No frills, diner atmosphere. If you are just looking for a quick burger that's cheap, this is your place. I got the Swiss and mushroom and the Swiss cheese was exceptionally good. Served in like a paper small bowl. I also got a side order of the potato salad. I really didn't care for it. Not very creamy and had a vinegar taste to it. Hubby got a bacon double cheeseburger. He loved it. Not the friendliest service but it is an in and out kinda place. The price and burger is the main selling point here in my opinion. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

This place is interesting. They serve decent burgers to decent people. Just remember to bring cash.

First time for me and have lived here 12 years! Great burgers with many choices. BUT this is a no frills AMI place. Flip flops and beach covers up welcome! read more

Cheap beer and good burgers! The inside was small but super cute. You order at the bar which was nice because you don't feel rushed. Burger itself was super juicy but a little pricey. As a whole it was very good and will be back! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Great no nonsense burger place. When you're tired of fish and seafood and want a good burger, they have several to choose from. No fries sadly to go with burgers, but chips and slaw or potato salad. read more

Road Trip 8/17 Took Fritz for a drive to AMI (Anna Maria Island) just to have a burger at Duffy's. I had arrived on the island sort of early so stop at a local dive bar was in order...Bortell's Lounge, my idea of a dive, but nice. Just stopped in for one and headed on my way to Duffy's. Got to Duffy's around 12:30 and plenty of parking to choose from. Walked inside and found a spot at the bar, yes. After all, all orders are taken at the bar, no table service here which is fine with me. I was immediately ask what Id have as soon as I sat...I ordered the cheeseburger with LTO...however, I was never asked how I would like it cooked. I believe they cook them all the same way, medium with just the bit of pink. I would of liked it cooked just a bit longer but a really good burger and juicy. So juicy that it filled the bottom of what they served it in, something fries would come in, so I needed to hold it the whole time. No fries here, just chips, potato salad and coleslaw. Just the fact that they have plenty of parking, when visiting the island and need a burger and don't care about fries, this is the place go. A true burger joint. Peace read more

See all

Took the trolley up from Bradenton Beach for some birthday fun, only to find out they are closed for Sept. no mention of this on the website or on the answering service when you call them. Would be a simple fix to keep customers most happy! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Excellent burger! Nothing is fried so no option for fries. They are a cash only restaurant with a ATM machine inside. read more

See all

Fabulous burgers! Great Cole slaw and potato salad. Great selection of chips. Coke in bottles. Old style local kind of place. Cash only so plan for that or use the ATM inside. read more

This is my favorite place on the island nothing fancy great burgers ice cold beer in a mug that is very reasonable price friendly staff very laid back ! Great place to toss a few beers back! It's a local favorite read more

Good Burgers at a place renowned for being a great burger spot on AMI. A very busy place full of local charm this Friday at lunch time..seems like a lot a locals pick this place so ya know it's gonna be good. We got the Cheeseburgers "loaded" with lettuce, tomatoe, onion, and mayo.....Good Burgers is what you expect and that's what you get! read more

See all

Part of what makes our vacation wonderful year after year, we like to call Duffy's our place:) the ladies work their butts off to provide great service, and an excellent burger! Walking in it always feels like home, love the laid back atmosphere! Thank you guys for creating a space we crave all year long! read more

CASH ONLY. A nice local dive bar. No liquor, which is strange for a bar, decent food and cold beer. CASH ONLY. Good location. Fair prices. Decent burgers. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Double cheeseburger with everything. $11 - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Great burger, fresh brewed tea. Nothing fancy but great food. Kind of a hole in the wall place but we got in about quick....just in time to watch the sunset. Would definitely go back read more

La comida fatal , estábamos un grupo y de los platos que pedimos de carne tres estaban quemados.

My fiancée grew up in Bradenton and has hyped this place up over the years. She doesn't even eat meat, so I've always been skeptical of how good this dive bar burger could be. Apparently, USA Today gave it high praise years back, too. Well, I'll be damned. This is a 5-star burger if there ever was one. The quintessential flat-top burger that's been making a massive comeback over the last few years. Except Duffy's has been doing it for over 50 years. Pro tip* add bacon and add a second patty. Queue the saliva-inducing food porn. It's juicy, it's meaty, dare I say unctuous? I said it. This burger rocks! As far as the bar is concerned, it's a beach dive. To my surprise and astonishment, they actually close at 8pm. Which I still can't wrap my head around. Locals say it's more of a post-beach spot. By the look of it, you'd never know. Not that need to change anything. Clearly they've won the hearts and minds of locals for over half a century, who cares what I think? I STILL FIND IT CRAZY THEY DON'T SERVE FRIES. I MUST BE MISSING SOMETHING. WHATEVER, WHO CARES WHAT I HAVE TO SAY? Go here. Drink a cold one, maybe two, maybe six. And indulge in this phenomenal burger. You won't regret it. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Double Bacon Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

