ST PAUL FISH COMPANY · YELP ASSISTANT
Ask Yelp Assistant
St Paul Fish Company Photos
St Paul Fish Company Popular Dishes
ST PAUL FISH COMPANY ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like St Paul Fish Company
Recommended Reviews - St Paul Fish Company
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
2 months ago
16 days ago
16 days ago
3 months ago
2 months ago
25 days ago
3 months ago
8 months ago
6 days ago
4 months ago
1 month ago
2 months ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
Page 1 of 40
More info about St Paul Fish Company
400 N Water St
Milwaukee, WI 53202
Historic Third Ward
Directions
(414) 220-8383
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.stpaulfish.com/
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
St Paul Fish Company Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - St Paul Fish Company
How busy @ 5:30 on Saturday's?
Once HH starts it's busy because it's a small bar. But most likely no HH on the weekend call to make sure.May have to wait but worth it. Get the giant Bloody Mary , it's a meal in itself with lobster tail & more. Daily specials are...Mon. Mussels,…
What is the best time to get a seat inside on a Wednesday?
We've gone on various days. Any time before 4:30p it's very easy to get a table inside. A large group may be an exception.
How busy it is on Sunday afternoon?
It gets very busy towards the late afternoon. They do take walk-in reservations and give you a buzzer. What we always do is go a little earlier than the time we want to eat, put our reservation in and walk/shop around the market. Then when your…
We are hoping to dine here this coming Saturday, perhaps around 5-530. What amount of wait time might we expect at that time? Thank you!
At that time on a Saturday can be pretty busy but I think not more than 30 mins
Is your seafood flown in daily? Where are your shrimp sourced from?
Sunday afternoon is a better time to go in the evening at sometimes very packed
Lobster rolls - Silly question but my lady wants me to ask... The cold lobster salad in the roll is made with mayo? She hates may but wants a lobster roll...
I'm pretty sure the lobster roll is bound together with some mayo from the ones I saw people ordering there. I can tell you it doesn't look like it's much though as they really pack in the meat! I'm sure she won't be disappointed. Been there many…
If it's too busy, can you order your food & drinks, and then go enjoy them in the upstairs area?
Yes you can.
Are there certain menu items that are better when ordering to-go?
I love the lobster roll and tuna salad there! The raw oysters are so fresh and delicious. I would stick to non fried items for to go options! Those might be on the soggy side by the time you eat them.
I am wanting to take my sister out for dinner for her birthday and she loves seafood. I would have a party of 6 and a toddler. Would it be possible to accommodate all of us?
Yes. But if you've never been, this place is very crowded and in the midst of the Public Market. It is NOT a stand alone restaurant. The food is great, but not your typical restaurant. Always very crowded, very casual and lively!
What's the difference between their Friday lake perch fry and their daily perch fry?
The same but cheaper on Friday from 4 till 8.
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
108 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
4 months ago
4 years ago
9 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
8 years ago
7 years ago
5 years ago
9 years ago
3 years ago
2 months ago
11 years ago
7 months ago
5 years ago
St Paul Fish Company - seafood - Updated November 2026
Best of Milwaukee
People found St Paul Fish Company by searching for…
Trending Searches in Milwaukee, WI
Alaskan King Crab Legs near St Paul Fish Company
Breakfast Burrito near St Paul Fish Company
Breakfast Sandwich near St Paul Fish Company
Cajun Food near St Paul Fish Company
Catfish near St Paul Fish Company
Chain Restaurants near St Paul Fish Company
Chowder near St Paul Fish Company
Coffee & Tea near St Paul Fish Company
Comfort Food near St Paul Fish Company
Early Bird Special near St Paul Fish Company
Farms near St Paul Fish Company
Filipino Grocery Store near St Paul Fish Company
Fresh Pasta Store near St Paul Fish Company
Fried Catfish near St Paul Fish Company
Fried Fish near St Paul Fish Company
Gumbo near St Paul Fish Company
Hispanic Market near St Paul Fish Company
Hot Pot near St Paul Fish Company
Jambalaya near St Paul Fish Company
Japanese Supermarket near St Paul Fish Company
Lobster Roll near St Paul Fish Company
Mexican Bakery near St Paul Fish Company
Mexican Breakfast near St Paul Fish Company
Oyster Happy Hour near St Paul Fish Company
Popcorn Shops near St Paul Fish Company
Prime Rib Special near St Paul Fish Company
Ramen near St Paul Fish Company
Restaurants Serving Thanksgiving Dinner near St Paul Fish Company
Restaurants That Take Reservations near St Paul Fish Company
Seafood near St Paul Fish Company
Soup near St Paul Fish Company
Southern near St Paul Fish Company
Spanish Restaurant near St Paul Fish Company
Steakhouses near St Paul Fish Company
Surf And Turf near St Paul Fish Company
Sushi Lunch Special near St Paul Fish Company
Browse Nearby
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Restaurants near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Coffee near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Things to Do near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Parking near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Breakfast near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Desserts near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Sushi near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Cocktail Bars near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Wineries near St Paul Fish Company
BEST of Milwaukee, Wisconsin Shopping near St Paul Fish Company
Browse Brands
Related Searches in Milwaukee, WI
Best Bar and Grill Experiences in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Clam Chowder Options in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Crawfish Restaurants and Vendors in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Dim Sum Places to Try in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Fish & Chips Restaurants Near Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Fish Restaurants to Try in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Fish Tacos Served in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Fresh Seafood Selections in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Mussels Served in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Oyster Bars to Visit in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Oysters Rockefeller Dishes in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Places for Brunch in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Places for Margaritas in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Places for Poke in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Soul Food Dishes in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Best Vegan Restaurants to Try in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Browse Local Meat Shops in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Browse Organic Grocery Stores in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Browse Popular Seafood Markets in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Browse the Finest Cheese Shops Found in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Delicious Cajun Seafood Specialties in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Delicious Cheap Seafood Deals Found in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Delicious Pasta Dishes to Try in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Delicious Soup Spots to Try in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover All You Can Eat Sushi in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Authentic Filipino Food in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Authentic Indian Food in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Authentic Italian in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Great Seafood Boil Spots in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Top Japanese Market Spots in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover Top Mediterranean Food in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover the Best Breweries in Milwaukee, Wisconsin Today
Discover the Best Cajun Food in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Discover the Best Sushi Spots in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy Alaskan King Crab Legs in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy Authentic Crawfish Boil Events in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy Fried Fish Specialties in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy a Classic Lobster Dinner in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Enjoy the Best Cocktails in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore BBQ Restaurants Near Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Chinese Supermarket Choices in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Crab Restaurants Around Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Delicious Sandwiches in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Delicious Vegetarian Food in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Fresh Fish Markets Around Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Explore Popular Cocktail Bars in Milwaukee, Wisconsin




































































































































































































