This place has the best crab!! We had the King crab here and is the sweetest king crab I've ever had!! I also had the Virginia and Massachusetts oysters. I liked the Massachusetts oysters better than Virginia. The Virginia were a bit gritty. I've always eaten my crab steamed and when I ordered it here it came cold so I gave it a try and because it was so sweet it didn't need to be warm! Dipping it in the hot butter was perfect. The king crab was huge, I held it up to my finger for scale. The crab was from Dutch Harbor in Alaska so I immediately thought of Deadliest Catch. I've been here twice now and the service has been great! I love sitting outside enjoying the weather, ambiance at night with the lights, watching people walk by, and enjoying the food. If you're looking for a nice evening dinner enjoying some scrumptious crab I highly recommend eating here!! read more

See all

We stopped in without a reservation and were pleasantly surprised by how accommodating the staff was. Chris greeted us as soon as we walked in and immediately found us a table in the bar area. He was not only our server but also tending bar for the restaurant, yet he never seemed rushed and provided attentive, friendly service throughout our meal. The menu is extensive, with plenty of options to suit a variety of tastes. It took me a while to decide, but I ultimately ordered the yellowfin tuna tartare, and it was the right choice. The tuna was exceptionally fresh, beautifully presented, and balanced with flavors that complemented rather than overwhelmed the fish. As we waited for our entrées, Chris brought over warm bread as well as smoked salmon pâté. It was an unexpected touch that made the experience feel even more welcoming and gave us something delicious to enjoy while we waited. Although we were seated in the bar area, the atmosphere was comfortable and conversational. The noise level was just right--not so quiet that you felt like you had to whisper, but not so loud that it distracted from the meal. From the warm welcome to the attentive service and thoughtfully prepared food, this was an excellent dining experience. Chris did a fantastic job juggling both the bar and his tables without missing a beat, and his hospitality left a lasting impression. We'd happily return. read more

See all

Had a horrible experience at Crab N Fin on St Armands Circle in Sarasota last night. Waitress was a bit bothered, my wife ordered a Filet Steak Tartare appetizer but was pulled away, our granddaughter was a bit overtired and was taken home early by my daughter in law. She eventually got back to the table and we all commenced eating. The appetizer (ordered as an entree along with another one) just wasn't liked. We were hoping she might take the appetizer off the bill. Its not an inexpensive place, you know. Her response was, you should have told me earlier. We more or less dropped the subject. I saw her most likely explaining the situation to the manager, showing him the check. Well, he did nothing...the check was presented in full. Manager didn't come over to express regret or ask why we were less than pleased about the meal, or even offer a dessert. Food has been good for a long time here and most of our meals were superlative. They've lost long time customers. We'll never step foot in there again, and business was really scarce that evening. My wife dined there for years and years and loved Robert who was manager/host. He saw her kids grow up, every Friday for dinner. She is done with the Crab N Fin. I am too. We were really looking forward to this dinner, mind you the kitchen is good. This new management is not. read more

We got there 30 minutes before closing and we're still attended with the most respect and patience. The fish was delicious and so was their home made bread. Staff was friendly and we sat with our dog outside. read more

Crab and Fin - Bronzini - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Very nice place. The service was good.friendly and knowledgeable server. We sat outside since I t was a beautiful day out. They offer indoor seating which seem a bit more white table cloth. For lunch I had the snapper and shrimp. It was delicious. Will come back for dinner read more

See all

I haven't been here in a really long time and last time I dined on the patio, but this time inside. We arrived 30 minutes early of our reservation in the hopes of having a drink at the bar, but the bar was filled with diners. This seems to be the new trend everywhere we go. Even more disappointing because we couldn't get happy hour prices for our drink because we were seated at a table. Our server was very friendly and quickly took our drink order. The list of cocktails and wines is extensive. I settled on a hibiscus infused cocktail with guava juice and lemonade. For me it was way too sweet. The menu is varied, but definitely geared toward seafood. There are no daily specials as the menu changes daily. I settled on a Caesar salad and the crab cakes. While waiting for my salad we were served salmon pate with some crackers and also fresh warm bread. Both were very good. My salad looked very nice and was good too. We waited a longer than normal time for our entrees. My crab cakes were just ok. Yes, there was tons of crab and little filler, but they were dry and the sauce on the side only helped a bit. read more

See all

This is an exceptional spot for seafood in the area. We had amazing service and highest quality fish dishes! We enjoyed the oysters, swordfish,sea bass, snapper, and bouillabaisse and finished with the amazing trio of desserts. All of it was so so tasty. Our waitress Kristen was incredible!!! Drink were also so great here. Highly recommend read more

