I don't know weather to give this place 3 or 4 stars. I'm going with 4 stars. I have been to this bagel shop 5 or 6 times. Do not be fooled by the bagel sign I will explain later in the review Location. It is a small bagel store. They are off of central ave in bethpage and are open 7 days a week from 4am-7pm. Food. They have a good selection of food for lunch. They have homemade soups like sweet potato and kale, chicken noodle and chicken florentine. They have Paninis with turkey spinach fresh mozzarella and walnuts. They have wraps and salads and this thing called a Italian quesadilla fried eggplant red peppers mozzarella and ricotta with marinara sauce. I have no idea if this place is a bagel shop a Italian place or a tex me place. From the outside it says bagels on the inside are all of these crazy sandwiches. Very confusing. They do get crowded around lunch time that is my only negative. Overall. It's a nice place for lunch. Not the best not the worst. I do recommend stopping here if you want to try one of these crazy sandwiches. Don't be fooled by the bagel sign this place has everything PROS: - good for lunch CONS: - is it a bagel shop or a Tex-myex Italian place?!? - can get crowded and cramped during lunch read more

Hands down best place around. I have no idea why the reviews are mediocre. Fresh doughy bagels, great range of salads and sandwiches, and relatively friendly/decent-paced service. It is a little overpriced, but not enough to bypass this spot! read more

Would give zero stars if I could. VERY DISAPPOINTED. Went there at 5:30AM, 30 minites after they were supposed to be open and there doors were locked. Saw workers in there. Called TWO times and they just ignored the call. read more

Great place! Sandwiches, bagels, eggs are all delicious! The staff is really nice also! Try their fresh baked cookies!! They also have hot food which looks great but I haven't tried. You might wait a little while on line.... Especially during lunch because they are packed.... But thats because they are good! read more

Not a fan of the bagels, they are true hand made bagels but a little too think and doughy for me. But the food and the sandwiches are really good. Service is usually very good. read more

I truly loved this deli, but it's heartbreaking to see how the employees are treated by the manager. Whenever I come in there the manager is degrading and belittling the employees and today she did it to me. As I was giving my sandwich order I noticed she wasn't writing down what I was getting, which made me hesitant, so I paused. Then, she grabbed a paper and began writing. Instead of saying "Can you repeat that please?" She said, "Well you were stuttering and not speaking correctly..." Who in the world says that to a customer? I have come there for years and paid the astronomical prices without hesitation, but today was enough! Then when my omelette was done (which by the way wasn't an omelette she didn't understand why I was confused when she asked how I wanted my eggs... IT IS AN OMELETTE... my boyfriend got scrambled eggs with melted cheese from the microwave and random ham slices on top), she goes "Ok girl not paying attention on her phone your eggs are done!" What? I was opening my Apple Pay... just beyond rude. To the owners, PLEASE GET RID OF HER. You can find someone 100000x nicer who can manage the store so you can save your reputation. read more

One star is harsh, but this place gets worse and worse every time I come here. This used to be my deli spot sometime back but I am extremely turned off by this place now. I've ordered grilled chicken in wraps and the chicken tastes like refrigerator and was the color gray. Gray chicken. The macaroni and cheese I ordered last week was SOUR. I took one bite and nearly threw up how can you serve this crap to people. The mayo on my sandwich was also sour today. Breakfast sandwiches have become dry and don't give you mich on a sandwich anymore. Shame... this place su la now. read more

Went here today, sadly not my first time, but will be my last. The service was horrendous, after being on hold for over 15 mins on the phone I walked into the location to place my order, and was snubbed by the young lady behind the counter, who was in no rush to help anyone. Nobody seemed phased at all that we left without placing or picking up an order, don't see any reason to return. After reading some of the other reviews on yelp, it's easy to see I'm not the only person who feels this way. read more

Their attitude is horrible. There is one lady that answers the phone and she is so nasty and never gets the order 100% correct. Pretends to know everything. Says she is the one in charge. (Very annoying) Other than that the food is fresh. It is a Good place to eat if you have time To check your order before you take it home. 5x out of 10 something will be missing from a sandwich or they will charge u for the wrong item. If you are getting a delivery allow extra time because the little Oldman they have delivering is a little On the slow Side. (Very sweet man) just slow. Pay attention and enjoy. read more

