Cancel

Open app

Search

Italian Pie

3.1 (43 reviews)
ModerateItalian, Pizza
Open 11:00 am - 2:00 pm, 5:00 PM - 7:30 PM
Updated 3 months ago

Order Italian Pie Takeout or Delivery

Italian Pie Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Italian Pie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Garlic bread - RUBBERY AND BURNT

It's used to be soooo good. Best pizza around. Now they just don't care at all. My last 2 orders have been horrid.

Italian Salad
Nick H.

I'm not too thrilled with this place. The first time I ate here was a couple of years ago when I went with my sister and brother-in-law. They got pizza and I got a calzone. My calzone came quite a while after their pizza and when it did it was cold in the middle and not cooked. I had to send it back. By the time it got back to me my sister and brother-in-law were done eating. Fast forward two years. I go for lunch yesterday. They offer several appealing lunch specials. I go for the Italian salad and calzone. The salad was pretty good. It was a pretty hefty size. I opted for ranch dressing rather than the Italian that came with it and if there is a next time I'll ask them to hold the 200 olives. Yuck! Up next is the calzone and guess what? It's cold in the middle! The cheese is not even melted. How many cold calzones does this place serve? I may try Italian Pie again sometime but I won't be going back to this location. The one good thing about the experience was the waitress. Her name I believe was Alyssa and she was really nice.

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

12 years ago

Love the fresh not frozen ingredients! Calzone was great! Service is friendly and attentive! Price for lunch is nice.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Italian Pie

You might also consider

Leonardo's Trattoria & Pizzeria - Tiramasu cake, perfect end to my lunch. I need to walk another 10k steps

Leonardo's Trattoria & Pizzeria

4.3(208 reviews)
2.5 mi
$$

Vivian and Haley the BEST!…read more Always amazing; been coming here since they opened. Never disappointed!

Stopped in last night after class to pick up a short rib plate to go; it was super cold and I was…read moreglad to get back into my warm truck, but man-oh-man was that a tough drive with the amazing smells from the to-go box wafting through the cab! I had planned to have it for lunch the next day, taking time to crisp the edges in the air fryer before devouring the source of those smells - but alas, it was too great a temptation and I tried a small piece when I got home. Small, meaning like TWO OUNCES that had fallen apart from the main rib into the mound of pasta and chunky red sauce. Sliced garlic, chunky tomatoes, and the essence of beef all through it made for a pretty tasty side dish that I ended up giving to Tiff. I was saving room for the MEAT. So, that little piece that dropped off to tempt me was eaten and savored. It was soooo good. Still, I managed to save the rest of the rib for lunch the next day - I crisped that beautiful short rib up, as promised, and shared the pasta with Tiff - we had a delicious meal and both gave thanks for the food, for Leo and for Ashleigh, the awesome server who packaged the boxes up so beautifully and made sure we were well taken care of even though we took it home. Looking forward to my next visit to Leo's - short rib pizza anyone???

Photos
Leonardo's Trattoria & Pizzeria - Counterr area

Counterr area

Leonardo's Trattoria & Pizzeria - Margherita pizza, Yumdilisious

Margherita pizza, Yumdilisious

Leonardo's Trattoria & Pizzeria - Lunch menu

See all

Lunch menu

Fat Boy's Pizza - Loaded Waffle Fries

Fat Boy's Pizza

3.4(66 reviews)
4.2 mi
$$

Another place that started strong yet has dropped the ball. Pizza is ok better pizza elsewhere size…read moredoesn't matter if it tastes like tomato brushed cardboard. You had a froze' daiquiris following yet haven't seen it in years. The chicken and burger sliders are a great addition though and taste great. Brought baseball team for championship pizza order a second pizza kids were leaving and did bring the second pizza went check they burned it and I said well I don't need it now can I just get a refund they said no! I was ok I divided it up and gave to remaining kids to take home but they did not even let me know it was delayed because it was burnt and had to be remade just pushed our food back an hour with no choice of refund. Manager awful customer service that day. It's chaotic atmosphere lazy servers no communication and always have to go to counter to grab attention for details on food. Bro no wonder why the Mandeville location tanked!

I like the interior. The ambience kind of reminds me of Pizza Hut back in the day when it was a…read moresit-down restaurant. Everyone was really nice and the place was clean. I ordered a slice of supreme-style pizza and it was floppy. I was wondering if they used a microwave to heat it. It was still good but I had just had a slice of pizza in the French Quarter the day before and they heated it to perfection so I was looking for a crisp crust on this slice.

Photos
Fat Boy's Pizza
Fat Boy's Pizza - 30 inch Cheese

30 inch Cheese

Fat Boy's Pizza - Ready Pizzas

See all

Ready Pizzas

Italian Pie - italian - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...