I stopped into Comella's to grab a bite to eat before heading to the TCAN. The restaurant is small but they make really good use of the space. They offer dine in, pick up, and I also believe delivery. They had a fairly decent sized menu with different meal sizing options. The prices were incredibly reasonable and the portions were also very generous. The young ladies running the front counter were incredibly friendly and hardworking. You could tell they liked the job and helping the numerous customers that were coming in. I would highly recommend this restaurant to others. One of the better dining experiences I've had during the past three years to be honest. read more

Comella's - a plate of salad on a table - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

See all

I tried to order by phone. Few evening ago (intended to order 10 large pies) but after being placed on hold for 3 minutes I was rudely told before I could say anything that they could not take my order. Lost my business read more

Family favorite Italian place! Always love their cheese pizza. Make sure to call in to put in your order if you are doing take out as it can take a bit of time to make, understandably. The staff is super friendly! read more

This a basic pizza parlor that does mostly take out. The are 5 tables inside. The menu is on tv screens on the wall. I had the lasagna. It was basic but tasty, came with ziti. Nothing special but ok. read more

Service is terrible! The staff is rude. I asked for a manager and they said that there wasn't any then and had no answer to whom I could contact, they got the order wrong. Rude! Small portions. Unpleasant experience!! read more

The tables are sticky and the cashier said its because of the table paint. In that case, why not use tableclothes or placemats. Food is not bad. I went in for a sit-down lunch after a long time. Not happy with the ambience. read more

See all

I've had chicken parm and pizza here before. The chicken parm sandwich is pretty good - mostly driven by their sauce which is top notch. I would joke they should bottle it but it is in fact bottled and available for sale lol. Pizza is ok - not my favorite crust but ingredients taste fresh and of course ... the sauce! I think it's more of a sub shop than a pizza shop but good to have options. Staff has always been friendly and attentive when eating there. The atmosphere has that old school Italian place vibe perfected. Half expect to hear the Godfather soundtrack playing when I come inside. read more

Small and cozy spot in downtown Natick that fed many hungry coworkers for lunch today! We stopped in for a pickup order which they had "hot and ready" as soon as they opened. We tried many types of pizza, with the chicken+bacon+ranch and plain pepperoni being top hits! The prices are a bit high for what I didn't know is a chain of restaurants, but it really did seem like they put the most into our food and we appreciated it. I will likely check out the Belmont location in the future as it's much closer! read more

Used to have $5 large cheese pizzas which were so awesome and my families and friends go-to, especially for big parties and events. However they continued to raise their prices and decrease the quality of their ingredients. I've had the chicken broccoli ziti and I liked it, just tasted like a classic pizza place pasta dish. My favorite pizza is their Olivia Rose, which is buffalo chicken pizza. It has the perfect amount of sauce and is definitely one of my favorites, but definitely a little pricey. It's also good to note this is a red sauce pizza, not white sauce. The thing about these pizzas is that they can be hit or miss depending the day or type of pizza you get. They can sometimes they can be kind of undercooked with almost too much sauce? The center of the pizza sometimes has cheese taken out and too much sauce / undercooked sauce in the middle. Or sometimes they are a little more cooked with less sauce and can also almost be a cheesy bread. Either way it is still good but I definitely would much rather not have much too much sauce. The picture below is one of their better pizzas, it was cooked just right. I feel like when you add toppings (like onion and pepper) is when the pizza is usually undercooked. read more

Comella's - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

It has gone downhill and the prices have skyrocketed,double check what you order their pricing in the system doesn't match their menu. Yes it is more they claim that they have not updated their pricing yet, but it is just a scam The food quality used to be good, now it is barely eatable. read more

Down to 2 stars... a plain pizza that looks like it was made by a 5 year old -! Keep raising price though. And a Buffalo chicken pizza where the dough is barely cooked. Come on ITS PIZZA!! Dough, sauce , cheese , toppings. Sorry to make it so hard for you. Embarrassing... read more

Comella's - a half eaten pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Hate to be this person. I keep hoping it'll get better but it really doesn't get much worse than this. Asked for them to make sure the food was fully cooked and this is what I got. Order somewhere else- save your money & save your time! read more

Comella's - A barely cooked pizza. - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Craving eggplant parm my tummy drove me here. Thank you yelpers for helpful tips! This is a small place and I can see why it is mostly take out. On the end of the corner of Main Street is this little place with just a few tables. It did give me that inviting feel to want to go back and eat there. The mess was just that. A mix of this and that which is hard to describe. Wanting the eggplant parm I ordered a side of the mess to go with it. For about $9 I got 3 meals out of it. Filling for sure. The eggplant parm reminded me of lasagna since it was layered. It was thick and delic and I was pleasantly happy with the side of mess. After placing my order and getting there in about 10 mins it was hot and ready to go. Now the dilemma is if I go back to try their pizza or getting seconds on the eggplant parm. Parking is hit or miss in downtown Natick but most of the parking is within walking distance with a meter. read more

