Pizza is delicious. Wings are good as well, but sauce applied differently. Clean restaurant, always people there. The single slices are HUGE! Many different sauce options. Everything I've had from there has been terrific. Guy who cashed me out was very friendly too read more

Ordered off DD which is why I think they made my pizza wrong ( not cut in squares like i requested) and they put 22 pepperoni on it (I only counted bc it looked so light) I googled it and apparently a large 16" pizza typically has 40-50 slices lol So I assume it's the kitchen looking out for their drivers or it's some new kid, i understand it's mostly young people working and I can't expect much from hs or college kids but I can't help but think that this is a "fuck you for ordering on DD and not using our driver" I love the pizza from here and it's usually very consistent but this is the 3rd time in like 6 months that they have made more than one mistake on an order of mine read more

Cusimanos Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lockport, New York

They have great pizza. They have so many options for pizza. I have tried the louder cheese which is a little too much cheese but so flavorful and gooey. The choose you own topping pizzas are very good. One of our favorite desserts here is the Anderson's ice team sandwiches. Their service is so nice as the employees reconciles local school jerseys and commenting so sweetly. There ambiance were great with a classic pizza place feel. This is a great local option for pizza. read more

The best steak sub I've ever had!!! I wish I took pics but I dug right in... steak and cheese sub was good and I can't wait to be back. Service was great. I came on a slow night and food was brought out piping hot with a smile!!! The restaurant, itself, is very clean and well lit. They had a cute Christmas tree up which added a bit to the ambiance. I'll def be back as I'd like to try everything on the menu!! read more

Very impressed! On Super Bowl Sunday my order was perfect. They also had a great deal on pizza and wings when other places did not. We ordered a sheet Pizza well done and our wings crispy/saucy and let me tell you they cooked it all to perfection! Our wings were jumbo, full of meat. Crispy and extra saucy! Our sheet pizza didn't have too much cheese or sauce but the ratio was so so good! Well done but not burnt. My entire family kept saying how good things turned out. We consider this place one of the top in Lockport. Extremely happy and will continue to order from them in the future. Great customer service too! Try them out. read more

Cusimanos Pizzeria - Pizza and Wings - Pizza Near Me - Lockport, New York

The service is very nice. However, I would never order a "well done toasted" sub. Cold, sad and pathetic.

Was just at Cusimano's for lunch with my family and they have poor service served 3 of us while they made a mistake and forgot their food for the fourth person when you talk to staff to get food takes a attitude said oh we will bring it out we had had been sitting quite a while already they did serve a couple while we were still waiting.Then fought and said you got your fries already wich we didn't Mark Cusimano you should invest in employees with customer service rating is a 0 read more

Came in for some slices. The slices were older but we didn't get there until 8:30 at night. I'm not sure how long they were sitting out but they were still served to us warm. The staff was friendly. I had one sweet sauce and one regular sauce slice. I actually liked the traditional slice more than the sweet which usually is not the case. read more

Cusimanos Pizzeria - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Still surprised not to see more reviews for this location. Have been coming pretty regularly for lunch over the past year. Do read my previous review. Consistent food offering, friendly staff, and always CLEAN surroundings. read more

Ordered a thick dough cheese and pepperoni pizza. Along with a meat lovers pizza. Got home and the meat lovers had the thick dough. Took them back to cusumanos to get them fixed. Come home and it's the same thing. No thick dough on my pizza, but on my husband's who didn't want the thick dough. I used to love cusumanos but they've been doing nothing but screwing up lately and they can't even fix it. Wouldn't bother going here anymore I don't know if it's new staff or just laziness. read more

Cusimanos Pizzeria - Thick dough? Not even close. - Pizza Near Me - Lockport, New York

Pizza ok, thick crust and chewy, the parmanson garlic wings over cook for the second time. Reminds me of Christmas vacation and Chevy Chase turkey dinner. Good pizza at best and lousy wings. read more

My family and I have been loyal customers to cusimanos and have eaten there several times. But our most recent dining experience was not even sub par it was horrible. My family's food came but one meal was not brought to the table. When a family member asked where there meal was they were told they had gotten the food and we're treated like they were in thw wrong for not getting there food. Then we got the meal but it didn't have the fries. The staff member that was spoke to got an attitude when being questioned. Additionally the reasturant was empty besides one other person who had takeout. Over all the whole experience was horrible as the staff was flighty and rude. read more

