Friday, January 16, 2026 - Two for a burger bite. Not before the FST show…read more (GOSUB to the **** for the meat/burger of the review ((smile)) ) I have reviewed about 30 restaurants in and around Sarasota since 2021 when we moved down permanently and are members of the FST. On this Friday night, nothing was going right. My wife was delayed at school etc. So then a delayed departure from Venice, a false stop at Mad Moe's for a burger in Osprey (PACKED) and then a direct shot and parking across from FST we hope for a quick burger or something at the bar or restaurant at FST? But it was PACKED and they weren't serving any more???? We threw our tickets in the trash because now we could not make it back in time, (( frown :-( )) So a walk to Main Street to see if Patrick's or anybody might have room for two? NOPE. and we were walking along and THERE WAS BREWSTER's GASTROPUB!!!!!!!!!! For some reason I have 128 restaurants on my Sarasota Favorites list and Brewster's was not on it? I checked them on as I entered??? Looked VERY full at the bar, and most tables were full but it looked like we had a shot...... and there was a four top high-top!!!!!!! WIDE OPEN!! I think the no table service might be the delineator. We weren't looking for a sit down "dining" and full service gig. Nor did we need the overhead and pomp and circumstance of a host/hostess, army of bus staff, a waitstaff and being waited on with drinks and water and etc? ******** We came to EAT GOOD SIMPLE FOOD and have FUN. **** And that's what we did!!! "Todd" at the bar was friendly and fantastic. All the bartenders and staff were helpful and friendly. The "security guy" when he saw me at the bar for about 20 seconds helped me get some ketchup. Zone defense and team effort!!!! I got the signature Brew Burger and a side of Street Corn and had an endless glass of water w/ lemon I think I had Todd fill about 5 times. My wife and I bantered about what the Street Corn would be and we were happily surprised with the authentic Mexican Street Corn (elotes?) on the cob with a stick and a delightful creamy Chile, garlic, and Cotija cheese sauce I think. (problem is we gobble them up before we could figure out the exact sauce composition here. BUT it was very tasty. 10/10 The burger (for this adult usually nutritarian plant-based eater) was EXACTLY what I had hoped for. A wonderfully fresh an warm brioche bun, fantastic angus burger, cheddar and a "secret sauce" . I got lettuce onion and pickles which are standard...... this was VERY VERY VERY tasty. only quip is I will opt for sauce on the side and its was a little too much sauce. This was mega and uber better than some greasy Five Guys or Smashburger or any of that stuff. 10/10 My wife got the Shroom & Swiss Burger that had a wonderful portobello mushroom on it nicely cooked, terrific angus burger properly cooked exactly as we ordered it, she loved the blue cheese perfect amount, She also felt a bit TOO much of the secret sauce, but its pretty tasty so not a catastrophe. This was also an AWESOME burger!! 10/10 The sweet potato fries were not crazy greasy and perfectly crisp but not crunchy for fries - good, cross-cut and obviously bulk bag. Cut or sliced would be nicer but of course not expected, its a side. 7/10 The place is clean and glassware and silverware perfectly clean. The counter/bar service is fantastic. I had to make a few trips for ketchup and place ware and etc but hey when your wife gets one of the better vodka cranberry w/lemon and club in a large tumble for $9 instead of $15 or $16 for a 6 oz martini glass with 4 oz of watery drink........ its a home run!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! With all the TVs and sports that is probably the summary of my review. Brewster's Gastropub is a Grand Slam for food and service......and especially burgers!!! Bravo Zulu.

Every thing about Brewsters is phenomenal. Food, outstanding, great beer and awesome servers…read more Plenty of TVs for sports watching, just an all around fun place

Fun place right in Fernando's Beach for a quick bite or to watch a game. We had the pretzel -…read moreserved hot and fresh with cheese dip and a tasty brown mustard. Also had the lobster crab dip that tasted more like crab - had to hunt for the lobster. They make a very good version of the BVI Painkiller served at Level 1,2 or 3 - depending on 'how much pain you tryin' ta kill.' No evidence that it is authentic Pussers rum, but the flavor was pretty legit with fresh ground nutmeg. The upstairs wasn't open when we arrived for a late lunch. I imagine the view of the ocean is fantastic. I'll look forward to seeing it next time we are in the area.