Comella's - Limited seating - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza is very inconsistent at Comella's especially for what the price is up to now. Ordered a large Pepperoni and while the Pepperoni was adequate, but the foundation pizza was minimalist with the tomato sauce and cheese and the dough was uneven and very thin on one side of the pizza. More attention to detail in making this pizza would be an improvement. The greek salad with chicken was a better option with a good balance of ingredients. read more

The Philly cheesesteak sandwich was very mediocre but the pastas were all fantastic. We have tried 3 different pastas and have not been disappointed. However I think they're are better pizza options nearby! read more

Usually I love this place, however tonight (a Monday no less) we just tried calling in a pizza order for pickup. 2 times they placed us on hold for 5 minutes and didn't come back to take our order.. dissapointing... read more

Ordered lunch from them online to be delivered. 2 miles away. 11:50 am. Called at 12:55 and was told 10 minutes so I decided to go pick it up. After a 5 minute drive I walked into an empty store ( no customers) and was told they are "just finishing up" after another 10 minutes I was told " they dont have any morning drivers" guess what, Ms. Entitled, its after 1 pm. Worst attitude and service ever. Hopefully they will go out of business soon. 9/2/21 read more

Great food! I'm having an event for 25 people and Comella's meatballs were requested by so many of my guests that I figured I'd have them do all the catering. Mo was great to deal with. Thank you Comella's! read more

I've been a fan of Comella's since when the only location was West Newton. No more. As the chain expands, the portions get smaller, and they disguise it by adding a mound of cheap pasta. read more

I came here to support a local business, and im sorry to say i will not be returning. I ordered the Grandpas Mess: The sauce tasted like it came out of a can, it was not fresh. The pasta was so overcooked i could swallow it without chewing, it was MUSHY. My family ate a few bites, threw it out and made something else for dinner. The food was overpriced, over cooked, and underwelming. read more

Comella's - Sausage, peppers & onions pizza - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

I wish I could give zero rating.The staff threw away my to go box in trash when I went to the restroom .( The food had hardly been eaten ,I had to catch a train so was rushing). This is still understood, but is the staff so dumb , I had just taken the to go box from them and I was the only customer in that restaurant. Then one of the staff offers me the to go box from the trash saying the trash can was empty do you still want it? What am I a slave to eat food out of trash can?. And the best part is when complianed to the owner he says this was not racist. read more

It's ok. Their eggplant Parm is thin and stacked nicely but could have used more sauce and cheese (was dry). Meatballs are awful. Way more filler and not a lot of meat or flavor. read more

I ordered a large pizza and some cannoli for a family Labor Day lunch and Comellas did not disappoint. The crust on the pizza had perfect snap/chew balance and it was aromatic from abundant freshly chopped basil. My only comment is the sauce needed more salt, it was a little bland. It's easily correctable at home, but something the restaurant could easily fix themselves. The woman working at the front desk was great also, very efficient and friendly. read more

We love this place. The menu is extensive. The prices are reasonable. The food is consistently good. We now have takeout once a week. So much easier than grocery shopping, cooking and cleaning up. read more

Great for takeout!! Love their sandwiches and pasta dinners, probability the best for either in town. Little pricey but I always felt it was worth it read more

I came here after signing a lease for my apartment over five years ago and have been coming here ever since. It truly is home made tasting, the pasta sauce or "gravy" is wonderful. The prices have gone up a lot, the $5 large cheese pizza is now $8+ which I do think is too much for what it is, and the calzones aren't very good. Tonight I went back to my first Comella's meal, eggplant Parmesan- it's so delicious! I suggest adding mushrooms and green peppers to it, even better! The portion is huge and with this you absolutely get what you pay for (I didn't order w any pasta either and it's a meal in itself). I'm also a big fan of the cannolis w chocolate chips. I've brought a lot of friends and family here over the years and they've always been happy with their food too. read more

Comella's - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

I love the kids size ravioli with meatball. Delicious and a good size portion, plenty for an adult, unless you have a HUGE appetite. In that case, any of their full entrees will be more than enough and most likely, you can have two meals from it. With Italian food, I think you either love the sauce or you don't. For us, we LOVE the sauce. Try it...you might like it! read more

Stuffed shells tasted like old fashioned homemade with quality ingredients. Delicious.

