Buckeye Bakery - The Sweetest Shark Attack in Mansfield Wandered into Buckeye Bakery on a mission for donuts... and walked out like a sugary Santa Claus. I picked up a dozen-mix of joy: Long Johns, glazed classics, cinnamon rolls (the kind that whisper "just like Mom used to make"), and pecan rolls that should come with a warning label: "May cause spontaneous joy." Dropped them off with friends and boom--gone in two days, like a Netflix binge with frosting. High praise was given. Teeth were thanked. Waistbands were stretched. But I didn't stop there. Oh no. I went full dessert diplomat and made a fast-follow with peanut butter cookies and some shark cookies, because hey--it's Shark Week, and nothing says "celebrating apex predators" like chomping into one made of sugar and love. Verdict: Donuts: Fluffy, fresh, and clearly baked by folks who take their carbs seriously. Cookies: Delicious and festive--like eating a holiday. Vibe: Old-school bakery charm with new-school treat game. Next time I'm in Mansfield, I'm diving back in. Sharks beware. I bite back. read more

Buckeye Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

My. Lord. First off, I'm not from here and took the Yelp reviews to mean good breakfast and man, were they correct. I showed up, told the wonderful women behind the counter that I'm not from here (TX here on a 6 month job), that I have zero idea what anything is in their display case because nothing in Dallas looks this good and just pick me 6 of the best things they have. 3 of the 6 never made it back to my jobsite that's 10 minutes away. The raspberry Danish, the deep fried glazed ball of heaven and the chop suey never stood a chance in the truck with me. When I did make it back, my local subcontractor looked at the box, KNEW I went to Buckeye Bakery and said "You did good". Overall, they're about to make me gain 20 pounds and lose all my money. Thanks, I guess. read more

Buckeye Bakery - It should be illegal to make food this good, and here they are walking free among us - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Great donuts and bakery items. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Would highly recommend!

Been here a long time. Bread sells out fast. They have a lot of old world cookies. Cream sticks are wonderful. Bring back lots of memories of how Mansfield use to be! read more

Still the best. One of my first favorite places to stop while in town. I usually call to have my goodies ready.

Usually when we make trips North this bakery is closed by the time we arrive. Recently however, our timing was perfect. We love their cookies and were pleased to discover that they can be shipped to us in Tennessee. Had we known sooner, we definitely would have been having them shipped. Bakery is very clean and staff was friendly. We would definitely return and/or place an order for shipment in the future. read more

See all

We were looking for a small dessert after a visit to the Shawshank Prison. It was the afternoon and they didn't have much left. I ordered a couple of cookies and the last maple nut coffee cake. I'm still not sure what is was. Everything was delicious. I just wish they had more to choose from. Parking was easy in the lot across the street. read more

See all

Love the people that work here always so nice and ask you how you are, baked goods are always amazing no matter what you get. Love the location and look of the store. read more

Great cookies another Christmas and holiday treats. We often try to go here when we're back in town in our family goes here from time to time as a live close by read more

Another trip to Buckeye Bakery. Had no reason to go into Mansfield. We have the gas guzzler and this is 50 mi round trip! We got in around 9:30 on TUESDAY. They had only been open since 7 AM but already they were out of goodies. If you arrived after me, then they were now out of all danish, cinnamon rolls, and low on cream filled donuts. I bought 2 dozen of these goodies for $23. They are large enough to split with hubby so I can enjoy my purchase without too much guilt. This bakery reminds me of the ones around during my childhood. Nope, it isn't upscale like my favorite places in San Francisco. But Buckeye charges $11.50 a dozen, not the unaffordable $70-72 that those fabulous San Francisco places charge for their incredible treats. So I am happy. I close my eyes and I am a kid again. Friendly efficient service. The only downside, no poppy seed breakfast rolls. I guess the supply chain is weird on poppy seed. read more

Buckeye Bakery - This is mine, this is why they were out if you came after 9:30! - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Oh my what can I say! Best of the best. Staff, Service. They totally is one of the best Bakery in the area. Hidden Gem!

Y'all Sugar cookies never let me down I love them there n other bakery that bakerying like Ohio bakery

Delicious bakery with adorable staff. Found this gem right across from the Carousel In Mansfield. It's worth a special trip from Columbus. read more

See all

The donuts here are good. Not too sweet or doughy. You've got your perfect amount of soft and sweet. I grabbed these for my clients and everyone else thought they were good. It would be killer if they had a ham and cheese croissant or something like that for breakfast. Donuts and pastries can only go so far. I'd be back. read more

A down to earth old fashioned home style bakery located within a 5 minute walk from the downtown carousel . Large Glass display cases boast of the days bounty As strudels , cakes , pies , cookies , cream sticks bear claws , poppy seed and nut rolls , and a variety of other freshly baked morsels temp both the eye and the palate . Specialty cakes for birthdays and anniversaries may be ordered in advance as should your holiday requirements of the popular poppy seed and nut rolls . Service is friendly and prompt and I can almost guarantee that ANY product that you purchase can Quickly become an all time favorite . read more

Grew up with this bakery. Live in Cleveland now, but will drive down any chance I get to grab some donuts, bread and some fresh cookies! Great cakes too! Family run business who actually care about the product and the customer. read more

Just wonderful! Everything is always so tasty. The donuts are incredible and addicting, and so are the poppy seed and nut rolls. This is our go to for celebration cakes, too. I grew up with Buckeye Bakery and still love it....Highly recommend! read more

Buckeye Bakery - Daughter's birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Great donuts, cookies and other sweet treats. Always fresh & delicious. You've got to try their chocolate or maple long John's.

