We have been here several times and always enjoyed the selection of beer and wings. I used to get the build a burger all the time. Unfortunately the burgers are now either undercooked or over done. I got a salad with oysters instead and the oysters were perfectly prepared. read more

Food is bland. Drinks are alright. Our bartender was friendly she clocked out not too long after we left and the young lady who took on the bar was prepping drinks in front of us and a gnat was in one of the glasses, in front of the customers at the bar she had another employee remove it and continued to serve the drink. That was just nasty. Not to mention all the girls were comfortably talking to each other on how much they didn't want to be there, loud and proud. Many lack professionalism. read more

Very nice atmosphere with a lot of indoor and outdoor (covered) seating. Very friendly waitress that was very helpful and attentive. Great selection of burgers and pizzas. One of the better burgers I've ever had and probably top 5 best pizza I've ever had. Overall, great place with great staff and great food read more

See all

Got a Hawaiian pizza to share. It was delicious. And the staff was very friendly. At one point, my wife looked at me and said, "This is very good! Almost as if we are actually in Hawaii!" I spent the rest of the meal in silence knowing that I will never be able to take her to Hawaii because I have a (reasonable) fear that islands will sink at any given moment. I am a broken man... But you know what? This place is awesome and it's not an island so I will return. read more

Craft 31 - Beer - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

We found Craft 31 by Yelping while in the area. My coworker and I have this thing for finding the right restaurant to go to when we're working in the field. Craft 31 fit what we were looking for. When we arrived, it was towards the end of normal lunch time hours so the restaurant wasn't insanely busy. As a matter of fact, I noticed customers at maybe 3 or 4 other tables. We decided to just get entrees and skip the appetizer. I wanted beef (I was clearly stress eating because I stopped eating beef over 2 years ago). I made up my mind and ordered the Grilled Cheese Patty Melt on Rye. Besides, I knew it would be good for my iron levels. My coworker ordered the Dill Fried Chicken Breast. Of course, I ordered my sandwich well done. When the waitress brought out my food, the hamburger patty had some pink and I almost gagged. I couldn't eat it! Determined to eat this sandwich, I got her to bring it back to the kitchen. Once the kitchen got my order correct, it was on. Being that I haven't had beef in a long while, it was okay. I can't say that I was in Heaven but it was good. I really liked that it had an abundant amount of sautéed onions. My fries were just right - hot and crispy. My coworker's chicken sandwich looked tasty as well. I eyed it and wish that I had ordered it but I was cool with what I had. Ha ha! Overall, this restaurant was a solid choice. The food was good and the waitress was attentive. Even the manager came out to bring my correct patty melt, which was nice. I would definitely try this place again if in the area. Don't think I'll be eating beef again no time soon but there are other attractive items on the menu. read more

Craft 31 - Grilled Cheese Patty Melt on Rye - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Food is amazing, we have only been there twice but the food we've had so far is sooo good! Burgers, Pizza, Brisket and shrimp. 10 out of 10 recommend. read more

This was so good that my golf group visited it twice out of the 4 nights we were in Williamsburg. Outstanding beer selection (watch the prices because a $15 pint can sneak up on you). Every meal we had amongst the 6 of us was delicious. Brisket sandwich, burgers, crab cakes, fried oysters, chili and pizza all got rave reviews. Great service as well both nights! read more

The food is always good. The burgers are top notch! The pizza used to be like bottoms up pizza from rva, but that has changed. They have raw oysters as well. Now to the beer and drink selection...super abundant. My only complaint are the gnats around the bar area. John Taffer would have a fit. read more

Came here for Sunday brunch because it was not busy, I guess for good reason. Though we asked for a booth in a nearly empty dining room at 12:00 noon, they were all reserved so we ate on the bar side. We ordered breakfast and the photo is what appeared to be a shaker of pepper sitting on the table, which my friend used. It was sugar. The eggs were sent back and replaced, but low and behold when the bill came, both orders of eggs were there, according to the waitress "because it wasn't their fault." I can't imagine how much replacing an egg would have cost the restaurant, but I suspect under $1, far less than all the business that they will lose for having a reputation with #badcustomerservice. read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

