Probably 4.5 We picked Mr AB's for the Misters bday dinner because he wanted scallops, and we hadn't been to this location yet. Wine - B+ A great list, no question. Verrrry pricy. App: B Shrimp cocktail - very meaty clean shrimp but the cocktail sauce was really just ketchup. I need my spice!! Main: Steak: A - perfectly cooked and absolutely delicious. Accoutrements: B You get a potato choice and a sauce. They're fine Side: C I love asparagus but these were not properly trimmed and had tough, woody ends. Dessert: A Crème brûlée, done right Service: A Friendly, attentive and professional Overall: B+ I'm not saying it's not a splurge-y spot but when you compare it to places like Carnevore it's honestly a good value. read more

I was eager to check out the happy hour menu since it's been a while since we've had dinner here. Sadly, I'd have to agree with some of the other recent reviews - prices aren't worth what you get. The ambiance and service was great - Yasbel was nice and attentive. Plenty of parking at this location and easy to get to. I did see another table got the sliders and that seems like it would at least be more filling with their brioche buns. The steak bites had a good sear and flavor but the steak sauce tasted like a sweet BBQ and not in a good way - very vanilla-y. The petite salad was maybe 2 or 3 bites - very petite indeed. The shrimp cocktail was worse - the shrimp was tough and the cocktail sauce had no seasoning. It was basically just ketchup. The price for these two items and a glass of house wine came out to $40. I'm happy I tried it out but now I know I'm not interested in the happy hour going forward. read more

See all

Date of visit: February 5, 2026 Team: Jeff and Nancy Regularly rated one of the best restaurants in the area by various publications, I took advantage of some Bartalotta gift cards that we had received for various occasions and never got around to using to get together with some friends that we hadn't seen yet this year. Half of us arrived early and were warmly shown to our table, even letting us slide over to a table against the wall that felt a bit more comfortable for us until the rest of our party arrived. Tables are a bit close together so be careful when getting up, you're liable to bump into a fellow patron. Things started out well with Jeff and Nancy but he really did not seem to care for the lone woman in our party, dismissing her substitution request for the bacon on the twice-baked potato as she was vegetarian and then offering no other option. His future interactions with her were a bit gruff as well, which was just odd. She noticed that another patron appeared to have dropped something underneath their table and when she brought it to Jeff's attention, he just said, "Oh," and went over to that table, almost as if she had again asked for some unreasonable substitution to her meal. Outside of that, everything was pretty good, if definitely pricey. My steak sandwich was very juicy, and the shellfish soup was quite good, pairing well with the warm bread brought to the table. Don't bother trying to pull them apart, there's plenty for everyone in that basket! Our friends did not really care for their cauliflower steak, apparently a poor follow up to one they had at a restaurant in Madison the previous month, though the mushrooms were a big hit. The flourless chocolate cake was very rich and moist, and while we probably didn't need it, it was a great way to end the meal. read more

See all

In my experience, you can't go wrong when you choose a Bartolotta restaurant, and this place is no exception. Beautiful interior with warm lighting creates a cozy and elegant experience. The two servers assigned to our table of 8 were friendly, knowledgeable, attentive and quick. Then there's the food, which was absolutely amazing. My husband ordered three appetizers as his meal, and thoroughly enjoyed them all. The Lobster Mac and Cheese was very rich and flavorful with a nice crunch on top, although the lobster pieces were on the smaller side and not overwhelming in number. The Wagyu Meatballs were not as tender or juicy as expected, but were delicious. The nicely sized dollop of ricotta on top was a nice touch. I had the Califlower Steak, which was a first for me. It. Was. Fantastic! The califlower was cut thick and roasted to perfection, creating a wonderfully firm yet tender texture. The accompanying flavors and textures made this dish smell and taste amazing. This is a beautiful option for those who prefer a meatless option or are looking to try something new. read more

See all

I had previously gone to Joey Gerard's and hated it. Food and service was horrible. This place made up for Joeys ten fold. JEFF AND ARNOLD ARE ANGELS SENT TO THIS EARTH FROM UP ABOVE. They are funny and witty and make your dinner an unforgettable experience !!!! We all started with the bisque. The second I tasted that I knew dinner was going to be good. So rich with flavor. I had the 8 oz filet which was done how I liked it. My mashed potatoes were to die for with breadcrumbs on top. My husband ordered 18 oz angus ribeye which he said was one of the best he's had. It was our anniversary and they brought out complimentary champagne and free dessert. Jeff and Arnold made our anniversary so special and we will never forget them for it. read more

