For yeeeeeeears I used to hear about this pizza and I finally tried it. I actually tried it twice to make sure my review would be off of more than one experience. Both times the pizza was the same quality. The pizza is good BUT NOT AT ALL the best. If we're judging off of Queens alone is #4 on my list. If we're judging off of NYC altogether its top 10. Both times I went there was a crowd, so they definitely have a large clientele, but yeah, I would only choose this one if I couldn't get to my other 3 spots in Queens. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

In my opinion, this service is good. The pizza is near perfect if not that. I've had catered lasagna from Gabby's. It was pretty good. The ambiance is casual and the aesthetics are that of an art gallery. It's a choice place for pizza! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Extra cheese n buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

Gaby's has fallen off the good pizza list. They use to be so great, but the last two times I ordered was awful. It looked good, but looks are deceiving. On 11/6/25 I ordered half extra cheese and pepperoni. Looks amazing right. Now look at the bottom. BURNT PIZZA. Yes that is what I paid $33.00 for. No more I will make my own pizza if I feel for pizza. Soon I will have my own restaurant everyone and you can come and eat at my place the way I'm striking out with food lately :(. Later everyone happy weekend. The whole pizza bottom was burnt. They said they wanted to make another one, but who wanted to wait 45 more minutes on top of the original 45 minutes we were hungry and only could eat 2 slice to hard. SMH :( read more

Gaby's Pizza - Bad on the bottom :( - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

I haven't been to Gabys in forever because the pizza makes me feel sick. However I used to enjoy their hot wings. This time their hot wings were burnt and dry. I asked for a new order but was told this was the best the way they not make their wings so a new order will look the same way. So I basically wasted my money. read more

"Great pizza!" Classic New York slice done right, crispy crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of sauce. Casual place with quick service, fair prices, and the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back. Love Gabby"s! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

The only pizzeria where I actually finish the crust. This place is so nostalgic, a Queens staple. Growing up this is where the teachers would order the pizza party pizza from. The space sits plenty and the staff truly knows how to put a smile on your face. My favorite part is the last few bites before you reach the crust, where the cheese has cooled enough and the crust is sweetened by the sauce. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

Excellent pizza with parking. I love their pizza but don't sleep on the calzones and their heros are delicious too. Everything is fresh at Gaby's and the staff is fast and friendly. There are a few tables as you first walk in but I've never stayed. read more

Ordered a head, a large cheese pizza. The staff is always friendly, helpful and service is quick. They have music playing and a flat-screen for sports. A very chill atmosphere. It's a very popular neighborhood pizzeria. They also have a wall of fame so if you're ever on Hillside Avenue and Francis Lewis Blvd, stop in and give Gabby a try! read more

See all

absolutely phenomenal!!!!! chicken parm on steroids!!!!! mystical & magical!!!!!!! you need to get this!!!!!!! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Chicken parm hero on steroids!!!!!! ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL, MYSTICAL, AND MAGICAL!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

I don't understand the backlash ... maybe bc I never tried gaby's during their "prime" back in the day. I was more of a margheritas girl. Not to bring up their other competition. I came across this gem rather late. But I feel like gabys genuinely makes good quality pizza. My pie was fresh piping hot & cooked well & tasted like good ol' classic NY pizza. The only thing I will say in which most ppl agree with is that their tomato sauce def has a sweetness to it. But I don't mind it. I love to pour a bunch of pepper flakes on my pizza so it balances it out. So they're still good in my book read more

Gaby's Pizza - Large pie half veggie/ pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

Came here after my Son-in-law Aunt (who lives around the corner) highly recommended this place. Sauce was good, crust was tasty and the cheese was delicious! Clean restaurant and have your mind made up before getting in line this place get's busy and people have places to go! LOL can you tell I wasn't prepared tehehehe BTW we reheated the pizza later that evening and it was still great - oven reheated. Anyhoo the grandbabies had the rainbow Italian Ice and they LOVED it. Next time we come to see Auntie we'll probably stop in again. Respectfully Reviewed. read more

