Came on a Saturday morning around 9am ish. It was summertime so students weren't around and it wasn't busy. I found parallel parking right in front. I ordered online for pickup so my food was already ready when I arrived. Got Sausage Party (sausage, egg, cheese, garlic herb cream cheese) on an everything bagel and a hash brown on the side. It's a solid option if you live near campus. Not expensive like the premium bagel shops but the taste matches the price. The bagel wasn't anything spectacular. I liked the cream cheese but the flavors were pretty light overall. Hash brown was good. I probably won't be back but I know they will do well since they appeal to the student population or folks that live in or near downtown. read more

Cocky's Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you're a New Yorker looking to replicate the morning bagel experience in Columbus, this isn't it. If you're in dire need of a bagel, full stop, then this is good enough to get by. I have to admit, I was a bit perturbed that they didn't have a simple "egg and cheese" on a bagel option on the menu. They menu only listed fancy high priced bagel sandwiches. It was almost as if they were trying to deter folks from ordering a simple egg and cheese bagel. I had to ask the cashier about it and so I was going "off menu" but it was much cheaper. read more

Cocky's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ordered a dozen bagels for a brunch party. Guests only had a bite then were throwing them away. I tried one and they were stale on the edges and rubbery in the middle. Same for both the plain bagels and the everything. Totally disappointing. Would not recommend this place for bagels. read more

Amazing service! The nice cashier wrote dairy allergy and they did not cut it! I appreciate it! A bit slow to make a bagel. Taste is great! A lot of vegan options! Ambiance is welcoming! 100% go there!! read more

Heard about a new bagel place, with a Miami (Ohio) connection, so Sweetie said she was going. Or rather, I was going, as soon as they opened. Sunday morning, semi-caffeinated, I head down. Website says they open at 8 on weekends (7 during the week) but I guess their social media said today would be at 9am. Oh, well, I'll find something to do. The staff were decorating and getting ready, but said they could make something for me, so I stayed. No line, though maybe at 9 there was one. Free shirt for first 50 customers, and it's a nice one. Super friendly, laid back, lots of family helping out looked like. Small space, bright and cheery inside. Fair amount of tables. Plenty of street parking early on a weekend, but at busy times during the school year might be tight. And free parking on Sundays; I didn't see a sign that said it, but I know that's true elsewhere in town, and the parking app wouldn't let me pay. Interesting menu, and I just went with my standard lox. Sweetie got the steak, egg, and cheese. Lots of other things that look good. We also got a maple one with cinnamon sprinkled on plain cream cheese. Sweetie liked hers. I liked mine. Good bagel (I went with everything,) fresh tomato, onion, lots of tender tasty salmon, I think garlic herb cheese spread, etc. Yum. Decent prices. Handy location. I bet we end up here a lot on Sunday mornings. read more

If you love bagel sandwich's you have to try Cockys. This Philly cheese steak bagel was so delicious and flavorful. The price was very fair and was definitely worth it. Their menu looks great and has tons of variety, the staff was friendly, and the ambiance was great. A good breakfast/brunch or even dinner spot honestly. 8.7/10 read more

Cocky's Bagels - Steak Philly - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Food is just okay. Not worth $10. Can deadass make this faster at my house by myself. They got 5 people in the kitchen and I'm waiting 15 minutes in an empty lobby for a bacon egg and cheese. f you want a breakfast sandwich and are cool to wait and pay overprice just go to the lox in the short north higher quality and worth the w read more

Cocky's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Price: $12 Rating on sandwich 7/10: Overall pretty decent. I'm from the east coast so I love a good bagel. I do think a bagel sandwich being over 8 bucks should not be allowed. Eggs were ok, not much bacon, the peppers and onions were meh. I think it's worth a try but I'm not sure if I'll be back or not. The price really did it for me. Service was good, it was fast and clean. The workers were nice and short wait. read more

Cocky's Bagels - Sandwich: Western with cream cheese on a Jalapeño Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I was seriously so impressed by this bagel sandwich! It was hefty, decently priced, and delicious! We ordered for pick up and our order was ready and hot. The cashier was super sweet too. This bagel was so good. I ordered the cocky, which is turkey, salami, prob and cocky sauce (spicy mayo type of sauce). It was crispy and flavorful. They have some other cool menu features that I'll try a different time! Definitely recommend! read more

Cocky's Bagels - The Cockys - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

There are few things I love more than a bagel breakfast Sammie. On this particular morning I NEEDED one. We searched high and low and went to three spots before finding cocky's. I'm so glad we did. The bagels were DELICIOUS, with the perfect amount of cream cheese. (Ya know how sometimes there's too much and it's a mess? Not a problem here) The lattes were decent, and gave me the caffeine I needed for the day. There was a bit of a wait, and one poor girl was running the show. She did it with a smile on her face! I recommend - but if you're hungry order ahead :) read more

See all

It's a bagel. Good bagel..Other breakfast items are high priced. I'll return for a bagel.

These are some tasty bagel sandwiches! I wanted to try something unique so I ordered the Frenchie: Sausage, Egg, Cheddar, Hashbrown + Maple Syrup on Maple Bagel. Hashbrowns should ALWAYS come on a breakfast sandwich! This was like a loaded French toast in bagel sandwich form. Very yummy! read more

Cocky's Bagels - The Frenchie - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Bagels were stale, cream cheese tasted off, and the service was awful! So many better places to try! Never again!