I'm not sure why this place doesn't have better reviews. I live about ten minutes from this place and have eaten here more than 30 times over the past 6/7 years. Their Margherita Pizza is the best I've had in/around this area, salads are great, and their subs are well-made, tasty. The place itself is small but always clean, and their staff is always very welcoming. read more

Dear Comella's, I wanted to like you. I gave you so many chances to impress me. I ordered different things every time I went. A mess one time, meatball sub the next, and an Italian sub the last time. Your siblings (the newton one especially) I enjoyed, but you...you fall short. The Mess: Poorly cooked pasta, skimped on the extras, and the sause was bland The meatball sub: Flavorless meat, same bland sauce, and soggy bread. And whoever made it just slopped it together carelessly, The italian sub: the flattest I have seen, skimped on the meat, way too small, looked like someone sat on it before you gave it to me (and kinda tasted like it too). Natick, unfortunately, is short on good lunch places. I thought Comella's could fill that void a bit, but it is just another disappointment. I haven't tried their $5 pizza, but I don't want to give them more business. Maybe they will be gone soon and something decent may actually go there. read more

First time I ordered I sat there for 25 min only for the guy to come out and tell me that they didn't have the sauce I ordered, and it would be another 45 min. I got refunded, but I would have expected a discount on my next visit for that type of inconvenience, especially since I only have a 30 min lunch break. Tried it again today...ordered Chicken Brocolli Alfredo. The price was mysteriously almost $2 more expensive when I went to pick it up, apparently because I got grilled chicken on my place (was never asked nor specified). Fine, ok, I was hungry so I didn't argue. The sauce was watered down and bland. The pasta was a bit overcooked. There was a pile of semi-melted mozzarella on the top, the chicken was a bit dry, and the brocolli a bit mushy. I will most likely not return anytime soon. read more

Back when we lived in Natick, we frequently got takeout from Comella's and enjoyed it! The only flaw is that they don't deliver, but it was usually a stop on the ride home or a short walk to pick up our order. They have typical Italian favorites and really give a big portion for a good price! The workers there are always friendly and it's never too long of a wait. Great spot in downtown Natick! read more

Yuck! Ordered two pizzas and a Greek salad for my family. WAY OVER PRICED at $53. First off, the salad had very little lettuce and TONS of those disgusting, cheap black olives from the can. Definitely NOT Greek and not a good sign regarding the quality of the food. The veggie pizza was bland and boring and the broccoli on it was scorched and burnt. The buffalo chicken pizza tasted very weird. Seriously, how do you screw up buffalo sauce?! Why is it so hard to find good pizza outside Boston? Sigh... read more

Same great food as all the other locations. And I had very pleasant service over the phone and at the counter, both times with a female. Not sure what the rest of these people are on about. The messes are fantastic. A single is enough for two people. (As long as one of them isn't me.) Overall the prices are really good; lots of value here. read more

.Wow, how to relate this place... The truth is that it is a pizza place that offers subs and pasta and a pretty good one. They have Sanpellegrino in the windows and an broad pasta offering, so present as a sort of trattoria. But that is where it ends... If you want pizza and munchies, this is a great place! If you want an Italian meal, it's not. The pasta offering was limited, the sauce was immature and pressed with sugar and there were no vegetables that I could see - and no wine. We tried for a whole meal and were served, garlic bread, salad, stuffed shells and veal - all at the same time. It was fun to - go family style and shuffle the food about. If you want to go out for pizza or cater pasta for something, this place is a fine choice. read more

Got take out to feed a crew location was chosen based on proximity to other stops along the way. Flavor was ok. Basic pizza flavor. It just isn't my style of pizza. Super thin crust that has no structure. You can't pick up a slice hot and eat it with your hands. If you're into eating pizza with a knife and fork, or eating your pizza cold, this is fine. read more

I have been a big fan of Comella's for the last 5 years. We have 6 kids- so the $5 cheese pizza was a great deal; we'd buy 6+ pizzas for $30+ tax and have plenty for everyone & friends. A couple of months ago, all Comella's locations bumped up to $6, and " I let it go ". I ordered 3 today to bring to my grandfather's nursing home as we do each Sunday. Cheese pizza now $7. I realize I sound like an old cynic, but within a nearly six month timeframe, their price for a cheese pizza (I hazard to guess their cash cow) increased about 30% read more

Great food. Fast. Good for a quick sit down of Italian. Reminds me of fazolis read more

Comella's - a group of people in a restaurant - Italian Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

I order Comella's meatballs and sauce for take out. The meatballs are big 3" across and the red sauce is tangy and full of tomato flavor. I have also ordered a half sheet of tortellini and it is a large portion, served 6 ppl. I usually order on a weekend night and the place has been hopping with ppl picking up orders. The dine-in area is tiny 4-5 tables but cost and clean. I have ordered take out from both the Natick and Wellesley locations. The staff is friendly and seem happy to be there. Yum! read more

Three for now - I know they're new. I will review again. This was for take-out. 1) The sauce on my mess (Cousin's mess) wasn't nearly as good as the one in Newton. Same flavor profile, but not as rich. Maybe it needs to reduce a little more? 2) My shrimp were cooked well, AND they take the damn tails off. YAY! Carla's Pelano Mess (Extra Eggplant) didn't really have much eggplant in it, though it tasted good. She had the same comment about the sauce. 3) The garlic bread was good, though not baked off, and I didn't know it was going to come that way. I had to bake it off myself to melt the butter and toast the bread. Weird. 4) The staff was very friendly, and the place was very clean and looked good. Look forward to coming in again! read more