Gaby's Pizza - NY Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

I feel compelled to write this review because I feel like I'm being gaslighted. I've ordered from this place so many times--plain pies, specialty pies, and everything in between--and I've been disappointed every single time. Yet, if you ask anyone around, they'll swear this is the best pizza in town, and they say it with absolute conviction. The pizza is borderline good at best. It's overly saucy and way too sweet, like they've taken San Marzano purée, diluted it with just enough water to make it spreadable, and called it a day. The sweetness is so overpowering that you can't taste anything else. At $20+ per pie, you're better off hitting up a Crown Fried Chicken spot--you'll pay less and get way more depth of flavor. And that's not even considering the horrible location. The plaza's parking lot is a nightmare--tight spaces, chaotic traffic, and nearly impossible to navigate without feeling like an accident waiting to happen. read more

Takeout perfection super cheesy pepperoni pizza. Sooooo hot and fresh!!! Loved it all the way down to the crust. Caesar salad was sub-par. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Cheese Pepperoni pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Felt like getting one last slice of pizza before leaving America for a while and Gaby's did not disappoint. Fast and friendly service.

Had a good time at gabys, order a large pie and left full. We did a video on youtube called Margherita Pizza Vs Gabys Pizza. Check it out if you need more visuals. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Order a large pie at Gabys - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

To me Gabys is still one of the best slices in Queens. The staff is always courteous. Order 2 slices (one pepperoni) a Sicilian and 2 medium drinks for $17. The slice were fresh and cheesy with the perfect sauce/texture. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

My family and I love the food from Gaby's! We recently ordered chicken francese, meatball parm hero, salad and ate a slice of pizza while waiting. Everything was really delicious and the portions are generous. This neighborhood gem serves food that tastes like home read more

Queens has always had this battle between Gaby's and Margherita's. Gaby's use to be able to hold their weight but there's no longer a competition because Margherita's has definitely won. I'm not sure of what has changed besides the price but they need to turn around somethings from the past shouldn't be changed. read more

The crust was great the cheese was the show stopper the sauce was a bit on the sweet side.Over all Gaby's made a customer out of me. We did a youtube review on Gaby's Vs. Margaritas Pizza. Check it out read more

Gaby's Pizza - A Great cheesy pozza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

I just ordered and received a pizza. A pizza I was hyped to eat because I heard great things about Gaby's . The pizza was not fully cooked and cold. I am very disappointed with this pizza delivery. We spent $32 dollars to eat the worst tasting, not fully cooked , cold pizza. I believe we deserve a refund. Very unsatisfied customer..... read more

Can't wait...,. ..... u have to try this spot! Anyone who knows and love great New York slices give them a try today! Great family vibes and amazing service. read more

Gaby's Pizza - LETS EAT! - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

I've been going to Gaby's for well over a decade and I never thought to write a review because it was just perfectly fine pizza, usually. The other day I bought a slice and it was pretty good so today I bought a pie and it was just so so. The problem with Gaby's is the lack of consistency. Usually the sauce is a little sweet, today my pie has a sour tasting sauce. Some days the fresh garlic is great, today I can barely taste it. Sometimes the dough has no taste and is kind of floppy, my pie today has great dough. It's the overall lack of consistency that is disappointing. I've come to the conclusion that I have to try a slice first before I buy an entire pie because it absolutely depends on the day and who's making the pizza. read more

I've been here before in my younger years (I'm still young ). I remember how someone loved their pizza so much. It's still pretty good. The place is very clean, spacious, and welcoming. I ordered 2 plain slices and 2 Sicilians. They also serve other Italian dishes such as pasta, which I'm eager to try. I'm giving it 4 stars for taste though...because for me I tasted more sauce than cheese. I have a particular taste for cheese and pizza in general that I've been missing. However their service was amazing, kind people and efficient. I see this place gets crowded quickly and often. It looks so different inside compared to outside. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

I've eaten Gabbby's since 1965 and it is still delicious. Don't heed the nay sayers Gabby's has not fallen off in quality, taste or service!

