I must have a special sixth sense because I was craving fish and chips randomly and, upon searching, stumbled across Dean's only a week or so after they had opened! I had a feeling it was only a matter of time before it would blow up in popularity. I got a reservation for dinner on a Friday with my husband which I highly recommend since it was very packed (granted peak hours). The place is very small, intimate, rustic and feels warm and welcoming. The menus were handwritten which felt personalized and special. It does feel slightly too elevated and exclusive to be a pub really but I like the idea and the energy was great nonetheless. We started off with some drinks, my husband got a half pint of the Old Speckled Hen which he really liked and came very cold! I got a regular margarita which was citrusy and refreshing. We also ordered the Guinness shooters with oysters which are so aesthetic and also delicious-- somehow the flavor of the oyster is elevated when chased by the beer. For food we got:
- oyster half dozen: fresh, and perfect to transition into the meal. These came with hot sauce, lemon, and a special English mignonette sauce. These were delicious and generously sized! Very tasty without being fishy. On the brinier side but they pair amazingly with the beer.
- scotch eggs: my first time having these so take my comments with a grain of salt. I absolutely adored the crispy texture from the outside layer of the scotch egg! It had an audible crunch every time you'd take a bite. The sausage was also very nice and had the texture of a meatball without being crumbly and holding its shape well. It had hints of an herb which tasted like ?anise which I am not a huge fan of but good overall when balanced by the sharp, nasal-clearing spice of the mustard. The quail egg somehow had the most perfectly soft yolk (not sure how they get all the elements right so that was pretty impressive!) Very comforting and warm app.
- fish and chips: the reason I came here! Truly some of the best fish and chips I've had in my life. Photos are misleading and the portion is pretty generous. The fish fillet is perfectly battered outside, and tender, flaky inside. You could tell this was very high quality fish by its freshness. The hand-cut chips were absolutely stellar-- they were medium thickness, and had the perfect bold crisp (my husband thought too crispy but if you like your fries crispy these are the best I've had in the city!) For condiments you get a wedge of lemon, tangy and creamy tartar sauce, and proper malt vinegar to cut through the fat and sweetness of the batter. I would come back exclusively for the fish and chips! This dish definitely exceeded my expectations.
-brandy snaps: for dessert we got the aesthetic brandy snaps filled with either chocolate and whipped cream. The flavors of the brandy, caramel, and chocolate/ or whipped cream were perfect and satisfying without being too heavy. It's also such a perfect dessert to share! Highly recommend!
Overall, I really liked Dean's! The fish and chips were amazing, the beer is cold, the service was excellent. It does feel a bit too elevated to be a true "pub" because ultimately this is another West Village restaurant that carries a certain exclusivity to it. I am not sure a average New Yorker would be able to come here every Friday night (competitive reservations, long wait times, and higher prices), and lacks the accessibility/ casualness which I interpret as the essence of the "public house". Nonetheless, it's a unique experience with a special touch that I highly recommend. I certainly will be back in the future! read more