Good little pizza place tucked away in the corner of a strip mall. They serve pizza by the slice or you can get a whole pizza. The staff is very friendly and cute! read more

38.00 bucks for a medium pepperoni pizza and a salad. Salad was good but the pizza? Not cooked Long enough and wasn't good had to bake it longer just to eat it. It wasn't good and definitely not worth the money. My once go to best pizza in town now I won't be back. read more

Pizza was good but I'm pretty sure the two guys that were working yesterday were high. I've never seen two people in a pizza place move so slowly and with zero intention to provide any form of customer service. It's important to note that the business was empty at around 2:00 in the afternoon. I placed my order for a small personal pizza. I was told 15 minutes. The person that appeared to be the most experienced walked around for a bit, talked to other employees, even disappeared for a bit. After about 12 minutes of watching this, he started to make my pizza. High AF. I left annoyed at pathetic work ethic and no attempt at customer service. I will not be back. Wow. read more

Gotta love false advertising. Website is showing a 50% off, Pizza after dark special on Thursdays after 7 but they aren't honoring it. Called in to see if I needed a promo code and they said it isn't a deal anymore. Nice of them to keep advertising it though. Two thumbs down read more

Cibelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

Very disappointed. It started with ordering at 330pm. Told it would be ready at 615pm. Got there - pizza not ready. Came back - waited another 15 minutes till after 7pm. THEN the pizza - just terrible. Extremely skimpy. Asked for onions on top. They literally put maybe 5 tiny one inch pieces of onion on the entire 18" pizza. How much do onions cost??? Not much meat on the meat pizza as well. The only reason I gave them 2 stars was because the crust was pretty good.wont be going back anytime soon - except maybe to buy a crust and make my own! read more

The staff was very kind and we watched as they made our pizza with a lot of care. The ambiance isn't great but it's just a tiny little pizza place with lots of LED lighting. The pizza itself was fine but I am not sure I would return as I think the quality of the ingredients could be improved. read more

Just had the strangest experience at the Eastside Bend location. I suddenly had a house full of teens to feed, so I stopped by Cibellis to order a giant pizza to go. I ordered at the counter, willing to wait if necessary. The young man who took my order said to wait in the car and he'd bring the pizza out to me. He even clarified which car was mine. I thought that was odd, as I had planned to just wait inside, but I followed his directions. We waited and waited. Finally, I went in to check and a different young man informed me that it had been ready for awhile! When I asked why they didn't bring it to the car, he seemed surprised that someone had told me that. When I pointed out the staff member, he mumbled a sorry. It was very weird! The pizza was almost room temp by the time it got to the kids. It also wasn't double cut as requested. Very disappointing. read more

Best slices in Bend hands down. Generous slice size. $5 for a slice is a bit much. Consistency is important which they are!

Ordered the Mama Mia online to be delivered. It was cold, and it was very greasy. The crust was gooey from the grease. It looked like a rolling pin was rolled over the top. Flavor was not good. read more

Disgusting. Period. The guy that was cutting and grabbing the pizza with his dirty hands just made me feel sick. He wipes his hands on his dirty jeans then grabs the pizza with no gloves???? They all seem like they hate their job and don't care about cleanliness. I watched the back guy touch 10 different things, then touch every single piece of pizza while cutting it. Not once did they use gloves or wash their hands. I wanted to get a refund but they honestly seem too incompetent to do that so I didn't bother. Don't recommend this place at all to anyone that wants their food prepared clean. ZERO STARS read more

Hand tossed pizza Great quality topping Better than Pizza Hut's stuffed crust pizza (which has been my favorite of all time) read more

Cibelli's Pizza - Delicious dinner! All local - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

See all

I love the pizza at this location and the people working have always been amazing to deal with -- even during Covid while everyone was super stressed out! We love the red sauce and crust! Sometimes we just order raw dough and make our own at home! read more

Been a while but we recently got a plain pizza there. Just as good as always. If you like pizza like they do it on the east cast you'll like this. Wonderful very thin crust with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. This is what pizza used to mean. read more

I have not ordered a pizza from Cibellis for over a year, I thought I would give them one last try. I ordered a medium pepperoni nothing else. To say this was one of the worst pizzas I have ever had would be an understatement. It was flat terrible. I decided not to return it, because the last time I attempted to do so just ended up in a nasty argument. This pizza was overly salty, tasteless, what taste there was , was dreadful. They have obviously reduced the quality of the ingredients to stay competitive. That's the kiss of death in the restaurant industry. That was a full on kiss. Never again. read more

Couple things: Great place, wonderful service. I love they do slices, very rare and a great option. I saw how the system worked and a fantastic business model. Can't say enough about how cool it is to get slices at 7pm on a Thursday night. Where the pizza missed was not cooking the toppings. It was a cooked cheese pizza with toppings added on. So did not feel like a slice off a fresh pie. That's my take. read more

Cibelli's Pizza - two slices of pizza on paper plates - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

