After spending $56 on 2 sandwiches which comes with a "pickle and side salad" ...the pickle is a quarter slice of a small pickle and the side salad is 3 tablespoons at most. I did get a large side order of fries which had no salt....not good. But what really really annoyed me and is the reason I am writing this is because the owner was behind the counter and when I asked for extra ketchup he said "oh yeah...I gotcha...lots of ketchup" .....well there was 2 tiny ketchup packs with this. Really? I asked twice so he knew it was important. If you are that cheap with the small stuff I am terrified to think how you try to save on the bigger items and food. The sandwiches were not good either. My kids were starving from playing sports and when I brought this they wouldn't even eat it....I should have gone to jersey Mike's or even McDonald's. Skip this place. read more

The only reason(which is a huge one for me), i walked in and while i was placing an order, I saw many flies on top of the bagels. I walked out .... Flies on the bagels is a big no for me. read more

Are you kidding me, over $15.00 for 2 slices of Swiss, on a roll. I asked for lettuce. I did not get it. And a water. This is absolutely Ludacris this place's prices for what they give you! You should be ashamed of yourself! read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Swiss on a roll... Where's my lettuce - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

I don't know how people go here and spend a shit load of money and the food is not good!! 2 egg whites Turkey and cheese and a coffee 19.00!!!!!!!! Highway robbery !! Never never again read more

I was starving thought I'd get something "safe" Ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a roll + iced coffee. Worst $20 I've spent!!Disgusting. Dryest sandwich on HARD STALE BREAD! Everything over cooked ! Cheese had to be the cheapest most artificial taste, just a gross sandwich over all. Stay away from this place. Coffee was trash too. read more

Just happened to be in the neighborhood during some waiting time. The place is bright, open spaced and the specials are posted at the front. Decided to head inside for a quick bite and was greeted by the man behind the counter. I decided to get the Monte Cristo and a small coffee. It was great, the addition of the coleslaw was a game changer. A bit pricey but overall a good spot. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Specials - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

So my daughter had a ton of company at her house today. Three weeks ago, she ordered food from this store for delivery. Delivery was scheduled for noon. 1215 my daughter called, and was told driver just left. 30 minutes later (1245) food finally showed up. I don't tip for bad customer service. 45 minutes late means no tip. My daughter looks at the sandwich in the house and it was not what she ordered. She called to complain and the girl said I have to call the driver and I'll call you back. 20 minutes later no one called back. My daughter called again. And they put her on endless hold. My son in law went to the store with the sandwich. They did refund the money but insisted on a tip because they hired the driver to make the delivery (the driver was behind the counter). I'm all for tipping good customer service but insist on a tip and you get nothing. Never going back there again. read more

Stopped by to get a bagel. Ordered 2 eggs and bacon on a flat. Nothing else. Took 15 minutes to get it with nobody else there! Almost $13. I inquired and the older gentleman stated that they use x large eggs lol. Nice place and was good but really? Not sure I spend that kind of $ on something I usually spend $8. read more

Nice people. Noce selection of cream cteam cheeses and spreads. However ovcasionally low on certain kinds of bagels

The chicken cutlet hero's were awesome - but this place used to have hands down the best macaroni salad , it seems like new ownership is somewhat keeping the recipe but stretching it bc this pasta was nearly dry , pls don't cheap out on one of the stars of the show read more

Bagels are bad, not fresh, and overpriced. People who work here seem angry to be there.

I want to give them 5 stars but their food was just ok for the price :( Will definitely be back for another chance read more

Today I ordered a veggie and tuna wrap with a side order of orzo salad and an iced tea and a bag of chips and for dessert I got a brownie. And today was my first time eating in here the service was really good and the ambulance ambiance is very good. Yesterday I met owner and his name was Brian nice guy and now I'm enjoying my dessert which is a brownie and I really love it I give this place 5 stars. read more

Mothers day the line wasnt long but took a while. seems like the manager wasnt happy with the production of the workers. Kinda frustrating but what can you do. read more

Absolutely amazing food, I've been coming for the last month at least once a week, and there's still so much I have to try. Salads are fresh, all the employees are helpful and friendly, and it's a nice calm place to enjoy and eat good food. Shoutout Brian for the excellent service! read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Front of restaurant - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

A decent bagel spot, the options are limited but if you're in a hurry and dont have time this can certainly do. The bagel was quite large and the cream cheese was a little thick but it was good. I got the fresh OJ which was okay, I wished it was sweeter. Staff were really sweet though! read more

