1. Highway Pizza

0

Williamsburg, VA

Cancel

Open app

Search

Highway Pizza

3.7 (52 reviews)
Closed • 3:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Order Highway Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Highway Pizza Photos

Business Info

HIGHWAY PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
DJ
Live music
Juke Box
Karaoke

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Highway Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Their wings are amazing.
Lily B.

To die for pizza! Their bumpy road pizza is insanely good and they have really amazing wings for a pizza place and a bunch of flavors, but that bumpy road pizza does it for me every time!

Dining room/bar area
Michael M.

The pizza is really great. The order was ready on time and accurate. The folks were all very friendly. However... Got home and realized that they had forgotten part of the order. They didn't answer the phone, called twice, left a message. Nobody called back. Finally stopped in three days later to ask for a refund and the bartender seemed utterly clueless about how to resolve the issue. Still very friendly, but really clueless. He ended up giving me a used gift card which had $2.21 more on it than my missing item. Cool... but not professional. The food was delicious. But the experience was... not great.

No Alfredo and definitely no extra cheese!

Sooo unimpressed!! Ordered pizzas both with extra cheese and pepperoni one WHOLE pizza and only got it on half and neither had extra cheese. One of the pizzas was also supposed to have Alfredo and it didn't have that either. I do not recommend this place at all! Worst pizza I've ever had. I had it delivered and live 30 minutes away which is the only reason I did take it back.

Great pizza and speed bumps! Wonderful service
Taniel C.

Took my kids on a pizza date and this place is the perfect atmosphere. The turkey pepperoni pizza and speed bumps are legit!

Erika B.

We decided to give this place a try on a whim while driving to the outlet mall. We were originally going to Domoishi, but Highway Pizza looked really cool and their custom delivery cars really caught our eyes! There were so many tasty looking appetizers to try on the menu, but we decided to save that for next time as this was just a small lunch meant to keep us from starving while shopping. The thing that stood out the most to me about the pizza was the crust- it was soft and crispy all at the same time-absolutely delicious!

Front Entrance
James C.

This is a new place here in Williamsburg, VA next to the premium outlets. Our bartender who was also the manager named Madison provided great outstanding service. They have the standard beers along with draft beer from the local Breweries. Our drinks came fast and were super cold. As far as food, we had a margarita pizza with a side order of mixed wings. Sweet hot and citrus chipotle. Pizza was well made and flavorful. Weren't cheap with the toppings, no soggy dough and not messy. The wings were well cooked, meaty and the sauces were on point. All the food was well priced. With the pizza, wings and 4 big beers, I wound up paying about $50. This is on par with the Average price for any similar meal at an any similar establishment in the Williamsburg area. If anything, cheaper especially given the quality of food and service. Wife and I will definitely be giving this place a 2nd go. I'm looking forward to the birthday shots!!

Margherita
Chanin M.

Loved it!! Great pizza and fast service! The beer cheese was great for dipping crust. The restaurant was clean and so was the outdoor seating area. All the street signs are fun and add to the highway feel.

Elizabeth K.

Cute decor, great music, and a decent menu. The garlic Parmesan cheese curds are enough to bring me back! Also tasty were the Mac n cheese bits and cheesesteak "Bump in the Road", cheesesteak rolled in dough and back with cheese. Yummy! Can't wait to try the other three meats in them. The only negatives were the pricing and that the kids pizza didn't have red sauce in it, but rather on the side in a ramekin.

parked motorcycles in a parking lot

See all

Reviews are mixed. Many highlight the flavorful wings, creative pizza options, and a fun, unique atmosphere. Staff are often described as friendly.

Read the full review summary in the app

Photo of Colo B.
0
65
55

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Marcus is a great server! He was very attentive, friendly and fun. Food was tasty and restaurant is clean and super cute.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Great food and great service. Nice to have another option in williamsburg other than chains. And dirty places that dont care or listen

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of J O.
0
2
0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Allison L.

Allison L.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Highway Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Sports Bars 630 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Oceans & Ale - Seafood Nachos

Oceans & Ale

3.9(929 reviews)
3.0 mi
•$$

The Seafood Spring Rolls are 10/10 everytime! I used to work i. Williamsburg, and live an hour…read moreaway! I was having a bad day and put my little one in the car, and said the spring rolls will make it better! And they did! His chicken tender kids meal was decent. I did ask for plastic cups and silverware, my server thought it was strange, but with a 2 year old, glass ware is not the best route! Their new location is super cute as well!