Dumbest shit I have ever heard at a pizza place in my life .. we have eaten here and the pizza is good usually but can be super soggy if you don't request cooked longer... this time we requested 1/2 cheese and 1/2 cheese and pineapple for my kiddo that likes it that way . I requested they put the pineapple on the side as I am allergic they said no they won't do that even though they have in the past ... it's against their policy they said ... how about fuck cibellis Amy's store bought is better any way .. read more

Ordered take out last night. They let us know exactly how long it would take for the Pizza to be ready. Correct to the minute. Really enjoyed the pizza. Kids devoured it. Great topping/cheese/sauce ratio. read more

Pizza is good but the salads are outrageously overpriced and most recently my lettuce had a huge mosquito in it. I emailed to tell them and never received a response so wasted literally $25 on a disgusting salad :/ read more

Cibelli's Pizza - a salad with dressing - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

Good pizza but hate the direction they're taking. Don't ask for side without it being cooked. Don't ask for half cheese that might mix with another sauce read more

Went in to pick up a salad for lunch. I looked at the salad dressing and told the person at the counter that looked rotten. They promised that it was fine and it just looked like that. Got back to work, opened and smelled the salad dressing; it smelled sour and it was absolutely rotten. Wasted $10, won't go back to any branch again. read more

I can't imagine there is a better pizza anywhere on this earth. White pie with pepperoni is an absolute masterpiece. Wait times can be long, so call early - no way to fault an establishment for being busy. read more

This Cibelli's location used to have great pizzas but a change in staff has shown a decline in quality. I would go here about once a week but the past few times I've gone, the pizza has been... not good. The cheese is very dry and tastes burnt. The pepperoni is slightly better but the last time I had it, it was on par with a Domino's pizza. Hopefully the new staff is trained better on how to make a New York style pizza, but I'll be going to a different location now and hope for the best. read more

We recently moved to Bend and this place is super close to our house and WOW! The chicken bacon ranch pizza is literally the best pizza I've ever had. We have now ordered it two nights in a row. It's seriously so good. Flavorful, cheesy, crispy bacon, big pieces of chicken and the dough is SO good. The ranch you get on the side too is thick and creamy. Highly recommend checking this place out. It's definitely our new go to pizza place! read more

I ordered a pizza and cheese sticks over the phone and arrived 5 mins before they said it would be ready. I paid when I got there and then waited over 20 mins before asking about my order. They forgot to make my cheese sticks, made those when I showed up and didn't tell me that it would be a 25 min wait. During that whole time, my pizza was sitting on top of their oven getting cold. They didn't put the ranch and marinara with the cheese sticks. And then the pizza and cheese sticks sucked. Worst service in Bend ( and that is saying a lot). Staffed by a bunch of kids who genuinely don't give a crap. I would avoid at all costs. read more

I was very disappointed by my pizza today. The cook took pizzas that were already made and tried to make the pizzas that we ordered. I ordered a margarita pizza and he just put tomatoes and basil on top of a pepperoni and my boyfriend ordered a barbecue chicken pizza and he just put it on top of a cheese pizza and served us like that. BBQ Chicken Pizza read more

Cibelli's Pizza - Pepperoni on margarita - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

What happened to my 5-star Cibelli's? I don't know. Maybe the owner stayed in Florida too long. I remember when Cibelli's first opened up, and my heart skipped a beat with its glorious crust, perfectly seasoned sauce and milky cheese. I was eating Cibelli's slices for lunch or dinner about four times a week. But recently, I've been disappointed. In fact, I had a day off and decided What The Hell and grabbed a slice from both Cibelli's and it's competitor, Pisano's. I took photos of both, and tried them side by side. Normally I get my slices from the Eastside location. This time it was from the Westside. Cibelli's won. But not by much. When did they start using a screen on their pies? The diamond-shaped imprint on the bottom of the crust made me weep a little. Char that bad boy! Don't be scared, pizza man. Just do it! For now, I'm sticking with Mondo and continuing to request it "extra cooked" for my favorite pie in town. I've posted a photo of my slice of plain from Cibelli's. Check out my post on Pisano's to see their photo, too. read more

Cibelli's Pizza - big slice, perfect cheese, meh crust - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

Cue music...The thrill is gone, the thrill is gone away, the thrill is gone... Oh, sorry. This is a review of Cibelli's. But it seemed to us from our visit this week that the song fits. Sadly. We've been Cibelli's customers for several years, since he had only one location in the little Tumalo complex. My Brooklyn born and raised, Italian heritage hubby nearly jumped for joy to have real, NY style pizza in Bend. I thought it was darn good too. But we both agreed, after our recent visit, that somehow the pizza just seems off, regardless of which of the several locations of Cibelli's one goes to these days. The same top quality just isn't there, in particular for the crust which is the end all for a New Yorker, like hubby, eating pizza. So, had we reviewed Cibelli's when we first started eating the pizza some years back this would have been four stars. But the last couple of times have been two star for the pizza. That said, the counter help at all locations are friendly, the service is fast and while none of the Cibelli's stores are going to win ambiance awards, some (like the E side store) are reasonably comfortable places if you want to eat in rather than take out. And there is no argument that Cibelli's offers the biggest slices of any Bend pizza joint. But as with other things in life, it is not always the biggest size the delivers the best experience. read more