From out of town, reading reviews saw the photos and comments and really interested me. The inside of the restaurant is inviting but the outdoor bar/patio seating was open and lovely weather so we enjoyed that. Service was amazing, the oysters were delicious and fresh, and the GF pizza was prob the best I've ever had. Def recommend and will return next time we are in town. read more

Visited last night with my parents, husband, and toddler. Server and food was excellent with the drinks being even better. My husband loved his brisket meatloaf especially. *The kids menu even has a "pick one from each category" that works for picky eaters. read more

Craft 31 - Margarita Flight - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Great food and great experience. Kelly, our server was very attentive and accommodating. We will make it back again. read more

Craft 31 - Oysters on the half shell - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Haley was our server and she was amazing! Went above and beyond as I was celebrating my birthday. Offered recommendations and brought out a birthday dessert. Food and prices were great! Will definitely be back! read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Our server, Morgan, was so friendly and knowledgeable. She gave us guidance on beers and food. Everything was delicious and excellent service. So nice to be on vacation and be at such a great place for lunch. read more

I was in the area for a lacrosse tournament and stopped by to get lunch. The food and service was good and reasonably priced. We had the crab, spinach and artichoke dip; build your own burger with Parmesan/garlic fries; and spinach/kale salad. I liked that they had variety of beers in different ounces, since I just wanted a small glass. It was perfect for me. Our waitress was very nice and responsive. The decor was nice. read more

See all

I should have known not to go back. It's was as bad as it ever was. I ordered the fish and chips, it was SO rubbery and greasy I couldn't eat it. We sat at the bar and in front of us was a cup of old wilted mint the bartenders were using as garnish. It had an inch of blackish moldy water at the bottom. The bartenders would take a sprig out and stick it in a cocktail for garnish, horrific. How is this place so popular? read more

My husband and I will not go back to Craft 31 again. We have had good meals there in the past, but tonight was not that great. I got the fish and chips and made sure there was tartar sauce or what I thought was tartar sauce. It was really watery and tasted like it had a lot of vinegar and not much else. I wish they had left the Old Bay off of the fish and fries. My husband got the smoked BBQ platter, the wings were just barely Ok and the Carolina BBQ sauce was again watery and tasted like vinegar. The brisket on his plate was chewy. The service was off and we were asked by someone other than our server at one point if we needed anything because we were just left sitting there waiting for somebody to help us. read more

Had to update my review. We consider ourselves regulars here. We love this restaurant. We love the online reservations, the family friendly environment (many guests bring children here), the indoor or outdoor seating, and the variety of food options. Also, I love their orange crush drinks for $7.95! Tonight I ordered fish & chips - their lime tarter sauce is delicious! My husband ordered their fried shrimp and fries. They have a pretty good kids menu too! Tons of craft beers and very good wait staff. Every time we go, the manager always goes table to table to make sure everyone is happy with their service. 5 Stars for this local spot! read more

See all

4 stars for the food. Everything was fresh and good. We had the goat cheese, spinach pizza, dry rub wings, the crunch salad and fish and chips. Wait for the food was long - about 40min to get our food. Come with lots of patience. read more

This place is nice. Good feel, overall good establishment. Server was really sweet and funny. (Shoutout to Haley) Food was pretty good other than one thing. TRUFFLE FRIES. I'm being dramatic but these personally weren't my favorite. If you like dirt maybe you'll like these. Other than that, great place! :) read more

We ate here last night, from reviews we saw this place is supposed to be hip, trendy and the place to go! From the minute we walked in, the hostess was chatting with two other servers and didn't break conversation to greet us, when she finally did we let her know we had a reservation, and we were seated inside. The place feels like an old Denny's pancake house just a little newer. The carpet on the floor was disgusting, our table was sticky and dirty, and the flies and gnats that were swarming us were not what we had expected. Our server was rather slow and did a very good disappearing act during our time there. We saw a manager running around with her phone in hand, going to different tables and trying to resolve other food issues from tables close to us. She had come over to us a couple times, one in particular I was telling her we hadn't seen our server to get another beer, manager said she would get it; and did not. By the time I did receive my second beer, I was already full and needed a box for my food, just to keep the flies at bay. I'm not one to complain about the small things, and I completely understand the pandemic causing waitstaff and serving issues. But a dirty restaurant with bugs flying around is no laughing matter. We did enjoy our mozzarella bread tracks and our pizza. But would not come back here again. read more