See all

I am surprised the reviews aren't higher! We had a great experience here today with my family. The staff was very accommodating. We had a large party with kids and wanted a table away from the crowds and they let us pick any table and even let us move underneath the heaters. Ambiance inside seemed to be more upscale. We sat outside and felt more relaxed. Great Bloody Mary's, fried calamari and warm fresh bread with butter. Fish (grouper) and chips were outrageous. Highly recommend if you're in the area! read more

See all

Had my birthday dinner here and it was an absolute dream. Our server, Tatiana, was so sweet and accommodating. We started with a bottle of caymus and a half dozen oysters. Our entrees were both delicious. I had halibut and my husband had the branzini. Finished with the key lime pie. We sat outside and had a peaceful, relaxed meal. Would come here again! Thank you read more

See all

This place was so perfect right in the circle, the food was perfect. The waitress introduced us to some amazing dishes we never had. The service was great and the ambience was classy and chic and definitely cool place to hang out. read more

See all

We live on LBK, and all of our visits, the service has always been ridiculously rushed, with the main courses always arriving before the appetizers were finished. The tuna ahi at my most recent visit was noticeably old with a fishy smell. For what you get, the food is absurdly expensive. This place has, "jumped the shark." read more

What an amazing place . We came to Sarasota just go look around and really was pleased to find this wonderful place for lunch'. So elegant and excellent service . Couldn't ask for a better atmosphere and all around excellent experience. read more

See all

Food was outstanding! We had the clams on the 1/2 shell and clam chowder apps. Alaska Giant Red King Crab and Shrimp Risotto and the Low Country Bouillabaisse as our entries . They gave us a smoked salmon pate when we sat down and bread basket with the meal Service was great and we will be back with friends! read more

We've been going here for valentines day for years but Went here for this Valentine's Day and the valentines menu left much to be desired. Everything with truffle and just nothing exciting. The bisque was delicious as usual but the stone crab was frozen and the new "reimagined" crème brûlée was awful. Mind you, it was 300 dollars so I would expect much better quality. Stick to Shore, or any of the other nice restaurants in the area. read more

Crab and Fin - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Food was good Nice service Noise level was acceptable Lighting was good - no glaring lights We were seated promptly read more

Martha's Vineyard salad was excellent. Perfect balance of ingredients. Raspberry vinaigrette was the perfect complement. I had arctic salmon on top and my wife went with chicken which she liked. The salmon was one of the best I have had. Cooked medium ( so many places overcook it) our server explained they get fresh fish every day and know not to overcook it. She was very knowledgeable. Unfortunately no pics. Sat outside and it beautiful out. They had someone playing guitar which was great read more

This place came highly recommended for a lunch in st Armand's. The venue is beautiful. Service was perfect yet I don't think the waiter knows what horseradish is. My husband ordered a Bloody Mary and when asked if it had horseradish, he was told no. Came with a ton of horseradish. We decided to split the tuna with cold vermicelli noodles and the Cobb salad. I loved the tuna, seared perfectly with a ton of flavour. Cobb salad on the other hand was beyond boring. So we ordered chicken to throw on top. The smell of the burnt grilled chicken was so intense my husband thought the chicken was bad. Worse 27.00 Cobb salad I've ever had. I can't believe we spent 27.00 bucks for that. We're not from the area so I can't imagine I would ever go back but I would highly recommend it. Just don't order the Cobb. read more

Crab and Fin - Before lunch drinks - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I have no complaints other than an uninspiring dessert menu. We started with a dozen oysters from Canada and Maine. Fresh and cold and really yummy! Caesar salad was exactly what a Caesar salad should be, light, fresh and dressed appropriately. I had the grilled Grouper and it was amazing! I'm from NY and it's not common on menus in the northeast so this was a treat. My wife had the whole yellowtail snapper . Both extremely fresh and flavorful. The only thing I would say is that the fried snapper could have been seasoned more. But I rather add salt than have it over seasoned. Service was good. A 4-5 star experience with the fresh fish and oysters as the star performers. read more

Crab and Fin - Fried yellowtail snapper. - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Second time coming to this restaurant over the 4th of July holiday. Our server off the bat was attentive and friendly - only comment is that we frequently had to ask for more water. Drinks took a long time to come out, which was AFTER we got our appetizers and ate them all. I ordered the espresso martini, which I unfortunately did not enjoy at all. Too bitter but also too creamy at the same time. What saved this place from getting 3 stars was their food -- their salmon dish was phenomenal. The steak and potatoes with caramelized onions an easy 10/10. Also highly recommend the tuna. Overall, a solid place with a few flaws that could be fixed. Willing to try them again! read more

Crab and Fin - Sashimi tuna - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

This was genuinely the best fish I have ever had in my life. If you come here order the bronzini it is humongous and absolutely incredible. My life is genuinely changed. read more