We have been eating here ever since they opened. The food was always great and the service was the best. The last year theyb have been very inconsistent, but would correct any problems. The last month or two they have been pretty bad. Getting orders wrong, food that is burnt or raw. Two weeks ago I spoke with the owner as he happened to be in the store and he stated that they were having trouble getting help. I told him that as we eat there a couple of times a week we could see the turn over in help and that its hard finding good help. I just seen they are opening another store and it begs the questions are they growing to fast, do they have quality controls in place. three nights ago our subs were burnt rolls and dry meat and last night our calzone was served with raw dough ( second time) so we wont be going back for a while before we give them another try. PLEASE fix the problems it used to be such a great place. read more

nastiest pizza ever! they been going down hill for awhile but this last time was unexceptable pizza was burnt my sub was not cooked ! manager said he would replace my money and 3 weeks later he had lied and said they never planned on replacing my money!!!! worse place ever i am so angery they lied to me! read more

Stopped here with some friends on a Sunday around noon, at first we were worried it wasn't open as there were not cars at all, and it was hard to see inside but upon checking the door we found they were open. I ordered the meat lovers calzone, it was really good, as described choke full of meat, the crust was soft and chewy and well seasoned. I ate maybe 1/3 of it, so there were plenty of leftovers. They gave 2 containers of marinara which while still not enough was more than some places seem to give. My husband got the steak and cheese sub and was very happy with it. You order at the counter and sit anywhere you want. There was plenty of seating. During our time eating a small amount of people trickled in. The parking lot has it's own playground which is awesome if you have kids. If you're in the area and looking for some good food, stop on by! read more

On the way to Niagara Falls and stopped by a pizza place on Lockport. Very friendly staff and clean place. The pizza selection was different from what I am used to.... Breakfast pizza and chicken. No red sauce. Instead it was mayonnaise and what looks like siracha(? Maybe). Nevertheless. I am thankful to eat after an hour and so driving. read more

Ordered ham sub requested toasted roll it was not toasted . I felt like this sub was lacking flavor and presentation was not the best . Lettuce was yellow . In the future I will seek another place to get a sub . read more

it's sub par. the pizza is like soup and the tenders are weird it's just a little weird.

The food is really good and if was only rating on account of the food it would get 5 stars but the service is slow so they get bumped down a little. read more

Omg!! I can't say enough about this place. Everyone is so nice. I like that this is a family owned business. Their cannoli's are awesome! It blows another local place out of the water. The shells are fresh and I believe they are made to order. Do yourself a favor and just try the cannoli! read more

Unfortunately it depends on what night you want to order from here depending on who is working the food is either great or complete trash. Sad Definitely has hindered me ordering here more. read more

Pizza was mush in the middle. Cheese slopped all over the place. Not thoroughly cooked, dough was raw in the middle. It was haphazardly cut. Obviously a rushed job. I normally like this place, but the last couple of times the dough has been undercooked. read more

They are willing to accommodate my dietary restrictions and everything still tastes great! I would recommend their gluten free pizza dough! read more

Great selection of classic WNY food. Awesome pizza and wings (especially the sweet sauce), subs, roast beef sandwiches etc. The only place around to get garbage plates and they certainly don't disappoint! read more

Don't order before closing time. When I first started ordering from here I thought that this would be my go to place. Last night I ordered a pizza. I did not know that they closed at 8pm. I had less than 15 minutes to pick it up after ordeting. When I brought it home, alomost all of the cheese was off the pizza onto the paper in the box. The crust was so thin you could almost see through it. Very disappointed. If you can't make the pizza in time, why did you take my order? Who ever was in charge, how could you let something like that out the door to a paying customer? When I worked closing at a restaurant, we took orders up to closing time, made sure everything was properly made, and waited until all the customers were gone. Things have changed. Guess I will not recommend or order from this place again. Sorry not sorry. read more

Amazing food . Our order is perfect every time rather it's pizza wings fries. Definitely recommend.

Menu and posted prices are outdated. Lockport staff are rude and argumentative to customers, do not know the menu, do not know how to ring up an order. Wings were dry and overcooked. Got a sub, got home with it and it had no cheese. Pizza is good but I wont be going back because of untrained staff with nasty attitudes. read more

ordered a pizza wing combo received it two hours after ordering all I got was we're sorry the reason I ordered food I had to go to work super early in the morning. These people don't care and the quality and the food and the weight price not worth it stevie V's marks much better service. read more