My husband and I stopped here for lunch when we arrived in town. Cute Irish pub vibes and good service with a smile. Our Guinness even came with a thoughtfully drawn shamrock in the foam! We ordered wings with their Cooley's Sauce. It took a while for them to come out, but the flavor was great! I ordered a burger and my husband got the Reuben. Both were delicious! Looking forward to going to Cooley's again! read more

The fried pickles are worth the visit!! The food order almost didn't happen, as I walked in early in the evening on Valentine's Day. There is a bar as well as booth seating but no direction or indication of waiting to be seated or seating yourself. I didn't want to go unnoticed so I sat at the bar. (Most of the tables are past the entry way and bar area). There was a family group, a few couples and a group of guys playing darts off to the side. I sat there for more than five minutes before I was even acknowledged. I know this because I could see the Guinness Countdown to St Patrick's Day (down to the second) from my seat. There were 3 girls behind the bar but one seemed to be doing most of the bar work. As I put on my jacket to leave, I finally had the attention of one of the girls so I decided to take my chances and stick with my dinner plan. She got me a menu and asked for my drink order. There weren't any hard ciders on tap but they did have canned Awestruck (local). I noticed the fried pickle appetizer and asked her about it. She told me they were spears and very popular. I decided to take her recommendation and ordered them, along with a Cooley's Handmade Burger with sautéed mushrooms and swiss cheese. My pickle fries came out first since they were an app and I can tell you two things about them...the portion was huge and they were absolutely the best I've ever had! Not long afterward, my burger arrived and that was really tasty as well. I opted to bring the rest of my pickles home and I can tell you that even the next day, with the help of the air fryer, they were still tasting great! I am so glad I stayed! read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Fried pickle appetizer, Cooley s burger with sautéed mushrooms and Swiss, Awestruck cider - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

We stopped by Cooley's Stone House Tavern in Cooperstown, NY, in October -- a month when leaves are falling, sweaters come out, and apparently the summer drink menu still reigns supreme. Nothing says autumn like a "Frozen Mango Breeze" while watching your breath fog up indoors. The soundtrack was off-brand Doors covers featuring an enthusiastic bongo player who was clearly paid by the beat. The volume fluctuated like the tavern's Wi-Fi signal -- one minute it was a whisper, the next it was like being trapped in a drum circle during a Jim Morrison séance. Inside the "non-smoking" bar, a delightful smoky haze drifted through the air thanks to the staff's decision to use the ashtray as a doorstop. It's like they wanted to recreate the authentic 1980s bowling alley experience. The single bathroom door doesn't lock, which adds a fun new twist to your visit -- the thrill of potentially making a new friend while washing your hands. After 25 minutes of waiting for our high-stakes order (boneless wings and a salad), our server cheerfully reported that it was "gettin' there." We decided our patience wasn't, so we paid for our drinks and told her our tip was gettin' there too. Five stars for unintentional comedy. One star for everything else. read more

A great pub/tavern vibe with a really good bar menu. I've been there several times and never been disappointed. The burgers are my favorite, but if you like a good salad they have some good choices as well, not just some lettuce and tomatoes thrown in a bowl. The Jersey Burger is my favorite, but it's very messy (burger with pork roll and a fried egg). The staff is friendly and the place just feels like a real bar. read more

Service was great ! We had the cheesesteak , chill fries and wings. All were delicious! The girlfriend and I love a good tavern/pub, the Jameson just taste different lol. read more

Fresh food. Homemade potato chips are delicious. Relaxed welcoming environment. Nice stop for early dinner read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Pot roast French dip w/ gravy for dipping. Those homemade chips - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

See all

In town on a cold February Thursday. Large table in the back room and the bar was pretty full. High praise on the service! 1 person behind the bar and serving the tables and she did a great job. My son and I said Cooley's had the best fried pickles we've ever had. read more

- decent service - they close early on a Monday night due to lack of business - is one of two places, that Im told, that's open after hours - decent neighborhood bar it is what you would expect it to be read more