Service was good, but $5:00 for a bagel with just cream cheese. I thought was too expensive. I went up the road to Calvert Manor this morning, got 1 egg everything, everything both lox cream cheese, 1 egg plain and 2 plain croissants. $15.99. Just saying much better value and the food was delicious. read more

[this review is mostly about the "Magic Bag" from the Too Good To Go app] Unlike virtually all other bagel places on the app that list their bags as "bread and pastries," this one was labeled as a "meal." Since I don't need 17 bagels at home, I thought I'd see what this meal was. The bag collection process was smooth and on time. The vibe inside was...weird. The place felt dingy and dark and thrown together. Not a reason on its own to avoid the place, but the manager (I think) who gave me the bag made it sound like they set aside food specifically for this program, which defeats the save-food-waste purpose of it. The bigger issue was that there was no "meal," just 17 bagels of several varieties. They taste fine, but like I said, I don't need 17 bagels. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - "Magic Bag" from Too Good To Go app. 17 bagels. - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Such delicious sandwiches, great salads and super friendly employees. Everything I have tried is wonderful. Check them out if you're in the area. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Americana sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

This was a grubhub order. We ordered 3 BACON, egg, and cheese sandwiches. 4 bagels, 1 muffin. No Bacon on the sandwiches. We asked for over medium. It was too soft and runny. And my entire order of 8 items was squished into a small bag. They stacked the sandwiches and then put 4 bagels in a bag on top of that and must have pushed down on it, flattening the sandwiches, and added the muffin on top. 2 and a half sandwiches were uneaten. It was disgusting. Add to that my meal was over 30 minutes late. Never again!!! read more

First of all, my family comes here all the time. Ryan, the owner, is a sweetie. He's hard working and serves delicious food. More importantly, I ordered a catered Shiva meal months ago that was beyond perfection. Both delicious and visually beautiful. His fruit platter was gorgeous and the fruit was perfectly ripe and delicious. The salads and cream cheeses were plentiful and the bagels were huge. Thank you as always!! read more

Just finished my hot breakfast and coffee... I ordered the Country Omelette it comes with ham, bacon, onions and peppers. I noticed they forgot the bacon in my omelette which kinda sucked. The omelette comes with Homefries and buttered toast as well. It was a solid and nutritious meal, a good hearty breakfast. They also have a FREE medium coffee offer if you check in on Yelp. The manager said its a mistake and shouldn't be there but will honor it since I saw it on the page. The prices here are a little high. But then again in this economy everything has gone up, thanks for nothing Biden! read more

See all

Bacon was half cooked but I should've been more specific I didn't want chewy bacon. The pancakes were 10/10 and the eggs. The service was excellent the manager and young lady behind the counter was a doll so sweet I'll definitely come back anytime but just maybe turkey bacon well done. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Chocolate chip pancakes , two fried eggs , Bacon - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

This is a great place to eat. When I was there, the service was quick and friendly. Freshly made when I would order bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll. There are sitting areas around the inside and outside, which I like when they do to-go and dine-in orders. However, I wish there was a TV when sitting down or even free wifi when eating at the table. Overall, I would come back again. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. Understaffed, long waits for non complicated bagel, way overpriced and I hate to say that the cashier was rude and practically yanked the money from my hand. Never going there again. And all for a so so bagel. read more

They're the best bagels on Long Island! Delicious, soft, many different cream cheeses to try. The coffees good, the menu offers a lot of options for breakfast and lunch foods. They're always busy, but I won't deduct a star for that because they're worth the wait! read more

Food was mediocre. Came here out of desperation because other places were packed, and boy do I regret that decision. I placed my order and only 1 person was waiting in front of me by the time I was done. 7 other customers walk in, order and leave with their food before mine was even started being prepared. And mind you I ordered a turkey and cheese sandwich. It took 8 minutes for them to even start making it. Guess they only cared about getting other people in and out. Several egg sandwiches were prepared in the same time I was left waiting for my food. Food was mediocre, other delis have better tasting deli meats. Potato salad tasted like cleaning product. Small bag of chips were insanely price gouged at $1.50 for a tiny snack sized bag. Never will I return and waste money on this establishment. The way they do business, it's only a matter of time before they shut down like their neighbors... Good luck read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - a bag of chips and a red pen - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Workers are nice but their prices are CRIMINAL. The breakfast sandwich was solid but it cost me $14 for 1 egg sandwich and drink got the total to $20.. that's robbery of the highest degree read more

A ripoff. I ordered from breakfast grill menu which said 2 eggs with sausage with bagel or bread 4.99. I ordered 2 eggs overeasy, sausage and toast. I got charged $6.84 for eggs & sausage and then additional $3.75 for toast. I spoke up and they told me prices went up and they didn't get there new menus yet. Bad enough you charged me $6.84 from $4.99 and now your also charging me $3.75 for toast that was suppose to be included. Last time you will see us there. read more

