Had a chance to try Feast while in the Island. It's located in an unassuming strip mall, so was a little apprehensive. Entered the lobby to a small area of 4 booths, then enter a larger room with multiple tables and a small bar at the end. We did not have reservations so offered the only option of the four tables up front, which was fine. Service from Ricardo was on point, prices average $36 for entrees. Each includes choice of starch, and was a great loaded baked potato, but not informed each item on the potato was a $1uo charge.. Salad substitution was available at $6.95 up charge, which I don't understand, so a few points off. Happy Hour ends at 530, which seems a bit early (and we were greeted at 533p, even 6 would be better, again minus points, but the drinks were ok at $8. Menu is heavy on Grouoer choices (and good Grouoer it was), with good sized portions. We both enjoyed our meals and the restaurant is located between an ice cream shop and a bar, if you want to continue the evening. We skipped dessert but they average $12 and sounded great. Food and service were both very good, just find all the up charges on a $36 meal annoying. Will be back and next time make reservations to be in the main room with the Adults! read more

See all

I do not recommend getting any risotto dishes here. The risotto is horrible and is more like mush or mashed potatoes. Actually, it looked like mashed potatoes. And the Braised short rib on the risotto looked more like deli roast beef sliced up super thin. I ate the meat off the top and left the risotto after one bite. My friends ribeye was paper thin but it was cooked medium rare It was expensive and the food was disappointing. read more

This restaurant is in a strip shopping mall at a busy intersection on Holmes beach. We went here on Valentines Day for dinner and were seated immediately (we had a reservation). Alexander, our server, was great. The Ribeye ala Feast was delicious and a beet salad, even though it was the small size was more than we could eat. Food, service and ambiance were all topnotch. I would recommend this place without reservation. The exterior doesn't look like much but the restaurant inside is one of the best on Anna Maria Island, IMO. Free parking in the shopping center lot where this restaurant is located. This would easily be one of my favorite places on the island. read more

See all

We loved it! The reviews almost kept us away but we tried it and loved it! We had the super flavorful and flaky black grouper risotto and the chicken carbonara. Benjamin our bartender was friendly and made the meal that much better! read more

We always have good food here. Service is excellent. Our drinks are good. I ordered the red grouper with shrimp and crab. It also came with a loaded potato. My smoked old fashioned was good.,my wife got the short ribs over risotto. Our experience was very good and food was excellent. Nice clean place that is decorated nicely inside. read more

See all

Great restaurant on the island! Our server was the sweetest and was super helpful. Forgot to take pics of the food was great! I recommend the pot stickers and the snow crab! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Been coming here for years and usually the food is good but on Thursday Feb 12 2026 we had a 8:15 reservation. A party of 5 we had mojitos which were excellent and ordered Grouper Captiva, Surf and turf and pecan crusted grouper. All the fish was way overcooked not flakey but rubbery The sauce was skimpy and looked like they used a ketchup bottle to apply it . The surf and turf meat portion was ok but the lobster was so overcooked and tough it wasn't worth eating. It seemed they were more concerned with closing the kitchen the chef forgot our food. Over all a horrible experience at the cost of almost $300. Everyone was so disappointed they don't want to go back. Its sad because this used to be our go to restaurant on the island eating here at least 6 times while we stay on the island. read more

Food was good. Ribs were meaty flavorful and very tender. Service was excellent. Ambiance was lacking. We sat in a booth across a narrow aisle from other booths. Gave us a good chance to observe others dinners and ask about them. Prices were reasonable too. read more

The service was amazing, our waiter remained attentive and was very polite. On the other side the food was... meh. No doubt it's tourist food, but it is higher quality than most other restaurants on this island. If you're used to flavor and taste I would avoid it, however it was perfect for just what it is. read more

The Feast is THE BEST Restaurant on Anna Maria! Food is superb, drinks are creative and fantastic and the Waitstaff is spot on, specifically Rodrigo was the absolute best server we have ever had! He was attentive, knowledgeable, simply exceptional! read more

Delicious food and drinks. Husband and I both got a risotto dish - his was the grouper special and mine was the lobster and shrimp. Both were incredible! Really kind and helpful staff. It's a nice place but we didn't feel uncomfortable bringing our 9 month old. Our server even brought her out these little silicone hands to play with when she got fussy. read more

So happy the Feast is back open! A delicious meal with family. I had the fisherman's platter with the baked potato! We shared the key lime cake for dessert. Everything was great! The Feast also takes reservations which we appreciate. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

