Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cold Stone Creamery

    2.4 (81 reviews)
    Open • 11:30 am - 9:00 pm

    Cold Stone Creamery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Cold Stone Creamery

    Recommended Reviews - Cold Stone Creamery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Jack R.

    Coffee milkshake with almonds and brownie pieces was it really good treat after a good hike in Pacifica. The problem was a service here was horrible. When I saw the girl scoop just a few almonds into the milkshake blender I asked for a little bit more and she charged me for two extra scoops. Yet, when I watched a couple of teenagers that she knew come in later on and ask for extra Cookie Dough Bites I look to see if she charge them extra and she didn't. If you're going to charge people for extra items make it consistent and don't play favorites.

    Chocolate Truffle w/Carmel & brownie mixed in!
    Jamie P.

    I love this location - it's convenient, great service and plenty of selection. The ingredients always seem fresh and I love all the mix-in options! My only suggestion would be to have more dairy free options other than sorbet/sherbet. They have remained open during this time of "Shelter in place" which is awesome, and I was happy that they take Apple Pay so I didn't have to touch anything!

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Cold Stone Creamery

    Does this store carry Oatmeal Cookie Batter? It's a favorite I can't find locally;(

    No onlycake

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    Review Highlights - Cold Stone Creamery

    “Sal is wonderful and has even made our "usual" minutes before closing when we've called.”

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Mazzetti's Bakery - This is what I ordered

    Mazzetti's Bakery

    4.2(1.8k reviews)
    3.9 mi
    •$$

    We were in Pacifica to celebrate my father-in-law's 81st Birthday. After a sumptuous meal at…read moreMoonrakers, taking a lovely stroll along the stunning beach walks, and browsing the local shops - we decided to swing by Mazezetti's on the way home. My FIL greatly favors apple pie a la mode (over the usual cake). We got there around 4pm and were surprised to see that there was still a bit of line to enter the shop. Thankfully, the line moved quickly and a friendly and beautiful young lady helped us select an apple crumble pie and a chocolate donut (for my young son who does not like pies). After dinner, we cracked open a tub of Trader Joe's vanilla ice cream to eat with the pie. Needless, to say the pie was fantastic! I had never been to Pacifica before today but after this euphoric experience - you better bet our family will be back to Mazetti's to get more pie and try out their other treats. My little boy also gave the chocolate donut 5/5 stars.

    I agree with the other reviewers -- their customer service has definitely become curt and…read moreunprofessional. I understand how popular their Derby Cake is, but I don't like supporting a place that seems to think rude service is acceptable just because they're popular and busy. A couple of times when I came in, I was met with eye-rolling and impatient service, and I initially excused it because I figured they were overwhelmed. Most recently, though, I called with a specific question and the person on the phone was again rude and impatient, then hung up on me while I was still speaking. The bakery is good and reasonably priced, but not good enough to keep overlooking poor customer service. Thanks for the memories!

    Photos
    Mazzetti's Bakery - Derby cake

    Derby cake

    Mazzetti's Bakery - Our naked cake!

    Our naked cake!

    Mazzetti's Bakery - Chocolate Derby Cake ($33/8"Round)

    See all

    Chocolate Derby Cake ($33/8"Round)

    Its Sugarlicious - We offer a wide range of custom-themed cakes and artisanal designs!

    Its Sugarlicious

    4.9(19 reviews)
    6.2 mi

    We just tried the cake and wow. It's delicious!! Much less sugar and still very creamy and very…read morewell balanced. By no means did it taste "healthy" as it is a cake, but it's one of the better balanced cakes as I do not feel guilty eating this after 3 pieces of battered, deep fried fish. I ordered a standard cake choice that can be available pretty quickly for a homemade cake. I chose vanilla and strawberry and the birthday boy loved it! He said it was the highest quality cake he's had ever! The cake was taller than the standard cake we're used to, but we loved that. The decoration of the cake was really pretty too. We didn't want to cut into it as the cake has both a minimalist and intricate design at the same time! The service was very streamlined (in a very good way) and also very friendly. I did not expect the cake to be brought out since we got there a little early. Lol. I think we found out where we'll probably order for other occasions. The cake also came with cute instructions to ensure its quality stays as high as possible. We're recommending to other friends as this was probably one of the best cakes we've had.

