Great pizza. Delivered quickly and still hot. Couldn't ask for better service or pizza

Smelled great, Didn't taste well. Crust was good, everything else was not that great. Service was okay

Great lunch combos with generous servings. Pizza crust is excellent. Calzones are large enough to share

Ok. 5-6 times a year pizza eater. When I get pizza I get it here. Since Covid they are back to the reliable stable consistently fresh salads and pizza I expect. Delicious cauliflower pizza but eat it here - it doesn't hold up like flour. Same servers. Same cooks. I see the owner in back 3:4 visits. So what if it's country music. I can take it here. Support local for lunch y'all. read more

It's used to be soooo good. Best pizza around. Now they just don't care at all. My last 2 orders have been horrid. read more

Italian Pie - Garlic bread - RUBBERY AND BURNT - Italian Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

See all

Delicious pizza!! Cooked exactly as ordered, thin and crispy!. Will definitely be back!. Locally owned, give them a try!

The food is OK. Better than chain pizza places, but they just don't follow any of their published hours. I can't even count the number of times I have tried to call them for a pickup or delivery without an answer. Sometimes I'd just drive to the restaurant to place an order and wait and it would be unexpectedly closed during their normal business times. If you can't answer the phone at 7:30pm on a Saturday night when it rings 5 times over 30 minutes, perhaps being a pizza restaurant (or any kind of restaurant or even any kind of serve-the-public business) is not for you. You must have some other way of earning money. read more

Italian Pie. One of the best pizza places in Mandeville hands down!! If you're looking for something new, this is the place to go! They have amazing food, and offer more than just pizza. And the service is even better. All of the waitresses are super nice especially Tiffany. A family owned restaurant that keeps you coming back for more! read more

I remember Italian Pie fondly from my days living in New Orleans. There was a location close to my house that delivered so we frequently had their food for dinner. I was unaware that a Mandeville location had opened until searching for an open business post Hurricane Isaac. I was without power at home and wanted a regular meal without having to fire up the grill. Italian Pie to the rescue! Because they were one of a handful of open restaurants, they were packed. I had called in my order ahead of time, so it was ready as soon as I walked in. Kudos to the staff for accurately estimating my wait time despite large crowds. I ordered the baked chicken wings and a Greek chicken sandwich. The baked wings were very good. So good in fact that they were better than nearly all of the fried versions I have had. It is hard to believe that the healthier alternative was actually better. The Greek chicken sandwich was good, but not as good as I remembered. I think part of the problem was the heavy crowds, but it seemed that there was too much bread compared to the meats, etc. Had the bread been smaller, the sandwich would have been much better. If you're in Mandeville, and looking for a reasonably priced casual Italian food, I encourage you to give this place a try. read more

Ffequent patron here in fact every Friday because have tried just about every pizza joint in the area and by far this place is the best . Food (pizzas, sandwiches and entrees are very good ) . Service is also very good . read more

I'm not too thrilled with this place. The first time I ate here was a couple of years ago when I went with my sister and brother-in-law. They got pizza and I got a calzone. My calzone came quite a while after their pizza and when it did it was cold in the middle and not cooked. I had to send it back. By the time it got back to me my sister and brother-in-law were done eating. Fast forward two years. I go for lunch yesterday. They offer several appealing lunch specials. I go for the Italian salad and calzone. The salad was pretty good. It was a pretty hefty size. I opted for ranch dressing rather than the Italian that came with it and if there is a next time I'll ask them to hold the 200 olives. Yuck! Up next is the calzone and guess what? It's cold in the middle! The cheese is not even melted. How many cold calzones does this place serve? I may try Italian Pie again sometime but I won't be going back to this location. The one good thing about the experience was the waitress. Her name I believe was Alyssa and she was really nice. read more

Italian Pie - Italian Salad - Italian Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

Tried to go here at 7pm on Saturday 2/15. Store was closed. Not sure what was going on. Building was dark.

Their food is good. But their staff is rude, they don't follow the business hours and it's not worth the aggravation. I just rather spend my money elsewhere. read more

All good things to say! Great food (my favorite is the Italian Special Sandwich) great people. Also highly recommend trying the spinach and artichoke dip! read more

My experience was terrible. I ordered a pizza to go and showed up about 5 minutes early. I saw a pizza on the warming table and asked if it was mine. The cashier/waitress went and looked and said not mine but mine would be out in a little while. I ordered a glass of wine while I waited and waited and watched other people come and pick up their to go orders. There was nothing BLT one table of people in the place and they had finished eating. After about 20 minutes I saw the cashier walk back into the kitchen then walk back the warming table and grab the pizza mi had asked about when I first arrived. She brought it out and told my pizza was ready. Really? I was mad as hell but already late getting home. So I expressed my deep disappointment in the cashier, paid and left with the barely warm pizza thinking I could heat it when I got home. At home I discovered the pizza wasn't what I ordered as I asked for the combo hold the ground meat add bacon. No bacon and if what looked like ground beef was Italian sausage then it was lacking any flavor and tasted like nasty ground beef. The pizza was so bad we just threw it away. read more

Love this restaurant. It is definitely the best pizza on the North Shore! Always a great deal, family friendly, generous portions and great service. read more

Great service. Must try cauliflower pizza crust. It is the best thing on the menu. Clean with quick service. Must try.