WORST FOOD EVER, super rude ass bartenders. They don't take credit cards and direct you to their ATM where they charge an obnoxious fee to get money to pay your tab. DONT WASTE your time with this shithole. read more

This place is a hidden gem IF you like a decent hamburger. Cash only also. It feels like more of a local joint with us being greeted by the patrons. I had a lemonade and a cheeseburger. Both were very very good. The cheeseburger cost all of $8.80 with all the fixings. My bud got a bacon cheeseburger for $11.80. He thoroughly enjoyed his as well. Great little place. I will be back. read more

I recently visited Duffy's for a quick bite while I was on the island. Having grown up in the area, I remembered them having a great burger, so I had to revisit to see of it was still as good as I remembered. It was actually better. This spot is a local island dive bar. The people are friendly and the service is as well. The bartenders were great throughout my visit. I decided I needed a burger and a beer. I went with a double cheeseburger with bacon, onion, and pickles. The burger came out and it looked exceptional. It was the ideal flat top style burger with crispy edges and oozing melted cheese. I dove in and was very happy with my selection. The burger was seasoned and cooked perfectly. This is a classic burger made perfectly. It really hit the spot and the price point was very reasonable. Overall, I loved my quick visit. The food was exceptional, service was friendly and fast, and the location was welcoming. I look forward to returning soon. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Double cheeseburger with bacon, onion, & pickles. Perfection. - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Who knew that a "hole in the wall" dive bar would have such good bar food? hee hee Hubby and I stopped by Duffy's for late lunch while on a recent trip to AMI. As soon as we walked in, you can tell it's a "locals hang out". Not a bad thing. :) I had a chili dog and a side of potato salad. He had a burger with the potato salad also. The food was surprisingly delicious.... so good that I had to order a 2nd potato salad. It's one of my favorite comfort foods! Know before you go - They only accept cash. read more

First off, the majority of the less than good reviews are about having to order at the bar, no fries and locals getting better service , oh and they only accept cash. Please, if you judge a place by these issues then Duffys may not be your spot. Personally we had great burgers, chili and a pitcher of ice cold beer. We were also happy to chat with one of the owners about the history of this perfect little dive whos' founder grew up in our hometown. We will return and recommend. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Brie/caramelized onion burger and bacon cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Went to see how they faired after the hurricanes. Looked like the Duffy's they we knew. There were some miss license plates on the bar. We love the place, we are snowbirds and we enjoy watching people. Please don't come, if you're not ready to do a little fending for yourself. You have to order from the bar, when your food is ready they will bring to you. That is the way it works, if you want another beverage, you will have to get up and get. They are cash only and who blames them, fees on credit cards are getting ridiculous and you are now see establishments charging an up charge. We had a cheese burger, bacon cheese burger both all the way. A bowl of bean soup, chili with onion and cheese and the collard greens and a tasty picture of Pacifico beer for $ 54.00 before tip. read more

This is a great place for a great burger. No fries just chips. The burgers are delicious and have been for many years . Staff is friendly. Beer is cold . The bean soup is good. They even have homemade bbq made out back. They close early so get some soon. This is a local place. read more

See all

Nice little place to get inside and beat the heat. Had the cheeseburger & hot dog. Both were really good. Cold draft beers. Stopped in there 3 of the 6 days I was on the island! read more

Typical local bar known for their burgers. We placed a large takeout order with 7 burgers and different sides. We tried to order potato salad but they said it wouldn't be ready. They offered collard greens instead, which was weird considering that isn't even on their menu. Two of the burgers were ordered to have bacon added but they forgot to add it on both. The burgers were tasty and were definitely better than fast food options and most bars but I wouldn't say it's the best on the island. The coleslaw and collard greens were both enjoyed by everyone. The staff was very friendly and our large order was ready within 15 minutes of calling, just like they said. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Double Mushroom/Swiss all the way with coleslaw - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

We've been coming to AMI for 10 years and usually pack something to eat on the beach. Today we felt like trying out a local place. Based on yelp reviews we choose Duffy's over skinny's. As soon as we pulled in and the lot was pretty empty I knew we were making a bad choice. You order at the bar & seat yourself. It was okay. Small. No frill burger. 3 of them, 2 cokes and a beer and it was over $40. For sure not worth the trip north on the island in gas. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burger - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

This is the OG burger spot on AMI. Simple and just good. Service is always friendly, if you sit at a table you have to order at the bar.