Ordered one of the Cocky bagel and im not typically a bagel person being from the south im more of a biscuits and gravy or sausage and eggs kinda person, in fact had the Big daddy in my cart at first but seen how it was their staple item so i switched my order and oh mannnn am i glad i did what an original and tasty bagel and it was huge im not a small guy and i could only eat half in one sitting but that definitely not a complaint will definitely order here again. read more

Cocky's Bagels - Cocky bagel, tots and cold brew. - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We made this a destination to try and it was pretty bad. But I'll start with the good: the place looks nice and the lady at the counter was great. My gf got a turkey sandwich and it was a decent size. UNFORTUNATELY, my sandwich had barely any meat on it even though it was the special and costs more. Also came with nothing. But the worst is that the bagels were soggy and gross especially the bottom half. Idk how they are cooking these but it didn't seem like my bagel had been toasted and however they are handling them they are absorbing a ton of moisture. I almost wanna say it had been microwaved. I don't know how a bagel gets that way otherwise. If you cook and assemble everything but the bagel, then when it's toasted, you can put hot food on a crispy bagel. If they are using a different approach that I don't know, then I guess I just don't know and I don't get it either. Maybe if they sold pumpernickel bagels I'd stop in again for one toasted w cream cheese. But they dont even have the most classic king of all bagels at the bagel place, so probably just not gonna consider it again. read more

Bagel was alright. Ambience was nice. I've seen larger $5 coffees in the most pretentious areas of LA though. Not really sure how that's possible. read more

As a Jew - and self-proclaimed breakfast sandwich enthusiast - I know a good bagel, and finding one in Columbus has been difficult. With the exception of The Lox, all other bagels are fairly the same - which means to impress me, you've gotta stand out a different way. Cocky's did just that. My girlfriend and I ordered The Big Daddy and The Frenchie respectively - and both had such unique tastes that we had never had in a breakfast sammy before. The hashbrown was such a subtle addition that made a huge difference texture-wise, and both the cream cheese and the maple syrup on our respective sandwiches made each bite a unique infusion of flavors that was really delicious. We went here because I had a $50 gift card thanks to an Instagram raffle - but I can promise we'll be returning many times more. Also - the interior was really cute and modern! Wish this was here when I was in college bc I would have gone far too often. Didn't go in with sky high expectations but came out massively impressed! read more

Cocky's Bagels - The Big Daddy - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Nope. I won't be ordering again. Had a bagel hankering this morning so I ordered an Everything with Garlic Herb cream cheese. Bagel tasted like it was 3 days old and they were very skimpy on cream cheese. Also got an açaí bowl. It was okay but I had to pay extra for granola and the bananas on it had seen better days. Sorry! read more

Mediocre bagels and they take way too long; I waited 10 minutes for a plain bagel with cream cheese. I said out loud but completely calmly to myself "what's taking so long?" and the person behind the counter said, in front of everyone, "I'm going to have to ask you to calm down." I told her I was calm. Never going back. read more

I've been wanting to try Cocky's for a while now, and I can say I was not disappointed! I got a breakfast sandwich with sausage, bacon, american cheese, cream cheese, and a hash brown. It was huge! And so delicious. We parked on the street right outside Cocky's. There was a bit of a line, so it took a little long to get our food. We sat for a while inside before we got our food, and then we took it to go. I absolutely love the design of the inside. I look forward to coming back soon! read more

Cocky's Bagels - a dining area with tables and chairs - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place is average. There is nothing special about the sandwich or bagels. They also forgot to include my hash brown that I ordered. It took a while for my order to come out even though the shop wasn't busy. There are better bagel shops in Columbus that are worth your money. read more

Cocky's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I was so excited to finally have a good bagel place near campus but I was disappointed. The bagel was expensive for what it is. It was very dense and heavy, it wasn't crunchy or hard on the outside which is what I typically look for read more

Cocky's Bagels - Lox - Bagels Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Bagel sandwich was ok, but PRICEY. With mac & cheese bites the total came out to $19. Definitely not worth $19, but this area has become ridiculous when it comes to food prices. Gotta pay for all these nice fancy new apartment buildings, I guess. read more

awful service and got extremely sick after eating the smash burger. Will never go back!

Bomb dot com!!! Love these bagel sandwiches, can't miss out, love me a bomb bagel sandwich and they sure deliver on those and a cup of Joe... can't beat it! read more

So delicious!!! I'm a bagel fanatic and they definitely met my expectations. Great service and super good prices.

Best bagels I ever had and staff is so nice and welcoming! Can't wait to take my sister that's coming from out of town next week .

Ordered a latte on door dash and paid 11 bucks for the smallest most basic latte that honestly didn't even qualify as a latte more so coffee with milk in it and got a steak and egg bagel came complete with egg shells in it definitely will not being eating there again read more

The food was incredible, highly recommend and the staff was extremely polite and welcoming.

bagels are sooooo tasty! make sure to try the buffalo dip it is AMAZING! And the acai bowls for a low carb day!

Amazing food, and fun vibes inside! Anna provided awesome service! The garlic herb cream cheese is really delicious too!!!

Super nice staff, great bagels! It's really disheartening to see all these fake reviews. Don't let others do your thinking for you