I went to this place tonight with my family on a whim. I've been to Italian Pies in the past and never found the food to be very good. It was about the same this time but I'm writing about our bad service experience. The waitress was nice enough when taking our orders. The food came out quickly...there were three other tables. By nice enough I mean she really couldn't give a shit. She didn't bring out silverware or napkins for our salad and pizza. We had to wait for the other server to bring them. The restaurant was basically empty. If that was it I wouldn't be writing this review. However, when we got the bill she had added gratuity of 20%. But get this...the grat was hand written. Like their POS can't handle that? I know it's somewhat normal to grat 18% for parties over 6 but 20? That's just insulting. We were going to give her 15 due to the lame service but man. We left feeling taken advantage of and that's pretty rare in a restaurant. I'll never step foot in an Italian Pie again. read more

Best pizza ever My favorite is Pepperoni and Chesse . Great staff always friendly service can't bet the the quality for the prices

No complaints here. The pasta, salads, and pizza are good. Nothing extraordinary, but good. My favorite pizzas are the spinach pizza and Hawaiian pizza. The caesar salad is delicious. Fast and friendly service. Check for daily specials. They do serve some alcoholic beverages. read more

This is their large Mediterranean salad. I did ask for no onions, but this is pathetic! 4 half slices tomato, 4 olives & 2 small chunks of artichoke heart...as well as no dressing! And the pizza was heavy & greasy. Decided to support a locally owned place and am seriously disappointed. read more

Italian Pie - Italian Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

Called to order pizza for my kids for dinner the other night while I was at work. Called on my lunch break so I wouldn't forget to order it later. I was told very rudely that they were too busy to take my order and that I'd have to call back after 3pm. I called back after 3pm and asked them to have pizza delivered to my house for 6pm. Pizza didn't arrive at my house until 6:20pm. We love their pizza but I will not order from there again because of the horrible customer service. read more

I work at a nursing home and our residents chose to dine with them. It was a little over 30 orders and they did pretty good. The food was delicious and our resident were happy. The portions they received were very generous. They were very pleased. read more

I enjoy Italian Pie pizzas for take out. The family decided to go there one night and we were not impressed. While the food was very good, the service was mediocre at best and the kitchen took forever to get the food to our table. It was not a busy night. I was so disappointed, I'm not sure we'll be back-in person or for take out. read more

THIS PLACE HAS THE BEST SERVICE. They are so nice and respectful!! The food IS THE BEST EVER!!!!! My experience here was the best ever!! I would recommend this to anyone and everyone!!!! Y'all need to come try the food and enjoy the friendly staff!!!!! read more

Had the pizza and salad lunch special. The Caesar salad was pretty large and very good. I opted for the thin crust pizza and it was cooked perfectly with high quality toppings. read more

Always did like the food ,,, I stopped in bc haven't been there in years ... Chicken fettuccine wasn't to my tasting but my finance loved .. I lived my spinach wrap , but the red bean soup that I was recommended to get from another staff member wasn't in my bag when I got home ... BUMMER read more

Don't go by their posted hours. Don't even go by the word of the staff. We called at 9:15 on a Saturday night to make sure they were open, to which the answer was yes. When we called back at 9:28 after perusing the menu and putting together our order, they said they were closed, that the manager said to close early. read more

Every time my wife and I get take out (don't dine in), there is a problem. From simple mistakes to losing our order all together. They never are busy when I've been there so it seems the only excuse is incompetence or they just don't care. Never again. Please change owner/manager, do something. read more

Hi, this is the greatest pizza in Mandeville, the food is great, and all the staff is the best in the area! The salads are the freshest! The Pizza is d-double great! I go for the lunch specials on Wednesday! Pizza is one of my favorite foods and they make it better than I have found since moving here a year ago! Thank you Italian Pie! read more

I just came In last night with my family. The pizza was good! We got the gourmet Greek. The service was good too. My only complaint was that the beer on tap wasn't as cold as I'd like, but I like my brew with ice crystals forming in it. I will be back. read more

Crappy service. Every time I've come here they are always in a bad mood and not nice. Not a good time. Food is decent though!

Similar in style and menu to an Isabella pizzeria. Offer pizzas, pasta, salads and etc. Dine in and take out. Casual family dining.

Got takeout from this place a couple times this week and I really enjoyed it! Their food is excellent and their servings are so large I can usually eat the same dish for lunch and dinner. Not to mention you get all that food for a pretty reasonable prices. Definitely plan on going here regularly! read more

I went to Italian Pie for lunch today for my birthday with a group of girls. The service was unacceptable. The food took an extremely long time to receive...almost an hour and the waitress couldn't remember who ordered what. The waitress had written down all of our orders but still managed to bring out the incorrect kind of salad/pizzas combo's. When I voiced my complaint I was told they were not a "fast food" restaurant and she was very argumentative. I ask the waitress for her name and she told me Ebbie. I ask her who the owner was and to my surprise it was HER! I support local restaurants and really hate to see one go under but with poor management this was my last time to visit there. read more

Today was so bad not only was our orders all messed up the owner was very rude. Took over an hour to get the wrong food brought out to us. The owner Ebbie ? needs to learn customer service. I would rate this -1 if I could. PLEASE GET SOMEONE THAT CARES ABOUT THIS PLACE! read more

Great food. Best spinach dip anywhere. Delicious pizzas. Take out ready at time they tell you it will be.

Food was great. The Mediterranean salad was fantastic and a small was the perfect size to split between two people as an appetizer. Their combination pizza was fabulous - really great toppings, good crust. read more

Yuck. Gross. Yuck. Ordered a calzone and it wasn't cooked through. The pizza was bland. We picked up a simple order and it was awful. I sincerely hope that no Italians are cooking in this kitchen. When you can't make a decent pepperoni pie it's time to throw in the pizza dough. read more

The atmosphere was a bit run down and did not look fresh, but the food (we had a pizza) was pretty good. Nothing special.