I have recently started visiting local coffee shops as a treat for myself on the weekends. I decided to try Cream and Sugar and it did not disappoint! I ordered the Hug in a Mug and it was possibly the best combination of flavors I've had in a coffee. Steamed milk, morning blend and brown sugar. Just delicious!! I will be back to try more of their coffees and delectables. read more

Gorgeous inside, and my muffin (although $6) was delicious! The cashier was really sweet. They seem to be really popular and mid-morning on a weekday, there was a line almost out the door. I heard of them through their great social media marketing and creative drinks they advertise. Downside: Definitely not a great stop to grab and go on your way to work. I stood there waiting just over 10 minutes for a small iced matcha, and it was chunky and not well mixed at all (perhaps because the only barista working was so busy). I tried to mix it more with a hand frother at home and there was just a lot of sticky residue at the bottom of the cup. I couldn't salvage it into something appetizing and just tossed it. read more

Stopped into Cream & Sugar. Inside is absolutely adorable and such a cozy spot! I grabbed a classic coffee, which was good (just a little on the sweeter side than I prefer). My husband ordered a coffee with just a splash of milk, but unfortunately it came out much sweeter with a lot more milk than he asked for, which was a bit disappointing. Overall, still a cute place with a great vibe! read more

See all

Cute cafe. Can get crowded and kinda loud depending on the number of people in there. Crowded also by the door as that's where the line stars. Staff is friendly and answers questions. Highly recommend the tomato confit ricotta. Latte was good but could have been a little more favorable. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Tomato confit ricotta and linzer tart latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

In the mood for some ice cream, I stopped in here a month ago when the weather was warm out. It has a coffee shop vibe with ice cream and milkshakes too. The staff was friendly and welcoming when you walk thru the doors. They have a wide variety of flavors. The prices are a bit pricey, but the ice cream was delicious and creamy. Will definitely return to try some of the other options. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - First visit - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

This is a cute coffee shop that's more than just a coffee shop. They have a pretty big menu with lots of sweet and savory breakfast / lunch options and ice cream! Plus a huge selection of unique coffee drinks. We tried - french toast sticks, chicken nuggets and ricotta toast. Prices are a bit high but all of the portions were really big. I wouldn't expect great chicken nuggets at a spot like this, but they were actually so delicious. My kids gobbled up everything, and we even took the cutest ice cream cone sugar cookie home. My husband said that the ricotta toast was super fresh. The inside isn't too large, but they have a good amount of outdoor seating. This is definitely a great new local spot, and there's not much else like it in the direct area which is a big plus. read more

See all

Have you ever seen a prettier coffee Cream and Sugar makes the most colorful and tasty coffees! I ordered a special Laffy Taffy Latte, which is a banana latte topped with strawberry cold foam (an iconic duo). I absolutely loved it, both the syrup and cold foam have such a refreshing, fruity flavor! My partner got a lavender cold brew and for starters the color is gorgeous! It had such a potent lavender flavor too which was so nice! read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Such a great cafe to hang out in! Great drop in location and always full of customers! Local favorite read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Local realtor - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Cream and Sugar is a relatively new coffee shop on Sussex Turnpike in Randolph. I stopped in here on a Saturday morning and there was a good crowd. After waiting on line for a few minutes, I ordered a large drip coffee and a cream filled croissant. The coffee was very good, but the croissant was just so so. All of a sudden there are lots of coffee shops in this area. I would just suggest improving the baked items here. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Been to Cream and Sugar a few times now and really love the made to order food options as well as the delicious chai latte! I think it's a bit pricey for what you get, but staff is friendly and the atmosphere is great for doing work or meeting up with a friend. But it seems lively!! I do wish there was a recycling / liquid dump for ice and cups. Or real mugs for those who want to sit!! Would be so much less wasteful. Otherwise I am excited to return again soon! read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

I'll never say no to trying a coffee shop I haven't been to yet. My friend and I randomly found Cream and Sugar during a search for coffee based on the area we were in. The shop is in a convenient location and has ample parking. Upon entering, you can get a clear look at the menus and what seasonal offerings are available. There were so many options to choose from, and we both went with a holiday drink for our first visit. The staff were friendly and patient, explaining what treats were on display since my friend had a sweet tooth that day. We finished our order and plopped onto some bar stools to yap and recap over our coffee. Although the space isn't huge, it's a pretty decent size, and the layout allows seating with tables. They've clearly prioritized making good use of the space available. I thoroughly enjoyed my drink and found the coffee base itself to be very pleasant. I can't wait to return and check out the next rotation of seasonal drinks. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Very beautiful coffee shop and bakery. The first thing that catches my eyes is the decor. I feel like I'm in an old time parlor shop but it's also very trendy. I tried the matcha marshmallow latte and it was delicious- not super sweet at all. Their banana and strawberry toast was also very good too. Cant wait to come back and try some ice cream! read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