So glad I tried a new place for me while on vacation, from the host to the bartender everyone was very nice and enjoyed the look of the place Food was excellent had the shrimp cocktail app, then the grouper sandwich for lunch washed them down with the Pineapple Drop and the Delicious Tropicanahattan read more

See all

Fabulous! Of all the places we tried while on vacation in sarasota crab and fin is my favorite. The setting and service is really nice. The food is excellent, all the fish is really fresh and delicious. Worth the visit when in the area. read more

Not even sure what to say. The mussels and wine were good. Nothing else was correct with the dinner. Everything I ordered was out. What I finally landed on was just awful. My sides never came. I left hungry. You should never leave hungry after spending $300 read more

This is the first review I've ever written because I usually don't complain. I ordered the halibut, which cost $64. Unfortunately, it tasted like it had been cooked the day before. The fish was extremely dry, and the aftertaste was unpleasant. I mentioned it to our waiter, and he said he would let the chef know. We paid our bill and left, but no one ever came back to acknowledge the issue, apologize, or offer any explanation. It was very disappointing, especially considering the price of the meal. Ana Venice , fl read more

Hubby and I dined here twice during this trip. First, we came for dinner. It's a great restaurant with a great ambiance. There's plenty of outdoor seating as well. The indoor has 2 huge dining sections. Our first waiter, Rio, presented the menu and recommendations excellently. He juggled a few tables and didn't forget to always check on our table. We ordered the octopus for a start. Wow! This octopus woke me up. I was getting tired from shelling at the beach. I should have caught it myself, but I was too afraid to go too far out in the sea to fight with the octopus. Then I had filet mignon, and Hubby had a pork chop, but he wasn't crazy about it. However, I liked my dish. This night's winner went to the octopus! We came back for lunch with a friend the next day. Our waiter of the day was Alexandro. He was happy and energized. We ordered calamari for an appetizer. It was perfect. Then, I ordered snapper and shrimp from the lunch menu. My dish was excellent, and I thought I would try again when we return in December. Again, Hubby said he didn't make a good decision ordering for himself. He ordered fish and chips, thinking the place would have the best fish and chips, but that's ok, I let him try my dish and he loved it. Our friend had Scottish salmon that looked so delicious too. I may try that next time. Alejandro liked seeing my empty plate ha! Overall, I gave the place two thumbs up! The lunch menu plus the octopus were my favorites. Excellent service, food, and ambiance. Stay open please! Thanks! read more

See all

We met friends at this restaurant while visiting Longboat Key. They dine here quite frequently as they live near St Armands Circle. The restaurant is a two-floor restaurant with plenty of seating and also an outdoor patio on the street. We were seated upstairs, unfortunately as it had no ambience as the first floor. I wish I could remember our servers name because he was excellent, a tall young man who was engaging and friendly. He brought us a smoked fish spread with crackers as a little starter. Our friend ordered the crepes aubergine for the table, which was eggplant rollatini with mozzarella, romano, and marinara - very good. The menu changes daily depending on the fish they catch. So of course we ordered fish when it's caught the same day that we're about to eat it. My hubby had the grouper and I had the branzino. The fish was cooked perfectly and we really enjoyed our choices. However, the grouper was a very small portion. As a person who weighs her food because I am on Weight Watchers, it looked like it wasn't even 6oz. Pricey for the portion. It was served with roasted rainbow carrots which were so good because hubby shared. My branzino was delicious, but I had a few bones that were missed when filleting the fish. Overall, it was a great dining experience and I loved that the restaurant offers fresh fish daily. I would request a table on the first floor, though. read more

Crab and Fin - Branzino - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

The Halibut on lobster-infused risotto was amazing as was the lobster and shrimp dish. We came early enough to get complimentary appetizers. As always, the service was impeccable as was the ambience. The restaurant was filled with reservations and no walk-ins. I highly recommend the Crab and Gin. read more

Stopped in with family for dinner. Food was outstanding, drinks great and service excellent. Nice place for a special dinner.