See all

We have been coming here since their previous location in Stonewood Village. Always had rave reviews for this place. Unfortunately 2026 has been not so good. Last visit was a disappointment and this visit even more so. It seems service is ok, size of steak goes down and price goes up, the quality of the meat seems to have changed as well as the cooks because last 2 times our steaks were not cooked the way they had previously been at medium and did not have much flavor. So sorry but such a disappointment for the second time in a row. read more

If you manage to snag a seat at the bar, Happy hour is a good deal and the cheese curds are one of the best I've had. My husband and I dined there for dinner recently. We started with happy hour, then moved to the dining room. The first time we dined here we were disappointed, so I was looking forward to giving it another chance. Yet again, we were overall disappointed. The food was incredibly overpriced for what we got. I love a good beef carpaccio and was super excited to try theirs, and I was very underwhelmed. It really lacked flavor and the rye bread as to opposed to a toasted crostini or something else, made it feel cheap and confused the flavors of the dish . I definitely would not recommend it. Overall, the only thing I would go back for would be the cheese curds. We went for a belated anniversary and spent a lot of money for food that was not worth it. We will not be back. read more

Another fantastic dinner at Mr. B's in Brookfield. The service was excellent - Arnold & Jeff were attentive and knowledgeable. Our table was in a quiet spot, but you could still see the action in the kitchen. Everyone who stopped by our table was welcoming and kind. We love the mocktail and NA beverage options - having Athletic on tap was a nice surprise. We enjoyed the Waygu meatballs and lobster mac to start - generous portions of both, and both were so good! Our steaks and salmon were prepared perfectly. You can't go wrong with the filet, bourbon peppercorn cream sauce, and bacon roasted potatoes - the perfect combo. The flourless chocolate cake and pumpkin cheesecake were amazing - the perfect end to our meal. We love having Mr. B's nearby for celebratory dinners and date nights! read more

See all

We came out for a company dinner on a busy weekend--the place was packed. Upon arrival, friendly staff offered to take out coats for the coat check process. We gave the hostess the information for the party and were quickly escorted to the back, where our company was located. When we entered the room, we saw tables filled with delicious, perfectly plated hors d'oeuvres. You've seen other photos, I'm sure--butter is cut in triangles, and garnishes are properly placed. It was quite apparent that they took the right amount of time to make things presentable and delicious. We had the Wisconsin Cheese Plate, Crab Cakes, The ambiance was quite nice, and on a busy night like this, it was loud. In the room we were in, there were plenty of things knocking around on the other side of the wall. It sounded like it was even on the roof, though I doubt it - the kitchen was right on the other side, and I'm sure they're sliding in plates and the like. Even if you're going to get a private room at Mr. B's, be prepared for the noise. Drinks were delicious: wine, Bourbon, Old Fashioneds, you name it. Everyone who came in to assist with the food, drinks, plating, etc., was professional, courteous, and surprisingly fast. I had even asked where the bathroom was, and it wasn't just an explanation-I was escorted there. The pace at which food came out was perfectly timed, which was surprising to me, considering that there were no empty tables. The staff deserves a lot of credit for the place running like a well-oiled machine. Shellfish Bisque was savory, and the fresh lobster, shrimp, and crab were a great start to the meal. The filet mignon and lobster tail were the perfect combo. Melt in your mouth for the steak, perfect seasoning combination, lobster and drawn butter were fantastic. The desserts were Apple Cobbler, Sorbet, and Cheesecake. All were excellent ways to end the night, and no one walked away hungry. I would certainly recommend Mr. B's and would be glad to go back any time. Thanks to everyone out there! read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Apple Cobbler - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all

Just sad to even write this. No pics bcuz not even worth the bother. When we got sat was advertised two servers will be with us but we only had one that was odd. Wasn't asked if we wanted anything to drink when was given the menus by the server. Must have overheard us complain then came back to ask if we wanted a drink... altogether slow for a Saturday night at 6:30, painful. Many tables just sitting with no drinks or empty drinks or credit cards in the server billfold waiting to pay. Steaks were ordered medium and ended up med well and dry just sad all around. Will stick with carnivore, Mason street and 5:00 steakhouse. read more