The inside is nice but a little dark. The people next to us were annoying but that's not the restaurant's fault. Service was nice and made sure that we were taken care of. Everyone enjoyed thier food, but the waitress never asked how we wanted our burgers cooked and they were not done enough to out likings. Other then that it was a nice family meal. read more

See all

After a long day of settling in kids into their barracks, we needed to refuel and decided to visit Cooley's. The service was quick, accurate, and friendly. The restaurant had a homey feel and the staff were very attentive. The food and drinks hit home, the grill cheese was gooey, fries crispy, and beef brisket was so tender and juicy!! read more

See all

Very good Reuben Burger. Huge burger. Was recommended by the waitress. Very busy place but worth the wait. Would definitely recommend this restaurant. Good atmosphere. read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Cooley's Restaurant - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

Ok, solid Irish bar had the Ruben that was a hit, my buddy went for the chicken tenders nothing crazy good but solid. Had a little buyers remorse as the guy next to me had the wings and they looked awesome. Overall a solid place with good bar food and a good option. read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Chicken tenders - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

We were in town for a weekend for a music festival and visited Cooley's two nights in a row. The bar was lively and Sam particularly was welcoming and very friendly. The food was great, the pot roast sandwich to die for. We highly recommend. read more

This is my go to place when visiting the Hall of Fame. Never have I been disappointed in all the years I been going - my first visit was in 2004 with my wife who was pregnant with my son and the most recent visit was Dec 2023 with my now 18 year old son. I think I said it 10 years ago that this is a place for locals and people visiting the HOF but all are welcomed. The locals at the bar are friendly. The staff is great. The food and beer selection are awesome. As long as this place stays open I can guarantee I'll be back with my son and maybe grandkids? read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

Ellie our server was cheerful. The place was packed with NFL fans in a baseball town (lol). My Reuben on rye with a side of dressing and house made fries hit the spot! read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Reuben sandwich with house made chips - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

As far as local choices are for a great pub\sports bar, Cooley's is king. Located around the corner from the Baseball Hall of Fame & Legends Field, this place would be my local watering hole. Street parking. Plenty of TVs to catch the games. Booths up front. Tables in the back. Decorated in baseball memorabilia. Friendly barkeep and customers. If not the locals, plenty of baseball fans stopping in for a break. Very good draft & bottle beer selection. Good menu. The wings were OK. We ordered BBQ and they came plain with BBQ sauce. In my opinion wings should be finished off in the sauce you choose, then the flavor really gets into the meat. But the real deal here was the French Dip. This had delish thin slices of house made roast beef but here served on a panini pressed ciabata bread. But they did not give the usual watery au jus sauce you get everywhere else. Here they gave one of the best brown gravies I have ever had to dip it in. Again house made from roast beef pan scraps. Fairly priced too. I highly recommend ! read more

See all

Waited over an hour for a burger and pot roasts sandwich we approached the manager about why' the food took so long made no excuses and just blew us off will never come back here again and will tell our friends visiting Cooperstown to avoid this place read more

Where does one go after a huge helping of baseball? A local pub with great food and drink: a.k.a. Cooley's. When we walked in, we were warmly greeted by the bartender. First, and most importantly, they had Guinness and Ommegang on tap. I sprung for the rainbow ale Ommegang: a nice and hoppy IPA. I had the Jamaican jerk wings and a cowboy burger with their fries. Oh...their fries....the perfect firmness and crispness to scoop up ketchup, two by two.... Yeah, the fries were a hit. Burger was a perfect medium rare, with criss-crossed bacon for better coverage and easier bites. Also hits with the family were the beer pretzel and veggie burgers, as were the Mac and cheese wedges. There was a big argument about how to apply ketchup to the fries. The whole family, except my wife, agreed that fries must be dipped or scooped. One does NOT drizzle ketchup over fries. Sacrilege. I found the wings to be really well made. They were big, not dry at all, and grilled, not fried, while still being crispy. Each piece is considered a one or two bone piece, not the entire wing. The Jamaican jerk was ok and didn't really taste like typical jerk, but it was still good. Service was great. Remember to tip well. read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