Met with the owner Ryan and his Dad and has the most delicious Pastrami, coleslaw on rye bread I have had in my lifetime. Iyou need to try it for yourself and if you don't care for pastrami they have so many other delicious options to choose from. Simply Amazing! John B (Honest Energy) read more

The two stars are for the coffee that was good. My mom and I came in here for a quick bite because we were in the area, and the food was terrible. I have never tasted bagels in NY that taste like loose leaf, that all changed today. Our order was messed up but that is completely irrelevant because everything was so tasteless that I kind of wish the guy at the register would've just did me a favor and forget to put my whole order in the bag to save me from having to write this review. I got a chocolate te chip cookie because I wanted soomething sweet, and it tastes salty lol, I ish you not, my cookie, is salty. Florida bagels 100000% better. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - I'm pretty sure it's not thoroughly baked through. - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Never coming back here. Store is clean, but the food is disappointing. My friend and I went and asked for hot sandwiches. I asked for a hot turkey sandwich on a roll with lettuce tomato Mayo and cheese, keep in mind I'm from Queens and I used to have a hot turkey sandwich almost everyday. The workers looked confused, I don't understand what's confusing about grilling turkey with cheese on top, and warming bread. I think they grilled the turkey, but it was barely warm, the bread was COMPLETELY cold, and the cheese was cold and not melted at all. My friend ordered a hot sandwich with lettuce, cheese, and Mayo (she's a vegetarian so she didn't get meat). Her bread was completely cold, the cheese was not completely melted, and they forgot to put the lettuce in?? On top of that, we got a side of potato salad, which tasted straight up like vinegar. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Disappointing turkey sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Found it odd that when charged over $10 for a egg sandwich with no meat and no cheese ... when asked for a receipt it said I was given 3 egg whites meanwhile I only asked for two... no meat no cheese on a bagel... on top of the fact it fell apart and was all pushed to the center of the bagel instead of on the actual bread I was just extremely disappointed . When I asked the man behind the counter why does your TV say 5.49 for two eggs any style on a bagel or roll he said he doesn't know why his computer isn't Tv isn't updated to match the computer. Doesn't know what to tell me .... " how about fix the over change you did.... Be careful as this was not the first time, and now my review comes after the second time over charged . Not only will they charge you for more then what you order, but will also refuse to correct it when they're caught ripping you off . Terribly over priced!! Rude and poor customer service ... don't waste your time...$13 for a Arizona and egg white. I can't even imagine what lunch would cost ... read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Organic Berry hibiscus teas are amazing, break fast sandwiches are not cheap, but you get what you pay for and the food here is pretty amazing! Worth the trip! read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Turkey egg cheese w/ pepper ketchup, - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

This is NY. How do you miss putting bacon on all the bacon-egg-n-cheese sandwiches in an order? So many better bagel/deli establishments locally. Avoid this one. read more

This place is right by our house and a pretty good bang for the buck.. it's good service's too

Ordered lunch today, and I didn't realize my sandwich was made wrong. I ordered a turkey time, which was a turkey cold cut with turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato and even asked for avocado, which is EXTRA. I called to tell them so they can make a new sandwich because there was no turkey cold cut and no avocado on it, and they told me to bring in the sandwich. So I brought in the sandwich. The 2 lady's behind the counter, including Kristina took the sandwich and looked at it. They whispered and told me that they will just put turkey on this side because I ate the other side. I said I would pay for half the sandwich and she said "Ryan will have to deal with it then" they proceeded to "make the sandwich". I understand they didn't want to remake it, but the lady who grabbed my sandwich literally didn't change her gloves nothing. Touch counters, register, everyone else's food and proceeded to touch the sandwich and make it. So then when she went over to Kristina and said she didn't want to make it, she said "she wants to be petty I'll be petty" and then continued to raise her voice and laugh, that's when I had it. I walked out and when the Spanish man whos behind the counter said I'm making your sandwich I told them to keep their sandwich and walked out. I had sown colorful language but after they proceeded to make comments about me. I literally have been going to the bagel place since they opened, and I will NOT be going back. Most unprofessional place I've been too. read more

Bagel & Deli Creations - Food I bought and what the sandwich looked like. - Bagels Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

Stopped here after work and it was so great! Bagels are super cheap after 2, glad I came by.

Best service ever! Best bagels on Long Island. 10/10 Best service will always go again the people are very friendly.

A very wide choice of bagels and cold cuts. Excellent daily specials. Friendly quick service.