My husband and I dined there last night. We weren't all that happy with our food. I ordered the chicken, because I use to really love it, but it was not great this time. Was dry, bad tasting, did not have much meat on it either. Potatoes were good though. It came with a salad on the plate that was tasteless, instead of the carrots I got the last time which were good. My husband just got a cheeseburger with fries. It was cooked properly, but he said it was not the best either. We both feel, for fine dining it should be better, even for what we ordered. We usually get steak, but this time felt like something lighter. On another note, I reheated the rest of my chicken and potatoes today and it was terrible. Small little chicken breast with terrible seasoning choice. I would not recommend this dish. read more

At Mr. B's you are greeted at the door. I recommend a reservation, but there is a nice bar to wait in if you don't have one. The service is always fantastic! Steaks are cooked to perfection, with terrific sides. The best part? They make brandy Alexander's the right way- with ice cream!! It is always a lovely time when dining there. read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

Went to Mr. Bs for a celebration and it was great! We got there early on a Friday and they couldn't seat us early (understandably cause they were busy), so I wouldn't recommend going early unless you're ok waiting. It's really nice that they had two people waiting on each table so they could give speedy service. We started with the crab cake that was very meaty and came with a creamy sauce and small salad. We then got the filet and shrimp combo. It came with a delicious filet that was cooked and seasoned to perfection as well as three jumbo shrimp. We got a couple sides to split including the lobster mac that was great! It had some but not a ton of lobster. Still good compared to a lot of other steakhouses we've been to. We also got the mashed potatoes and creamed spinach that were both great! We ended with the key lime tart that was also great and not too sweet. The vibes of the place are upscale but we didn't feel out of place with a toddler which was great. We would definitely come back! read more

got reheated steak for $80 because they could not cook it to order - for clarity three steaks all ordered medium and one out of the three was cleary less done. have bot been there for awhile, should have taken the hint since there was no one there on a friday night. read more

Our family visited for the first time and ordered a selection of appetizers and I ordered a chicken Caesar salad with fries on the side. The food was enjoyable - the chicken was fresh and juicy. However, the service was quite slow, even with two waiters assisting our party of about ten. The experience was similar to other Bartolotta restaurants, though it didn't stand out as exceptional. I'd consider giving it another try, but I'll likely stick to their other locations in the meantime. read more

Steak cooked to perfection in a custom 1100-degree wood-burning oven. That means your mouth will thank you. Be sure to order the mushrooms and onions because that and a glass of Cab will make for the perfect pairing. read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

First things first, we've been here multiple times throughout the years and have had absolutely the best experiences , until tonight. We were here for our anniversary and were looking for a special night. Before I dive deeper, the food and drinks were amazing! No complaints about that! Nancy (our 1st server) was amazing, no complaints except we wish it was just her serving us. Arnold on the other hand was the opposite. Un-attentive, mumble the entire time, seemed to be mumbling under his breath as well. Treated us very poorly like he expected we wouldn't tip well (yes we are younger but we work in the service industries and almost always tip over 20% no matter what, unless the service is poor). Have been coming here for years and have never had a problem before like this. Felt like our presence wasn't welcomed with Arnold. read more

My husband and I went out for our 18th wedding anniversary for a nice dinner along with our three kids. We made the reservation a night before using the OpenTable site. Found the time slot we wanted and noted the occasion. The next day Bartollota's called to confirm. Easy and convenient process. We were greeted quickly and seated quickly. Our waiter came to greet us and served our water as well as took our drink orders. Staff was attentive and friendly. The bread came hot and fresh. I don't like bread but could have eaten the entire basket myself. Sooo good. We ordered Calamari for an appetizer which came pretty quickly. For dinner 4 out of 5 ordered steak and my one kids had Lobster mac and cheese. All the steaks medium rare as requested even the kid's small steak came medium rare. Mine...I requested rare plus. Kudos for not over cooking it. The sides seem smaller than I remember. But the roasted Brussel Sprouts and button mushrooms were still good. Bernaise sauce was lighter and not as flavorful or rich as others I have had. Ended it with a complimentary raspberry sorbet. It was refreshing end to a heavy dinner. read more