I'm honestly surprised that this is going to be the first review for this establishment. I came to Yelp, just to find out how early in the morning they open. I've been eating here for years. I absolutely love the pumpernickel everything flagel. That's my go to item, with roast beef, lettuce, tomato and deli mustard. read more

This review has nothing to do with the food or the service per se. I agree with other reviews, breakfast is the way to go, lunch is overpriced. I've never had a problem with food quality or portion size. My issue is the attitude of the owner (who I've noticed runs the place like a prison warden). Just this morning I noticed the flag was not lowered to half staff out of respect for two officers who were killed in the line of duty. I mentioned it to her nicely and got this half cracked smirk of a smile and she asked "why" when I said she should see if one of the guys could lower the flag out of respect. I mentioned that the local PD who frequents the place would appreciate it and its a small sign of respect for two men who died in the line of duty. Her answer was some nonsense about she lives in Brooklyn where these cops were killed and it would be nice if someone did something nice for the neighborhood for a change and blah, blah. I was so enraged I ignored her completely. I can't even say what it was she said to be honest I wasn't listening. Lower your flag and show a little respect because if something happens at your business or home the first thing you'll do is call for a police officer to save your butt. I outright refuse to ever go there again. read more

Best deli around this area. Fresh food and great staff. Never disappoints for breakfast A+++

I like the bagels here. The flagels are good. But seriously what the hell is going on with that parking lot. You could lose your entire car in some of those pot holes. Put some money back in your business and pave that thing. What disgrace. Bagels are pretty good though ... read more

Ordered a chicken culet sandwich and it was not good at all... Chicken cutlet was to thick and tasted fatty. My buddy ordered a roast beef sandwich which just looked like they sliced up the cow in the back and served it off the knife. I might give it another chance but i see a lot of reviews on this place and it's mostly all bad. Hopefully they can step their game up. read more

I have been going here for a few years but I will never go back. Breakfast is simple enough to not mess up so my egg sandwiches were always fine. My biggest complaint is with the attitude of the workers. Many (not all) of them should take a basic course in customer service. They are too rough with customers. And the cashiers generally don't pay attention to you. I will be going to Fireside in Plainview from now on. Much better Deli! Food and service! read more

Central Ave Deli is pretty close to my job, but that's pretty much the only reason I would stop in for lunch. The food is mediocre at best, honestly. Their chopped salad bar is seriously lacking in ingredients & because it's priced by pound depending on who's chopping your salad the price varies significantly. Additionally I often question the freshness of their vegetables as they're almost always wilting (and/or brown). Their breakfast is bland - particularly the home fries..have they heard of salt? To add insult to injury the woman who answers the phone in the morning (petite, brown haired Hispanic woman) is extremely rude. Do me a favor & get another job if you hate yours, toots. read more

Absolutely the best deli on Long Island! Everything they have if delicious! I come here every Sunday with my ambulance crew and it has become a tradition. The staff learn who you are and make it personal. Rudy is the absolute best! I've also had them cater a party and they went above and beyond! Everyone raved about the food! Delicious, fresh, made to how you like it. read more

Food is really good, but the service is slower than most places. I also find it always seems to be a different price depending on who rings it up. I've paI'd anywhere from $8 to just under $11 for the same sandwich. Also, never place phone orders. They are usually wrong and the girl gets rude and nasty if you ask her to repeat the order bacm for accuracy. It's a good locall place to stop by though. read more

Not enough people working there. They can't get people in and out fast enough to long of a wait. Ordered a chicken ceaser salad and got no chicken. Not going back read more

Just found this place driving through. Staff is very friendly and energetic. Bagels are really good and have egg everything and whole wheat everything which are my new favorites. I took some co workers here that came in from out of town and they were all impressed. read more

Terrible set up terrible bagels terrible people what the fuck literally terrible set up unorganized incompetent day old bagel on a Sunday. Do I need to go on... Going to All American for a knish. read more

Good food, however this deli is chaotic. Seem to always have many people working, however a simple bagel or bacon egg & cheese will take forever to make. Limited seating, you have to stand in a crowd to get an order in. Nothing negative to say about the food, just a confusing and hectic environment. read more