A group of four of us were excited to finally go to the new location of Oceans & Ale, and I'm sorry…read moreto say that we were disappointed. The fresh catch meal included a simple house salad, and it took 30 minutes for the salad to arrive. Shortly after the salad arrived, our meals came out, and they were lukewarm. I had the grilled mahi mahi with lemon dill butter over some roasted fingerling potatoes and corn. While the fish itself was a nice piece and well prepared, its not-quite-warm temperature made it less appetizing to eat. The same was true for our other meals: the seafood pot pie and the mahi mahi fish tacos. While our waitress offered to have them all reheated, we both didn't have time as we had theatre tickets and reheating the tacos with their toppings, the pot pie with its pastry crust, and the seared fish didn't sound appealing. The restaurant's dining room was comfortable, and the bar area looked vibrant. Hopefully they are still breaking in their new facility, as we liked dining with them in their previous location.

Photos
Oceans & Ale
Oceans & Ale - Seafood Mac

Seafood Mac

Oceans & Ale - Mason jar piña colada

See all

Mason jar piña colada

Craft 31 - Fried Oreos

Craft 31

3.8(615 reviews)
3.1 mi
•$$

Visiting from out of town. Made reservations for a Friday evening and had no trouble getting in,…read morealthough it was busy. My husband was pleased with the offerings of beer and enjoyed what he had. WE had Boat Cheese Curds with Marinara as an appetizer and they were quite good. I ordered Fried Crab Claw Cakes that came with potatoes and a slaw. All were very tasty. My husband got the Chicken and Sausage Jambalaya and loved it. We took desserts for later at the hotel: My husband's brownie was good and they packed the ice cream separately, so that made him happy. I had the peach cobbler, and while good -- I tend to like my peaches a bit more "peachy" ....they use lots and lots of cinnamon and allspice. The fruit was dark brown. Good, but not what I'd hoped for.

Today I ordered two entrees and a side, to pick up for take out. The place is very cleqn and…read moreworkers polite. However the food was terrible! We ordered a Diners burger, Virginia burger, and house wings. The Burgers were borderline inedible due to the huge amount of salt. If i had been dining in I would have sent it back. I would not feed that much salted meat to my dog. The burgers dampness also had literally demolished the lower bun and iceberg lettuce. So i had to disgard those sodding blobs. The Virginian burger also salty, and the crab cake, small and underwhelming. The Chicken wings tasteless and dry. On too of this i had no choice but to pay a 10% tip for "take out prepare ". If i can give zero i would. Id say "fire the chef"

Photos
Craft 31 - Outside bar area picture is of taps as a decoration

Outside bar area picture is of taps as a decoration

Craft 31 - Tuna Steak Entree (Available After 4PM)

Tuna Steak Entree (Available After 4PM)

Craft 31 - Fried Oyster Appetizer

See all

Fried Oyster Appetizer

Second Street American Bistro - Flatbread  pizza

Second Street American Bistro

4.4(1.8k reviews)
3.4 mi
•$$

Upon our families suggestion, we had lunch here and thoroughly enjoyed the experience. The parking…read morelot was almost full, but they were able to accommodate our party of 6 in less than ten minutes. I server, Robin, was a hoot! My two brother in laws gave her a run for the money and she didn't miss a step. I enjoyed watching the show. Lunch fare was typical bistro style food, but they made it delicious. We started with homemade chips for the table and we got down to ordering. I had the Waygu burger and my wife had the salmon burger. Both were overly generous in size, quite filling, and reasonably priced. I really didn't see what the rest of the family had due to my place at the end of the table, but everyone seemed to enjoy their meals. We ended with each couple sharing a large warm fresh baked cookie. I'm looking forward to them opening a location closer to St. Louis!

Just happened to discover this place while browsing yelp looking for somewhere to get dinner with…read morethe family. Well it worked out well! The ambiance was very nice and way larger than I anticipated. I was nervous for a wait but although it was very crowded for a Tuesday there is ample seating. The food was really good. We had onion rings, sticky ribs, meatloaf, peach flatbread, and and kids burgers and pizza. The ribs were outstanding! So happy I threw them in the order last minute. Meatloaf was good and the flatbread was quite delicious. Kids enjoyed their food as well. Onion rings as well, can't go wrong. All in all a great meal at a nice looking restaurant and will definitely recommend it to others!

Photos
Second Street American Bistro - Bar area

Bar area

Second Street American Bistro - Crab Norfolk

Crab Norfolk

Second Street American Bistro

See all

Highway Pizza - sportsbars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...