Great food, reasonable prices, and amazing service. Nick's serves up your typical favorite town style pizza. I tried a few of their different pizzas: pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and their Natick Hill special (grilled chicken, broccoli, garlic). It's town pizza, but it's similar to NYC style. All were fantastic! I would probably go for their specials or classic toppings, skipping the buffalo chicken, but regardless anything you get here will be good. I also tried their cheeseburger sub and onion rings which were some of the best onion rings I have ever had. On their menu they also have sandwiches such as grilled cheese and BLT sandwiches which go for $4!!! The staff is so nice and the food is always ready within 15 minutes of ordering. This is a great spot for pizza, and great prices to feed a bunch of people. It has definitely become my go-to in the Natick area. read more

See all

Old menus - for ordering in the restaurant and prices were increased at the register ($3 per item). No verbal communication to relate new prices - only a half hidden sign that prices are subject to change. My croutons were soggy. The manager said I could return the food to get my money back (and leave). read more

Hit or miss but once you find the item you like, its consistent. The caeser chicken wrap and the caeser salad with chicken are delicious and a good sized portion. The turkey sub had hardly any turkey on it. The pizza is forgettable. read more

decent food and accurate delivery. I like the apps, mozzarella sticks ect. The pizza was okay read more

I ordered a small pizza through the Slice app and was very happy with it! It's a foldable thin crust style rather than the thick Greek style everyone makes. Great balance of sauce, cheese and toppings (ask for extra sauce). I also respect that Nick's does their own delivery and the delivery person was very friendly. I'd order again! read more

Nick's Pizza House - Small pepperoni, green peppers, onions, extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Just fabulous again! The owner is fantastic, he makes whatever you order the way you like it! Food is excellent and prices are reasonable ! I luv the pizza & greek salads with feta and pepperoncini ! Italian subs are great too hot and fresh made to order thanks! read more

Nick's Pizza House - Delicious pizza Wirth a great cheese blend! - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

See all

Great prices and we love the burgers, onion rings, salads, super huge pizzas. A hidden gem. -Rob

I ordered a large bacon pizza the bacon taste like it was old and it looked brown. The chicken had missing pieces to it broken apart and the food was cold I called and the man that answered was not polite. He said that's not his problem. Call DoorDash. read more

Nick's Pizza House - a partially eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

The order was quick and correct, but it just isn't good pizza. The crust is thin, but seemed undercooked. There's hardly any sauce. The cheese is the kind you find on all Greek pizzas. And the pepperoni was thin sliced, nothing special. Sorry - I wanted to like it, but it is not my kind of pizza. read more

This is our favorite local pizza place! We drive by 3 other pizza places to get here. Great pizza and we also recently tried the calzones, which were great too. The crust is the perfect thickness, not greasy and not too dry, and the sauce is delicious. Our go-to pizza spot! read more

Nick's Pizza House - Large Spinach and Feta Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

If I could give a zero star I would. I walked in to place, waited at the counter and no one came to take my order. I saw an older gentleman and a young adult in the back chatting with each other. Older adult saw me, kid was looking at his phone. After 1 min of waiting and having no one acknowledged that I was there I left. No business deserves my hard earned money just because they exist. I wanted pizza, but as I was walking out I was happy to not have ordered a slice because it looks dry and days old. read more

So I was on a post-work out foodie run, and just got some great food next door at Rich Noodles....... so what else would go great with asian food.... PIZZA! my order came out hot and fresh and I have to keep nicks on my go to list. great food. read more

See all

Use to be 5 stars "Dinners Served with French fries or onion rings or rice & salad". I ordered the 'Fish & Chips' DINNER with the rice and salad side. I'd received NO 'Chips'. I believe Nicks under the impression that fish and chip means...fish. He told me "you're NOT in England!" read more

Important!!!!!!!!!!!!! I never thought pizza could taste as bad as their bbq chicken pizza which had pink bbq sauce that smelled and tasted horrendous and made me nauseous. They didn't even fully cook the pizza and most of the cheese was unmelted. When we tried to bring it back and get something easy like a cheese or pepperoni pizza they said there was nothing that they could do and we probably won't like anything there then and took our pizza in th he back. If your thinking about getting pizza there please do yourself a favor and just go to Roch Bros. down the street and get a frozen one, you have been warned. read more

