Cancel

Open app

Search

Craigo's Pizza

4.3 (90 reviews)
InexpensivePizza
Closed • Closed

Order Craigo's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Craigo's Pizza Photos

CRAIGO'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Craigo's Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Craigo's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Counter with menu above
Gary B.

Just getting off a 3 day camping and off road trip in the Paiyute region in Utah and being one of the few places (non-chain) open on a Monday we stopped in for lunch. Boy, am I glad that we did. This charming pizza joint was atypical. There was a map on the wall with nearly every country being represented as having visited. Pretty small place that had a small gift shop, a few games for children including a brio train set and some gum ball machines. They did a lot with a small space. Being the only car in the parking lot we had a brief thought of hesitation until we walked in and smelled the aroma of what could only be great pizza. We were greeted promptly by Catherine who had the kindest of smiles. We ordered a pepperoni calzone, a 16" pepperoni pizza, a meat lovers calzone and the cinnamon-twists all with a side of ranch. This place had a nice little spice bar with hot sauce, grated Parmesan, basil, crushed red pepper, and several other options to top off your pizza. I had the pepperoni pizza bomb (calzone.) Just 5.50!!!! it came out hot and fresh delivered to our table by Catherine. It had sauce on the inside; the dough was perfection with that red pizza oil that dripped down my fingers. The quality, price, and service absolutely exceeded expectations. The meat lovers calzone and thin crust pepperoni were equally good. We thought that the server had forgotten the cinnamon twists until we finished eating and Catherine brought out the hot dessert covered in homemade caramel sauce and a huge cup of fresh made thick whipped cream. Absolute heavenly taste. So, if you're passing through Beaver, Utah and are hankering for some good pizza stop in Craigo's An excellent choice and there's plenty of entertainment for the kids while you wait. Very pleasantly surprised by the entire experience.

Breadsticks with Cheese
Corynn B.

This place is the perfect stop on your way to southern Utah! It's definitely slower service, but it's worth the wait. After coming here a few times, I've learned to order about 30-45 minutes ahead and the order is typically done by the time you arrive. I believe you can order online but I've always called in my orders. They have a drive through as well, but I'm not sure what it's for as this is definitely not a fast food restaurant. We made the mistake of going through the drive through the first time we came, and ended up waiting a very very long time and ended up coming inside. The pizza bombs are aptly named, because they are THE BOMB! They're so freaking good. I always get the veggie pizza bomb - it has artichokes, mushrooms, peppers, Alfredo sauce. SO delicious and flavorful. I can hardly wait for it to cool down enough to eat it because it's so delicious. We also got the bread sticks this time and added cheese to them - we thought we would have leftovers but we scarfed them down so quickly. The interior isn't anything to write home about, but the food is incredible and worth the wait. The staff is also so kind and friendly! I make sure to stop here every time I visit southern Utah!

Breadsticks with Cheese
Bryan D.

Craigo's was an institution when it was in Rexburg, ID back in the 90's. There isn't a single student that attended Ricks College that didn't eat at Craigo's and enjoy the wonderful atmosphere, food, and live music. And the Breadsticks with Cheese were unbelievably awesome! No longer in Rexburg, the original Craigo's has reopened in Beaver, UT with the same great food and friendly staff. If you're traveling I-15 definitely stop in and try a Pizza Bomb or breadsticks. Call ahead to get the order started so it's ready when you arrive. I've missed Craigo's since I last ate there in 2004 in Rexburg and I'm so happy that they've reopened so we can pass this goodness now on to our kids.

I don't usually leave food reviews, but my son, my best friend, and I were passing through Beaver on a road trip and looked up food near us. This place stood out. I should mention that we were in a van, traveling for a week, living out of the van, and taking in Utah and Arizona's beauty. When we stopped for pizza in Beaver, our lives were changed. Allow me to explain. The pizza was incredible - the perfect crust and flavoring. You can really tell that these people take their pizza seriously. It was some of the best pizza I'd had in a while, so heavy that we ate it for an entire day; one piece was enough. Now, what happened is really why I'm writing this review. As I mentioned, we were traveling and not staying in Beaver. I realized about eight hours later that I had left my wallet somewhere, and I backtracked it to this place, but they were closed on Sunday, and my flight was Monday morning. So, I called them, and the lady was very nice, saying they had found my wallet and mailed it off. Three days later, my wallet with my ID and credit cards was in my mailbox. I highly recommend this place - get the Meat Lovers Pizza and the cheese bread; it's literally insane. Beaver is very lucky to have a place like this. 10 out of 10, I'm recommending.

two pizzas on a table
Chris S.

