I was at the Upper East Side location of this miniature Israali/Levantine chain a while back with a…read morecouple of others. Compared to some of their other locations, it's a bit nicer here, being a bit more dimly lit. The service was friendly. Overall, the food was pricey and just okay, with the Upper West Side and especially the Park Slope locations being much better in both flavor and presentation, enough so that I wouldn't recommend this one.
We started with two of the mezze/appetizers. Much better of the two was their interesting take on a Spanakopita for $18, consisting of a Swiss chard and feta pie, cherry tomato, and a spicy pepper sauce. The portion was a bit meek for the price, which became a theme, but the flavor was nice. The phyllo had a nice mix of crispiness and softness, and the inside wasn't too sour from the feta. The cherry tomatoes added a nice burst of freshness, and there wasn't too much pepper sauce, or else I think it would have become a bit too soggy. This was good.
Much worse was the $15 Babaganoush with chopped pickles, Fresno pepper, and sesame bread. I'm unsure why, but the color was very off compared to the typical version, being greenish instead of the usual gray, which made it look just a bit unappetizing. I liked the pickles and pepper, and the bread went well with it, but overall it didn't help, as it lacked smokiness and wasn't as thick as a typical version. Overall, it was flavorless and pricey, with a good 20 places even in the area making a better version, with most of them being cheaper.
My main of choice was regrettably a $32 Salmon Papillote with chermoula and root vegetables that thankfully no longer appears to be on the menu. The portion size was tiny for the price, and for it being chermoula, it lacked the spice or depth of the tasty Moroccan sauce. The salmon was decently tender, but the root vegetables were undercooked to the point that the carrots were still hard. This was terrible, but it's been replaced, which is a good thing.
Another person had the same dish, and the last person had the much better $27 Chicken Shawarma Tacos, served on a toasted za'atar pita with fermented red cabbage, pickles, and spicy yogurt cilantro sauce, served with za'atar fries, tahini & amba. The portion size was much more decent, and the flavor of the fries, at least, was nice, with the za'atar adding some nice herbal and sour notes, and the fries themselves having a good texture. He also liked the "tacos," and the portion seemed adequate.
For dessert, we had two. Mine was the good Malabi for $13, an almond milk pudding currently served with rose & beet syrup and pistachio. Back then, it was more dark chocolate and orange-based, with a dark chocolate-covered orange slice and the cake having a bit of orange. The floral rosewater and orange flavors reminded me of a very tasty mix of malabi and Greek Portokalopita.
The others shared a pretty good Knafeh for $16 with baked phyllo dough, sweetened cheese, and pistachio ice cream. The knafeh/kunafa was served a bit differently than at other spots, and it was much less sweet than normal. I liked how many pistachios there were, but the cheese texture felt a bit off. Outside of the soft phyllo, the dish reminded me more of some less sweet versions of the Turkish künefe than the Levant style. It was fine.
We had an off experience here. We disliked one of the two appetizers and found the other one OK. My entree was pretty terrible; the other entree was good, and both desserts were different but tasty. I would recommend the other Miriam locations instead, as at this price point, some consistency would be nice.