See all

I was really torn on writing this review because I LOVE the Bartolotta group restaurants, but unfortunately this just did not hit the mark and realistically I wouldn't go again or recommend this location. (But the others are amazing and you definitely should try them out)! When I think of a Bartolotta Steakhouse I think upscale, high quality, and SUPERIOR service. (Aka lake park bistro - my favorite restaurant). However, even with 2 servers we did not feel this was an upscale service experience. Our servers didn't seem to like each other (just a feeling we got) and did not communicate well, we were asked the same questions by both - and offered the dessert menu twice at the end of dinner even though we had dessert FIRST. Both servers were friendly and pleasant when interacting with us however, they just didn't give off the superior service feeling and I didn't feel like they worked well as a team. The food was very flavorful and both our steaks were cooked to the perfect temperature. Also, We actually started our meal with a crème brûlée, which was absolutely perfect. The drinks, however, left some thing to be desired. we got an espresso martini and their coffee cocktail and neither screamed out to us with flavor. And then we attempted to order a bottle of wine, but unfortunately, our servers didn't know that much about the different wines and even took the menu from out my hands to read the description when I asked a question about a bottle. The bartender was very kind and came over and offered a sample of a different wine to see if I liked that without me asking which was amazing. But again at a Bartolotta restaurant I expect my server to be well-versed in their wine list if I'm paying that price point for a bottle, or at least have someone else on staff that can come and properly answer my questions. And a personal note, I hate the checkered tablecloths it does not give that clean/upscale vibe. The inside gave more suburb supper club vibes where you can enjoy with your family versus a fancy date night experience. (Which isn't a bad thing - if that's what you're looking for this is the perfect location for that.) Overall, this restaurant is very pleasant and if you have the money to enjoy it, absolutely go for it. But when my husband and I treat ourselves only once a year to a Bartolotta restaurant for our anniversary and expect an amazing meal from start to finish this just didn't hit the mark. read more

See all

Could not get in to Joey Gerard's so we picked this place. Our onion rings were given to another table (so they comped them) our dinners were delivered to the wrong server table and then moved to the correct one. Sat there for 5 minutes before our waitress realized it and took it back into the kitchen and walked around and talked with chef and then brought to our table. Said it wasn't the same one that I saw moved from server table. My potato was hardly warm (not hot) and my steak was rare and not medium well as I requested. She even asked me twice how I wanted it done. They comped that too and asked if there was anything that they could get for me. Sorry, I waited all day for this meal and now had no appetite. We will have to just wait for Joey's to have early opening. (They didn't have anything until after 9:00). Joe said his was good read more

I visited Mr. B's for the first time last night and I had a very pleasant experience. The food was delicious and the service was amazing. My party ordered two appetizers - lobster mac and cheese and fried calamari. The mac and cheese was absolutely incredible. The ratio of lobster to pasta was just right. You were able to get a bite of lobster with every forkful. The toasted breadcrumbs gave the whole dish a nice bit of texture and crunch. Although it wasn't anything revolutionary or mind blowing, the fried calamari was also yummy. We ordered two of the 44 oz. Porterhouse for two dinners, and the steak was cooked perfectly. I ordered it done medium, and it was exactly how I expected it. However, it wasn't sizzling hot. The first bite was pretty warm, but by the end of the meal it was venturing on the cool side. The Yukon gold potato purée was creamy and flavorful (although I forgot to take a photo of it). The loaded baked potato was also top notch. The glazed carrots were sweet and a little crispy on the outside but melt in your mouth soft on the inside. The asparagus was seasoned well and had a little bit of a crunch to it - not soggy at all. The shrimp cocktail was also good - but you can't really mess up cold shrimp with cocktail sauce. My mockjito was perfect. It didn't skimp on the berries and mint. Patrice, our server, was attentive and friendly. My brother and I were celebrating a special event, so she brought us each a little dish of peach sorbet with a candle. The sorbet was more icy than smooth, but it was still good. It was a really nice way to end the dinner. I think Mr. B's is one of those places you come for a celebration, but not for regular outings. The food is extremely expensive, but this is the best steak you will get in the area. So if you're willing to shell out a couple hundred bucks for a nice meal, I'd give this place a go. read more

See all

There are much better steakhouses in the area. The steak had good flavor, the onion straws were overly greasy. As for the service - I expected more, especially if it's 2 servers per table. There is no reason to wait 15 min for a drink (and not a cocktail, a glass of wine) on a Monday night. I also think it's inappropriate to chew gum and talk to your table at the same time. read more

I think they are way over priced. They do not include anything with the price of a steak. I live only a few blocks from there and will go somewhere else for my steak dinners. Kurt's in Delafield is more reasonable. They include salad and potato with the meal. I don't think the food is that great for the price. I will not be going back there again. read more

