Service was warm, inviting and attentive. The food here is a wow. Totally unexpected and really…read moredelicious. I had the Mushroom & Swiss Burger. The menu suggests, "you'll need a fork for it" and that was no lie. It honestly was one of the best burgers I've had in ages. And the mushrooms? Cooked to perfection. It was juicy, cheesy, messy. Cooked to temp and perfectly seasoned. It was everything an awesome burger should be. My guy had the Reuben. I'll admit this out of the gate: we are corned beef snobs. We abhor the dry, thin-deli-sliced attempts that try to pass as food. We grew up on Benji's, Jake's and McBob's. We love a thicker, moist, pulled corned beef and good gracious--this corned beef Reuben was fantastic. Our mate had a classic BLT. No complaints. Killer bacon. How could that be wrong in any way? Love that they have a salad bar and offered both a soup and chili on a Saturday for lunch. Can't wait to go back. The fried chicken (and buckets to go are offered) looked great.

I was coming home from disc golfing at nearby Tendick Park and wanted to grab lunch to go along the…read moreway. Between the Greens was a bookmarked place I hadn't been to yet, so I stopped and placed an order to go. I got cheese curds and The Whaler (a three piece cod sandwich) with waffle fries as a $2 add-on. The cheese curds were good. Not super crunchy like I prefer and they retained a little too much grease, but they seemed to be freshly battered, so that's a plus. On paper, $16 (as of 10/6/2024) for a fish sandwich may not sound like a good deal, but the sandwich was HUGE and tasted amazing. The $2 charge to add waffle fries was also worth it as they give you a ton for your money. I'd gladly order this again. Given their name and the golf greens in their logo, I assumed Between the Greens was a clubhouse restaurant at a golf course. Instead, I was surprised to see a country bar & grill that's simply close to a couple golf courses. For a moment I thought I may have been in the wrong place. Glad it all worked out.

Great food and great atmosphere! Quieter inside but has a great patio. Met there for a business…read morelunch and our server was phenomenal. She sensed the business meeting vibe and was so professional and timely. I will definitely be coming here again!

First time checking out this place, and we definitely will be back! Beautifully redone building…read morewith an amazing outdoor area! We were instantly greeted and sat when we walked in, with our choice of indoor or outdoor seating. Our waitress was super nice and quick. I enjoyed the Old Fashioned Flight ($14 for 4 kinds) and the Bayou Mac was amazzzzing. Already looking forward to having it again sometime soon!

Ryan was excellent! We had a delicious quick dinner and drinks. Fancy chicken, cheese curds,…read moremac&cheese so good. Ryan really helped us enjoy our meal. We will be back!

Pros: -Very friendly servers. We've dined here multiple…read moretimes, both as a foursome and as a couple. -Bartenders are great and really work to help you find a drink you'll like. They also have different specialty cocktails throughout the year. -Cheese curds...I know, it's Wisconsin, but these are right up there with the elite. Cons: -I'll let you know when I find some. We've been to Crafty Cow several times over the last year, probably four or five times, and we've always been impressed by how friendly the waitstaff and bar staff are. The owner is also very nice and clearly involved, which I think is cool. I almost always order the same thing: the chicken strip meal, which comes with three huge strips and a large side of fries. The chicken here is really interesting because it's marinated in pickle brine. You can definitely taste the brine, and it adds something you didn't even realize was missing. My wife used to order the same thing, but now she tries something different each time because she knows she can share my strips. Everything she has tried has been good. Also worth mentioning: they have really good ranch dressing. I was surprised when I looked up Crafty Cow on Yelp and saw that it had less than four stars. Looking at some of the older reviews, I'm guessing it may have had a bit of a rocky start. But based on our experiences, Crafty Cow has been consistently great, and we'll definitely keep coming back.

Great great location great burgers I give them a five but why serve excellent food and then serve…read moreit with cheap ketchup!? I've actually ruined the taste of the burger. I took my meal home and then applied real catch-up game changer will be back, but I'll bring my own ketchup! Food is too good to be served with cheap ketchup - spend the extra couple bucks and give it the extra excellent accompaniment it deserves

Well if you are hungry and and want to eat I would not go to this restaurant! We were excited about…read moretrying it out! We were seated at our table. Looked over the menu and picked out our drinks. Then we watched one waitress go by. Another would go by and another. They looked away we are to busy to acknowledge you. Well maybe they can not see us. Shut the menu so the know we are ready to order! Still not even a smile, nod, nothing. More worried about pulling dirty plates off the tables that are finishing up. Hummm there are people waiting for tables. Finally after being passed by continuously we set a timer. We will give it 5 more minutes. STILL not one waitress came to our table. The people that were seated after us were finally served. Really???? We probably won't go back or recommend them.

I was eager to check out the happy hour menu since it's been a while since we've had dinner here…read more Sadly, I'd have to agree with some of the other recent reviews - prices aren't worth what you get. The ambiance and service was great - Yasbel was nice and attentive. Plenty of parking at this location and easy to get to. I did see another table got the sliders and that seems like it would at least be more filling with their brioche buns. The steak bites had a good sear and flavor but the steak sauce tasted like a sweet BBQ and not in a good way - very vanilla-y. The petite salad was maybe 2 or 3 bites - very petite indeed. The shrimp cocktail was worse - the shrimp was tough and the cocktail sauce had no seasoning. It was basically just ketchup. The price for these two items and a glass of house wine came out to $40. I'm happy I tried it out but now I know I'm not interested in the happy hour going forward.