3 hairs in food..... got food two hours later from sitting down..... will not return We did like our waitress tho but manager was unprofessional read more

Went for crab legs because we were by the beach we got the all you can eat crab legs and a surf and turf the food was good but not good enough to put up with the treatment of the staff our waitress was a doll but that's about it they had a creepy man at the door that stared at us the entireeee time we were eating on the patio I was so uncomfortable I asked my waitress to pls ask him to stop and she offered to sit us further so he couldn't but I didn't want to be a bother so I just asked her to say something to him and he kept going and the manager joined him staring us down with the most uncanny valley stare as we ate once we finished our meal we asked for the check and my boyfriend realized they added on a 35$ LARGE PARTY FEE........there was TWO of us so I went up to the counter to ask what this was about and the manager proceeded to tell me it is a fee with the all you can eat crabs that is listed nowhere on the menu I pointed that out and he grabbed the menu looking for it and realized it was not there then proceeded to tell me they needed to add it to the menu I lost my cool and told him absolutely not I don't do secret fees remove that or I'm not paying and he got into a whole fight with me saying he saw me feed my bf a piece of crab and that's not allowed with the all you can eat crab so that's why I got charged and I went off needless to say I did not pay that extra 35 and that restaurant direly needs a new manager and host the current one is a piece of shit and the host is creepyyyyyyy would NEVER return read more

Have been lots of times and love the food. Grouper bites amazing. Short rib grilled cheese sandwich to die for. The marry me shrimp and lobster pasta yum. The beef stroganoff I licked my plate. We loved there pizza they are soon opening up just a pizza place read more

Very expensive for basic bar food. Fish had fishy taste so not fresh. $30+ dollars for a sandwich? Will not eat there again. I think everyone else knew this as it was very easy to get a seat there while all other places were full. read more

Not only are the drinks beautiful they taste amazing as well. This cocktail was like dessert! Yummy! The bartender was the sweetest young lady. Asked her favorite cocktail to make and she happily listed 3. The short rib risotto was made with a Gruyère cheese and rosemary. It was rich and creamy! Cooked to perfection. Do not miss this spot if you are on Anna Maria Island. Congratulations on re-opening after back to back hurricanes! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Key Lime Martini - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Friends had raved about this quirky named casual beach restaurant so it seemed perfect for Mothers Day. Will, our server was well versed with the menu and steered us straight. We had the grouper bites first which were lightly breaded . My New England clam chowder was thick and loaded with clams. My entree was the crab cakes- very little filler and two large cakes. The house chips and slaw were perfect accompaniments with the crab. The sangria was tasty and perfect. My wife's beef salad was large and loaded with goat cheese as well. We were too stuffed to try desserts but they sounded delicious(next time). Very unpretentious, casual attire in a strip mall, this is a gem. The table next to us got pizzas and raved about them. Plenty of parking as well-4.5 stars. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Wall scene - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Always great food and good service plus they take reservations. And not to forget the bar with a creative bartender.

When you walk in, it's like a week old fish punched you right in the nose. Really gross, they clearly need to change the oil in their fryer because our tempura grouper was a deep, deep brown and tasted like burnt cooking oil. Ended up just eating the fries. read more

The food was great and service was good too. Glad they are still open after the big storm.

Food was fine, the prices were not. Pasta for my kid was $25. And the place smelled like a urinal cake and sewage.

Great food, but they need to upgrade their menu prices on line. Significantly higher than what is currently listed.

Great service. Great waitress. Great food. We were only there for 7 days but I wanted to go back to this place. If I ever get back to Anna Maria, I will definitely eat at The Feast again. read more

Food was delicious. Service was stellar. The staff was very efficient and professional and offered solid recommendations. Shrimp & Shrimp and Lobster Lafayette was perfect. Everything was cooked correctly. The sauce was just the right amount of spicy. There was deliciousness in every forkful. Trey, the server made some great recommendations. Paired this with a Big Storm lager that was quite tasty. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Shrimp & Shrimp and Lobster Lafayette - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Service was quite well our waitress was good and attentive to our needs. The ambiance was peaceful and calm but being on the coast a little light would be alright. And the food was the letdown of this review. I'm not one to say it was bad but for the Alfredo I ate had a bit of a weird texture and the mozzarella wedges (I didn't get a picture of) we're very splendid though. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Shrimp and Crab Alfredo - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