This is the THIRD time in the past year I have been ignored for over 10 minutes with more than one man behind the counter. When i finally did give my order of two basic turkey sandwiches it took 15 minutes to make. Yes...15 minutes. The reason, the man who took my order was too busy talking to another worker and just stared into space for a while. Four people were waited on during my time there and left. This is not the first time this has happened to me. I think that as soon as the manager/owner leaves it is a "who cares" attitude. Good potato salad, but not worth it. Will never go back. read more

Miserable MAnager!!!!!!!!! food is great. Prices are a little higher then most deli's. If you get a Coffee refill it's the same price as the first cup ( most deli's give a discount.) WATCH OUT FOR THE MANAGER. She has 0 patients. She gets a addititude all the time. Your eating breakfeast and she screams across the room at employees. She doesn't belong dealing with people. I've seen her be nasty many times to customers and employees. I've been a customer of this deli since they opened when manager was a employee. I will no longer go to this deli. Don't want to see miss miserable person when I get breakfeast. SHE'S ALWAYS MISERABLE!!!!. read more

If you can, try to avoid ordering from this deli. We order on Saturday's and have someone pick it up, because they don't deliver on the weekends. When our order gets here. We always have a problem. The toast is burnt, with no butter. The sandwiches are soggy. The home fries are hard as hell, with no taste, the same with the scrambled eggs. NO TASTE. Then the check out morons, ask if you want utensil to eat. (I ordered the #10 breakfast box) No, I like to eat with my feet. idiot! Then if you ask, for salt, pepper and ketchup. The check out morons will say its in the bag. NOT When you call to complain no one is really help full. They want us to come back and they will fix the order. We are at work sometimes we can not leave again. So we are out of the money we spend on the bad breakfast and we are still hungry. This place just sucks so bad. I wish I could show the pictures of the nasty food. We just throw out their menu. This was the last time we aggravate ourselves in the morning. The worst thing is being hungry, then getting your food and its half ass. i do not want to give a star. Its making me. This place get a negative star. They should just close down. read more

Very dirty. I went here one day and the guy behind the counter takes a napkin, wipes the sweat off his forehead, grabs a bagel and makes another customers sandwich!!!!!!!!!!! I mean he didn't even try to hide it or change his gloves!!!!! I'll never go back here!!!! I used to go here all the time!!!!! read more

This is by far the best bagel place in the area. When I moved to the area a few years ago, I tried several others. But once I tried this place, I never left. The bagels are awesome, breakfast sandwiches are great, and lunch specials are yummy. I will not go anywhere else for bagels. read more

Came all the way from Orlando Florida to visit friends in Holtsville. First stop after landing at Islip was a 28 mile trip to the central Ave deli. Food was great service was was quick for food that had to be prepared. Prices were reasonable (hey if you want a five dollar lunch you need to run over to McDonald's for assembly line burgers.) cleanliness is good. Have absolutely nothing bad to say about the place. Plan on making this a priority stop every time I come back to New York read more

Just moved to area can't seem to find a place that a) knows how to do business or b) cook a Bagle and eggs. Don't waste your time even looking at this "deli". Overpriced, people cutting lines that seemed to be friends with the counter people. No plain Bagles only rainbow. Incorrect order twice. $10 minimum on credit (which is illegal). Horrible parking lot. And the place didn't seem very clean. Not one nice thing to say about this place but that I'm still looking for a deli in the area that's not horrific read more

Nasty dismissive people working here. Counter people never get the order right. Checkout girls need a lesson on how to treat people and not stand around talking to each when you are trying to pay. They are totally self absorbed and think who they are---Girls you work in a deli---get over yourselves ! Oh and the food is average, nothing special. For my money I prefer less attitude read more

Terrible customer service!! Multiple times I went there for breakfast to get a whole wheat everything bagel with cream cheese only to come home & find out they gave me the wrong bagel. I can understand waiting on a busy weekend morning but when I come in for soup in the early afternoon with no customers there and everyone just hanging out behind the counter ignoring me, then I have a problem. I patiently waited 15 minutes before I just walked out. I called to speak to the manager following my experience and he argued with me basically saying that's not the case there and they never get any negative feedback. I told him I've had many bad experiences there and they have now lost a really great customer and he said okay bye and hung up on me. Thanks a lot for caring about your customers and for not making things right. I'll make sure to let my friends and family know if they are looking for a great deli to not go to this one unless they want to be as disappointed as I was. read more