College Pizza in Fenway is actually pretty good! Last night, we were feeling hungry and decided to look on UberEats for food delivery. Food options are definitely more limited once it's after 11pm/12am and we took our chances with College Pizza. We ordered one large buffalo chicken ranch pizza and in less than an hour, it was delivered. First impressions: The pizza looked pretty good, I'm not gonna lie! Slices were HUGE & the flavor was very good. It's was unexpectedly tasty; I say this because pizza places that are open late are hit or miss. The only thing that I wasn't a fan of was the temperature of the pizza. It was room temperature haha. The flavor was really delicious though. Perhaps in the future, I will try in person take out and see if there will still be the temperature issue. read more

College Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

" Pizza is good , opened late " This pizza place is clean and the pizza is good . It also taste , very fresh . It's open late . Price is great for portion size and quality. Parking is difficult but manageable. Staff is super friendly. Vibe is warm and welcoming. read more

College Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Had the chance to walk over from Fenway to College Pizza. I had their pizza before but only a small slice so I wanted to check it out. On the day that I was there, it was very busy due to a University graduation that was happenning. I was able to put my order in and have a seat to wait. The time it took to cook was pretty quick...which is always a good thing! The pizza was as good as I remembered it. They do not have small pizza size only Medium and Large. I had a Medium and brought back more than half for some co-workers at Fenway! The pizza was cooked perfectly and I enjoyed my pizza and the crowd on a wonderful sunny day in the Fens! One of the things I noticed was how many Grub-Hub and Uber Eat drivers were coming to pick up orders for delivery! Pretty substantial amount in the time that I was there! The store has some seating and there is outside seating available, as well. Store was clean and seemed very organized. Would I come back? I think I would Price- a little steep for a Medium Parking- limited since it is on a one-way street (Queensberry St) Vibe- good...seemed like a big college crowd Taste- 4 stars read more

College Pizza - College Pizza, 50 Queensberry St, Boston - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

On a warm Thursday afternoon I was sitting in my office starving borderline dying. I have been looking for about 10 minutes for a good spot to eat with no success. my coworker recommended this place and to my surprise it is the best pizza I have ever had!! Made to perfection best way I can explain it is like being at heaven gates! 10/10 would always recommend. read more

College Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

My family and I always come late at night and order a large buffalo chicken pizza ($30) and we eat it in the car when comes out super hot and fresh. It's breaded chicken with a yummy ranch and parsley on top. The dough is crispy (but not too crispy) and light/fluffy. The slices are huge. I've tried pepperoni and chicken bacon ranch, it's just not the same. Usually I prefer a plain pepperoni, but everyone in my family loves the buffalo chicken pizza here and this is the only place we can agree on. Their pizza always hits the spot, especially after a bad dinner. It's a small takeout spot with few seatings. The service is fast and I usually order 15-20m before and I don't have to wait. I haven't tried much of the other food but the buffalo chicken pizza is 5/5. read more

College Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

Food was mediocre, and ordered ahead after waiting in line a food delivery person was behind me and the instead of taking the next customer (me). The cashier jumps over me and starts taking care of them. And then walks away and doesn't even try to acknowledge me. After a few mins, another worker finally ask if I've been serve. Need less to say my food was there made just had to hand it to me. read more

Good food and wings service is 10/10!! Also it is very good and clean. This place is the best pizza spot in town , highly recommend

Decent pizza, I ordered in. We got a medium which was a pretty good size with leftovers for the next day. The food arrived hot, so the delivery was good. read more

Popped in after a concert around 1130pm for some slices. 4 slices buffalo chicken, 2 slices veggie, a poland springs, and a vitamin water XXX cost $37. The pizza had no complaints from us. My GF ordered a slice of buffalo chicken and 5 cheese and she threw away most of the 5 cheese. Expensive imo but good in a pinch. Nice lil interior with bartops to eat ur slices. Employees were nice. read more

College Pizza - Buffalo chicken slice. $5. Tasted good around midnight after a concert. - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

We ordered a "Margherita" pizza and this is what they gave-- literally just a cheese pizza that took 25 mins. If we didn't ask them for our pizza, we would have waited for much longer (they handed us the pizza that was already ready). We went to the place when it wasn't busy and still took them very long, which was frustrating for a pizza that doesn't have basil, tomatoes, and just 99% cheese. The taste is a regular cheese pizza but expensive for what it was. read more

College Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

I ordered a medium veggie pizza and some mozzarella sticks via DoorDash tonight and I was impressed by the quick time it took to be made for my roommate and I, even on a Saturday night. The pizza was delicious, but not something to really write home about - just your typical veggie pizza. I liked the mozzarella sticks better than the pizza and found them to be super good, but found the marinara sauce to be extremely watery which was a major letdown. While I wasn't over the moon with what I ordered, I'm a huge sucker for anything buffalo chicken, so I'm excited to return and try their signature buffalo chicken pizza which will hopefully be a lot better! I'm also excited to dine in at College Pizza and get a feel for the ambiance and overall atmosphere. It seems like a popular stop for other college students on the weekend, but I want to give it another chance before solidifying it as my go-to place for pizza in my area of Boston. read more

Ordered late night on a Saturday and the food was bomb!! Pasta cooked perfectly and great amount for price read more

College Pizza - Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

I discovered this place while walking around the city. Though the restaurant itself is small they make good use of its space. They offer thin crust pizza (single slice/full pie), cold beverages, and a kiosks of various deserts. The slices are quite large and very fairly priced. I would highly recommend trying the 5 cheeses pizza. They have a small in and outdoor seating areas and they also offer pickup services. The staff were prompt and friendly and were ever able to serve multiple customers at once. I would highly recommend this establishment for a quick bite to eat. read more

College Pizza has a FANTASTIC buffalo chicken pizza. Truly, it's original and such a creative take on it. First, the chicken is breaded and fried and cut into bite-sized chunks. Then this is paired with cheese, buffalo spicy sauce, and topped off with ranch and a sprinkle of cilantro. Standard buffalo chicken pizza usually comes with blue cheese and heavy buffalo sauce, but this version isn't spicy and very creamy from the ranch dressing. It's genius! Also, if you want something other than pizza, they make a killer steak sub sandwich. Bread is pillow-y soft and they grill fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms. When you unwrap the foil around the sandwich, the entire thing lets loose a steam cloud of steak-cheese goodness. read more

College Pizza - Best Buffalo chicken pizza. Ever. - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

Best slices in Fenway. Looking for a speciality slice in the area, give College Pizza a try. I've had the chicken bacon ranch, veggie pizza, and buffalo. Service is quick. It's a small takeout shop with a few seats. Always welcoming, open late. read more

College Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza with red pepper flakes - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

College Pizza delivers quick service, tasty slices, and ultimate convenience--ideal for anyone in the neighborhood! read more

College Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Average, but still good and hits the spot when you want pizza. Plus, they make it pretty fast. I like the thin crust. Still sort of expensive (almost $30 for a large). read more

College Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

little takeout place with a few cute tables outside to sit. solid pizza, nothing too crazy special but it did the job and we were satisfied read more

College Pizza - buffalo chicken/pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

Six months later, still just OK. I got a veggie slice and heated it up at home Still just OK read more

Good pizza, wings and fast delivery through DoorDash Asked for ranch and wasn't included read more

Solid dependable pizza, highly recommend the Chicken Bacon Ranch. Cost has gone up making it less of a value for late night college shenaningans, but nevertheless remains a post-party staple. read more

I have lived next to College Pizza for 2 years now. Through my graduation, two jobs, 3 evening shifts (3-11:30) a week, the crew at College Pizza has always welcomed me with a smile and fantastic service. The hardest part about moving away from this neighborhood is leaving my buddies at college pizza. Try my usual: one slice of buffalo chicken pizza which is by far the best, and one slice of pepperoni. For $10, nothing beats this kind of comfort food that is always hot, ready, and DELICIOUS! Thank you guys for always making me smile and having my order ready as soon as I come to pick it up, I will miss you terribly!!! read more

FIRE. Needed some late night grub and got the pasta and fries. Could feed 3 easy. Portions are insane, taste is Devine. Thanks.

Pizza not yummy We ordered the chicken bacon ranch and the sauce tasted like alfredo... not yummy read more

My favorite is the buffalo pizza The new management is awesome.great food and amazing customer service....very professional Gd luck guys will definitely see u again and highly recommended read more

This pizza will literally transcend you to a different plain of existence it is so fucking good. like please just try it. it's unreal. Amazing service and food. Don't listen to the haters read more

The pizza are amazingly delicious and dry, the service is great, and the place is right in Downtown Boston

Great dinner plates. I love the chicken fingers, fries & salad dinners and the hamburger plate with fries and salad. The new owners are friendly and have always treated me well. It's a nice change from national franchise operations with uncaring low paid employees with no vested interest. It's obvious the owners of College Pizza care for their business and customers' satisfaction. R J H - West Fenway read more

We ordered a pizza that arrived stone cold. There was little on the pizza and the pop we ordered wasn't even what we ordered and had been previously dropped as there was a small hole in the cap read more

They have the best veggie pizza I've ever had. They are very generous with the ingredients, not only the quantity but also the variety. Never get disappointed. The staff is very friendly, including the delivery guy. read more

College Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

Placed an order for pickup. They said that the pizza would be ready in 15 minutes. 45 minutes from the call and I was still waiting for my pizza. I understand places can be busy but on. Tuesday night? I saw my pizza in the oven and the guy behind the counter kept opening the oven door to check on it; I just figured they took awhile to start the order. When I got the pizza, I was pleasantly surprised to see the pizza packed with an abundance of toppings. The crust was thick, and cooked all the way through. With a meat lovers pizza, you expect a ton of grease and the toppings to be so heavy, the crust just flops, right? Wrong! This pizza was mildly greasy and the crust was baked to a crisp and it did not flop when held (with crust ends folded side-side)!! I had a moment of realization - maybe they did start my order on time, but were spending the extra time baking it, making sure their pizzas wouldn't disappoint. And it indeed, did not disappoint. Large meat lovers wa $18 and some change. Definitely satisfied and a great place to check out if you're in the mood for a pizza house style pizza! read more

College Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

I ordered delivery through Grubhub on a Tuesday night. It took 2.5 hours to arrive at my house. I called once it was about an hour past my delivery estimate (which was already estimated for an hour after I ordered, so I was quite generous). They were very flippant on the phone and said it would be there in "20 minutes". About an hour later I called again, got no answer, called again and they connected me to the driver who said he would be there in "5 minutes" and did not arrive until about a half hour later. The driver was very rude and when I mentioned that I would not order from them again said "see you tomorrow!" I work in food service and so I am very forgiving, but this business clearly has a history of being terrible. DO NOT GIVE THESE JERKS YOUR MONEY. read more

Nothing wrong with wanting a little grease and some buffalo wings late night on Sunday...I didn't want to order from Papa John's or Domino's like I usually do (I haven't found a good pizza place to order from so I just stuck to basics that was close to my area) I'm not sure how I came across this place...but I remember seeing pictures and the pizza looked DELICIOUS in the photo so I HAD to try it out. I ordered a large cheese pizza, Buffalo wings, and curly fries. Food came promptly, food was still hot! The smell....the smell of the buffalo wings....i'm salivating. It definitely has a kick to it. I don't eat much spiciness but I ate it anyway, despite my burning lips. It was so good! So from now on, College Pizza will be my Go-To pizza place to order delivery from! Let's hope they are consistent *fingers crossed* until next time I order! read more

College Pizza - Screenshotted from my snapchat. Foodgasm is right! - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Don't order delivery. I came back to my hotel hungry after a day of Boston Calling revelry, and made the mistake of ordering from College Pizza via grubhub. The price and delivery charges were reasonable, but apparently it was too good to be true. After missing the initial delivery estimate, I had called grubhub customer care to check on the status of the order, at which point I was told to expect my order within the next 20 minutes. Half an hour later, and it still hadn't arrived, so I called to check up on my order again, this time with no response from the restaurant. Given the lack of response, they canceled my order. I was understandably disappointed, but at least this whole ordeal had come to a close, or so I thought. Adding insult to injury, the delivery driver arrived at my hotel 10 minutes later - with my canceled order. All told, 2 phone calls and over 2 hours later, and I'm eating a bag of snack mix for dinner. Needless to say, I will not be ordering from College Pizza again. read more

Love that they are open late. The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing! the buffalo was flavorful but not too spicy and there was a good amount of ranch. the four cheese was not what I expected and also not my favourite. read more

College Pizza - buffalo and four cheese - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Whoever gave this 4 stars or less were not high, or not hungry. These guys have the greatest buffalo chicken pizza on the planet. Thank you for being there for us. read more

The Buffalo chicken pizza is insane! Never had a better pizza than that. The place isn't all that fancy, however, the guys are hardworking and friendly read more

See all

Ridiculously disappointed with this restaurant. I ordered off of Grubhub and my order went through at about 4:40 and I did not receive my order until 2 hours later, when I discovered that they did not bring my complete order when doing the delivery, at which point I told them to forget about coming back to bring the Gatorade that I had also ordered because I'm sure it would have been another 2 hours for delivery. Do not order from this restaurant. The customer service is absolutely terrible and there is no excuse for saying that an order will be at its location in 15 minutes and then making the customer wait for an additional 45 minutes. Extremely unsatisfied read more

Cons : This is the second time I had this pizza. The first time I had a heart burn and thought it was just something else I had. The second time I had the pizza, it gave me the same feeling. I was also amazed by the fact that it costed 4 dollars for an extra topping. Whoa! Pros : the chicken was in huge quantities. One slice should fill you up read more

Yuck. Tasted like COVID-19! Disgusting! Gotta love when you taste Corona Virus on your lips. No masks, no gloves, no business! UGHHHH! I would not order again! #MyCorona read more