This is a cute establishment located in town. The staff was very friendly and the order was fresh. There are a handful of tables close to the door and I wish the heat was on stronger?? It was bit to cold in there for me to want to stick around longer and yes it is winter but still. The Americano was delicious. It was hot and strong. The dirty chai as we know should be chai with a shot of espresso. How ever the Espresso here over powers the chai flavor which is a bit disappointing. The food was great. We waited 5-8 mins for it which just meant they were preparing it and it wasn't something just tossed in a microwave. The croissant was flaky and my favorite part is the fig jam with the cheese. The frittata flavor wise perfection but the frittata its self was luke warm I would have preferred it a bit hotter.. read more

See all

We love Cream and Sugar! What a great add to Randolph's community. We love stopping by for a quick coffee fix as well as taking the kids for an ice cream date. Place always have people in and out, and sometimes they form a line, however, the orders are ready pretty quickly. Still want to try some of their bites, but love the special drinks menu. Ambiance is good for a quick stop, since they don't have much space inside is not a place to hang for hours but perfect for a coffee date. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Cinnamon muffin - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Delicious late's and great variety of flavors. Very creative with their beverages. Always very warm and friendly staff when you walk in. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Blueberry pancake late - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I've been dying to come in to this small coffee place in Randolph NJ. It is very cute the decor is nice. Not far from my home and I drive by it on my way to one of my jobs. The young lady who was my cashier was very sweet and greeted me nicely! Since it was 11ish I decided to go with brunchie items so I chose a cortado 12oz and ham and Swiss croissant. I've never had a 12 oz cortado but went with it. The young lady asked me if I wanted my croissant warmed up so that was nice There are approx 7 to 8 tables inside and 2 outside. They have a counter seating too. I wanted to sit in a inner table away from the door but 2 of their females customers decide to stand near 3 of the empty tables and chit chat ...not realizing they are hoarding 3 empty tables ...they could have moved to the countertop and stood there but that's just my common sense. I received my cortado and it didn't seem like 12 oz. But that's ok if the taste is ok...but the ratio was a bit off. But wasn't bad. The croissant was very fresh and delicious. Not much ham but it's there lol. Definitely a good place to stop and try. They have ice cream so perhaps another visit to try that out is in the near future. I love supporting local businesses so if you are in the Randolph area on sussex turnpike pop on over and give it a try! Enjoy ! #tastebudadventures #yelpelitesquad read more

See all

Such a great little mom and pop coffeeshop. I loved the latte I had and the cookie was delicious. It's really the type of place you feel the love baked into every bite. read more

Great decor and friendly staff. Been here twice and definitely like their cappuccino. Also tried the French toast sticks ($9.99). Prices are definitely high. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

This is a cute cafe! Very old-world and cozy. It's small, and the line is right at the door so even if there's a few people it becomes tight. The food and coffee are okay, nothing to write home about. I feel like the flavorings could be a loooot stronger, I barely tasted mine. read more

Charming new-ish ice cream cafe with that old timey feel. Almost reminds me of something out of Mary Poppins. It's cute with an extensive menu. Coffees. Ice cream. Sandwiches. Snacks. Their baked goods, as one other Yelper stated, could use an upgrade. The croissants & muffins just looked sad. The place was insanely busy but it's a Saturday. Despite all that, I was greeted very kindly. Got The Affogato and it was heavenly! Simply perfect! So happy I stumbled upon this place! read more

See all

We love having Cream & Sugar in town! Perfect for a caffeine fix, a quick lunch, or a sweet treat. This has become our go-to spot several times a week. The staff is always nice and helpful, and the space is beautiful. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Avocado toast - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Ordered the chicken salad on a croissant although it was yummy, for $10.99 I was lucky if there was a tablespoon of chicken salad in the sandwich, also menu said it came with greens, which I would assume is some kind of salad on the side, and it didn't. read more

Went on a Sunday morning and the place was jammed packed. The staff were friendly and handled the crowd efficiently. There are tables but they were all full. We had lattes (iced and hot) and a blueberry muffin. All was delicious albeit a little expensive. read more

See all

Stoped by to get an iced mocha with almond milk on my way home. This is a cute new coffee place and they were super nice. They have their coffee, snacks and they even have ice cream, their Flavors nicely displayed. Their croissants, muffins and cookies look good, but sadly i didn't get any to try this time. What i liked was that my iced mocha was not super sweet. Maybe next time i come i will try one of their seasonal favorites. Overall this place was cute with indoor seating only and the service provided was great. read more

See all

Having a cute coffee shop on my way to work is definitely going to be dangerous! The first thing that caught my eye was the pastries and treats right at the counter. The vibe is very trendy yet cozy. What sold me was the large variety of specialty lattes - it was so hard to choose! They even had cute seasonal ones for Valentine's Day. I will definitely be back. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Inside - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

I am obsessed with this little shop only had munchy items. Avocado toast is killer. Can't wait to try their ice cream love their hours.

