I heard about this place in a movie called Gibsonburg. It was about their state championship…read morewinning baseball team. And I am a huge sucker for going to places that I see in movies so I just had to come and try this place out. I just had the best strawberry danish I've ever had in my life and I can't wait to try this blueberry muffin next.

Visited in September. Childhood memories as I visited our grandparents when I was little. I placed…read morean order ahead & they were so accommodating. I ordered Co-can cookies( think shortbread flavor with mace) & their fruit bars. The smell of the bakery took me back to decades ago! My order was ready & I ordered a few other goodies to take to local friends. They even have OSU cookies...I even bought these even though i was raised a UM fan. Thanks Ideal for making my trip back to Ohio special.

love this place staff is always amazing and the food is the best breakfast in Sandusky. try to go…read morethere when ever we are in town for cedar point!! be prepared it could be busy but worth it!! interior and atmosphere is pleasant upbeat old school diner car when you get in said. it's a must go on places to try!!

I miss the old jolly donut, the donuts that I used to get have now doubled in price and the old…read morestaff of waitresses that were there are no longer. It doesn't have the same feel anymore which is disappointing since we came for charm of the old diner car feel. If you're changing the prices, update the website, and please make sure you get requests correct when people come from a long distance and preorder donuts. These now feel more in line with Dunkin. So disappointed in the new changes.

I showed up to order some donuts and the person behind the counter was a bit grumpy that I was…read morethere and ordering more than just a couple donuts. When she started to ring me up, I tried to hand her my card for payment, and I was told they only accept cash. I wish I had known, the only sign saying so is on a 3x5 card hidden near the cash register. No other place, not on the front door or here on Yelp. Would've been nice to know, especially since this seemed to make her more grumpy. So I had to run to the bank and get money. Came back, paid and off we went. The donuts, super fresh and tasty. Great selection, lots of cake donut options too. Just wish the person was friendlier and they'd put a note on the outside of the building or something so a person doesn't look like an arse and make people more grumpy.

Well - I found out that they only take cash after I had made my order and they had packed it up and…read moreprovided me with two cups of coffee. Potentially embarrassing but luckily I had some paper money on me. The coffee was okay. The donuts were fair to middling. Nothing to write home about. It's a shame because its got the location and the look but underneath, though it looks like a typical donut shop there was something lacking there.

Buckeye Bakery - The Sweetest Shark Attack in Mansfield…read more Wandered into Buckeye Bakery on a mission for donuts... and walked out like a sugary Santa Claus. I picked up a dozen-mix of joy: Long Johns, glazed classics, cinnamon rolls (the kind that whisper "just like Mom used to make"), and pecan rolls that should come with a warning label: "May cause spontaneous joy." Dropped them off with friends and boom--gone in two days, like a Netflix binge with frosting. High praise was given. Teeth were thanked. Waistbands were stretched. But I didn't stop there. Oh no. I went full dessert diplomat and made a fast-follow with peanut butter cookies and some shark cookies, because hey--it's Shark Week, and nothing says "celebrating apex predators" like chomping into one made of sugar and love. Verdict: Donuts: Fluffy, fresh, and clearly baked by folks who take their carbs seriously. Cookies: Delicious and festive--like eating a holiday. Vibe: Old-school bakery charm with new-school treat game. Next time I'm in Mansfield, I'm diving back in. Sharks beware. I bite back.

My. Lord. First off, I'm not from here and took the Yelp…read morereviews to mean good breakfast and man, were they correct. I showed up, told the wonderful women behind the counter that I'm not from here (TX here on a 6 month job), that I have zero idea what anything is in their display case because nothing in Dallas looks this good and just pick me 6 of the best things they have. 3 of the 6 never made it back to my jobsite that's 10 minutes away. The raspberry Danish, the deep fried glazed ball of heaven and the chop suey never stood a chance in the truck with me. When I did make it back, my local subcontractor looked at the box, KNEW I went to Buckeye Bakery and said "You did good". Overall, they're about to make me gain 20 pounds and lose all my money. Thanks, I guess.

As a kid it was always a big deal for me and dad to sneak away on a Saturday morning to get a fresh…read moredonut and a carton of milk. Half the fun was leaving mom and little brother at home and getting an hour with dad by ourselves. We made it a point to go to a special spot across town driving by others to get the best plain glazed donut or jelly filled still warm from the oven. Imagine my surprise when I stopped into Cafe Donuts and was immediately transported back to my youth and breathed in that smell from 40+ years ago! Looking at all those different donuts had me feeling like a boy again. The wife and I got a dozen. Cream filled, raspberry filled, chocolate, and of course, a few plain glazed just for me! The young lady behind the counter was patient as we kept asking what was that one and that one and... I'm not going to lie, it was torture to smell those donuts in the car on the drive home! I've been back again and again for of a few reasons. First of all, the donuts were delicious. Moist and chewy, with a good recipe. You can tell when places cut corners or use cheap ingredients. The icing is perfect and the fillings are good. I think they have the best cream filling I've ever had. The staff have always been good to us, too. I appreciate the half off dozens but frankly don't mind paying full price for anything as long as the quality is there. All those pretty little donuts on display in the shop takes me back and I can't wait to sneak away on a Saturday morning with my newest granddaughter for a couple of glazed and some milk and to spend an hour or so enjoying the simple things.

Café Donuts was a great little find on our road trip! The donuts were fresh, flavorful, and not…read moreoverly sweet. If you're vegan, they also offer some great vegan options on weekends, which was a nice surprise. Cronut fans, don't miss it, it's definitely worth trying. Was my fav of the dozen. The only donut I wouldn't order again was the lemon-filled, but everything else we had was delicious. I'd happily make this a stop again on a future road trip.

Service was decent. I order via the app 2 days in a row. The 1st day the breakfast sandwich was…read moredecent but I was not a huge fan of the 2 donuts (honey dip & old fashion) that I ordered the 2nd day. The Lattes I ordered were good though and that's what's important.

Hair in the donuts the workers need to listen to orders better thought that I asked for a burrito…read morewith no tomatos and lettuce. They filled the coffee a little over halfway instead of all the way. Other than that they had a nice clean ambiance and we got a free drink. But not coming back unless to get my free drink.

Donuts are excellent. This is my go to place if I am feeling like a donut!…read more The chocolate glazed peanut butter filled are my favorite! They have a wide assortment. They are creative in their creations and they all look so good you want to try every one!

After visiting a couple other donut shops, we wanted to try this place. The donuts were okay…read more Pricey. The staff was friendly.

Sugar, Sugar! If you…read moreor your day isn't sweet enough, this is a must stop. Every time I have stopped here for sweet treats my family or co-workers rave about the quality of the doughnuts. I can't disagree. They always have a very nice selection of fresh baked goods and you will not be disappointed. Additionally, they also have the morning staples of coffee, tea, and fresh milk available. Add this one to your favorites!

First off the staff are awesome. Donuts not so much. I only tried two and threw them both away. The…read morefried cinnamon roll tasted so salty I had to spit it out. The cake donut (Dunkin) was edible but extremely dry. I didn't finish it either. Assuming other donuts there might be better based on others reviews but that fried cinnamon roll was absolutely not good so I probably wouldn't go out of my way to go back and see.