Had the ribeye and mashed potatoes. Was the best ribeye I've ever had out at a restaurant. We also enjoyed the haystack onion rings. Service was great! I would love to go again, but it's pretty pricey if not for a special occasion. 10/10! read more

First time visitors, we came in for dinner on Saturday 4/12/25. We had reservations and were seated promptly. We had 3 in our party, my wife, son, and myself. Beverages were served promptly and kept refilled throughout dinner. All three ordered the 8oz filet, with different sides. Everyone loved their steaks and sides. Son raved about the truffle fries (slight upcharge for those). We had a wonderful experience and will be back. read more

Fantastic food, 2 waiters to each table which is the Bartolotta restaurant model. Steaks properly cooked to perfection and the scallops were delicious. Looking forward to my next visit. read more

Fantastic spot for a special occasion. We enjoyed a family holiday meal at Bartolotta this December. The service is top-notch, the atmosphere is has a classic, classy feel, and the food is delicious. I enjoyed my fillet mignon (tender and full of flavor) and the sides of brussels. broccolini, mashed potatoes, and mushrooms. I also enjoyed the non-alcoholic berry fizz - so, so good! We ended the night splitting the apple crumble - yum! read more

We have eaten here literally dozens of times, however, the last few times both the service and food have gone downhill, fast. The bisque was lukewarm (17 dollars a bowl) scallops were cold, a medium-well steak was literally charred, black and dry (with no pink center). The baked potatoes were hard and one member of our party was served his crab cake, soup and salad all at once. Despite asking for his soup to be served first. Oh, and our server forgot our soup spoons. We waited 5+ minutes to get them. Overall, an awful experience. Will not return anytime soon. read more

We had a wonderful meal. The steak , a12oz fillet was done perfectly rare and came with Mushrooms and a wine sauce., the baked potato we shared was large and the skin was salted well. We had decaf coffee which was good. For desert we shared the crème brûlée Which was large and excellent. The building was well done and the Waite staff, of which we had two, were very good. read more

I enjoyed my first time at Mr. B's, where we enjoyed Easter brunch. The atmosphere of this restaurant is nice and elegant and the service is excellent. The food was great, being my highlights the salmon, pasta and French toast. I just would have liked to some kind of Easter decoration for pictures with my party. I think this is a great place for a date or a business meeting. read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Easter brunch mini cream puffs - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

Excellent steak, ordered the 18 oz angus ribeye, and cooked to perfection. Highly recommend the burbon peppercorn cream sauce to pair along with it. They also prepared an excellent whiskey old fashioned. read more

I saw a few other Yelper state this and it needs to be said again. I am a huge fan of the Bartolotta family of restaurants. Bacchus and the Bartolotta 1993 in Tosa are outstanding. So, I thought I'd take my dad to try out their steaks. He had the filet mignon and was throughly pleased. I, sadly, didn't have the same luck. The strawberry salad was dirt tasting and some of the strawberries were gamey. When I told the waiter he just replied with, "Oh. Alright. I can get them to make you another." Not a good start. Next, I had the 28 dollar pasta with eggplant. The pasta was flavorless and had a bit of a rubbery consistency. But, the eggplant hadn't been prepared correctly. It hadn't been salted prior and was a bitter, undercooked, rubbery chunky mess. I got a comp on the bill for the salad but paid for the pasta dish. This actually is common around town at steakhouses. They pride themselves for the steak and sod the rest. So, for the great steak, I give them a 5 and for the rest they got a 1. Split the difference and an OK is all I can muster. read more

Absolutely awful and less than average. The staff are a bunch of kids that have no professional waitstaff experience whatsoever. The host AKA manager could care less about your experience. And the food can easily be found at any Applebee's. read more