Love a good Duffy's cheeseburger!!!!! Greasy, messy & cheap. Tiny little spot on AMI but it's a must try. In my opinion Skinny's and Duffy's burgers are very comparable in taste & flavor but Duffy's seems to have a bigger & juicer patty. 4/5 stars because we never got our potato salad & would've slugged down another drink if the bartender checked in. Tips for visitors: Authentic burger joint on the island...perfect to cool off after the beach or on a rainy day Cash only - ATM available inside No French fries (potato salad, coleslaw & chips available) Order at bar...super casual vibe read more

Awesome world famous hamburgers and a rustic bar like atmosphere. Service was good, order food at the bar. Food is served and then pay at the bar on the way out. Cash only but there is a ATM inside. read more

We visit Duffy's several times during our month on AMI. Good burgers in an unpretentious place for a reasonable price. What's not to like?

Passed it on our bikes a number of times before stopping in. This place is probably a locals popular stop. They have outdoor seating that is private from the road and indoor seating. Children are welcome and we noticed a number of families coming and going, eating hotdogs and hamburgers with their kids, and people running in for a beer while waiting on a Togo order. Incredibly inexpensive compared to other area options. A true tavern check out part of menu and prices pictured here. $3.00 bottle beer compared to a $7.00 draft nextdoor. Hamburger choices looked great too. Closed on Tuesday's hours weekdays and Saturdays 11-8 Sundays noon-8. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Part of the menu notice the PB&J! - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

We ordered two burgers to go. The prices are three dollars higher than their website says. When we got the butrgers nome, we could only eat half of each of them as they were extremely red in the middle and well undercooked. Unfortunately they are closing so I don't have time to take them back. Very disappointing! The cold beer while I waited for my order was the best part! read more

First and foremost, this place has AMAZING burgers! Definitely stop here if you want a juicy, basic burger. I had the cheeseburger "all the way"and others had the hamburger or the caramelized onion and Brie burger. I got the Cole slaw, which was not very flavorful. I would skip it next time. We all really enjoyed our food overall! The service here is not great. You must order at the bar, which is fine, but our drinks didn't come up until after we went up and asked 10 minutes into waiting. But the food came out promptly. The atmosphere here is pretty typical for a bar with basic food and had a nice casual quality. However, I found it very unpleasant to see a confederate flag "license plate" posted on the bar wall next to other license plates as decor. I don't think that posting a confederate flag as part of a restaurants decor provides a welcoming environment for all customers. Furthermore, upon inspection it wasn't even a real license plate (see no letters or numbers or state insignias), which indicates to me that the plate was bought for the sole purpose of display. I understand that it's Florida, but I think that using this item as decor sends a message that not all people are welcome. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Overview: 5/5  This is the best burger I have ever had. We visit this place every time we come to AMI. It has a rich history and a family owned business. Ambiance : 5/5 It's a "Tavern" so manage the expectations on decor. Lots of bar seating ( no social distancing in the year of Covid) and masks are "optional". Several tables for medium size parties. Food/Drink  5/5 Best juicy burger and cold, cold beer in a mug. FYI they DO NOT have fries. Period deal with it and try another side. Service : 5/5 Self service ordering and cleanup. Conclusion : Always the best from this Yelper. read more

See all

This is must stop for your beach days if you want to not only have amazing food and the coldest beer but to truly feel like you've walked into a place all the locals go. You have to try it! read more

The burgers are always delicious but if you add their potato salad it gets even better. My favorite local restaurant.

Duffy's is the best. My favorite burger place on the island. Burgers are fresh, juicy and cooked just right. Need plenty of paper towels. Beer is ice cold! Don't need anything else but a good burger and beer! Peggy and Patty are the best! They sure know how to run a great establishment! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Bacon Cheeseburger "All The Way" - Burgers Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Right up front: cash only, no fries. Great burgers, cold beer, dive bar sort of feel, good tater salad. Come on in with your swimming duds on and grab some cash from the ATM. Fine for families although not as roomy in dining room area. A few places to get burgers on the island but this one should not be missed, at least once. I always leave Duffy stuffed. read more

Great service, everyone is friendly, and neighborhood bar feel! Just off the free shuttle service!

Definitely a neighborhood place to gather. Hamburger tasted like a real juicy hamburger and the price was very reasonable. Definitely, a place to enjoy your friends and parking or walking was easy. read more