One day heading to a friends house i was extremely hungry. I remember seeing this little plaza and decided to check it out. The option was between Mcdonalds or Gaby's Pizza, of course i went for pizza. They also have a parking lot which makes it alot easier for you to go grab that bite. At this certain time i was craving a Chicken and Broccoli Pizza. Now, i like pizza a certain way, the chicken has to be made a certain way, the broccoli has to be just right. I dont know, maybe I'm picky but, hey, i rather be picky and have a great taste than something that doesn't taste delicious. Gaby's Pizza definitely came through for ya girl. Mmmm mm mm, is all i gotta say. So much love put into it. Every bite made me wanna take another bite. If you around this side of Queens I recommend trying them out. read more

See all

It's so wonderful to be able to order food that is consistently excellent year after year. We ordered sausage roll, broccoli slice and baked ziti. Sooooo flavorful! The crust on the roll was so buttery, the slice was deliciously plentiful and the ziti was cooked to perfection. The restaurant has accommodation to eat in. Very clean and the staff is very friendly and attentive. Thank you Gabys for keeping the tradition of excellent food and service. I'm never disappointed!! Bravo. . Still the best pizza hands down. read more

Neighborhood favorite for many many years and still going strong. Sauce a bit on "sweet" side however, that's their niche and what Gaby's known for. Casual ambiance and excellent attentive service. read more

See all

I come here frequently. Always pleasant and quick service. Their pizza is consistent. They even has the restaurant decorated for Valentines Day! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Picked up a regular cheese slice and a buffalo chicken slice- WOW it is amazing!! The buffalo chicken specifically had the perfect ratio of chicken to cheese to spice. The price for both was under $10- definitely a steal!!! read more

Placed a to go order. Was introduced to Gabby's by family that lived a few blocks from there in 1994. Every trip back to NY, this local joint is a must stop for the nostalgia. Nothing like a pizza from CA. Simple and delicious, a definite staple in queens. read more

This weekend I had a chance to hang out with lifelong friends and we all agreed to hit up Gaby's. I've been going here since elementary school and the pizza has remained the same for decades. Gaby's is one of the best (if not the best) pizza in NYC. the pasta or salads recently but they are great also. Nothing fancy just really good food. read more

A Queens staple! Been going here for over 30 years. The pizza and the service is always great . My youngest kid was in love from the first slice .... Calls it the "Sweet Pizza " top 10 in the 5 Boros. Always clean inside with historical pictures of local stars on the wall . read more

Been coming here since I was a kid and it's still top 3 in NYC. Sauce is just right and more important- the crust, doughy and just the right amount of sauce. Fast service. Ambiance is average, but love the old school pictures. read more

This place has been a staple in the community for years. I think I had tried it years ago, the pizza was always delicious and tasty. I tried it last week and the pizza was dry, needed seasoning and tasted like it was there from the night before. I don't see the hype about this place, the pizza was not as great as it used to be. Service and ambiance was good. read more

See all

What's not to love about this place. I make it my priority to stop here every time I come to Long Island and pass queens. 25 for a large cheese pizza but worth every bite of it. Will be a fan for life. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Huge cheese pizza, cooked to perfection. - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

I just don't get the hype and I've tried so many times with so many combinations but at best their pizza is mediocre. The crust has no taste to me, no salt, no butter, just flour. The sauce tastes like it came out of a can. The toppings are the only way to somewhat enjoy it. The only reason I've returned the few times that I have is because there's parking versus Margherita's on Jamaica and Guy Brewer that has no parking but better pizza. I tried the funnel cake fries which are nice but I found a random feather on a fry. It obviously must be me because their entire decor is a collection of awards and accolades and famous people that love their pizza and I cannot imagine why. Is it really good marketing or are my tastebuds broken? read more

Gaby's Pizza - Funnel cake fries were better than the pizza, feather and all - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

As a native and life long New Yorker, I've had many pizzas. Gaby's sauce, dough and cheese are on point. Excellent slice of pizza! read more

Gaby's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

The place is clean & always crowded. This has been my 3/4 time here and it's great pizza. Last visit I ordered a buffalo chicken salad. It was good but nothing special. I will continue to visit Gaby's when I crave pizza. The servers are always very nice. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Buffalo chicken salad - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

See all

My husband grew up in queens village and always bragged about how good the pizza is at Gaby's. Today, he realizes that all good things must come to an end. He was so embarrassed by this pizza and swore that's not the pizza he grew up eating. read more

Gaby's Pizza - Well done regular large pie - Pizza Near Me - Hollis, New York

Decent pizza slice, very clean fast service good ambiance and very attentive. A good stop for pizza amor Italian dishes