Nick's Pizza House - Unmelted cheese and pink barbecue sauce no thank you! - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

I've ordered delivery from Nick's through Foodler.com twice to my Natick office. The food has arrived earlier than estimated (tasty surprise) & it's always warm. The steak and cheese salad is delicious. I've also had the mozzarella sticks & BLT sub - both good. I recommend giving Nick's a shot when you're in the Natick area looking for a quick tasty lunch. read more

Great pizza. The taste is amazing. For pizza this place is amazing. Other food is satisfactory. I order here often but I stick to pizza. The grinder I had was sub par. The pizza is greasy the cheese is great and the crust is perfect. Nice job guys read more

Ordered the spinach feta tomato pizza using yelp. The order came in early. The pizza was nice and warm. It was very tasty with generous amount of toppings. Would definitely order from here again. read more

Nick's Pizza House - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Great food and they remember you when you order and also go in. Highly recommend them

Don't go there. They used to be all right but now they're terrible. The pizza I got was mush and obviously made without any effort or concern. read more

The Boyfriend and I picked up food here twice in the last 8 days because we just moved into our new apartment and things are crazy. The first time we got subs; Italian Cold Cuts and a Meatball Sub. Both were very good and an okay price. Tonight we picked up a pizza which we didn't a large was 18", which is gigantic. We ordered pepperoni, tomatoes, mushrooms and fresh garlic. The crust was tasty and overall it was better than average and definitely better than the chain pizza places. We will definitely pick up from here again. read more

My family and I get Nick's pizza every Friday. I'm not a huge fan of the pizza but I love the side dishes. Such as the mozzarella sticks and the potato skins! A delight to the taste buds! 4 stars! read more

The gyros here are very good. I also really enjoy their steak and cheese sub. Cheese pizza is average/ run of the mill. The calzones are large but about average taste. Definitely worth a try if you live in the area. read more

Nick's Pizza House - Front of menu - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Went in to pick up lunch takeout and workers were not wearing masks. Food tasted good but that is not reassuring at this time.

A little off the beaten path, but the sandwiches are very tasty, and the price is right for lunch! Haven't tried the pizza here, yet, but it looks like that might be next on the list, based on previous reviews. Glad I found this diamond in the rough! read more

This place doesn't get enough love! Good food, surprisingly not greasy pizza at all! Thin crust, fresh veggies and friendly serving. Quick delivery And reasonably priced. I read another review about canned mushrooms. That would be a huge deal breaker for me so I steered clear but really enjoyed our food and I am a pretty snobby pizza eater so this says something. We would definitely order from here again and recommend you try it out! read more

Nick's Pizza House - Spinach & feta! So good! - Pizza Near Me - Natick, Massachusetts

Nick's delivered 2 pizzas 2 nights ago during a torrential downpour. We had the driveway lights on and the front porch lights on and were waiting for the delivery. Within 15 min. of scheduled delivery we checked outside - there were 2 pizza boxes in the pouring rain disintegrating - pizza slices literally floating around in the rain. Are you kidding?? We have had Nick's deliver for the past 20 years no problem. What happened? They always rang the doorbell - someone would be standing there on the porch - come in and unpack the order from the thermal canvas container - everything was great. Yesterday I brought the mess back to Nick's. The guy behind the counter said his brother the owner would not be in until tomorrow and threw the mess out immediately before I could stop him - Before I could take a picture - something's not right -should have been settled right then and there. Today I called the owner - he lied and said the delivery guy called us - NOT! no phone call. I also checked that Grub-Hub did not make this delivery. We are 20-year customers - this is a lousy $18.00 order. I am now pursuing this through our credit card company -on principal. If Hollywood is looking for new horror movie material - try a pizza house named Nick. read more

The best pizza place around !! Great prices and portions! Fast delivery and very easygoing workers ! I call to order the weirdest shit and they make it for me ! Great place for a fast bite after work read more

Everything is good here, but I always get a calzone. Service is always great and friendly.

