Best pizza around! Gotta get an extra sweet sauce too Better than Tommy's in my opinion and we used to go there frequently read more

I called to place an order the girl who answered the phone was rude and I still to order the smallest pizza and she tells me that's going to be over an hour and half do still want to order that i was in shock and I did ask her was she for real she told me yeah that's the wait ok no thank you she then said I knew that was going to happen and hung up on me I get that some businesses are busy but the rude and ignorant people person on the other end of that business could really destroy your business overall in the long run I will rather go to a little Cesar's for $5 dollars pizza then to be treated like that and still try to give them my money read more

The first highlight of Commodore's was the brown haired waitress, she is a beautiful young lady. The pizza was very good but not sure about the sweet sauce wasn't bad just different. I'd come back to give their traditional sauce a try for sure. read more

Commodore's Pizza - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Louisiana

See all

Terrible customer service. They claimed it wasn't a busy night yet I waited over an hour for 1 pizza. Asked the manager about our food multiple times and was given the run around. His employees said that it wasn't even in the oven while he said it was in the oven and would take 7 minutes. Then 20 minutes later a horrible pizza finally emerged. read more

Commodore's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Louisiana

I took the family here on a Friday night. The place was packed. There was some confusion at the door because we didn't know whether to sit or wait to be seated. We eventually got seated and ordered. There was no wi-fi, unfortunately. The food took a while in the kitchen (understandably, it's pizza) , but it was delicious and worth the wait. I appreciated that the atmosphere was friendly and the music set a nice tone. I love that there wasn't a dozen TVs on every wall. I would definitely come back. read more

The cauliflower pizza was awesome! Will definitely be visiting again! Glad to have them in Amite!

First time here and we will be back. Cheese sticks were the best ever. Pizza was absolutely delicious 10/13/18 Went there for the 2nd time and it was very delicious as was the first time. Will be back again. Best pizza. We like the sweet sauce w the mozzarella sticks but traditional on our pizza read more

This is truly a great pizza spot. The owners and wait staff are a pleasure. I found this place a couple of months ago and have been back several times and a have never received anything I didn't love!!! The Greek pizza is one of my favorites. read more

Best pizza in town. Get the sweet sauce. And they have a gluten fee selection for those that need it.

Love their pizza! The best part about their pizza is that they're not stingy on their cheese. The cheese stick are to die for and the staff is amazing. Be prepared to wait a good bit is the only downfall. But the pizza is amazing. And their house ranch dressing is to die for! read more

this place is one of the better places in town, I started going here when Tommy's started to have roaches in the food

We just moved here from Arizona, where I was born and raised. Although, we fortunately moved to state known for their fantastic food. You still miss the food and restaurants you grew up eating at. We found Commodore's on a Facebook page and decided to give it a shot. We were thrilled that it gave us that pizza from home taste we were missing. They have that perfect combination of sauce, cheese and crust. The cheese goes almost all the way to the edge, my kids eat the entire thing without discarding the crust. We have been eating here to continue our "Pizza Friday" tradition. If you're in a pizza mood and trying to find a spot to satisfy that craving, give Commodore's a try! You won't be disappointed! We have tried the hot wings and the muffuletta, they're pretty good as well! We usually get one of yheseThis establishment gets an all around A+ from us! read more

Quote from my wife "This cheese pizza taste exactly like the one I had in Rome". So if that doesn't make you want this pizza I don't know what will. Go get one!!! read more

Best pizza in town and Louisiana! Never skimpy always delicious with plenty of cheese and toppings. Makes other pizza places look bad! Buy local.! read more

Passing through LA, Had the Greek pizza and being from NJ our experience was a 10. I t was delicious and the service was excellent.

Holy moly! This place is a hidden gem.... best pizza in Tangipahoa parish. The waitstaff is so nice and the pizza is so good compared to local competitors. read more

Best meat lovers pizza in town! The Parmesan cheesy bread is off the chain! My husband & I have a rating scale for every restaurant we go to. We believe the supreme (Godfather pizza) is really good here, but East if Italy has the best supreme pizza in our opinion. I expected this place to be a very tiny hole in the wall, but to my surprise it had booths, a bar, & friendly service. Go just after lunch around 1 or 1:30 & your wait won't be so long. Tommy's is delicious, but Commodores is better in our opinion. read more

Hey the pizza was cold but it was good Harding no cheese on the pizza and I heard they give Lots of cheese the servers for good but who won't a cold pizza read more

Absolutely delicious pizza with all the best toppings! High quality ingredients, piles of melted cheese and sweet red sauce! This is what Tommy's used to be. It's not cheap, but it's worth it for the ingredients. read more

Ok, this review has nothing to do with the quality of the food. On Father's Day, they were only serving pizzas and salads. The problem is that they should have informed the customers on their way into the restaurant. Either tell them upon entering the restaurant or post signs to inform the customers that they were not serving the full menu. Very poor customer service. read more

Love this place. I never dine in however they hands down have the best pizza in Hammond. Taste like Tommy's did when they gave a shit.

