This place is the absolute best! The food is incredibly delicious, the pizza is obviously amazing, but the chicken wings are my favorite! They are so juicy and flavorful. The staff are super friendly and personable, and the vibe of the restaurant is so fun, comfortable, and welcoming! The events they do are always so much fun! This truly is a great place to spend a few hours with friends. I miss them so much! I can't wait to go back when they reopen, I wish them the very best! read more

See all

Ambiance: 4/5- They stick with their theme of Highway with license plates and road signs throughout the walls of the restaurant. Even in the bathroom they have a gasoline pump for the sink! Food: 2/5- On Saturday's they have $2 off slices so we tried a total of 5 slices. The Margherita slice was so soggy overloaded with tomato sauce and then the mozzarella pieces were not even melted. Worst slice I have had. So much sauce I had to use a fork and knife. The route 60 slice was okay. Not much flavor. The supreme wasn't bad either, and the meat lover was also okay. The dill pickle slice was good. Service: 2/5- Our service was not good. Our waitress did not come to check on us and it took a long time for our food to come where a table who ordered 6 different meals just a few minutes before is, had basically finished their meals when we finally got our food. The pizza is not that great especially for the price and size you receive. Plenty of other slice laces in Williamsburg with better slices read more

See all

To die for pizza! Their bumpy road pizza is insanely good and they have really amazing wings for a pizza place and a bunch of flavors, but that bumpy road pizza does it for me every time! read more

Highway Pizza - Their wings are amazing. - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Highway Pizza is a fun and relaxed pizza joint in Williamsburg. The decor is cool with a highway theme featuring road signs, cars, and truck parts. Be sure to check out the restrooms for their creative wash stations and unique trash cans. Now to the food. We ordered the caprese side salad, which came in a cute small bowl consisting of mozzarella balls, cherry tomatoes, and lettuce with ranch dressing. It was refreshing, though next time I'll ask if they have a balsamic vinaigrette dressing. We tried three pizzas, starting with the The Nacho Mama. We ordered a single $5 slice to share to taste. It had tortilla chips on top and was tangy. Then we got two large pizzas--one was the vegetable with fresh toppings. We especially enjoyed the juicy roma tomatoes on top. The crust was thin with a golden finish. Everyone enjoyed the veggie pizza. The final pizza was the cheesesteak pizza with garlic white sauce. This one was not a favorite of the table as demonstrated by so many pieces left uneaten. Service is friendly and cheerful. We happened to be there on a trivia night. They also have karaoke nights. These folks embrace having a good time! read more

See all

Delicious pizza really friendly staff I went in to get a medium cheese pizza great price as well

Sooo unimpressed!! Ordered pizzas both with extra cheese and pepperoni one WHOLE pizza and only got it on half and neither had extra cheese. One of the pizzas was also supposed to have Alfredo and it didn't have that either. I do not recommend this place at all! Worst pizza I've ever had. I had it delivered and live 30 minutes away which is the only reason I did take it back. read more

See all

The pizza is really great. The order was ready on time and accurate. The folks were all very friendly. However... Got home and realized that they had forgotten part of the order. They didn't answer the phone, called twice, left a message. Nobody called back. Finally stopped in three days later to ask for a refund and the bartender seemed utterly clueless about how to resolve the issue. Still very friendly, but really clueless. He ended up giving me a used gift card which had $2.21 more on it than my missing item. Cool... but not professional. The food was delicious. But the experience was... not great. read more

Highway Pizza - Dining room/bar area - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Highway Pizza is a fun place for a good pizza. Decked out in road signs and this, the place has plenty to look at while waiting for a meal. We stopped by on a Saturday and ordered fried pickles and two small pizzas. The appetizer arrived hot and quickly. The pizzas took a while even though the place was empty. The pizzas were good although the cup of bleu cheese on the buffalo chicken pizza would have been better on the side. The server never checked on us after dropping lunch off and we would have liked a refill. The food is reasonably priced and worth a visit. Hopefully the service is having a better day when you make your way in. read more

