the best one. The Hero's and dinners have the biggest portion from the rest and consistently tastes good. If you haven't tried Mario's give them a shot read more

My favorite pizza place in Oceanside. Looks can be deceiving. They deliver on quality!!! The food is delicious and the people who work there are friendly. read more

Its been close to 15 years since I graduated high school and I have not eaten at Marios since then, after my visit yesterday I know why. I went in with Two other friends and we order a calzone, chicken roll, and some pinwheels. The food was really greasy and lacked taste. I figured that was the end of that, boy was I wrong. Myself and both of my friends all got ill within 6 hours of eating there,I called Marios to tell them abut the situation and some guy says hell tell the boss and hangs up. There are a lot of pizza places in this area and many other places that you would be better served spending your hard earned money. read more

Me and my friends went to Mario's pizza because it is close, but after going in I realized going further is worth it. We went in and I ordered a regular slice and they gave us an old slice from the back. The restaurant was very dirty. My friends said they hated their food, and other kids were sitting in next to us but the manager told them to leave because he needed to clean the tables. The staff started laughing and everyone thinks this is a joke. I recommend never going there. read more

phenomenal pizza great service nice people easy to get along with if I could I would rate the place 10/5

This has been the standby for any random take-out dinner night in the area. The pizza is good and the menu is actually pretty varied. One of the best gyros I've ever had came from Mario's. In high school, it was one of the few local restaurants you could get food from and make it back to class. They also had some random concoctions, like the "taco pizza", which is exactly what it sounds like :ground beef, taco sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese on a pizza crust. yes, it was delicious. read more

We love their plain regular slice ! But I can't believe they will not cater to gluten free crowd , I would love to get the same flavors on a gluten free slice ! Get with the times Mario! read more

This place serves Great Italian food, all at a Great price!! Everyone working there are efficient and good people. Especially the boss Mario, who always makes sure the food is on time and delicious! I've been coming here for years on a weekly basis and I recommend it to all of my friends. I highly recommend it to everyone. read more

Outstanding service food and experience every time!! Friendly staff and always welling to accommodate n get you what you want. Loveeee this place read more

Love the pizza! Spinach pinwheels are the best!

Marios pizza is the worst in Oceanside. When delivered it's often late, cold and sometimes the wrong order! This last time I ate a Mario pizza. We all got sick eating this pizza. This place is dirty... sick thinking about it! Never again! read more

I've stopped in here almost every year in December for the past 10 years. Really good thin crust, crispy pizza. Yes, it's oily. Use a napkin to sop it up. Love their spinach pizza. Big slices. Small place, often frequented by local kids. They used to make baseball sized zeppoles, but it seems they stopped making it this past December. I was never actually that crazy about them anyways. A slight renovation removed the storm door and increased the seating area slightly. I'll give it 5 stars when they renovate the unisex bathroom (It was clean, but it was essentially a broom closet) and if they put zeppoles back on the menu and offer to make them fresh to order. read more

Very bad experience tonight. We ordered a meat lover's deep dish pizza, as we get nearly every week. They delivered a regular pie. We told the delivery man it was wrong and he told us to keep the regular pie and he would bring back the meat lover's pizza we ordered. Got a phone call 15 or 20 minutes later from the pizzeria. The man told tried to tell us we were wrong even though 5 people heard the order repeated twice. Then he said we could get the meat lover's pie but had to return the regular pizza. Not only is that against the department of health code but 3 kids had been told they could have that pie and it was gone. So we paid for something we didn't receive and they tried to take back a pie 20 minutes after they left it at someone's house. Terrible service. You would think they would be honest with their customers. read more

I liked their pizza, and had it delivered whenever we were in the mood for it. But after actually going in one day, I'll never order from there again. It was dirty & disgusting, complete with dead bugs all over the window sill. And the worse part is, the guys behind the counter were too busy talking and playing on their phone rather than cleaning. It's a shame but they absolutely lost my business. read more

I have ordered from Mario's for years. However, the last time I ordered and picked up a pie it was a reheated pie. It was so dry and it almost looked like one piece didn't belong to the pie and they just added it. It is unfortunate because a freshly made pie from them is delicious. Unfortunately, there are just way too many other pizza joints to order from. Thankfully, I found one. read more

best grilled chicken and broccoli rabe!!!

I stopped going to this restaurant for a while because the food was horrible ended up going there recently and since under new ownership the food was amazing and they gave you so much food I ordered eggplant Parmesan and had three meals out of it read more

As a former employee here, I will obviously have a biased opinion. I do love the food though, and would order from them regularly even when I wasn't working there. Mainly, though, the reason I decided to leave a review here, was because I read some other reviews about their online menu being disgraceful. Truth is, Mario, the owner, never made an online menu. A customer or someone took it upon themselves to make one for Mario's, and the menu is completely inaccurate with the prices and even some of the food currently on the actual menu. I've watched the cooks make the food and I've always thought they did an excellent job and the pizza as well. read more