The. Best. Pizza. Ever. You have to get the sweet sauce. My husband isn't a pizza fan but he will eat this with me any day. So good.

Excellent pizza. Excellent service. Great price. Super friendly. Best pizza in town. We will definitely be repeat customers. read more

Commodore's Pizza - GREEK PIZZA WITH TRADITIONAL SAUCE - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Louisiana

See all

Tried 2 times to place a to go order and nobody would answer the phone. Was told 15 to 20 minutes so I arrived 20 minutes later and still had to wait over 10 minutes for my order. That being said the pizza was good and the people were friendly. Not the best pizza I ever had but close to it. Fix the phone answering and promise time and I would give it a 5 star then. read more

Whether your choice is the sweet sauce or the original, the pizza is outstanding with generous toppings. Great service and wonderful atmosphere. My favorite pizza is the Commodore, but The Godfather is very good also. read more

Service was fantastic! Very friendly people! I had the lasagna special and the sauce was incredible and and the portion was perfect. All the ingredients were very fresh! We will be stopping next time we pass through! read more

Commodore's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Louisiana

I wish they would have warn me about how good this was gonna be. Ordered a commodore pizza, parmesan cheese sticks, and a pepperoni calzone. The pizza sticks and bread sticks we're great, no doubt. I then had a bite of my girlfriend's calzone, and I felt like I was going to pass out from my orgasming taste buds. 10/5. Would come here all the time if I lived locally. read more

They have the best pizza in tangipahoa parish honestly! Everything even other then just the pizza is always hot and fresh, and everyone is always friendly, welcoming. Sometimes you may catch a super long wait but other then that there isn't any negatives. They get extremely busy mostly every day so if you aren't to keen on waiting or being in full places I'd say get there at 11 exactly. read more

Best pizza ever, beats Tommy's and all other local pizza joints. I wish the hours were better. But pizza is phenomenal! The chicken parm pizza is my favorite and the buffalo ranch dipping sauce is a great addition! read more

GREAT JUST GREAT, great food, great people, and just a great place i hope your buisness blows up. yall have the best pizza ever

WONDERFUL pizza! I love the slim one with pesto it's so yummy their crust is so delicious....

Good service, very polite!! App- Eggplant was super greasy, oil wasn't hot enough. Apologized it away, said fried food tends to be greasy. Pizza- got a cheese to really taste the major ingredients. Sauce was oddly sweet, didn't think it went well with the cheese and dough. Sweet sauce is not what I expected. Dough- definitely frozen, not made in house. Could be wrong but it doesn't taste like it. Decent taste though. Bottom of pizza burnt black on bottom. Cheese- good quality cheese, salty blend though, good cream/oil ratio. Food is priced too high for it being lower quality Overall (0-10) 4.6 read more

Best pizza and entrees! Try the chicken Parmesan pizza with sweet sauce. It's our favorite. Amazing service. It's like being with family. Great weeknight specials. read more

I didn't like the Commodore pizza at all. The beef tasted bad. The waitress did not ask why we did not eat our food nor did she refill our drinks...not even once. She never came back with our change either. I felt instead she was talking about me with the owner because I didn't leave a bigger tip. I hadn't left a tip yet! That was change from the bill. It wasn't busy at all. The breadsticks and Alfredo were good according to my 11 year old. I still wouldn't recommend at all. Then to add to this review, my daughter left her phone there. They called her dad using her contacts instead of calling her mom she was obviously with nearby. I'll never understand that or how they got into her password protected phone. Glad for the heads up but definitely not the way it was done. read more

I love this place. We go often & the pizza is always great. I like the Greek salad as well. The wait staff is very friendly & attentive. There's plenty of comfortable seating. It's our "feel good" place for an enjoyable meal in a family friendly atmosphere. Thank you Commodore's Pizza. read more

I am a huge pizza snob. I think the best pizza anywhere I have ever found is Tower of Pizza in Metairie. I have eaten pizza all over the United States. Commodores Pizza was absolutely amazing... ate there for the first time today. I cant believe their is pizza that good right here in Hammond, LA. It is right there neck and neck with Tower of Pizza in Metairie. I recommend this place highly. Great people and amazing Pizza. read more

This pizza place is a hidden Gem. Super good, super friendly all at a reasonable price. I guarantee you won't be disappointed!

Best pizza in town! Staff is friendly and the restaurant is clean. Love the buffalo bread sticks!!!!!!

We just found "the best kept secret in Hammond"! When you are greeted by the owner, his parents, AND his grandparents you know it's gonna be good. If you like Tommy's sweet sauce and breadsticks you are gonna LOVE Commodores. They beat Tommy's in every aspect. It's quieter, more family oriented, and very personalized by the fact that the owner and family make it a point to talk to the customers and make sure you are enjoying your meal. I had the Calzone and all I can say is "da bomb". The portions are large enough that if a couple wants to split an order, there's more than enough for two. They also have some of the great local beers such as Gnarly Barley brewing and Anita Beer. I will definitely be back! read more

Had the chicken parm pizza with the Italian salad. Both my friend and I enjoyed it! I will be back. read more