Everything was bad. High prices with bad service and even worse management is a recipe for disaster. Food was terrible and it was obviously pre cooked and heated. My wife's salad had so much dressing it was wilded. Called for the manager and it was apparent why the place is so bad. He could have cared less about a customer. Will never be back and will be sure to tell everyone I know. read more

We celebrated our 63rd wedding anniversary this evening at Crab & Fin, our cherished place for family milestones, and it was once again a truly special experience. We began with Prince Edward oysters and a Caesar salad, both fresh and delicious. My husband enjoyed the sashimi tuna, which was not only beautifully presented but also absolutely outstanding to eat. What made the evening especially memorable was our server, Audrey. She was warm, attentive, and gracious throughout-truly a wonderful presence who made our celebration feel even more special. Thank you for helping us mark such an important occasion with such care and excellence. read more

My tuna was outstanding! My husband got the halibut and was a bit underwhelmed. His risotto was thick and paste-like, not creamy at all. Service was great. Tabitha kept our drinks full and was attentive. Ambiance was cool, casual but nice and not too loud Peanut butter pie was Delicious. read more

Crab and Fin - Gulf Yellowfin Tuna - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

If you are in St Armand circle there are many choices for the restaurants but this is a good spot for fresh seafood. Try their octopus it is very tender and good spices. Muscles were fresh and a good Caesar salad. Weather is amazing in Sarasota in the beginning of March! Sit outside and enjoy! read more

See all

Great location in St Armand's Circle. Food was pretty good but not worth the high prices. Don't go there with anyone that doesn't like seafood. Only non seafood items on the menu were steak offerings at $40 and up. What really turned me off was when one person in our party asked if they could give her another vegetable besides asparagus on her order. The waiter said they could give her string beans but at a $3.00 up charge. Her dish was $40 for a 5oz steak and you wouldn't change asparagus for string beans unless we pay $3.00? Ridiculous. read more

Crab and Fin is an upscale restaurant right in the heart of St Armand's circle. It's larger than it seems, with outdoor seating, a nice inside bar and an upstairs (I didn't venture up there). Being an upscale place, service was very good and our booth was very comfortable. We brought our own special bottle of wine and paid the $20 corking fee. I had the scallops, which were surprisingly tiny, but good. The overall portions of our meals were fairly small as well. As they're going for the upscale feel, pricing matched as well. I'm glad we tried it, but don't think I'll try it again. read more

We have been coming to Crab and Fin for years. And we always get the seafood tower (it used to be a tower and used to be served with fingerling potatoes and veggies). It's changed over the years to this large plate. We still get it bc the King crab is wonderful. But it was much better years ago. Last nite's clams were really fishy, the oysters were OK and the cocktail shrimp were overcooked. We had an 8 pm reservation on a Friday nite. The restaurant was lively and seemed packed inside. There were a few empty tables outside (which are first come first serve), and live music with a pianist outside. Our experience last nite was meh. Our server didn't talk about where the oysters were from and we had to request bread. She did recommend the desserts which were good. We will probably just get the king crab next time. There is smoked salmon spread/crackers as a welcome snack when you are seated. read more

See all

This has plenty of reviews already, but I added our pics. This is a nice, slightly upper scale restaurant in the heart of Armand's circle. Service was awesome. Drinks were great, we ordered the ultimate Bloody Mary and the Tito's strawberry lemonade. Highly recommend the gazpacho. Very bright and flavorful. read more

See all

Had an amazing meal at Crab & Fin! We ordered the scallops, wahoo & tempura shrimp dish, and the foie gras two ways--everything was packed with flavor. The scallops were tiny but perfectly cooked, the wahoo was super fresh, and the tempura shrimp had the perfect crunch. The foie gras was a nice surprise, super rich and delicious. Service was great, and the vibe was just right. I also love that they have a constantly rotating menu every day. Definitely coming back! read more

See all

Nice restaurant, came here on Sunday evening without reservation. Service was attentive and friendly. Amazing menu, I would eat every single item on a menu. Seafood and fish! They do have some chicken options as well. We had a salad and bisque to start, both were delicious. I had bouillabaisse which was amazing! They didn't have many options for non alcoholic cocktails. Also the vibe is a little for an older crowd, most people were way past retirement age and the place seems to fit that style. Basically it is not a modern hip style. It's more traditional. Overall great experience. read more

See all

Beautiful ambience and great service. The menu i looked at online was not the menu they had. They change it everyday, so I had to change my order. Husband got the whole snapper which was very good. The New England clam chowder was among the best. The eggplant rollotini was yummy but small, even as an appetizer. read more

Crab and Fin - Whole snapper - Seafood Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Meh. Met w friends visiting from out of state . No beer list ?! Nope . We asked what kind of local crafts they had - ' Stella ' he said walking away - aka the Budweiser of Belgium . Disappointed . We got his attention : "local IPA's " we inquired . Hazy high wire - well ok . How much ? Who knows ?! Maybe they're free . Because - ya know - no list no price. Sushi app was ok and a good little taste for two - not four . Calamari was eh . Overcooked and lacked presentation . Blah . My shrimp pasta w crabmeat etc was pretty good - and a good enough portion to take some too. My wife enjoyed her shrimp and grits too . This is a case of tourist central/ great location / hey - don't let the door hit ya on the way out... an ok place but nothing at least that night felt special - company aside ! read more