Food was tasty and atmosphere was extremely clean and pleasant, however it was very loud due to the crowdedness of the restaurant. Our service was decent, but nothing to rave over. I liked their menu options. Our meal and drinks took quite a while to come out, and we noticed that we received our food sooner than some people who had been there before us. read more

Stayed in Williamsburg for the night and yelp led us here for dinner. Food was very good and portion sizes excellent... but service was kind of disappointing, had to wait a long time for our drinks that we saw just sitting at the bar getting warm. We'd definitely come back when in town again though! read more

My wife and I found Craft 31 while exploring the area. We loved it! The food was good, and the variety of drink options was excellent. The staff members were very friendly also. We recommend highly! read more

We went for a late lunch during a time when the restaurant wasn't busy. There were only a few tables besides ours that were occupied. We ordered a burger, a salad and 2 kids meals. It took at least 30-40 minutes for our food to come out. I asked for grilled chicken on my salad for which they charged an additional $9. I barely got any chicken and what I got was flavorless and did not taste freshly grilled. Overall, the service was slow and the food was overpriced and mediocre. Would not recommend. read more

We made reservations ahead of time and when we got there about 15mins early our table was already ready for a party of 20. The beer and drink selection was very good. Lots of options! The food was very good too. They serve bottoms up pizza which we remembered from Richmond and that did not disappoint. The kids ordered their food and a side of chips, we weren't told the chips would be kind of spicy - it had the old bay seasoning on them but we were allowed to swap them out and got the fries instead. Overall good spot to check out. They also have bands that play sometimes and the patio area is really nice and laid back! read more

Craft 31 - Chesapeake crab pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Ok place , pizza wasn't the best! Have tasted way better pizza. Takes for ever to get anything. No refills on pop or water. I guess they were busy . read more

Excellent food, extremely excellent service, pricing is on par for the current economy. Took a while to get our food, but it's a pub like atmosphere in the dining room so we expected that. It has a feel for being an establishment for the locals and not the vacation crowd. We all enjoyed that atmosphere. Next years vacation will definitely include a return! So glad we found this wonderful place! (For those complaining about wait times: WE ARE IN THE MIDDLE OF A PANDEMIC. EMPLOYEES GET SICK OR DON'T RETURN. You've read the news. We heard it from every establishment we visited, from the Pottery to other restaurants to grocery stores: "We are having staffing issues." Think twice before you stomp your feet and remember what the world is going through right now) read more

I have never been to a restaurant that had nasty food until I unfortunately dined in & wasted my money here @ Craft 31. I'm not too sure who wrote the positive reviews- MUST be the staff because ain't no way people eating here & posting good reviews. Salad was basic & expensive as well, burger was BURNT & service was poor. read more

I've visited this restaurant twice. Both times I was not impressed with the food at all. It was very bland and I actually would not have gone back a second time had it not been for the wife. It's a shame that the food isn't on par with the atmosphere because the outdoor seating area and bar are really cool. read more

Very clean and nice restaurant. Waiter and hostess very friendly. Had to make reservations on a Tuesday evening. Took almost 40 mins to get our food, everyone around us took a long time also. The food was very good. I got the Carolina burger with chips..burger was juicy. Chips were a little burnt. Tator tot appetizer was really good and full of toppings. Hot dog was delicious..very big. Meat pizza was also covered in toppings. Looking forward to returning. read more