First time trying-definitely an extensive menu for a coffee shop-with bites to eat and lots of coffee choices, along with specials menu. Got a specialty latte that was good and now I wanna go back to try more! It's cute there with an ice cream parlor type feel, good amount of tables and wifi to work if desired. Staff was nice and polite read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Blueberry pancake latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Second time here I thought it might be a little better. Coffee is terrible. Ordered a pistachio coffee tasted like dirty water had no flavor will not be stopping here anymore. Plus it was very expensive. read more

We are always looking for a new place locally to have ice cream and Cream and Sugar is a great find. The ice cream was excellent, they have coffee and espresso's too. The place is clean and the service was great, very friendly which is nice. The place has the old world ice cream parlor vibe which is nice. Would definitely recommend it if you are looking for some good ice cream. read more

Best coffee in NJ. I live in Mendham with Dunkin, Starbucks, Simple Coffee, Mendham Bagel. But I know if I go for convenience that I'm cheating myself out of a great coffee. I typically get a cold brew iced coffee black, my brother gets the Americano, my wife gets one of the fancy lattes that I generalize as a "fat girl" coffee drink (not saying she is fat - she isn't). We all think they have the best coffee. Starbucks doesn't even come close. El Monte's in Chester comes in 2nd behind these guys. I like black coffee - so I don't have a bunch of sugar and milk influencing my opinion. I consider Cream and Sugar to be the "breaking bad" of coffee shops - Walter White must be in there making sure everything is completely perfect with the brew process. That's as high of a compliment as I can give anyone. I hope you keep your current "standard" of excellence going and it doesn't degrade bc you are providing a real gem to the community. By the way the woodwork and design of the place is really well done. They must have dropped a fortune on all the wood work and moldings alone. Awesome place! read more

I had such high hopes for this place but I was truly disappointed in my experience. I really enjoyed the aesthetic and the menu looked great. I decided to order one of their seasonal drinks-- the Blueberry Cold brew Latte. I've had a lot of blueberry coffee drinks at different places and personally love the ones at Beanbury in Roxbury-- they have a delicious and really natural tasting blueberry syrup. This is sort of what I was expecting. I hate to sound dramatic but the drink I was served was borderline offensive. It looked disgusting and not at all what I was expecting. I'm really not a fan of the overly artificial and dyed looks to their drinks, and I seriously think that the vast majority of folks ordering blueberry would not want their drink to look like this, as it was not at all disclosed that it was full of dye-- in fact it literally said it came with "vanilla" cold foam. If I had to guess I seriously would have assumed this to be a "Superman", "birthday cake", "Cookie Monster" latte, and I feel like that's how it should have be advertised, because who in their right mind expects a blueberry cold brew to look like this? The taste was not any better--extremely artificial and left a weird taste in my mouth. I really wanted to like this place, I'll probably come back for ice cream another time but seriously, I think they should consider laying off the extremely artificial tastes and overly colorful looks, as it's a huge turn off and makes the drinks look tacky and gross, especially when this is not what first-timers are expecting when they order and it's not explicitly stated‍ read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - Blueberry Coldbrew Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Delish breakfast at this adorable new cafe in Randolph. Clean, well staffed, 7 tables and a few bar stools. read more

Cream and Sugar NJ - French Toast Sticks - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Great ice cream. Need to go back for the coffee and pastries . Nice decor and pleasant staff

Big fan of Cream and Sugar! The coffee is stellar and I love that they are always coming up with new monthly drinks concoctions. The baked goods are some of the best around - especially the heavenly muffins and chocolate chip cookies. Their ice cream is so fresh and creamy, too! To top it all off, they have the friendliest service and a calm, welcoming environment. So happy to have them in our town! read more

Food here is amazing as well as the drinks. Service is super quick and everyone is pleasant. Reminds me of a cute cafe with a little city vibe. read more

Welcoming feeling, Best in town, in a league of their own !! You will not be disappointed and make it a regular visit !