My favorite is the maple coffee cake! Been having this all my life. Been eating this for 43 years. Was my dads favorite and he would surprise us with donuts from here on Saturday mornings. Memories I will always cherish. read more

Delicious donuts only downside is if you get there after all the baked goods have already been snatched up by baked goods lovers faster than you read more

These are by far The BEST Long Johns (Cream Sticks) EVER!!!! If you don't order ahead then Good Luck getting any, they sell out so fast! They also will make you any flavor of cupcake with any flavor filling that you want. Their cake is so moist and full of flavor; chocolate cake with ho ho filling- YUM!!! Vanilla cake with any Berry filling- to die for!!!! You Gotta try Buckeye Bakery! But Order Ahead! read more

A must visit by the carousel in downtown Mansfield! From delicious cream filled donuts to glazed. Coffee cakes special occasion. I've been going to buckeye since I was little (1970s) and will continue to crave such masterpieces. Never had a complaint (that's because of the aroma when I walk in the door, it brightens up my day). Highly recommended read more

Last year in October I picked up two dozen of their large cut out cookies which were $1a piece if I bought a dozen. They only had bats available and she told me if I ordered ahead next time I could get a variety of shapes. So I called in September and asked them if they still had the large cut outs and if they were still $12 a dozen and she said they were and to give them a days noticed so that they would have them ready for me. So I did this picked up the cookies and they are small cookies. I called and they claim they never make the large ones unless special order and they are $3 a piece. I don't appreciate being basically called a liar. They charged me $10.50 a dozen for the little ones. Nothing special about these little ones as they use the same size cookie cutter I have at home. I remember how my kids eyes lit up when they saw the size of the cookies Buckeye use to make. I also got four cream sticks while I was there and they were not as good as Cornell's IGA. Disappointing!! read more

This is my favorite bakery in not only Ohio, but across the United States. I have lived in Texas, Washington, Louisiana, and Virginia and nothing holds a candle to their maple cream sticks. I have been eating donuts from here since the 80's and the quality and customer service has not dwindled. The last time I visited they were completely out of maple cream sticks and they got some plain ones and iced them for me on the spot! Thank you for being a part of my childhood that makes it feel like home every time I come back to Mansfield! read more

Best donuts ever! We are in town visiting from Florida and made sure to try these because they are a relative's favorite. Worth it! Don't pass this place up! read more

Buckeye Bakery - Great selection and sooo soooo soooooo very delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

A nice family bakery with friendly people behind the counter. I wouldn't recommend their coffee unless you were in dire need. Pricing in fair but get their early for best selection. read more

I decided to hold my daughters birthday at the Richlawn Carrousel Park and wanted a carousel themed cake. I live in Cleveland, so I needed to find a bakery in mansfield that would meet this need. Not only did they make an adorable cake, but I swear it was the best tasting chocolate and strawberry cake that I've ever had. I also grabbed a donut while I was picking up the cake and it was delicious too! If we lived closer, I think we'd become regulars at the Buckeye Bakery. read more

Buckeye Bakery - Carousel cake for a party at the Carrousel Park! - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Eat a cut out cookie and you'll know what heaven tastes like! Get there early as the good stuff goes quickly and you want it fresh any way right? If I left Mansfield tomorrow someone would have to routinely send me these cookies. They are that good! read more

As a native of the area, their coffee cake brings back many good memories... Additionally when we travel to the area, our adult children ask us to make extra purchases so that they might share this slice of buckeye heaven with their friends in New England or Chicago. read more

We ordered a full sheet cake for a party pretty much at the last minute. The lady we spoke with was very accommodating. The cake was ready when needed and tasted wonderfull. The frosting was tasty and not overly sweet, but I would suggest that if you're not a big frosting lover to ask to go light on the frosting as there was a lot of it. read more

Yummy childhood good. Have to get their cut outs when I come home. The best. Go during business hours or you might have a little begging to do. Thank you so much for letting me in. Smile! read more

I grew up in Mansfield and love the cookies. I moved to Florida and i have people sent them to me. I sure miss that getting them when i want. read more

Unbelievable ! The service was absolutely pathetic. Went on Friday 2/12/16 about 830 am. First time in this bakery. I asked about a certain item because i didn't know what it was. The middle aged woman behind the counter was put out by my asking her to do anything. I asked if she could tell me what that item was , she repleid "its somethin'" . Really?? Its somethin? I have lived here two years and i finally go into this location and this is the service I received. What a joke, in a town where the population is leaving in droves, where industry has long since left, you are left with junk trash businesses like this. Great Job Buckhole Bakery, I will NEVER return and will tell EVERYONE I come in contact with to Avoid your business like the plague! read more