Saw this place when I was driving around lost so decided to come back and try it out. Had the margarita flight that was cute and just the right size so your not tipsy and still remember what you ordered. I ordered a pizza and my friends ordered burgers. The service was quite slow but it was busy, too a while between the server check ins so you better make sure to ask for anything you might need early in the meal. I thought we would try one more time, called asking about a reservation the woman said no reservations available but come in right now and we can seat you. Of course I drive the 5 miles like a maniac to get there in less then 20 minutes only to be told sorry we are all booked up. What the heck very upsetting and waste of my time. Food and service wasn't good enough to ever go back. I'll keep driving next time I get lost. Sad it looked so promising read more

My family went to this restaurant last night due to the amazing reviews. When I looked on the other yelp reviews, I noticed there were only pics of pizzas, a few burgers, an oyster plate, and a combination of beers. So naturally, we decided to order a pizza. My husband ordered the bbq chicken burger and I got a 6 piece hot wing with fries. The pizza was nothing out of the ordinary and we were disappointed. If you want a good pizza, go to Brickhouse Taverns or Venture! My wings were pretty good, but was room temperature. My favorite were actually the fries! They were amazing! But I wouldn't come back just for the fries... All in all, you'll be spending some money to get anything other than maybe the burgers, they're the most affordable. Our experience wasn't terrible, but we personally wouldn't go back. read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Good food good service great atmosphere. Good locals spot. We come here often. Especially in warm weather to enjoy the patio and music.

Good food reasonable price got the promised discount. Easy to get to accommodating staff.

Nice place. They take reservations and we're able to accommodate our family of 9. Staff was friendly and our waitress was great with our kids. Food was good. read more

Loved the staff and atmosphere and the casual dinning in the semi enclosed patio. We had our wedding reception on the patio with 40 people and it was wonderful. Limited seating, sit at the bar it's fun if you are a couple and immediate service. Drinks are also very good. Try the orange crush. read more

Had reservations for Sunday evening and arrived a little early. They had no problem seating us promptly. Their menu offers a variety of choices. Burgers, pizza, and seafood. We started with the crab spinach and artichoke dip. Served with warm pita chips, it was hot and had a decent amount of crab. The flavor was a bit bland but ample serving for four people to share. The table of us each ordered something different. The garlic Parmesan wings were underwhelming. The flavor was not what we expected. No garlic present. The blue cheese burger was unimpressive. They claim this is their own special blend. The flavor was lacking and the burger was a small, preformed patty. The candied bacon was rather odd. The truffle fries were good. The tuna on grits was presented well and the flavor was good. The room was so cold our food cooled off very rapidly. Service was friendly and not terribly delayed with delivery of the entrees. Can't say I'd go back. If I did I might try their pizza. Just not worth the price. read more

This was a homerun of a find on our first night in Williamsburg. I have learned to do my research well before going to an unfamiliar place...especially when it comes to food! The food was fresh and full of flavor. The prices were excellent. The selection was fantastic. Amazing service, very friendly, and also...quite a selection of craft beers. Burgers are really flavorful. Great atmosphere. Very clean. Service was excellent and very attentive. They have a couple of bars that are connected (one in a patio atmosphere) the other is attached and inside the restaurant. Plenty of seating at the bar if that interests you. Bar service was quick while I waited for a table despite being very busy. We ordered the cheeseburger "tot"chos which I found to be very tasty, but also very small. It was served in a small bowl. Not enough for two growing kids and me. I am used to larger apps, but we filled the gap with their steamed shrimp. Probably about 15 medium sized shrimp here. Peel and eat. Tasty. The three of us had burgers...they were excellent as I stated. For dessert, we tried the fried oreos. WOW! First time I ever had fried oreos and they didn't disappoint. Served with vanilla ice cream. We planned to go back before leaving, and I wish I would have. They have plenty of other interesting menu items that I would love to try. I will definitely return. If you are on vacation or just looking to try a new place, this is a great find. Restaurant menu: http://craft-31.com/menus/ read more

Craft 31 - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Update: Another fabulous meal at Craft 31 and server Damica was fantastic, friendly, and attentive. Damica is one of the reasons we come to Craft 31! Thank you Craft 31 for Damica! read more

See all