I've been to Black River Barn a few times now and it's a solid local bar/grill. The menu has a ton of options, so there's something for everyone. Most recently, I've had the California Chicken Avocado Salad, Buffalo Chicken Wings, and the Barn Angus Burger. The portions are great and prices are reasonable. Service is pretty good. I noticed during my last visit our server had tables both inside and outside, so she was trying her best to juggle both. Parking can fill up quickly on busy nights but you can usually find a spot if you're patient. They have a beautiful outdoor patio area with lots of seating overlooking Black River Pond. FYI, there are some really cute turtles in the pond if you look closely :) Buffalo Chicken Wings: 5/5 California Avocado Salad: 4/5 Barn Angus Burger: 4/5 read more

See all

The crispy eggplant sandwich was lacking .. eggplant! We mentioned to the waiter and granted after we were winding down dinner, but no one did anything about it. You might want to rename the sandwich a "whole lotta bread and hardy any eggplant sandwich" to be more accurate. They charge $14.00 for this empty sandwich. They also don't put drink prices on their menu so you don't actually know what you are spending. Not a good experience. read more

Black River Barn - Empty sandwich. - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Food is delicious. Variety is very good. Waitress super nice and on top of things.Ambiance is very welcoming. I totally recommend Black River Barn. read more

I came here for a special occasion on a beautiful spring day so of course it was very busy and there was a line for outdoor seating. However, my party chose to sit around the bar. Upon entering they had run out of menus so we were sitting and waiting for menus for quite some time, passing around the one menu we did have. Overall service was great and they were accommodating for our larger party. The food was ok. I ordered the filet sandwich which was bland and required additional salt. However the bread it was served on was soft. Overall, I would come here again maybe at a less busy time but would probably order something else from their extensive menu. read more

We came here on St. Patrick's Fay for dinner. Walking in I thought no way would we get seated but to my surprise, they said they could seat us shortly. The place was packed, green beer flowing, Irish dancing and a bagpipe player! It was such a fun and lively atmosphere! The staff was excellent attending to everyone amongst the busy atmosphere waters and drinks were received quickly! We ordered a few appetizers, calamari, which was fine and Bavarian pretzels which were excellent!!! For dinner I ordered a Greek chicken and rice bowl. They were very accommodating in cooking my chicken with my beef/pork allergy. It was good, but not enough rice I thought. A few in our party purchased burgers, excellent, pizza, very good, and some boneless wings. Everyone enjoyed their food. We left feeling festive and full! read more

See all

Stopped here totally by chance because where we wanted to go changed their policy on the items we wanted to try. My husband ordered the sauerbraten platter and I ordered the pierogi bratwurst appetizer. Both were fantastic! We were lucky enough to sit outside on a beautiful day , and there were bees and bugs galore. We are in our home, not the other way around! My only removal of a star had to do with the server of another table using the bus table to set down plates and the smell of mulch / bees in our food. Would definitely come back again all things considered! read more

Black River Barn - Water and the bus table in front of our seating. - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

It was a gorgeous day to sit outside on the large deck and enjoy live music by Dante Max. Even though it was super busy, the wait staff was attentive and accommodating. https://www.instagram.com/dantemaxmusic?igsh=MTE4YW9sdzRwc2k5MQ== I ordered the fall special burger w/ grilled onions, bacon, cheese and thin apple slices. It was served w/ homemade chips. Hubby ordered the gumbo then got the sirloin burger and onion rings. My daughter got the grilled chicken / honey mustard wrap. She opted for fries and instead of the salad and we all shared our sides. We were to full to order desert, but will go back and sit outside to enjoy it all again. read more

See all

The fries were okay but could have been more salt.But they were very kind just took so long for the food to come about 20mins.But unfortunately the restaurant was not clean at all. read more

I've been living in this area for 5 years now finally got to try this restaurant on Sunday and I was a bit disappointed by the service and food quality. We came in around 730ish and we had asked our waitress if there was a menu for the smoked meats since this was advertised on one of the signs, she had no idea what we were talking about. My husband ordered the steak off the Cinco de Mayo menu and it was supposed to come with Spanish rice. He got a heaping mountain of mashed potatoes and asparagus that tasted like it was 3 days old. The chimmichurri also had this weird grayish color. The food did not taste fresh at all. We told our waitress and she couldn't care less. The other person in our party ordered the pizza which he said was good just the dough could've been cooked more. I ordered the street corn off the small plates menu and it was good. read more

Black River Barn - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Came with a group friends 8 people and we were seated immediately. This place is large with in and outdoor seating. Very all-American type bar and restaurant style. Our server Alfredo was awesome event though he seemed very busy. He got all of our orders right and he was nice. It got crowded so he was all over the place towards the end, but still good service. The pork chop and steak with the blue cheese crumble was excellent. No complaints about the ribs either. The desserts were also good and a great take home treat. Overall a good time was had. read more