Great bar. The guy working was so on point, he's about 6'3, super hot and made the best drinks. I'm…read morea local and mad I don't come here more often.

This is such a gem. Delicious beer and the food is all homemade! The staff is also a hit. I would…read morerecommend this bar 10/10! New ownership!! Jim & Lisa are amazing. They opened in May 2024.

Late to review but stopped in this place several times on my vacation and it was a very solid local…read morebar. Kinda place I would hang out at if I was local. Great bar food and the wings I had were pretty great. Staff was fast and friendly. They had a DJ but also have live bands. Slight bathroom water backup issue one night we went but that is such a one off. Staff apologized but again it was a sewer problem. Didn't stop the cold drinks and hot food. When I come back to this area of Florida...I'd def come back here for a brew and wings

Julie made our lunch so nice! She was sweet, thoughtful and a fabulous server! We loved sitting on…read morethe deck outdoors and watching the waves. Julie made us and our little dog, Bingo, feel welcome. We will come back!

Julie was an excellent server, pleasant and very accommodating. Answered all all questions made…read morerecommendations, made for a pleasant atmosphere. Food was excellent! We ate there twice! location was amazing! We will definitely go there again next year when we return!.

Stopped in on a work trip. Great Food, Cold beer, and even better atmosphere! Bartenders were super…read morefriendly as well! Highly recommended!

My wife and I were walking in and as soon as we walked in , cigarette smoke hit us right in the…read moreface. We turned around and walked out. Smoke was really bad

Great little stop to enjoy great food and service as well. The family and I have been there several…read moretimes never to be disappointed.

Had take out. Chicken taco…read moreNot the best Had steak sandwich One bite, spit it out. Do not ever remember a meal this bad. If I served this leather horsemeat to my clientele they would shoot me!

Everything went well and this place is the best!! Delicious…read moretoo.... I always have ordered the burgers or the nachos. Plenty of food to share... Enjoy!!

I cannot understand its success, sometimes I feel that my taste buds are not aligned with majority…read moreof Sarasota's diners. The interior is dark and feels like it needs a good cleaning. I had a tuna poke bowl, tiny pieces of tuna on a bed of fresh veggies which tasted like dirty dish water. The saving grace was the wasabi dressing which helped cover up that odd flavor. I could have had a whole bowl of the wasabi salad dressing! Service was nice.

3 Keys Brewing is conveniently located on Manatee Ave close to 41. The building has an old time…read moreFlorida feel with porch seating. Upon entering the restaurant, you will see a bar directly in front of you, and plenty of table seating off to the right in the main dining area. When 3 Keys first opened, they did not have the best food. Now, their food is high quality. I ordered the "we be jammin" burger and it was excellent. The beer did not impress me on my most recent visit. I tried two IPAs and found them to be below average. I would return, but I would hope to try better beers. They certainly have a local following as the brewery has plenty of customers on a Sunday night.

We had a nice time here. We sat outside in the back and enjoyed a little show. It was great! The…read morefood was good and being outside created a great ambiance! The servers did a great job as we had a large party. Great experience and enjoyed the craft flight!

Such a fun place. Great atmosphere and fantastic food! The Yellowtail was the best I've had in a…read morelong while. You are in for a crunchy surprise with the chicken tenders. Their quality of beef for hamburgers is outstanding. And the giant pretzels are meal by themselves, get them to share. Friendly people, excellent staff.

Awesome neighborhood pub! They opened for the USA men's hockey game and it was packed at 8 am that…read moreSunday! Great drinks and food. Our bartender, Jordyn, was the BEST. She was our bartender on several occasions and made the best cocktails, and had the nicest personality! Can't wait to return!