My wife went to college in Rexburg, ID back in the 90's. She always went on and on about Craigo's and their Pizza Bombs and breadsticks and how much she loved them. I went back to visit with her once after we began dating and I ate there once. I remember it as being fine but I don't always trust super old food memories, as my palate has developed and evolved over the years. I am probably one of the biggest pizza snobs you'll encounter now and if you lay that "there's no such thing as bad pizza" BS on me, I will gaze upon you in disgust and never trust any food advice you ever give me again, Thanks to Yelp and a need to find a place to eat in Beaver, a place that neither of us were familiar with during a trip to UT from our new home in LV, I discovered that Craigo's lives on. We knew it wasn't in Rexburg any longer because one of our kids is going to school there and it's definitely not there. We planned to stop and see if it was indeed my wife's beloved college haunt on our trip back to LV after spending a few days in Provo with our other daughter and her husband. We rolled on in and after examining the menu and chatting with the extremely helpful lady behind the counter, we discovered that it was indeed the place. My wife ordered a Pizza Bomb and some breadsticks and I ordered some pizzas for the other kids and myself. It was exactly as my wife remembered and it and she was very happy. I really liked the garlic chicken pizza I ordered for my youngest daughter and the Hawaiian I ordered for my middle kid. My Meat lovers would have been better without the sausage. I didn't care for the flavor and it was very salty but other than that, it was OK. The prices were great and I sampled everything that everyone else ordered and liked it all very much. We will likely stop here either coming or going every trip we take to UT going forward and our oldest and her husband stopped and tried it on their way down to see us a couple of weeks later and loved it.

Combination Pizza!
Sky T.

If you are traveling from Salt Lake City, Utah to Las Vegas, Nevada, and need some food midway through then this is a good breaking point to grab some 'za. This place has pizza that is made ready to order which can take a little bit of time, but there's no rush getting to Sin City because it never sleeps. The pizza dough is almost bread like and is a bit heavier than I would like, but it is definitely filling. It is next to a gas station as well so you can pump up while you grab some a slice. I like stopping here because of the location being halfway and it supports local business.

See all

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Dan M.
0
13
0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Friendly atmosphere! Best calzones in the world! Very clean place. Also try the salad! Very fresh!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Great home town pizza. Love the breadsticks too. Excellent service

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Yummy crust, friendly and helpful service. I will eat there again. Pretty good price especially for a small city.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Craigo's Pizza

How long should wait to get pizza?

15-20 mins tops

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

The Creamery - The Creamery stands tall in Beaver, Utah, with a view of the beautiful surrounding landscape.

The Creamery

4.1(758 reviews)
1.4 mi
•$$
Locally sourced ingredients
Kid friendly

Absolutely love this place but also have only had their ice cream. There's soo many flavors to…read morechoose from so beware that you can only sample 2 per person. You really cannot go wrong the ice cream tastes fresh & creamy. This spot is the perfect spot to stop if you're on a road trip. There's ample parking, nice/clean bathrooms and tons of outdoor seating. There's even corn hole & grassy area for dogs. We arrived right before closing and the service was quick and efficient getting us our ice cream. Super helpful knowing the flavors all while still being friendly. 10/10 will definitely be back. Just make sure you check the store hours. They close early during the week.

This place was HOPPING on a Sunday afternoon. They have ice cream scooped on the left side, merch…read morein the middle and food on the right side. Lots Of cheese curds, T-shirts, souvenirs. We got ice cream. I had the Ripe Raspberry chunk which was good. My friend had the cinnamon churro which was not cinnamon-y enough but still good. They have a big grass area for dogs & kids to play. And there was a dairy educational play room for kids inside. I bought a magnet & a sticker. It's worth a visit.

Photos
The Creamery - Enjoy a scoop of locally-made ice cream in our outdoor space during the warmer season.

Enjoy a scoop of locally-made ice cream in our outdoor space during the warmer season.

The Creamery - Our menu is dairy inspired and family friendly, from rich macaroni and cheese to oh-so-good grilled sandwiches.

Our menu is dairy inspired and family friendly, from rich macaroni and cheese to oh-so-good grilled sandwiches.

The Creamery - Fuel up at The Creamery Kitchen, open Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.

See all

Fuel up at The Creamery Kitchen, open Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Centro Woodfired Pizzeria

Centro Woodfired Pizzeria

4.6(1.8k reviews)
48.2 mi
•$$

This place is excellent! I had eaten here years ago and was so happy to discover that it's still in…read morebusiness. My husband and I had the Gorgonzola salad, which was HUGE, the meatballs and delicious, and a pizza split into two halves--Calabrese & sausage on one and fennel sausage on the other. We loved every bite! They also have a great beer and wine selection, which made the meal even better. If you're ever in the area, do yourself a favor and give this place a try. It's the kind of place I'm always excited to find again--and definitely one I'd come back to!