See all

Came here on a Saturday afternoon for a family dinner, and the place was pretty busy as they were having a wedding! It was a very nice place right next to the river, but it did smell from time to time which wasn't great. We got their salad pizza and the nachos for appetizers. The pizza was okay, it would've been better if they had drizzled some olive oil or maybe balsamic over it. The nachos weren't really good, the chips weren't crunchy and the cheese was hard. For drinks I ordered a cosmo which was average, and my boyfriend ordered a strawberry refresher which unfortunately tasted like a white claw that had been left out in the heat. I got their Asian Rice Bowl - the shrimp was good, the vegetables weren't very savory and tasted overall bland, the brown rice was overcooked and reminded me of the ShopRite instant brown rice, which is not what you want to get at a restaurant. My boyfriend ordered a burger which was a pretty mid-rate dinner-like burger so not great. Overall, everything was very overpriced for the quality of the food. read more

See all

This review is for takeout orders only. We've ordered from Black River Barn multiple times. The burgers are excellent. Ordered the Cajun chicken Alfredo and seafood jambalaya this time. The food was flavorful as always. Both dishes were beautifully seasoned but could've used a bit more of a kick. The restaurant has a large parking which is always packed. One of these days, we'll have to do a sit-down dinner at Black River Barn. read more

Black River Barn - Seafood jambalaya - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

We enjoy going here during football season as it's very lively in the bar & the have good football specials. Other times we come we either sit in the bar out outside. Recently we sat outside & our waitress Laura was wonderful. We enjoyed our food - clams, meatball app, & cheeseburger. The wings are also a favorite of mine & we enjoy the pizza as well. They are very accommodating & will make changes to your meal no problem. Owner is always present & works very hard doing whatever is needed to ensure everyone is satisfied- definitely recommend! read more

See all

Have been a customer for close to 20 years, always excellent food and attentive servers, this is where the good stops. Sadly it appears this place has turned into a weeknight hub for narcotics and worse. Weekday nightlife here appears to be a criminal in nature. This isn't an embellishment, its activity our group has witnessed multiple times during a weeknight at the bar. We chatted with one of the locals here who advised she hosts online live view sites for pay and hinted she "befriends" men here. Many occasions we have witnessed ladies sitting all alone at bar, random guys approaches and after a short chat they appear to leave together. While none if this appears to be illegal, it's shady. The bathrooms are being used as open air drug markets. I have personally witnessed the physical exchange of baggies over stall doors, followed immediately by the audible use (snort) of the substances. Really? Weekends the place is packed all day/night with families and regular folks, its the slow weeknights that brings the shady characters out of the woodwork. My friends and family will no longer frequent this establishment read more

I booked my son's wedding rehearsal lunch with 29 guests. When we arrived I said the Reed party and was shown to the back room that was not our party. I came back to the host stand where I find out later was the general manager. He said that's your area over there not asking if I need anything at all or if this is all good. We all are swamped into a session that clearly was was too small to accommodate a party of this size. However if the manager was paying attention at all or the server. They would have tried to add a table on instead of some gift table set up that again if asked should know noone needs that . Because it's a wedding rehearsal lunch. Hence no gift table needed. As we squeeze into our seats that literally were back to back and smashing against the wall , the I guess server who never introduced his self . I thought he was just doing the waters. He brought out 1 on each table of 9/10 people a small plate of wet mozzarella and a larger salad but on one side of the table only and definitely not enough of that many guests. Then we were brought out a pizza thing that is the size that 2 people would have as an appetizer. We grew people were expected to somehow share then that was in for like 20 minutes . So everyone had bird sized portions that they were nervous to eat too much. So me the host mother of the groom completely embarrassed. I walk to the host stand to explain , not knowing at this point my so who manages for years knowing this is unacceptable. Spoke to the GM and said this is crazy we need food on each side of the table . I also said we have literally no food some guests choose not to grab anyfood so there wife's can have it. I brought this information mode you I can see the manager for my seat. So you should know and care about your guests and check on your party and introduce yourself to us . I was told by his after mentioning we have no food . That ready for it??? We should have asked for more!!! Um what? No you should bring out enough for all the party. Finally a waitress named Kyrsten . Saw the Chaos that was happening and she literally stepped up and turned the entire experience around. Not the "GM" the waitress who was not ours. However made us here number 1 priority. Because of here and only her , she made us feel like no longer had to worry or serve my guests and I was able to enjoy the experience with my family. Literally at point did he come into the room and try to make sure my guests were ok or apologize to them. This did not have to happen if in first place he acknowledged our party, and our guests. The food was very good and Kyrsten was hands down the best part of this experience. This is a day that I can't redo . It's my first borns wedding rehearsal. We were ignoring and that's not how you treat guests. read more