What an awesome place! We're visiting from Arizona, and we looked on Yelp to find a good pizza place. We saw the pictures on Yelp of the pizza and decor, so we decided to give it a try. Boy, are we glad we did. The road signs and license plates made for a fun atmosphere. And I won't spoil it, but you HAVE to check out the bathroom. I know--you just have to trust me. And then there's the actual food. My wife had a hard time picking what to order--there were so many great options she wanted to try. She eventually went with the Nacho Mama Pizza (it's literally a pizza topped with tortilla strips, ground beef, peppers, and nacho cheese!). She loved it. My boys shared the Meat Lover's pizza and demolished it. I had a slice myself, and wished I could have had more. My daughter is pretty plain, and just wanted a slice of the cheese pizza (which ended up being the perfect size for her), and she thought was really good. I love spicy foods, so I tried the 6-piece, bone-in, Ghost Pepper wings. Wow! Some places claim their food is spicy, but it's actually pretty weak. Not these wings. Their Ghost Pepper wings really do pack a punch--not for the feint of heart. The only bummer part is they were out of the pretzel sticks. We saw a picture of those on Yelp, and they looked great. The waitress was very apologetic, so it was fine. Overall, it was a great find. We'd definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a fun, tasty pizza place. read more

The pizza is fantastic, if you like real New York style pizza this is your place! My favorite is they're pepperoni!

My husband and I have been here before and it was pretty good, it had been a while since we had been here. We ordered a large hand tossed pizza half of it was pepperoni and half was oh my veggie. The waitress came to see how it tasted. I told her it was not as good as it was before when we had been here. It wasn't very good this time. She told us that they had a new cook . She thanked us for the feedback that we gave. I only had one piece of pizza. Left the rest, it wasn't worth taking home. It was a big waste of money, a frozen pizza would have tasted better. I wished that I had taken a picture of it. We will not be back to this establishment. Next time we will save our money and buy a frozen one or go to papa John's or mellow mushroom much much better pizza there. read more

I can't say enough great things about this place. Amazing beer specials and customer service! Perfect place to watch nfl games on Sunday's with more than a dozen tvs read more

Good food, great service and everyone was very friendly! We went on a Wed evening and they play trivia that night! Had so much fun w the family! Definitely going back! read more

If you haven't been to Highway Pizza you are missing a great place to spend time with friends and family. This is truly a fun place!!! They have Trivia on Wednesday's and Karaoke on Friday's. I attend Trivia weekly and it's so much fun!!! The staff is so good to us. The food is great and the servers are great. They work together to take care of everyone. Last night my daughter and I decided to try Karaoke....and we had the "best freaking night of our lives."lol We truly enjoyed every second. Karaoke Karla is AWESOME!!! She is a one of a kind gem. The kids were so cute. Everyone is so kind and supportive of everyone. If you are looking for family friendly fun and of course great pizza then HIGHWAY PIZZA is your place. Come out and support this awesome place! It will become a family favorite. read more

First off Page our server was a hot mess of a stress case during our visit. Us her only table of 8 seemed to overwhelm her from the moment she walked up to take our drink order. She was not friendly or professional. The place has the ambience of a Pep Boys mechanics shop. Nothing really remarkable or note worthy to talk about. The food can out in irregular intervals. As the entree fries and sandwiches came out first, 10 minutes later one of 3 pizzas, 5 minutes pizza #2 came out, finally pizza number three came out. The people in our party who ordered sandwiches were finishing up by the time the last pizza came out. As a former sous chef this was a server and a kitchen timing problem. Out of ten I'd give the Route 60 pizza a 4 outta 10. This was my first visit here and hopefully my last! Highway pizza sucks read more

We wrapped up Busch Gardens and were absolutely famished! The NCAA Sweet 16 games were on deck, but finding a good family friendly sportsbar in Williamsburg was a but challenging. I honed in on Highway Pizza as it seemed unique with fun decor. Thankfully, it was a great choice! It happened to be bike night so my son enjoyed seeing the bikes outside. Everyone at the establishment was super friendly and helpful. We were immediately seated, and when we asked to put on a hockey game that was on ESPN+, they subscribed to the App so that they could air the game! Now that is customer service! We soon got our drinks and an order of the Speed Bumps (pizza rolls). I highly recommend the Speed Bumps, totally delish! Next we ordered boneless wings with the garlic parmesan and hot buffalo options. Both excellent and cooked perfectly. We went heavy on the wings so we're stuffed after this. If you're in town and want a good sportsbar, look no further than Highway Pizza! Oh, and you have to check out the bathroom.. lol my son got quite a kick out of it! read more

Took my kids on a pizza date and this place is the perfect atmosphere. The turkey pepperoni pizza and speed bumps are legit! read more

Highway Pizza - Great pizza and speed bumps! Wonderful service - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We decided to give this place a try on a whim while driving to the outlet mall. We were originally going to Domoishi, but Highway Pizza looked really cool and their custom delivery cars really caught our eyes! There were so many tasty looking appetizers to try on the menu, but we decided to save that for next time as this was just a small lunch meant to keep us from starving while shopping. The thing that stood out the most to me about the pizza was the crust- it was soft and crispy all at the same time-absolutely delicious! read more