Everything you would expect of a usual NY style pizza joint. Random pictures and kitsch of NYC. Red plaid vinyl table covers. Being in Bend, you're pretty limited to the options of (good) food. Mostly American fare, with the random Thai restaurant. So if you're going to do pizza, you'd better do it well. Cibelli's definitely succeeds with their thin crust, the right amount of cheese, flavorful toppings. But the real clincher here is the "white slice." 4 kinds of cheese with garlic sauce? Yes, please. read more

Cibelli's Pizza - Artichoke white slice - Pizza Near Me - Bend, Oregon

Came to pick up my pizza. Was overcharged Even though I know I ordered a med. pizza want even started when I got here even though I called in over an hour ago. There are 4 people working tonight. What gives.Service at Southside has gone way down hill. Have come to Cibellis for years but will think twice before coming back after this. read more

Cibelli's was a great experience for our family the other night! I've heard the south location we went to and the Westside location are fabulous, just don't have experience with the Eastside one but sure it's great as well. The employees were super nice and not mean mask nazi's like so many places are these days. The place is clean and great! And the pizza is wonderful! Our family would highly recommend! read more

The best pizza! fresh dough which makes the crust soft and yummy. The "kids" working there know what they're doing. Be sure to call ahead of time.. once our pick up time was 45min from when we placed the order. My favorite pizza so far is the bbq chicken. read more

Wonderful wonderful pizza. I only gave four stars because they aren't allowing employees to wear face masks during this pandemic

Let's examine the problems: 1. In the not too distant past, we had a pizza that was still kind of "doughy." I emailed them...no reply. So I emailed again with the same results. They ignored me. 2. Apparently there website that appears to be 20 years old, must not allow for replies, or...they just don't care. 3. Prices have gone through the roof,($32 for two 10" pizzas) and they've removed Margherita pizza, which one of their employees told me was a favorite. 4. They were able to McGiver a margherita, at $2 for every item added. Tomato pieces $2, Mozzarella $2 Basil $2 (skimpy on all of the added toppings) so the price of a 10" pizza went up $6. Hard working high school age young adults do a good job, but I bet the owner of his 4 pizzerias just kicks back at home counting his dough...Ha, get it? Anyway, I'll give other places a chance, or pay $8 for a Paul Newman thin crust at the grocery store, with all profits going to charity. Arrivederci... read more

Yummy by the slice pizza. It's large, thin & "floppy"..my favorite! Quick service too!

Consistently good pizza and friendly staff. The pizza and salads here are delicious, the crust is crusty and chewy with just the right amount of toppings. For my family and I this is the go to on those nights when the thought of cooking is daunting. We can always count on Cibellis to make a great pizza by a staff that always has a friendly word and smiles. read more

Very poor costumer service from the manager, Ed. The Pizza was not worth the price. I would not recommend it and I will not be going back.

Closed dining area long after the shutdown ended. No sale. Who cares what the pizza taste like. It's top dollar and zero bang for the buck. Might as well go to little Ceasers read more

Bummer. We used to really like Cibelli's, but no more! Something has happened over the past year and now they seem to be using inferior ingredients and half the amount of toppings. I'm thinking that the general manager here in Bend has been cutting costs in the wrong places because it definitely shows with a really unappealing pizza. They are now making it so thin that my husband just compared eating it to eating a piece of construction paper. We're not wasting any more Friday Night Pizzas by ordering Cibelli's. It's too bad, too, because the kids that work at all of their locations are always so friendly. read more

I am very picky when it comes to pizza, particularly the crust and they in my opinion, do have the best crust in Bend. Their prices are very reasonable compared to others in town though very conservative(at least the east side location) with their already OK quality pepperoni. I specifically ordered a specialty pizza with pepperoni covering the entire pizza. I told them three freakin' times how important the pepperoni was to me!! The guy who made my pizza was the same guy who took my order!! They charged me for extra pepperoni but the finished pizza looked like a standard pepperoni with a few large pieces scattered around. That said, I will probably go back occasionally for the crust and the price but will have to order triple pepperoni!!! _______________________________________________________________ Edit(12/02): I went back again and the gentleman working there gave me exactly what I ordered and would not let me leave until I checked the pizza and knew I was happy. I will be back again and again until I die of a heart attack!! read more

When I hear Cibelli's, I just get excited about the food to come! Our friends have taken us here several times and I am always amazed by the sheer size of the pizza!!! The box barely fits from my chest to the windshield of my friends Outback!!! Huge slices of good pizza!!! The pizza is tasty and while somewhat thin crust the slices are big enough you are full after 1 slice! Also due to the size of the pizza (surface area of cheese) you get a lot more topping on your slice. Great for groups because the pizza is huge and we love how it tastes!! Would definitely recommend if you're looking for pizza or want to try a "novelty" thing (because the slices are so big). read more