    I've worked with Fariha at Its Sugarlicious twice now and she is absolutely incredible! There is no…read moreone I'd trust more to deliver on beautiful AND delicious cakes! I messaged her on IG and she texted me that same day. I secured the date, made a payment, and sent her inspo pics and on the day of, she arrived on time and delivered the most beautiful cakes I could've dreamed up! The first time I worked with her, it was a simple sun themed cake and the second time I asked for a fairy-woodland inspired cake. Both were so good and were the centerpieces for our dessert table. I also ordered smash cakes from her, which were also really good even though they are made from really simple ingredients - my guests enjoyed both! lol. Our favorite is the strawberry shortcake - it got SO many compliments and the design was so gorgeous, some guests thought it was a fake cake hehehe. LOVE working with Fariha and will definitely think of her first for our most special events!

    Photos
    Its Sugarlicious - Custom edible logo cupcakes available for your next corporate event.

    Custom edible logo cupcakes available for your next corporate event.

    Its Sugarlicious - We work with you to curate the perfect cake that matches your tablescape.

    We work with you to curate the perfect cake that matches your tablescape.

    Its Sugarlicious - A classic 6-inch vintage-style cutting cake for an intimate wedding. 
 
 Perfect for the traditional cake-cutting ceremony.

    See all

    A classic 6-inch vintage-style cutting cake for an intimate wedding. Perfect for the traditional cake-cutting ceremony.

    Sweet Dreams Bakery - Mario and Luigi Custom Cupcakes

    Sweet Dreams Bakery

    4.3(431 reviews)
    6.6 mi
    •$$

    I was tasked with ordering the cake for my best friend's milestone birthday and knew I wanted a…read morevintage cake design. I reached out to Sweet Dreams Bakery with the design that I had in mind and Maricel responded quickly and assured me that Sweet Dreams could make the cake that I wanted. The end product was BEAUTIFUL and delicious. We brought the cake to a restaurant and someone outside of the group even requested to take a photo of it! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a custom cake. Thank you so much Maricel and Sweet Dreams Bakery team.

    I can't say enough about this bakery what started as a sweet tooth fix has turned into an obsession…read moreand love. The cake flavors are amazing, and I love that they have mini cupcakes of such a variety of flavors. But they are also one of the most talented cake artists. I contacted them on whim last year when my default baker went out of business and I needed a cake for my kids birthday party. It was a Bluey themed party, and they really came through with everything. Sometimes its hard going with someone new, especially when you don't know what to expect. But I knew their cupcakes were amazing so figured it was worth the risk. But they created the most amazing cake that was beautiful, moist and flavorful. This year, we choose a hawaiian theme and then subthemes of a Hawaiian Hello Kitty, Hawaiian Squishmellows, and Hawaiian teenage mutant ninja turtles. It was a challenge to put it all together but they did it and I was so happy with the results! And the cake literally melt in our mouths (the berry flavors, for anyone interested). Everyone has been so easy to work with and I love that they do a consultation to get information on what you are looking for. Highly recommend if looking for a mini sweet treat, or bigger sweet treat. Or any speciality cakes. Oh yea, did I mention they make macaroons and cake pops too!? Literally can't go wrong with anything here.

    Photos
    Sweet Dreams Bakery - Mario Cupcake

    Mario Cupcake

    Sweet Dreams Bakery - Mario themed cake

    Mario themed cake

    Sweet Dreams Bakery - Luigi Cupcake

    See all

    Luigi Cupcake

    Cold Stone Creamery - icecream - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...