See all

I'm not sure what's going on, but this is the second time I've come for a DoorDash order and you guys are not prepared. You guys were on top of it before whether you were busy or not but now I find myself waiting for 10 minutes or more past the time it's supposed to be picked up. I tried the first time and had to cancel and I didn't wanna say anything but two times in a row in a week is ridiculous. The place is empty. Once you get that ticket you guys should start making the order because what you're doing is affecting us as Dashers we don't get paid that much to be waiting around. I hope you guys could do better. I haven't had your food the ambience is beautiful. I would recommend anyone to go there for a nice scenery and the location, but as far as the customer service and the kitchen, I don't know what you guys got going on, but it should be addressed. I shouldn't be waiting around that long for a simple order. And then what frustrates me-more is when the server is dishonest and tell me it's gonna be a couple of minutes. Just tell me how it is. Hey, we didn't start the order. We started on it now. I think the best way to explain it is if you're working by the hour, you wanna get paid for the hour that you work in each hour we get paid by delivery. I know it doesn't matter to you guys because you're getting paid by the hour, but you should be more considerate towards the people who are delivering your food and not only that we're all over the place we deal with hundreds of people a week at least for me because I dash full-time and you have become one of very few that doesn't have it together when it comes to these orders lately, at least be hospitable and honest about what's going on and stop hanging out in the back gossiping it's just a shame because you guys have a really nice place. We now have the option to block orders that come from you as premium Dashers. I'll give you one more chance but after that, I'm gonna have to block you and it just sucks because I'm a top Dasher and I take care of the customers. read more

This is a new place here in Williamsburg, VA next to the premium outlets. Our bartender who was also the manager named Madison provided great outstanding service. They have the standard beers along with draft beer from the local Breweries. Our drinks came fast and were super cold. As far as food, we had a margarita pizza with a side order of mixed wings. Sweet hot and citrus chipotle. Pizza was well made and flavorful. Weren't cheap with the toppings, no soggy dough and not messy. The wings were well cooked, meaty and the sauces were on point. All the food was well priced. With the pizza, wings and 4 big beers, I wound up paying about $50. This is on par with the Average price for any similar meal at an any similar establishment in the Williamsburg area. If anything, cheaper especially given the quality of food and service. Wife and I will definitely be giving this place a 2nd go. I'm looking forward to the birthday shots!! read more

See all

Loved it!! Great pizza and fast service! The beer cheese was great for dipping crust. The restaurant was clean and so was the outdoor seating area. All the street signs are fun and add to the highway feel. read more

Highway Pizza - Margherita - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Cute decor, great music, and a decent menu. The garlic Parmesan cheese curds are enough to bring me back! Also tasty were the Mac n cheese bits and cheesesteak "Bump in the Road", cheesesteak rolled in dough and back with cheese. Yummy! Can't wait to try the other three meats in them. The only negatives were the pricing and that the kids pizza didn't have red sauce in it, but rather on the side in a ramekin. read more

See all

The staff is extremely friendly. The foods been consistently good. And the environment that is formed each night of the week is different. Something for all crowds from bike nights on Saturdays an trivia, bingo and music on n other nights. Recommend checking out their Facebook or IG. read more

Highway Pizza - parked motorcycles in a parking lot - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Have been to this place a total of 4 times. The food was ok but the service... Not so much! The restaurant is all but empty. Took almost 30 minutes to get a drink order. It's staffed by a bunch of young college aged folks that just want to do there own thing. Its decorated like someone went to a sign shop and had all Theses road signs made up and there are gas' pumps for sinks in the bathroom which is cool. Lookin back at my visits to this place I have spent a total of 169.60 at this place. That's a 169.59 too much on my opinion. read more

Doordashed here while the family and I stayed at Great Wolf lodge. Was not expecting much but the pizza was actually pretty decent. The garlic Parmesan cheese curds were top tier! read more

The place where I was served chicken wings that were not fully cooked , manager had no apologies and just took it off the bill, I called her over before we finished our pizza to see if she'd offer a discount on our meal but her answer was I already took the wings off the bill, I explained to her tht we could possibly have gotten sick from tht raw chicken but she had no reply an just walked away, Pizza was okay not great but better than others we've visited in Virginia? I really don't recommend this place at all, Didn't like the manager's attitude at all read more

Highway Pizza - The place where I was served chicken wings that were not fully cooked , - Sports Bars Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Pizza is decent - nothing spectacular. The chicken sub is very good! Let down by poor service. Our first visit the server literally forgot to put our order in! Our second visit had a server who tried hard, but the kitchen sent out pizzas to our group and the subs followed about 10 minutes later. That can't happen. read more