Our first stop upon arriving Cedar City is Centro to have some pizza. We went through the back…read moreside to park our car and went straight to the front. It was not crowded because it has passed lunch hours. The place is like any pizza parlors with more high tables a few standard height on the sides and front. The flooring seemed untidy. But overall it was cozy and relaxing. We noticed that there were a few businessmen dining. Apparently there are 2 conventions going on. We got seated right away and our server, Cassandra welcomed us with a big smile. She introduced herself and apparently she is from South Dakota and just started there two weeks go. She gave us all the info on their wood fired pizzas and made some suggestions. She observed that my husband and I have different tastes so she recommended to order half/half which was a great idea. My hubby opted for the spicy one for half and ordered my side to have artichoke and added mushrooms. She forewarned us that their salads are huge good for 4 people but it did not discourage us to order. Glad I did order as the Caesar's salad was fresh, crisp with lots of Parmesan shavings and the dressing was perfect. It tasted like it has a hint of anchovies which we love. By the time we were done with the salad, the pizza came and it was delicious! The red sauce topping was perfectly spiced and the white sauce topping on my side was flavorful. I normally like my pizza crust crispy but since it's oven fired, it was just as good. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal. The service was amazing and we will definitely go back the next time we are in town.

Photos
Centro Woodfired Pizzeria - Great Vibes Indeed!

Great Vibes Indeed!

Centro Woodfired Pizzeria - @ Centro Woodfired Pizza - 8/23/18

@ Centro Woodfired Pizza - 8/23/18

Centro Woodfired Pizzeria - Pollo Bianco

See all

Pollo Bianco

The Pizza Barn - 12" pizza with pepperoni and sausage

The Pizza Barn

4.0(75 reviews)
33.1 mi
•$$

YES!! I wish I lived closer to go back!…read more We stumbled upon this gem during our 17 hour road trip from San Diego CA - Colorado! We stopped in the small town of Parawan, Utah and stayed at the motel Mountain View Inn that was very cute!! And to our surprise the Pizza Barn was right next door! We were starving from our long drive and decided to try it, I was shocked at how amazing the pizza was and they even had gluten free options! (which I highly try to incorporate into my diet to reduce feeling sick) and it also helped us acclimate to the higher elevation. We loved everything about our experience! The pizza was fantastic, they had great service, very friendly and welcoming. We loved it so much we had it twice! When we arrived and on our way home. I wish there was another pizza barn in Cali!

We came to The Pizza Barn because pretty much everything else in Brian Head was closed, and it…read moreended up being a huge letdown--especially after a 50-minute round trip and waiting 30 minutes for our food. The spaghetti came with absolutely no sauce or meat--just plain noodles. We only realized after getting back, which was honestly crazy. The wings were overly gooey (honestly, 7-Eleven has better wings), and the pizza tasted like something straight out of an elementary school cafeteria. The salad even had the full root of the lettuce still attached. The chicken Alfredo barely had any chicken, and the sauce tasted like it came straight from a jar. And the garlic bread? Literally just a regular slice of bread with butter--nothing else. Overall, the food was extremely disappointing across the board. Also, the only menu photo on Yelp looks like it was uploaded about 6 years ago and there's no real website, so I'm posting an updated photo of the menu to help others out.

Photos
The Pizza Barn
The Pizza Barn
The Pizza Barn - Menu (front)

See all

Menu (front)

Bar86 - Tater tots loaded

Bar86

4.6(100 reviews)
44.0 mi

We arrived at this bar and restaurant as part of the Harvest Host program while passing through…read moreRichfield Utah on our RV trip. We went into the bar and restaurant and were greeted by the hostess who asked for out IDs so she could scan them. (They scan everyone's ID, so be sure to have it with you when you go into the establishment. There is a large selection of draft beers. The menu is pretty large with everything from sandwiches to pizza and tacos. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and some carne asada tacos. The tacos were amazing and their pico de gallo was very tasty. The pizza was a good size for the price. This place is great. The food is tasty l, the beer is cold, and the seats are comfortable. Most important of all, the prices are absolutely reasonable for the quality and portion sizes. This is a must visit for my return trip to Richfield.

Bar 86 is a nice watering hole in an alcohol free desert known as central Utah. Primarily looking…read morefor a place to eat we stopped by on our trip from the Red Rock country of Southern I Utah to Salt Lake City. The bar is a bit off the I-70 freeway, but not too far. It is spacious inside with large tables and a friendly, welcoming staff. I had a margarita with my lunch; only one though because I was driving. It wasn't strong but was tasty enough. The beers are mostly domestic with only one micro brew selection but there were plenty of national brand choices. The food was home made and not bad for bar food. I had a Pittsburgh cheese steak sandwich that I thought was good. I ordered it with a side salad instead of fries as I had also ordered the loaded Pastrami fries which came with cheese, pickles and mustard on top. It was a bit too rich and heavy for my taste and the flavors didn't really work well together. Maybe without the mustard I would have liked it more. Not a bad place for a rest stop or a reasonable local hang out as well with some decent food.

Photos
Bar86 - Interior pool tables

Interior pool tables

Bar86 - Cauliflower crust steak and cheese pizza was fabulous.

Cauliflower crust steak and cheese pizza was fabulous.

Bar86 - Sprite and Jameson.

See all

Sprite and Jameson.

Craigo's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...