Let me be very clear, the food at Mr. B's was very good and would warrant a 4 star rating if all was "normal" in the world today -- however, this place has taken the COVID scare to a new level and has completely ruined the special experience that Mr. B's once was. I should have expected something was off when 1 hour prior to our arrival they contacted us to go over the COVID requirements but shrugged it off as they were just being extra thorough. I honestly thought that previous reviews of all the COVID restrictions were over the top ---- I was wrong. Unfortunately, Mr. B's is no longer a special place to relax and enjoy a nice dinner.....it has morphed into a painful dining experience and almost comical on the levels in which patrons are inconvenienced. I can get past the thermometer check before you even walk in, or even wearing the mask as you enter the restaurant.....but then the craziness begins... First we were required to follow the arrows on the floor to get to our table --- patrons must also follow the arrows to head to restrooms as well....God forbid you don't walk the right way, because you will be corrected by the designated hall monitors. Now let's get to the what I like to call the "Mask On, Mask Off" policy in place.......the servers will not even approach your table unless you have a mask on.....in fact, you REQUIRED to put a mask on whenever addressing an employee from your table. Place a drink order--Mask On. Talk to your table mate(s) -- Mask Off. Drinks arrive -- Mask on. Enjoy your drink --- mask off. Server shows up to go over specials --- Mask on..........I think you get the picture. Servers will stand at least 6 feet from your table holding your food/drink order UNTIL you put your mask on. Of course the server comes back to check on you (as they should), and they mask has to go on even through you are in the middle of the meal. One last little nugget --- they actually have the gall to charge you $4 per person as a COVID fee on the final bill!! The print is so small at the bottom of the menu, it is ridiculous. They will remove it if you ask, but again the way it is snuck onto the menu is a bit disturbing. I would have been fine had that been disclosed in the initial call to review the COVID guidelines, but it was not. Also, I would suggest the $4 per person fee be given to servers in the form of additional gratuity which I suspect many people would have no issue with. We have been loyal customers since 2006 and were really looking forward to going back now that they were open. I can say that we never need to go back after this experience. We have been to many fine restaurants in the area throughout the pandemic, and have never experienced anything this over the top. I have been to physicians since this pandemic began and have not experienced this level of prevention even in a healthcare setting. If you are this afraid of COVID then you should continue to shelter in place. read more

The service was subpar. The waitress forgot about us as it got busier. Our main meal took for ever to come out and the food was Luke warm. The wait staff never brought more water or asked if we wanted anymore drinks. We ordered dessert and again took forever that i had to ask the wait staff. The dessert was terrible, the blonde brownies were hard as a rock . I expressed this to the staff and the dessert was taken. We will never eat there again. read more

We have such amazing food and service every time we come here!! The lobster mac & cheese was our favorite appetizer! I got the filet mignon and it was perfectly cooked. All of the waiters and waitresses go above and beyond to make sure your meal is just what you want and ordered! Highly recommend!!! read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Lobster Mac n' Cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

We chose Mr.B's for a birthday dinner. We wanted to bring the kids along and found Mr. B's had a kids menu. It gave my daughter the opportunity to try her first steak at a restaurant. She gave the kids steak a 5 star and is already asking when she can go back. Didn't get too many photos because we were too busy enjoying the atmosphere and fine food. From the bread basket to the flourless chocolate cake everything was delicious. Wife had the scallops and found them to be perfect, did mention that she would prefer them on a bed of risotto but aside from that she was satisfied. I had the New York with the loaded baked potato. The flavor of the steak is remarkable and you can tell they really take the time to prep the steaks. We also had the wedge salad which was a perfect size, full of fresh ingredients. Service was 5 star, they kept all the beverages full, cleared the table quickly. We will definitely be back, with the kids. read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - New York Strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

We had a very disappointing experience on NYE, steaks were subpar, service was good, but can't get over how blah the steaks were.

As a Bartolotta this restaurant is already going to be known as a "great" in the Milwaukee area. The food did options did not disappoint. The "meat display" was interesting, informative, and kind of a clever idea. The food itself was perfectly cooked to order. All the things I've come to expect out of this brand. I was here with a party of nine and the biggest issue I had was that the dinner was a 3+ hour affair. I felt service was a little slow, appetizers didn't hit the tables until an hour and fifteen minutes after we were seated, and through the course of the night I was only asked once if I wanted a drink refill. This meant two drinks the entire night over three hours. For a social event like this I would have hoped service would be more on point and the servers would be better about keeping drinks full. The server wasn't very good about water either, in fairness. Lastly, the menu sizes are super awkward and unwieldy. Especially since we had them in our hands through the appetizers. Many of us ultimately just put them on the floor but it was an awkward and odd situation. read more

Mr. B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - 40 day dry aged steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

As before the steaks were not cooked to requested level.... How does a steak place stay in business if they are unable to cook them to perfection?? Plus the Caesar salad was so overdressed...who does that any more? WOW However the waitstaff were accommodating and constantly checking with us. Only pleasant thing about Mr. B's because the table we were seated at had every other person walking by or stopping and talking to each other loudly. What a night!! read more