Ordered pizza from here recently. Went with the basic combinations. The pizza was ready on time and was tasty. Adults and kids enjoyed it. The pizza is not gourmet, but it is not priced that way either. This is a medium thickness crust style. Solid local pizza joint. read more

I ordered 2 scoops of tuna salad to be delivered..received water sogged tuna dripping from the container.i have Never had a problem with Nick's before this.when I called back the person was arrogant and dismissive.i will never order again. read more

Nick's is great! The delivery service is fast and courteous. Food is always delicious and the prices are reasonable. Best deal is the sandwich on the round roll!!! Can't beat it! read more

We ordered ziti and meatballs, which came to us as linguine. We also ordered chicken, broccoli Alfredo with ziti, which also came as linguine. My chicken parm with ziti...yes, also came as linguine. Ordered through Foodler.com, and I'm not sure if that had anything to do with the slight screw up with our order. Either way, it was O.K. The sauce is super watery, and doesn't really stick to the noodles. However, the chicken in our dishes was quite good. Nice little side salads too. Shining star of the meal was the pizza. I wish we got a large. Very nicely cooked, with a good chew and nice crunch to the crust. I'd absolutely order pizza from here again, and maybe try some non-pasta menu items. read more

Absolutely gross. We ordered a large order, and everything was in the order. However, the pasta was dry and perhaps days old; it was in large chunks as if boiled tjat way and never stirred. No sauce. The sausage was incredibly questionable. We ordered 25 wings, 3 were eaten. They were soggy and undercooked. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. read more

Used to order their food all the time. But one day they screwed up the order blamed me and didn't offer any recompense. I would have been fine if they either remade some of the order or worked something out, but was consistently told that I ordered it wrong. Decent food otherwise. Just a misunderstanding that lost them a customer. read more

Ordered delivery from here, they apparently knocked on the door and though I asked them to call when they arrived (because I cant hear the front door) I never got a call. They apparently then left and I never received food. So I lost $20 and never got food. I called and they refused to refund me or help in any way. Felt extremely cheated... and will never come here again read more

I only ordered a ham and cheese sub with lettuce tomato and mayo but it was fantastic. No complaints at all. The guy behind the counter was nice and greeted me the minute I waked in. The prices were also very reasonable! I would go back again. read more

Ordered pizza from here for the first time. We usually order from Natalie's but decided to try something new for a change. They used canned mushrooms on the pizza which is something I absolutely can't stand. Other than that the pizza was pretty average. We will definitely go back to ordering from Natalie's. read more

I had been here years ago and it was okay. Ordered a small cheese pizza today (the benchmark of quality, if a they can't do a cheese pizza that tastes good....). When I got there the place was filthy and no one was there to help. I had to wait five minutes before the surly, I presume owner lurked out fron the back room and grunted at me in disaproval. I knew then I would be lucky if the pizza was edible. I opened the box to apply hot pepper flakes and was momentarily pleasantly surprised to find a pizza that looked appetizing; well looks deceive. Upon biting into a slice I was met with the unnatractive flavor of rancid grease and burnt pan drippings. Beyond that there was no flavor whatsoever. Mozzarella, robust sauce, a well crafted crust: nope, none of these flavors that make pizza my favorite food were present. Just rancid grease. I was starving and forced myself to finish a slice to my own personal disappointment. Imagine the worst pizza place you've been to on a late night desperately hungry, and all they have is disgusting slices to offer that have been reheated multiple times over a week due to their unpopularity: that is what Nick's fresh pizza reminded me of. Even dousing it with salt was not enough to eke out a scintilla of taste. I'm sorry I wasted my time, money and appetite on this swill. I have no idea how they stay in business. If you have taste buds avoid this place at all costs. I'm always amazed to find a place that can't make a halfway decent pizza, I mean where is the pride in making something so simple inedible? If there are pizza places in hell, they would resemble Nick's. Get a frozen pizza instead, itwill be better than this. read more

awe hey awesome for Nick's Pizza i'm right down the street from them and i have to tell yeah the Italian subs are the best ever a great sub for lunch and always the cool guys that put these together are totally great and i think it's the best in the Natick area read more

My boyfriend and I ordered a pizza tonight. It was our first time and I have to say this will be our go to place for pizza, it was cooked perfectly, the sauce is great and the crust is awesome. read more