See all

Fathers day dinner for family of four started out great. First we had to ask for cutlery. Then our appetizers failed to arrive. The kids food was 15 minutes ahead of my wife and I, so we could not eat together. The steaks were tough and poor quality. NY strips. They are tasty, just not pleasant to eat. There was no butter with the baked potato, no steak sause offered for the steak, no ketchup provided for the frenchfries, and the black pepper was in the salt shaker. The server never came to check on anything, so we had to flag down whoever was coming by. It was not as busy as usual and staff was everywhere. The beer was perfect in every way so bravo to the bartender. The pizza was okay too. Everything else was a disaster. read more

We are loyalty members. I ordered vegetable califlower pizza. It was room temperature. I ate two pieces. I did not send back because I did not want the cook to burn it by putting back in oven nor did I want it microwaved. Probable will not order again. My other question, I have a disability, why are there only 2-3 spots in lot. I never parking spot there. It is such a large lot which is great but not to disabled. read more

I love this little tavern. I got put on to it by a friend once and I came back to try it again and I am glad that I did because the food is banging. The bartenders are cool AF and the clientele play good music through the TouchTunes jukebox. My new favorite bar in Morris County, New Jersey. read more

See all

They made my handicapped son's 46th birthday special with a complimentary appetizer and special attention from Wilmer. He gives my son an especially warm welcome. My fish and chips were filling, my husband's crabcake sandwich came with their wonderful sweet potato fries and my son loved his cheeseburger. read more

This restaurant had no wait when we came on a Friday night. The menu had plenty to choose from, and I opted for the Asian Stir Fry Bowl. The meal came out within 10 minutes and it was very good. Our waitress is very friendly and they were plenty of options for my four-year-old daughter. Great place! read more

Black River Barn - Asian Stir Fry - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Was very happy with our meal tonight. I ordered the greek chicken bowl and my friend ordered the salmon. Both of us are pretty picky about what we eat and where, yet we were both very satisfied with our food! Wilmer, our waiter, understood our needs and delivered. The owners were happy to speak with us as we were leaving and extremely friendly and personable. We will definitely be going back! read more

Compliments to the chef! In an era where it's hard to find chicken breast not overcooked and dry, the chicken fillet on the pecan salad was moist and tasty. The salad was fresh, the perfect dish on a hot summer day. The wait staff were very accommodating to the children in our party. This is a family restaurant - casual, not noisy - with tables far enough apart to have privacy yet be able to get an unobtrusive glimpse of others' dishes. read more

This time we were here with a small dog. It's a dog friendly restaurant! Service was good, better than last time we were here. We assumed it was because this time was dinner and last time was lunch. Different groups of people. All were good, food was delicious as well. The only thing was that the table we sat was outside and it was so dirty. We cleaned it ourselves. read more

Black River Barn - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I can't complain about the flavors, but for the pumpkin ravioli, the pumpkin was overpowered by the Gorgonzola cream sauce. They forgot my barn salad. Service was fast and friendly but not spot on for lunch on Saturday. The place looked like the inside of a barn but was decorated nicely and clean. read more

Black River Barn - Pumpkin ravioli - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Tons of seating both indoor and outdoor. Outside has a lake so it very pleasant. There is also a bar area seating. The food was excellent. It has been years since I went there and now I have to make sure to go back. The server was a bit slow and seemed to forget us but maybe he was new. read more

We have eaten at the Barn many, many times and the food is always great. They have a huge selection so there's always something for everyone. Recently we held my Mom's 80th birthday here in the River Room and our celebration was a huge success! Andrew and Tim were fantastic to work with during the planning process and definitely came through. The room was perfection (and it had a lake view which was a bonus!!!) and the food was amazing. Everyone kept complimenting the venue and the food the whole time. It was a wonderful, memorable event and I would not hesitate to have another celebration here again!! read more

See all

I've been coming to the Barn for YEARS and it's about time I gathered my photos and share a review! The food here is consistently filling and delicious! If you havent been.. you're SERIOUSLY missing out. My absolute favorite dish is the Grandma's Pasta Bowl with ricotta, pesto and marinara. It's so hearty that I always have leftovers for days!! Their seasonal specials and cocktails are fantastic and always change so I can always try something different with each visit. I can't say enough about the staff, they're always so friendly and welcoming like you're a part of the Barn family. read more