See all

we made a reservation for families from Cooperstown. They called an hour before to cancel the reservation because apparently they double booked. We stopped looking for other reservations because we thought we had this set in stone. We were all left scrambling and unable to find other accommodations. read more

Stopped in today because it was recommended highly by the guys at the Hall of Fame when we got there, the bar was empty was excited to have a quick bite to eat before we left. We waited at the bar for about 10 minutes, Give or take could hear chatter in the back nobody came around or came out to see us in the time we were there. Normally we would've waited longer were used to waiting for food, but there was maybe five people total in the bar. Very bummed we didn't get to try the Reuben that was so highly talked about. Next time we are in town, we will try again read more

I did not expect to give these guys 5 stars. BUT- started out with a local beer on tap- Neon Rainbow IPA (a "hazy"IPA) by Ommegang. John Tapper from Bar Rescue would be proud! The tap is clearly well maintained. For an IPA it is spectacular. Followed by our order of burgers. Among one of the best burgers I have had in a bar/tavern! Everyone's burger came out perfect. Exactly the temperature we asked for, juicy as humanly possible and the toppings exceeded expectations. Service was fast and friendly. Definitely would come back. read more

After visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame & Museum, my family decided to eat at one of the many eateries on Main Street. Just about all of them are within walking distance. We knew it would be lunch hour for some, but this was around 2pm-ish that we arrived and groups of people were leaving. Me and my parents sat at a booth by the bar. We weren't going to order anything big just something light: salad for my dad, burger for mom, cheese fries for me. Simple as that, right? Waitress took our order, brought us our drinks and we didn't see her again for another 45 minutes. Luckily, we were in good moods that day and we weren't on a time schedule -but the waitress could have acknowledged us during that time frame. We finally got our food. She apologized but it was a half-ass one. We didn't tip her. read more

Stopped in for dinner after arriving in Cooperstown. Definitely a local place, people at the bar seemed to know each other. Friendly atmosphere and service. Our server was Kennedy and she was so sweet and helpful. Started with some beers and they ordered the Rueben Fritters and Wings. We never had anything like the Fritters before and they were delicious. Wings were really also great, big pieces and sauces were great. Nice meal and easy on the budget. read more

See all

This place is a vibe, definitely gives off Irish pub meets dive bar. The guys are all at the bar watching the game, it's kind of cute. Our server was great, she checked in on us quite a few times. We ordered wings and a side of onion rings, they were delicious. The wings were freshly made so they took a while but we were there to hang so it's just something to be aware of if you order. read more

See all

Cooley's is a classic bar. I've been there a few times, most recently during Hall of Fame weekend when things are very hectic. The service was excellent. Again, it was very busy, so I did have to wait a couple times for a round, but nothing crazy. Knowing how busy it was, they served beer in plastic cups, allowing you to step outside if you liked. I was there for dinner as well. Being from Jersey, I ordered the Jersey Burger which has a piece of pork roll and a fried egg. It was messy, but delicious. I've had it before. I've also had their chicken sandwich and their salads as well. Never disappointed. The atmosphere is always friendly and the service is always good. read more

Had chicken fingers. The portion of fingers/fries was definitely generous. They were thick fingers, too. They came out good and hot. The server, Zoe, was very nice but very overworked. The place was quite crowded and as with many restaurants, the place seemed understaffed. She did the best she could, which was very good. Good pub atmosphere. Only 2 local beers on draft. With 4 microbreweries in the area, I wish there was another one or two on tap. read more

All the food here is fairly priced. The wings are cooked to perfection. Great environment while visiting historic Cooperstown.