I've eaten here several times and enjoyed it so much that I've returned with guests that come to visit me on Anna Maria. Tonight, I got food to go and have to say that from the moment I called in my order to the time I sat down to eat, I was impressed. The man who took my order over the phone was polite and helpful. The order was cooked to perfection, a nice piece of grouper with a beet salad. So delicious, prepared with care and the price was more reasonable than most places on the island. I've never had a bad experience at this restaurant, but tonight, eating at home alone while going through a stressful time, they were a huge comfort to me. read more

We went here not knowing what to expect. My wife likes seafood and I had heard they had really good pizza. When we sat down my wife quickly found some seafood that looked good. I didn't see pizza on the menu but when I asked the waiter he brought me the pizza menu. We both ordered and the waiter was very nice and personable. My wife's stuffed shrimp came out great and I loved the pizza. It's a small place and I guess it gets pretty busy but we were lucky enough to have not too big a crowd. I would recommend them anytime. It's really good read more

See all

This restaurant survived the two 2024 hurricanes and officially re-opened on February 28, 2025 and they're not closed! Restaurant has an amazing new bar and the cocktails are prepared by Benjamin, who is an amazing bartender and goes over and beyond. read more

See all

Fantastic!!!! They are OPEN!!!! My drinks and meal were amazing!!!!! Benjamin the bar tender and Adrian one of the owners were so great!! You won't be disappointed!!!!!! Lobster risotto gets a big thumbs up as do the specialty drinks!!!! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Lobster risotto - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

This restaurant was surprisingly good for being in a strip mall on a tourist island. The staff was very friendly and the estimated wait was accurate. We waited a little longer for a table outside that's basically on the sidewalk of the strip mall but they made the best of what they had. We started with the Firecracker Shrimp which was very good and carried a kick with it! The size was very favorable and it was more than enough for 4 of us to share. For dinner, our parents shared a large White Pizza and then 2 entrees that my wife and I had were the grouper special and Chicken Carbonara. My wife enjoyed the grouper and my parents loved their pizza. It was large enough to bring some home and enjoy the next day. My chicken carbonara was pretty good but the penne was over cooked and basically falling apart, which was a bummer. I enjoyed the garlic bread as a side and the portion of pasta was perfect. Don't judge this place by the sign and location, stop in and give it a shot! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Large White Pizza - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

First time patron here and you have me sold. We live only an hour away but are down for the week at a timeshare, and discovered this restaurant. You would totally not notice this place since it's buried in a strip mall, but it is so worth the stop. The menu has many appetizers, salads, entrees and pizza. Our server, William, was wonderful. He was attentive when we wanted him and he was behind the scenes when we didn't need him. We ordered a nice bottle of wine and then ordered our food. I ordered the pasta agrigento with chicken. There were so many items that interested me, but I was so happy with my choice. The flavors were so good and I finished my entire dish, which seldom happens. I would absolutely order this entree again. Overall, loved my food and the service. read more

See all

The feast is amazing! Misty took great care of us, excellent service; we are on vacation from Texas and this was the best spot we've eaten! 10/10 recommend. The short rib grilled cheese and lobster risotto was delicious. If we vacation here again, we will definitely be back. read more

Short wait but we got there early, it's a small resturant. Brian our waiter was so nice and attentive. We had they'd homemade chips and Bleu cheese. Then two small salads and split a decedent slice of chocolate cake. All delicious. They also have pizzas. Trying one next time. Buyer beware on the salad protein is extra you could end up paying $25 for a salad that's crazy to me. Overall an excellent dinner read more

Excellent food and service. We eat here a couple Times while in town. They take reservations too! read more

After several visits, which we usually bring friends & family from out of town & make reservations. We specifically made reservations for all you can eat crab legs, we get seated and are told they didn't have enough and we had to pay per pound, we quickly questioned the staff. Quite rude a false advertisement, I suggest going elsewhere, for not just this reason but the audacity and rudeness was unacceptable and then the lies spewed afterwards. read more

So happy to see Feast open again. New look and some new items - the food is amazing. We had Fish, lobster, and pasta dishes - all amazing. Our server, Melissa, was attentive and friendly. Considering this just reopened we expected some missed but there were none. read more

The food was excellent. Service was wonderful server was friendly and attentive. Prices reasonable. Would definitely recommend.

This pizza far exceeded expectations for beach town pizza. Growing up in NY and CT I have high pizza standards and was pleasantly surprised. Would go back! read more

We made a reservation for 11 at 6pm . Arrived on time and the table was ready . We had excellent service and the ambiance was cozy. They have an excellent menu and a ton of choices . I recommend the escargot ! Spot on. We did however find out the pizza is take out only . You can't get a pizza in the restaurant . Will definitely return again . Well worth the money spent. read more