Date of visit: February 5, 2026 Team: Jeff and Nancy…read more Regularly rated one of the best restaurants in the area by various publications, I took advantage of some Bartalotta gift cards that we had received for various occasions and never got around to using to get together with some friends that we hadn't seen yet this year. Half of us arrived early and were warmly shown to our table, even letting us slide over to a table against the wall that felt a bit more comfortable for us until the rest of our party arrived. Tables are a bit close together so be careful when getting up, you're liable to bump into a fellow patron. Things started out well with Jeff and Nancy but he really did not seem to care for the lone woman in our party, dismissing her substitution request for the bacon on the twice-baked potato as she was vegetarian and then offering no other option. His future interactions with her were a bit gruff as well, which was just odd. She noticed that another patron appeared to have dropped something underneath their table and when she brought it to Jeff's attention, he just said, "Oh," and went over to that table, almost as if she had again asked for some unreasonable substitution to her meal. Outside of that, everything was pretty good, if definitely pricey. My steak sandwich was very juicy, and the shellfish soup was quite good, pairing well with the warm bread brought to the table. Don't bother trying to pull them apart, there's plenty for everyone in that basket! Our friends did not really care for their cauliflower steak, apparently a poor follow up to one they had at a restaurant in Madison the previous month, though the mushrooms were a big hit. The flourless chocolate cake was very rich and moist, and while we probably didn't need it, it was a great way to end the meal.

Sad to have to make this review! We've been coming here for…read moreat least 4 years. The cod fish fry has always been great with excellent potato pancakes. Bartender Kayla, (owner's daughter) has always been pleasant. This past Sunday 9/28/25 we stopped in for a drink at 5:30 after attending a Celebration of Life for a friend. We got a chilly reception, seeing as they were closing soon we were told The KITCHEN was Closed! We both ordered a scotch and club soda. Both of us said it didn't taste right. They were very faint in color and taste. When we mentioned to the owner, she got defensive and claimed "I've never been accused of pouring a short drink!" We didn't say she did. She then took our drinks and poured them in the sink saying "We're Done Here!". My husband & I looked at each and said "Let's go." that's when the owner said "I Think So! We then left! I can't believe the way we were treated! To treat your customers with such Disregard! The scotch didn't look right or taste right. Could be that it sits in the window with the sun beating down on it everyday or possibly it's watered down? Don't know. What I DO KNOW is we won't be going back!

The staff is friendly service is very good. The prices were average, I ordered a full ordered of…read moremozzarella sticks they came in under 10 minutes from when the ordered was placed.

We previously had good visits with this restaurant, those times the food, drink, and service was…read moreperfect. We were here a week ago for our anniversary and it was not the same. The restaurant was clean upon arrival, and seemed to be a normal night for this restaurant even had the piano playing in the background. That's all when things started to snowball, upon being greeted at the hostess desk we were invited to help ourselves to a seat at the bar as they would be with us in a few moments. We had a reservation so this was odd but ok. They came back and just pointed us to a table from the bar. Waited a good while to finally get our drink order taken. Mine came quickly the misses had to wait for a good while for hers which was disappointing as we were already previously seated at the bar where we were pointed to help ourselves to a table. She said something about her water being off flavored and shortly after noticed a chunk of something stuck to the inside of her water cup. We decided to order an appetizer of the bacon jam toast thing as it was obvious at this point the staff was struggling to keep up with all the tables and they needed a moment to regroup before placing a whole meal order. The appetizer was great delicious and left us wanting more. We then ordered our steaks mashed potatoes and tried the lobster mac. All of that tasted great also. We were questioning each other where the lobster was in the mac and overheard the waitstaff talking to what sounded like a regular that they ran out of lobster. (They told them to enjoy a round of drinks on them someone was already running to get more). We finished with desert as it was our anniversary the peanut butter cheesecake. Upon arriving at the table it looked as though it had fingerprints on the side like someone used their fingers to place it on the plate. We ate it and again was very good rich and had a great flavor. You probably would ask yourself if we told them any of these things, they apologized for wait to be seated, apologized for the service several times stating "there's a few large groups in back" on their own. Replaced the water cup and said sorry about that. They knew they were out of lobster and tried to pull one more dish before getting more. Lastly we were done when desert came and just wanted to leave. Definitely not going back here anytime soon!

First visit. All I can say is very disappointing. I had high expectations. I had one cocktail and…read morewas charged an extra $3.50 for ice. We had a crap cake appetizer and virtually no crab, just breading. I can't recommend and I see no reason to visit again.

Finally wandered my way over to this place after seeing it for so long and just never stopping in…read more Not sure why I waited so long! The May burger special was so good, I went back for a second time before it was gone. Smash Burger Tacos were just SO good. I tried the truffle fries the second time, and thought they were delicious as well. (My Dad got the pasta special of the month and had nothing but good things to say about his dish as well, and repeated both stops.) Servers were nice and quick both times. No complaints, and we will be back!

Burgers are very good. I would definitely get a double cheeseburger if you can eat, because I've…read moreregretted the single size a couple times. Neat creative burger combinations. If you like crab Rangoon, you MUST get that appetizer. If it's just two of you, it's big & filling, but worth bringing home leftovers when you smash it before your main course (hard to stop eating it). Service has always been good and it's a great small town atmosphere inside.