Looking for a lunch menu and this place looked good. Burgers, sandwiches, soup and salads. Several beers on tap with a couple from a local brewery. Waited on quickly. Didn't realize at first but there is a back room with more seating. Seems like some regulars occupied the bar. Many people came in as we were eating. The portion size was great. It was much cooler than out doors, but I am not sure if they had A/C. I would come here again. read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Hot dog with beer battered onion rings. - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

See all

I'd like to give this place a higher review because our food was good and when we moved to a table when there was finally one open, we had a better experience. My wife and I were just looking to grab a few drinks and a quick bite at the bar, but the bartender was clearly frazzled and sweating all over the place and if I'm being honest, it was quite off-putting. Also, I know that I am older and of a different generation but my wife and I were shocked at how short her shorts were. but I'd like to give credit or credit it was due. The food was great and once we are at the table, our experience got better. read more

We were in Cooperstown for a week and ate here three times! The service was great and the staff was friendly. The wings are a must! The Caesar salad was really good too! I would also try the alcoholic root beer drink! Definitely would tell anyone that is visiting Cooperstown to eat here! read more

This place has a great Irish pub vibe. Service was very prompt in spite of the fact that they were quite busy. Great pour on the Guinness. I ordered a beyond burger with provolone and my parents ordered regular burgers. Mine was delicious and the others were reportedly also very tasty and perfectly cooked. The fries were also very good. Overall, great experience, very reasonably priced. Highly recommend. read more

I would describe this as a dive bar / pub. It's a tiny spot where lots of locals hang out. Bartender was friendly and attentive. They had a decent beer selection including local brews. They serve food but we didn't eat, however the portions looked pretty generous. read more

This place is a stone's throw away from the Baseball Hall of Fame (see what I did there?). Decent under the radar spot to grab a bite before hitting the road, or to have a drink and watch a game on TV. Traditional decor with lots of wood seating, paneling, and an easy laid back vibe. After a long drive, and a few hours of walking around, this was a welcomed stop to eat lunch. Good: -Reuben Fritters (order of 6) are a must -Delicious wings (order of 10) that hit the spot -Food and drink orders came out FAST -The beer was ICE cold, very refreshing. -Plenty of TVs to watch various games -Just around the corner from the Baseball Hall of Fame Bad: -None read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Reuben Fritter, with corn beef is a must have!!! - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

Where the locals eat- super friendly and amazing pub food. Try the the Cooley sauce wings- excellent. Pretzel and the grilled cheese highly recommended. Prices and service were excellent read more

Great wings! Good beer list, a lot of locals, juke box music. Nice place to stop for a pint. read more

Cooley's Stone House Tavern - Pubs Near Me - Cooperstown, New York

See all

I would like to give this place a higher rating as the food was decent, but the waitress we had yesterday just makes me wonder why people go into customer service when they are clearly loath being a waitress. The attitude displayed by our waitress was observed by even our youngest dinner, who asked "why is that lady mad at us?" It wasn't that she was outright rude that you could call her on it, but the eye rolls, smirks and condescending attitude said it all. Oh, and the answer "it changes every day, so I never know what they have" when asked about flavors...really? Isn't it your J-O-B to know what your restaurant has available? If you hate serving people, go find another job. Otherwise, nice place, lots of tv's for watching games. read more

Great wings,,get them with Cooley's sauce you won't be disappointed!fun bar with locals and tourists alike,,,burgers looked cooked to the way they are ordered from a person sitting close by. read more

Went there for some for lunch. It was quite disappointing. They were out of ice and several things on the menu. We decided to go elsewhere and paid for the two sodas we asked for. Our server was nice, but the bartender was less than professional and gave my husband a passive aggressive "Happy's Father Day." Lucky for us, there were other places to have lunch, that were not out of ice or any items on their menu. read more

Came in on a Saturday afternoon after reading good reviews. Asked waiter where to sit and was told wherever I was comfortable. First sat at the only high table and after waiting 20 minutes figured this was only for bar service so we moved. Luckily a table just got cleaned. Waited for 30 mins and got no service. The table next to us and asked for the check. Waiter walked by us three times first to bring check, second to take credit card and third to bring boxes. All three times purposely walked with her back to us and ignored us. Tried to get her attention and finally gave up. Got up and left. read more

Average food. A few orders were incorrect but after the long wait we didn't bother sending them back.