See all

Wilmer gave us excellent service throughout. Try their caprese salad plate, not on the menu, but still excellent. The atmosphere is definitely family-oriented, with a sports-bar touch. The veggie pizza had a thin crust, and we took some home. My fish and chips were filling, and tasty. Their bread bowl featured a brown bread that was a bit sweet. We sat near the open fireplace, and enjoyed the meal. read more

Great place! Didn't have to wait too long even though it was a crowded Saturday night. There was more seating than I thought there would be which is good! I liked there were TVs with baseball and final 4 basketball games on which added to the cool decor there too. I had crab cakes which were really good. I'd go back! read more

It seemed to change Pizza not really good Had pork and Mac and cheese It was cold and mushy.. Good waiter though Also it should get a facelift inside !! read more

Food & service were outstanding! Atmosphere was outrageous. Despite the fact that a repast was taking place & the restaurant was at near capacity, a noisy remodel was happening in the middle of the restaurant. This should have been done before or after hours! I love this place. Food is always good, staff is always friendly & efficient. My lunch was just a small, friendly gathering for the squash soup. I felt so sorry for the family having the repast. read more

Solid local bar with above average bar food, especially their pizza. Great for lunch, to watch sports or a casual dinner. read more

Black River Barn - The Barn's Turkey Club* - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Everything's always pretty good; love the disco fries - large menu & never disappointed

The food was excellent and I like the view of lake. Prices are reasonable. But the service was terrible. My daughter and I sat there for nearly 30 minutes. No one asked if we needed anything after we got our food. And waited and waited our server never came back. read more

We showed up with 20+ people and they were extremely accommodating. Restaurant was very roomie on the inside. Very large menu. Food was OK, decent bar food. Our waiter was very good and once we ordered food, The food came out very quick. Waiter was able to give each family individual checks and kept track of everyone very well. Would recommend of you are in the area! read more

Fast service and fun spot for Friday night! My dad is gluten free and said their gluten free pizza is very good, just took longer for his food to get there but it always was a busy weekend so overall a great time! I got the BBQ pulled pork and my mom got the chicken bruschetta and we were all happy with our meals. read more

Black River Barn - BBQ Pulled Pork - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

This restaurant sits right on the bank of a river/creek. The menu is very versatile and offers something for everyone. The house bread is a nice treat and went well with the saucy shrimp appetizer we ordered. Can't wait to come back in the spring/summer so I can enjoy the deck. read more

Quesadillas were great very yummy. Salad was good too however my friend asked for some shaved parm and the waitress gave us parm you put on top of pizza (shaved parm comes on the Caesar salad) and we asked if they had that instead but said the pizza cheese is all they have . Besides that food was good. But Wait was long , waitress not very attentive. read more

Black River Barn - Cobb Salad w chicken - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Loved our visit to black river barn! Food wasn't the best we've ever had but was very good; however the atmosphere was great, such wonderful service, beautiful patio and a huge menu to choose from. This was a really great restaurant with excellent service. read more

Black River Barn - Ribs, Mac&Chz, Shrimp - American Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Be very careful if hosting an event here. I opted for open bar for a brunch & the staff delivered drinks guest didn't request & kept upselling drinks to doubles & extra-large drinks. Within the first hour of guests arriving I hit my established limit, with only 20 people being there. I needed to double it!!! Mind you only 32 of my guests drank. So the average drink tally was as if every guest had 3 to 4 drinks per person in a 2 hour period. It was a Sunday brunch, I wanted self-serve bar service so staff could spend their time waiting on my guests this was agreed to when I booked upon arrival, I was instructed only wait staff could take drink orders. The full focus was on bar orders & reorders. One guest was delivered 4 additional mimosa without ordering and other guest did go directly to the bar for a second drink. The food was due to be served at 12 along with coffee, tea and juice, that didn't happen. No guest was offered coffee, tea or juice. The food was served at 1:20PM once my sister approached the staff & asked, When will you be serving food!!! Many of my guests arrived after 1pm due to traffic. The food was removed at 2:30PM. I expected 4 hours of food since I booked and paid for a brunch from 12-4. Cake was ordered and due to be served. Most guest were never offered cake. but guests should have been served instead mainly self-serve. Limit the bar at this restaurant to drinks, size and be clear on limit and self-serve. Also put someone in charge of keeping an eye on service and direct staff. No food was offered to take home. So expect to spend a lot more money here. Probably a better idea to use another restaurant even if the cost is 2.5 times the offered price of this restaurant. I was very disappointed in this type of treatment. I like to have a local restaurant to host events but it won't be here. Food was average. I did contact the restaurant and explain all of this, but I said I wait until after the holidays to hear back. I was sorry to hear from my guest I poled that this is a common practice at this restaurant, up selling from the bar is well known. I wish I'd known. Be guided Disappointed. read more