Food was excellent beer was cold and the service was on point highly recommend if in the Williamsburg area

The pizza would be soo much better if you would just lay off the salt a bit. I don't know if you are adding extra salt to the pizza or the pepperoni is just too salty. Soo much potential there. The chicken wings and sauces are amazing. Love the honey hot and ghost sauces. This place could be a gem with a little tweaking. Blue cheese is great BTW. I can tell the owner has the heart. Just tweak some things and make it great. Much love! read more

Very good pizza. Friendly and helpful staff. I only did take out, so I can't comment on the bar or wait staff.

Highway Pizza makes quite possibly my favorite pizza of all time, The Bumpyride Highway Roni. I order it with extra sauce and even dip the bumpy things in Rao's back at home. Came into town four weeks ago, have ordered 4 times now. Each time pwerfect. Staff is very friendly! read more

We went on trivia night and it was a great experience. The food and service were excellent! Thanks.

We live in Norfolk but we drove up to meet family here for dinner. The evening started off okay, but then the waiter spilled an entire tray of drinks on our table, chairs, bags, floor, me, and a high chair, which included a baby. The kid cups didn't have any lids on them so liquid and ice went everywhere. He was apologetic because the baby started screaming (soaking wet and cold, who could blame him) and we told him it's okay it happens and he brought us some napkins. I cleaned the table, the high chair, my chair, myself, and my bag which all were covered in liquid. My sister had to take her bag to the bathroom and a drink spilled into her bag while we tried drying the baby off. A waitress mopped the floor. We did the majority of the cleaning. The staff did NOTHING else to ensure items were properly cleaned and not sticky. Our food was basic at best. The pizza was on par with a fast food type pizza although I've had better pizza at chain places. My salad was extremely small for the price. The kids meals are overpriced, as are their kid drinks. We ordered mozzarella sticks and the sauce that came with them tasted like it had been heated up in the microwave and their ranch isn't homemade (ranch lovers will understand that). When the bill came we paid it IN FULL (as in no discounts) and even left a tip despite the awful evening. While we were leaving we were in the middle of discussing how surprised we were that they didn't even offer us a discount or even a small plate of fries for the cold, crying, wet baby. But we would never ask or demand that from an establishment. However as we were leaving my sister plugged in her phone and realized it wouldn't charge due to "water in the charging port". My brother in law went in to explain that this was happening so they were aware in case the phone stopped working due to the damage the liquid spilling in her purse caused. They said accidents happen and they would not be doing anything to help and they didn't care. No here's a 10% off coupon, let's amend your bill, if it doesn't work come let us know, nothing. They were not apologetic, they didn't care, and did not even bother asking if the baby was fine. I will never tell anyone to come here or to ever support this business. But I'll tell everyone how horrible they were to us. Customer service goes a long way. Even with mediocre food I'd still return if the customer service was stellar. This place offers nothing for families except hassle and stress. You'd be better off going ANYWHERE else within a 1000 mile radius. read more

first review i've written these wings were that good. me and my mom are on a trip and decided to order from here, we got the teriyaki wings, they were so meaty and juicy!! best wings we've had in a while (considering we used to run a bbq restaurant) definitely recommend!! buffalo chicken and hawaiian pizza was bomb as well. read more

Pizza was subpar. Tried the nacho slice and it was extremely dry. Had a slice of pepperoni and that was similar to skating rink pizza. Servers were no where to be found. Had to hunt for ours just to get water and there were only three tables here. Restaurant was very dark and music too loud. This was more a bar atmosphere than anything. Just not what we were hoping this was going to be. read more

Best pizza place I have had in Williamsburg. Great atmosphere and service by all staff. The pizza dough tastes fresh and ingredients as well. Satisfied have visited and ordered more than once and it has been excellent!!! read more

My salad was fresh and my wings were so good!! I will definitely order again! And the delivery driver was nice!

Wonderful atmosphere, servers who genuinely care about your experience, and fantastic food! Really cool theming. Restrooms were immaculately clean! read more

Pizza was good nothing beyond but a good slice. Ambiance was neat but try to make it a dance club with a DJ. If you want to sit and eat with your family this is not the place. Serves were rarely out on the floor most people had their credit cards out just waiting for checks. You can tell this is mainly for locals that know the owner. read more

If you like pizza, you need to go! It is great pizza, good draft selection, and a cool atmosphere. Service was great, really nice. Food came out fast and they need your business! read more